Annie & Hailey are back with a brand new name and a brand new guest. This week they try to befumble their pal Maria on all the deets of Matt James' night one ladies. Plus they reveal some amazing news about all their future guests (hint: it might involve wedding bells), confess their fave contestant and recap the rest of the dramatic no-sleep-sleepover that is night one!

Instagram - @befumbledpod

In preparation for Matt James' season, Annie and Hailey dive into his cast and their bios on ABC.com. They already have their favorites, but they speculate how accurately these bios reflect the women they're going to see on television. They discuss their favorites, their picks for villains, and what makes or breaks a good bio.