Beneath the Law

Beneath the Law

By Stories and StrategiesBusinessNewsNews CommentaryPolitics
Download on the App Store

All Beneath the Law episodes

  • The Needle and the Law: Who’s Really Protected?

    Send us Fan Mail

    Is our approach to drug addiction helping or hurting our cities? 

    Gavin and Stephen tackle one of the most controversial issues in modern urban life: safe injection sites and the opioid crisis. 

    The duo breaks down a controversial court injunction that temporarily blocked the government's plan to convert supervised injection sites into rehab-focused "hubs." But in a twist worthy of a legal thriller, it turns out 9 of the 10 sites had already voluntarily agreed to transition — a fact the judge was never told. 

    With sharp legal insight and candid commentary, they question whether harm reduction truly reduces harm—or if it's deepening the crisis. 

    Listen For

    8:37 Old Policy, New Crisis: Are Safe Sites Effective?

    15:17 Legal Showdown: Government vs. Harm Reduction

    23:54 Can Courts Force Policy?

    25:29 The Notwithstanding Clause: A Charter Time Bomb

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email  

    29 min
  • Sue You Later: The Rise of Vexatious Litigants

    Send us Fan Mail

    Ever been sued for making it rain? In this thought-provoking episode of Beneath the Law, Gavin Tighe and Stephen Thiele dive into the murky waters of vexatious litigants—those who weaponize the justice system for personal vendettas, harassing opponents with endless, frivolous lawsuits.  

    From gladiator references to baby stroller briefcases, they unpack real-world cases, including a wild Ontario saga involving 13 lawsuits, social media rants, and accusations of a legal crime syndicate. 

    They explore the gatekeeping role of the courts, the need for better safeguards like a vexatious litigant registry, and the human cost of unchecked legal abuse.  

    Listen For

    1:32 What Does “Vexatious Litigant” Even Mean?

    4:13 A Wild Case of 13 Lawsuits and a Legal Crime Syndicate

    6:06 How Courts Declare Someone Vexatious

    11:04 The Missing Registry: How Do We Track These People?

    12:24 The Baby Stroller Plaintiff: A Wild Legal Tale

    20:39 SLAPP Suits and the Broader Problem

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email  

    26 min
  • Lawfare: When Law Courts Become Political Battlefields

    Send us Fan Mail

    Are the courts becoming the new political battlegrounds? 

    Gavin and Stephen dive into the concept of "lawfare"—the weaponization of the legal system for political gain. 

    Focusing on the Ontario Place redevelopment case, they explore the delicate balance between democratic governance and the courts' role as a check on power. 

    As they reflect on the nostalgic past of Ontario Place, the hosts tackle complex legal issues like standing in litigation, the public trust doctrine, and the broader implications of challenging government decisions in court.

    Listen For:

    05:11: Ontario Place: A brief history of its rise and fall

    09:34: Standing in court: Who has the right to sue?

    19:58: Lawfare in action: How Ontario Place’s redevelopment became a battleground

    23:01: The “public trust” doctrine: A failed legal argument

    A Practical Guide to the Law of Defamation. ow.ly/Wnml50T6Zbe - This book offers guidance on current and developing defamation law in Canada. It lays out prominent cases, prevalent legal principles and more.

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click 

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    28 min
  • Disney vs. The Doctor: A Case of Arbitration and Tragedy

    Send us Fan Mail

    Are you aware of the hidden dangers lurking in your restaurant orders and online agreements? 

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen discuss a tragic case involving a fatal food allergy at a Disney Springs restaurant. 

    They dive into the legal complications that arose, particularly focusing on Disney's controversial attempt to force the case into arbitration based on a seemingly unrelated online agreement. 

    The discussion highlights the broader implications of clicking "I agree" without understanding the potential legal consequences. Tune in to hear how this case unfolded and the lessons it offers about food safety and legal agreements.

    Listen For:

    02:29 - Tragic Allergy: A Fatal Dinner at Disney Springs

    09:27 - Wrongful Death Claims: Surprising Low Damages

    17:52 - Arbitration vs. Court: The Hidden Costs

    22:15 - Contracts of Adhesion: The Click That Binds You

    A Practical Guide to the Law of Defamation. ow.ly/Wnml50T6Zbe - This book offers guidance on current and developing defamation law in Canada. It lays out prominent cases, prevalent legal principles and more.

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    32 min
  • Libel, Lies, and Lawsuits: Dong vs. Global News

    Send us Fan Mail

    Is the media failing us with sensationalism? 

    In this episode, Stephen and Gavin explore the controversial defamation lawsuit involving Canadian MP Han Dong and Global News. 

    They discuss the critical issue of media responsibility in reporting, the allegations of Chinese interference in Canadian politics, and the resulting legal battle. 

    The conversation highlights the challenges faced by mainstream media in maintaining credibility in a sensationalized landscape, the legal principles surrounding defamation and anti-SLAPP motions, and the broader implications for democracy and public trust.

