Beneath the Law

Beneath the Law

By Stories and StrategiesBusinessNewsNews CommentaryPolitics
Download on the App Store

All Beneath the Law episodes

  • The Democratic Dilemma of Judicial Selection

    Send us Fan Mail

    Judicial appointments spark controversy. 

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen dive into the contentious debate surrounding the political nature of judicial appointments in Ontario. They discuss Ontario Premier Ford's candid remarks on crime and bail, the inherent political process of selecting judges, and the criticisms levelled against this system. 

    Addressing everything from the role of laypeople in judicial committees to the independence of the judiciary post-appointment, the hosts argue that while the process is far from perfect, it is deeply rooted in democratic principles. 

    They champion the idea that judges, once appointed, are shielded from the political fray, able to exercise their duties with impartiality—a cornerstone of the Canadian legal system.

    Listen For:

    4:20 - The Provincial Power to Appoint

    11:21 - Reality of Supreme Court Appointments

    19:36 - Independence of the Judiciary

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email 

    31 min
  • Trump, 14th Amendment, and the Ballot Battle

    Send us Fan Mail

    It's a constitutional showdown. Gavin and Stephen discuss into the implications of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, particularly in light of recent events including the January 6th riots and legal actions concerning former President Donald Trump.  

    They explore the historical context and application of the amendment, especially Section 3, which pertains to insurrection and its consequences for political participation. 

    The conversation also explores a recent legal decision from Colorado that sought to remove Trump's name from the ballot, examining its constitutionality and potential impacts on U.S. democracy and the electoral system. 

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    36 min
  • Puck, Power, Prosecution: Canada’s Jr Hockey Scandal

    Send us Fan Mail

    Hockey, scandal, and the law.

    Gavin, Stephen, and guest Lad Kucis review a controversial case that’s made headlines across the Country. It involves former members of the Canadian World Junior Championship hockey team, now facing criminal charges for an alleged sexual assault that occurred six years prior. 

    Amidst the legal discourse, the conversation critically examines the interplay between civil settlements and subsequent criminal proceedings, the impact on the accused players' careers, and the broader implications for the sport's integrity and the justice system at large. 

    The episode is a potent reminder of the complexities and consequences when sports icons fall from grace, leaving a trail of legal quandaries and societal reflection in their wake.

    Listen For:

    2:47 – The Incident Unveiled

    5:34 – Regulatory Bodies React

    7:40 – The Civil Settlement Conundrum

    23:56 – Public Perception and Prejudice

    Guest: Lad Kucis, Gardiner Roberts

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    38 min
  • Riding into Risk: A Legal Look at ATV Safety

    Send us Fan Mail

    An ATV, a tragic turn, and a court decision that changed everything.

    Hosts Gavin and Stephen, dive into the Ontario Court of Appeal's ruling on de Roche v McInnis. The case unravels the duty of care owed not just by drivers, but by vehicle owners, accentuating the utmost importance of insurance and proper training. 

    They reflect on the broader implications for owners of recreational vehicles, the devastating consequences of negligence, and the workings of statutory interpretation, emphasizing the importance of having insurance for recreational vehicles.

    This discussion is a stark reminder that with the thrill of high-speed adventure comes a weighty responsibility, echoing the dire need for precaution and protection in the realm of recreational vehicle use. 

    Listen For:

    3:15 - Introducing the Case: de Roche v McInnis

    8:45 - The Duty of Care Explained: Navigating Negligence

    17:32 - Understanding Statutory Interpretation

    22:41 - Insuring Adventure: The Safety Net of Liability

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Read Stephen’s blog on the McGinnis case

    2024 ONCA 63 (CanLII) | Desrochers v. McGinnis | CanLII (McGinnis case)

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    29 min
  • Confidentiality vs. Transparency: The Supreme Court’s Stand on Mandate Letters

    Send us Fan Mail

    The Supreme Court of Canada has really stirred the pot this time. The issue is whether mandate letters should be subject to disclosure. Mandate letters are instructions or views given to cabinet ministers by the leader of a government. 

    Sparked by CBC News' request for one collection of letters from 2018, the legal battle questioned their confidentiality. Ultimately, the Supreme Court reversed lower court rulings, emphasizing the importance of cabinet confidentiality for democracy and effective governance. 

    Gavin and Stephen Thiele explore the decision's implications, arguing it protects necessary government deliberation zones, akin to privacy in other professional realms. They critique the media's and opposition's transparency demands, suggesting such pressures could undermine responsible government by stifling free debate and decision-making within the cabinet. 

