Befumbled: A Bachelor Nation Podcast

Welcome to the shortest episode yet--all thanks to that boring Men Tell All. The girls rehash what little drama there was, including Tayshia's "painful" break up. Annie successfully befumbles Hailey on the bizarre content that there was in this episode--sculptures??? Streaking???? A lawyer??? There isn't much to talk about, but the girls do their best!

Hello hello! We have returned with a guest and we're about to spill to her all the Olivia Rodrigo "Sour"-esque details about the John/Katie situation, along with an episode rundown of Michelle's hometowns! Will our guest be fooled? You'll have to listen to find out.

It's episode 30 and Annie and Hailey decide they should maybe have some sort of podcast introduction? Annie successfully befumbles Hailey, while the girls reflect on what it means to bring someone home to your parents. The girls are still obsessed with Michelle and also confused why Clayton was picked as the next Bachelor. All in a day's work!

We're back and with a brand new guest! Meet our friend, Jojo... but is it Jojo the singer, Jojo the dancer or Jojo the bachelorette? You'll have to listen to find out.

*This episode was recorded on the eve of Red (Taylor's Version) so skip ahead to 8:00 minutes if you’re not interested in Hailey and Annie’s swiftie talk”

Join Annie and Hailey for another week of Michelle's season! Hailey befumbles herself with her poor note-taking skills and then forgets that cell phones existed ten years ago. The ladies discuss Clayton's lack luster performance so far this season, their guess for Michelle's final four, and Rick’s intense eye contact. And, of course, the girls get into all the drama as to why Everybody Hates Chris.

Hello hello! Hailey and Annie are spiraling this week. Annie watched the episode and somehow barely retained anything. But what did she remember? Insane quotes. The gals also gab about Hailey's secret life as the Pier One princess and limes. Oh, and they recap the episode.

Michelle's season has begun and Annie and Hailey are ready to dig right into the drama. Hailey does her best to befumble Annie, while also starting to solidify her fave men of the season - where are my Olumide and Martin fans at? The girls discuss the elephant in the room (Katie and Blake's short-lived engagement), but to be honest, Annie and Hailey feel pretty meh about the whole thing, and are hoping for better luck with Michelle. The girls also speculate on the richest couples of Bachelor Nation; explain a Nebraska classic, Heritage School, to their listeners (#iykyk); and discuss Hailey's passion for apples, which seems to be at least slightly stronger than Rodney's.

Hello Befumbled buds! This week, we're befumbled about everything. Well, Hailey isn't but Annie definitely is. We didn't get a look at the guys because Annie needed a break last week (oops), and then her descriptions to Hailey certainly weren't anything to write home about. But hey, it's only night one baby! It just gets better from here... hopefully?

In case you were wondering if Annie and Hailey like Joe and Serena, this episode is them just 60 minutes of them spiraling over the best Paradise couple of all time. Hailey recaps the final whirlwind six hours of this year's Bachelor in Paradise. The girls check their BIP predictions made at the beginning of the season, Hailey genuinely shocks Annie with all the twists and turns of the finale, and the girls reflect on what it's like for your ex to get married.

It's been a crazy couple months, but the girls could not be more excited for Michelle's season.

ALSO SORRY MY CAT WAS PLAYING WITH A TOY FOR THE LAST TEN MINUTES OF THE EPISODE --HAILEY

If you’re sick of listening to Hailey and Annie's voices, they finally have a guest again! Annie’s boyfriend Chris joins the girls to help Annie befumble Hailey and recap the most recent episode of Bachelor in Paradise. Together, they analyze Joe and Kendall’s history and speculate which couples are going to ask after paradise. Also... What do they drink and eat on Paradise? Does Wells actually make drinks?