Beneath the Law

Beneath the Law

By Stories and StrategiesBusinessNewsNews CommentaryPolitics
Download on the App Store

All Beneath the Law episodes

  • The Sad Story of Former Supreme Court Justice Russell Brown

    Send us Fan Mail

    Last month, Russell Brown announced he was stepping down as a justice of the Supreme Court of Canada. His resignation put a halt to the Canadian Judicial Council’s probe of a claim of misconduct directed against Brown related to an incident in the United States. And it means there won’t be a public report on the matter.

    Accounts of the incident differ but it has been established there was some kind of fight between Brown and a US Marine veteran at a resort in Scottsdale, Arizona. The Marine veteran, Jon Crump, alleged Brown was belligerent and harassed his female drinking companions. 

    There’s a lot more to this story.

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

     

    33 min
  • When Chat GPT Hallucinates Your Case Studies

    Send us Fan Mail

    In June 2023, prosecutors for a case in New York filed a motion backed by six case studies. The defending attorneys looked at the case studies and scratched their heads… they never heard of these cases.

    It turns out the six cases had been found by the prosecuting attorneys using Chat GPT, the generative AI tool. As artificial intelligence tools are prone to do, Chat GPT hallucinated the cases. They didn’t exist.

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

     

    32 min
  • My Sugar Daddy is a Lawyer

    Send us Fan Mail

    It’s a concept known as Sugaring or Sugar Dating. A website service created to connect generally older males with younger females. Sugar Daddies.

    The older men are generally expected to provide younger women with gifts and money. The expectations of the younger women can vary.

    A very old (and somewhat creepy) concept. 

    But in this particular case, the Sugar Daddy, was a lawyer. And the issue was professional conduct.


    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

     

    26 min
  • Social Media Vigilantism

    Send us Fan Mail

    There’s a scene in the 1931 film “Frankenstein” that conjures an easy image – an angry mob of people storm the castle of Dr Frankenstein armed with pitchforks.

    Nearly a century later we the people still have the same mentality, we just prefer to do it online.

    In 2013, a Nova Scotia woman, convicted several times under the Animal Protection Act over more than a decade, became the focus of online anger. Someone developed a Facebook page, using her name prominently committed to harassing her. People posted angry comments toward her, someone suggested she should be beat to a pulp, and others suggested she should be shot. 

    But harassment is also a crime in the Criminal code. Ruling on this case was finally handed down a few months ago.

    In this episode, vigilante harassment? Or vigilante justice?

     

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

    28 min
  • The Municipal Candidate Who Lost By One Vote

    Send us Fan Mail

    Robert Pella was a candidate in the most recent municipal election running for Catholic School Trustee in the City of Toronto. He was running against an incumbent and fought a tough battle and lost… but by only ONE VOTE.

    He first went to the school board and asked for a recount. They refused.

    So, he had to go to court and won his case, but with strict restrictions in place. You need to hear the rest of this story. 

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

    34 min
  • If a Golf Ball Hits a Neighbouring House…

    Send us Fan Mail

    If you own a property bordering a golf course you know the risk involved. Stray shots will see golf balls enter your property or maybe even hit your house.

    Who is responsible for damages? The homeowner? The Golf Course? The Golfer?

    As with all things involving the Law, it depends. There are various claims homeowners can make including negligence and yes the Course and the golfer themselves can be named.

    In this episode Gavin and Stephen go through the case studies to find responsibility is a narrow fairway.

    Read Stephen’s blog on this subject https://www.grllp.com/blog/Golf-course-liable-for-escaping-golf-balls-467 

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

    28 min
  • A Prime Minister, Rocks Thrown, and Using the Legal Process to Gain Political Points

    Send us Fan Mail

    Prime Minister Justin Trudeau gets a lot thrown at him. But in 2021 in southern Ontario, the CEO of the Peoples Party of Canada, a rival party, threw a handful of small rocks at him. 

    Unquestionably that should never have happened. There’s no room for that in our society. Charges were laid and the accused acknowledged what he had done. But as part of his defense, he wanted the Prime Minister called to give evidence at the trial.

    Trudeau decided to challenge the subpoena and won his challenge. He wasn’t required to testify.

    Normally a defendant is given every opportunity to defend themselves in a court of law including calling witnesses, but would the Prime Minister’s testimony have lent anything to the legal proceedings? Or was this an effort simply to try to gain political points?

    Read Stephen’s blog on this story 

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

    26 min
  • Are the Charges Against Donald Trump Politically Motivated?

    Send us Fan Mail

    In late March 2023, a Manhattan grand jury indicted former US President Donald Trump on more than 30 counts related to business fraud. 

    Sounds ominous. Is it though? Is a grand jury truly… Grand?

    A Judge in New York once said a prosecutor could indict a ham sandwich in front of a Grand Jury because the process is designed to do the prosecution’s bidding.

    In this first episode of Beneath the Law, Canadian lawyers Gavin Tighe and Stephen Thiele examine what the charges really mean, what the grand jury process is really about, and how these legal proceedings might spill into political impacts.

    Is it time for just desserts? Or ham sandwiches?

    Gardiner Roberts website https://www.grllp.com/

    Email Gavin Tighe [email protected]

    Email Stephen Thiele [email protected]

    39 min
  • Is Toronto's Homelessness Crisis Out of Control?

    Send us Fan Mail

    Are Toronto’s homeless encampments pushing the city to its breaking point?

    Gavin and Stephen sit down with Dana McKiel, former sports broadcaster and founder of Toronto's Downtown Concerned Citizen Coalition (DCCO).

    McKiel offers a firsthand look at the challenges faced by Toronto's downtown residents, highlighting the rise of homelessness, makeshift camps, and their significant impact on the community.

    They discuss the city’s evolving response, from controversial "homeless hotels" to facilitated public encampments, questioning the effectiveness of current policies.

    Listen for:
    04:42 Homeless Hotels & Pricey Contracts
    10:18 Explosions & Danger in Public Parks
    19:21 Encampment “Whack-a-Mole”
    24:29 Tourists & Homeless in the Same Hotel?

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Connect with guest: DANA MCKIEL, Founder Downtown Concerned Citizen Coalition
    LinkedIn

    Contact Us
    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email  

    32 min
  • Criminally Charged for Shooting Her Neighbour… With a Water Gun

    Send us Fan Mail

    What happens when a water gun incident lands someone in court?

    Gavin and Stephen dive into the bizarre case of a 63-year-old woman charged with assault for spraying her neighbour with a water gun.

    What initially appears to be a ridiculous legal issue turns out to have deeper, darker undertones involving allegations of racism and long-standing neighbourhood animosity.

    The unintended consequences of being criminally charged, from legal fees to job suspension, to the use of valuable court resources on trivial disputes.

    Listen For:
    02:36 Assault with a weapon... or a joke gone too far?
    09:02 What makes an act criminal? Legal definitions explained
    16:15 Legal aftermath: What happens if the charges are dropped?
    21:02 Good fences make good neighbors... or do they?

    Leave a rating/review for this podcast with one click

    Contact Us
    Gardiner Roberts website | Gavin email | Stephen email  

    23 min