    Listen For:

    04:20 - Manipulation of Facts in Modern Media

    09:01 - Defamation Lawsuit Against Global News

    24:09 - Potential Consequences for Global News

    29:46 - The Future of Media Credibility and Public Trust

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email 

    32 min
  • Injunction granted to remove U of T campers

    Send us Fan Mail

    Background

    - October 2023 terrorist action in Israel in which over 1,000 people were killed by Hamas has led to war in the Gaza Strip

    - War has resulted in displacement of Palestinians and estimates of over 30,000 killed

    - In response, there have been numerous pro-Palestinian protest and anti-war protests, including at University campuses in the United States and Canada

    - Injunctions to remove protestors in Quebec had failed

    - After more than a month of occupation of King’s College Circle, U of T brought an application to remove pro-Palestinian encampment on the grounds that protestors were engaged in an unlawful trespass of the university’s property

    Injunction proceeding

    - University is private education institution, not affiliated with government

    - Property of the university is private, but with spaces open to the public 

    - King’s College Circle is for use by the entire university population and is also a tourist attraction

    - After attempting to engage in negotiations with protestors, U of T finally issued a Trespass Notice under provincial Trespass legislation, but police would not enforce notice

    - Required U of T to go to court for an injunction

    - U of T argued that protestors had caused damage and had engaged in violent actions on campus, and that occupation was simply illegal as the grounds constituted private university property

    - To obtain an injunction, generally required to establish serious issue to be tried, irreparable harm and that balance of convenience favours the granting of an injunction; however, serious issue to be tried standard elevated to prima facie case where result is a mandatory injunction, like the removal of the encampment

    - Court finds that U of T’s argument that protestors engaged in violent actions or were engaged in expressions of hate toward others not proven; no prima facie case on these allegations

    - However, court finds that there was a prima facie case on the issue of trespass; property belonged to U of T and occupation of King’s College Circle was essentially exclusive to the pro-Palestinian protestors

    - Protestors controlled entry to King’s College Circle and only permitted those sympathetic to their position entry to the King’s College Circle grounds

    - King’s College Circle, however, was an area of U of T to be used by the entire University community and others such as tourists

    - Protestors relied on Charter to protect themselves against removal from the encampment; contended that they had a right to freely express themselves and associate together in protest

    - Court finds that Charter did not apply to protect protestor because protestors had not provided notice of constitutional question as required under law, but that Charter did not provide protection in a trespass case. In any event, Trespass Act was reasonable limit prescribed by law

    - As well, court noted that protestors were actually violating free expression of others because of their control of King’s College Circle and who was permitted entry

    - In connection with the injunction test, there was a clear trespass

    - In most cases, a clear trespass ends the inquiry and a party is not required to prove irreparable harm or satisfy the balance of convenience test

    - U of T, however, suffered irreparable harm because of damage to its property that would not be recoverable from the protestors; act of trespass on its own constituted strong irreparable harm

    - U of T also suffered reputational loss because of the protest

    - With respect to balance of convenience, court found that the protestors were not being absolutely prohibited from protesting; this weighed in favour of U of T who had established that it suffered harm

    - Public space of campus had been taken over by protestors to the exclusion of others and in breach of rights of U of T to control the use of its own property

    29 min
  • Justice Served: The Widow Who Defeated the Bank

    Send us Fan Mail

    An elderly widow scored a courtroom victory!

    In this episode, Stephen and Gavin dive into the gripping legal battle between a powerful Canadian bank and an elderly widow over a disputed $50,000 credit card debt. 

    They unravel the complexities of the case, highlighting the bank's aggressive tactics, the widow's defense as an authorized user, and the court's sympathy for her plight. 

    The discussion explores broader issues of predatory lending, the ethics of increasing credit limits without consent, and the nuances of law versus equity in the judicial system. 

    Listen For:

    02:50 - The Modern Credit Card

    09:40 - Authorized User Defense

    14:03 - Missing Evidence

    23:12 - Law vs. Equity

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    32 min
  • Risky Business: Understanding Waivers of Liability

    Send us Fan Mail

    Ever wonder why you never read the fine print?  

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen look into the often-overlooked world of waiver of liability clauses. They discuss a recent British Columbia case where a mountaineering company's liability waiver was scrutinized after a climber was injured. 

    They explain the importance of these clauses for businesses, the strict standards courts apply to enforce them, and how they balance protecting economic interests with ensuring consumer safety. 

    Listen For:

    02:49 - The Case of the Injured Rock Climber

    09:28 - The Role of Clear and Concise Language

    18:00 - Waivers in Consumer Contracts

    25:42 - Waivers and Minors: A Legal Gray Area

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click 

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    33 min
  • Blackballed by the Bank: One Customer’s Legal Battle

    Send us Fan Mail

    From defamed to victorious: A mortgage manager’s triumphant battle.

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen discuss a case where the plaintiff, accused of fraudulently processing mortgages, was blackballed within the banking industry due to a defamatory alert. 

    The court found the bank's defenses of justification and qualified privilege unconvincing, leading to significant damages, including punitive damages for the bank's reckless disregard of the truth. 

    This case underscores the importance of careful and truthful communication, especially when wielding the substantial influence of a major financial institution. 

    Listen For:

    02:21 - Defamation in Canada

    08:48 - Fraud Discovery

    17:14 - Investigator’s Role

    24:03 - Damages Breakdown

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email 

    34 min
  • Greasy Harvey Weinstein’s Case Reversal

    Send us Fan Mail

    Weighing justice and prejudice in the Weinstein case reversal.

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen explore the controversial overturning of Harvey Weinstein's conviction. They explore the nuanced and often polarizing landscape of legal standards, particularly focusing on the balance of evidence and the dangers of prejudicial character evidence in sexual assault cases. 

    They discuss the implications of Weinstein's case on the #MeToo movement, the role of similar fact evidence, and how past behaviours are used in court to shape perceptions of guilt or innocence, shedding light on the complexity of ensuring fair trials in the emotionally charged atmosphere of high-profile sexual misconduct cases. 

    Listen For:

    04:57 - Review of Weinstein’s charges and trial evidence

    08:50 - Analyzing the appeals court decision

    18:29 - Contextual challenges in the Weinstein trial

    20:57 - Power dynamics and consent in sexual assault cases 

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click 

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    33 min