    Listen For:

    1:13 The Impact on Democracy and Governance

    6:34 Legal and Constitutional Framework

    11:36 Media’s Role and Responsibility

    17:07 Implications for Legal Scholarship

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    30 min
  • Digital Words – Real Damages: Defamation in the Age of Instagram

    Send us Fan Mail

    Gavin and Stephen discuss a defamation case involving a social media influencer in Edmonton, Alberta. The influencer, Rosemary, had a falling out with a couple, leading to a series of defamatory posts about them on her Instagram account. The court found in favour of the couple, awarding the female plaintiff $50,000 and the male plaintiff $75,000.  

    This highlights the importance of being careful about what you post on social media, as defamation can lead to significant legal consequences. They also discuss the challenges of applying old defamation laws to new technology and the changing nature of media.

    Listen For

    1:54 There’s Been a Seismic Shift in Defamation Law Due to Social Media

    3:04 Challenges in Applying Traditional Law to New Technology

    4:56 The Role of Social Media Influencers in Defamation

    11:08 The Difficulty of Enforcing Defamation Judgements 

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    30 min
  • The Federal Court’s Verdict on the Use of the Emergencies Act

    Send us Fan Mail

    In this episode Gavin and Stephen discuss the recent decision by the federal court on the challenge to the constitutionality and legality of the federal government's decision to invoke the Emergencies Act in response to the trucker convoy protest in Canada.  

    They argue the protest was non-violent and did not pose a threat to the security of Canada, making the use of the Emergencies Act unreasonable and ultra vires of the federal government. They also express concern about the potential for damages to be awarded to those who were unlawfully injured by the misuse of the statute, which could result in significant costs for Canadian taxpayers. 

    No doubt where this one’s headed… the Supreme Court of Canada.

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    34 min
  • How Expensing Two Sandwiches Cost a Banker His Job

    Send us Fan Mail

    In this episode we’re unwrapping the tale of the Banker’s Sandwich Scandal. 

    You might have read the headlines. Szabolcs Fekete, a financial crime expert at Citibank was fired by the bank after claiming a two-sandwich lunch on expenses. He’d claimed he ate one sandwich for lunch then ate the second for dinner. 

    But under closer scrutiny he admitted he had travelled with a partner and the second sandwich was for them.

    But is firing the right price for this deception? Seems a high cost for a low price. In this episode Gavin and Stephen put a bit more “meat in the sandwich” so to speak and explain the rest of the story.

    Listen For

    1:32 Understanding the Foundation of the Employer-Employee Relationship

    6:56 The Consequences of Dishonesty and the Cover-Up

    16:04 Contextual Approach and Intention in Legal Analysis

    27:05 The Importance of Clear Policies and Fair Process 

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    30 min
  • Trump, Trust, and the American legal System

    Send us Fan Mail

    Have former US President Donald Trump’s legal battles exposed biases within the Us judicial system?

    How do you think the election of judges affects their impartiality and the perception of justice in the US?

    How does public confidence in the judiciary impact the overall health of a democracy?

    In this episode, Gavin and Stephen would argue YES to all of the above.  And they argue the American judicial system may not survive the divisive political climate. 

    Listen For

    1:16 Trump’s Exclusion from the Ballot in Colorado

    3:25 Politicization of Judiciary and Judicial Appointments

    6:53 Public Confidence and the Health of Democracy

    9:18 Trump’s Influence on the Perception of Judicial Bias

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    38 min
  • Legal Bodychecks: Navigating Criminal and Civil Liability in Hockey

    Send us Fan Mail

    Gavin and Stephen discuss the intersection of law and sports, specifically focusing on incidents in hockey where players have been criminally charged or sued for their actions on the ice. 

    There have been high-profile cases, such as those involving NHL players Dino Ciccarelli, Marty McSorley, and Todd Bertuzzi, who were all charged with assault for their actions during games. They also discuss a recent case in England where a player was charged with involuntary manslaughter after his skate blade cut another player's throat, resulting in his death. 

    There is potential for both criminal and civil liability in sports. Players need to understand the potential consequences of their actions. And there are also challenges in determining damages in such cases, particularly when a player's professional career is ended due to an injury. 

    Listen For

    5:45 Consent and Liability in Sports

    8:03 Incidents Leading to Criminal Charges in Sports

    11:29 Civil Liability and Damages in Sports Injuries

    20:18 Legal Implications of Sports Regulations and Player Conduct

    Contact Us

    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email

    35 min