Best Comics Ever

Best Comics Ever

By By Dave Buesing (Comic Book Herald)ArtsBooksLeisureVisual ArtsHobbies
Download on the App Store

Best Comics Ever episodes

  • Krakin’ Krakoa #93: X-Men X Of Swords Pt. 1 – Creation Review!

    It begins! The 60+ page “Creation” kickoff to X-Men: X of Swords is here, marking the epic beginning to the 22 part X-Men event of 2020.  The launch book is fantastic, effectively a Lord of the Rings for the Krakoa era of X-Men, with plenty to dig into.

    Today I’ll answer:

    • How does Creation kick off Ten of Swords, and what do we learn about the event?
    • What major or minor revelations are given, and what X-Men characters are most impacted?
    • What are the secrets of Otherworld and S.W.O.R.D.?
    • Theories and predictions for what’s to come!
    • X-Men: X of Swords – Creation #1

      Writer: Jonathan Hickman & Tini Howard

      Art: Pepe Larraz

      Colors: Marte Gracia

      Letters: Clayton Cowles

      Related Reading Orders:

      Hickman’s X-Men

      X of Swords event

      Video Script Notes!

      We open with the first horsemen pounding on the gates of Otherworld, approaching the Starlight Citadel, on their ultimate march to Krakoa. As we learned in X-Men #12 last week, these first horsemen are the children of Apocalypse, and have been trapped in the dimension of Amenth of generations. The first horsemen leading an assault on the tower of Del Di’Lorr. The speak exactly like Hickman’s East of West horsemen.

      What is the Starlight Citadel? The Starlight Citadel is summarized nicely as “the most literal representation of the conjunction of all realities.” It is the nexus of all realities. As we’ve learned in the pages of Tini Howard’s Excalibur, the Citadel is without it’s customary Captain Britain Corps defense, which has left it to Opal Luna Saturnyne, Omniversal Majistrex to protect the Citadel – and by proxy, reality.

      Hickman’s back on his Wheels within Wheels grind here, a frequent refrain back in his work on Marvel’s Secret Warriors, and a decent metaphor for plots seeding plots and the constant motion of story found in his superhero work.

      In Krakoa, Summoner comes busting through the External Gate on the back of a huge Demon, with a dying Banshee. It’s far from shocking that Apocalypse’s plan to send Banshee, Unus the Untouchable (poor Unus) and Summoner into Arakko alone came up wanting, and if you aren’t already getting Summoner skepticism at this point, you’re a little behind the curve my Krakoan pal.

      This is generally applicable throughout the entire book, but DAMN do I love Pepe Lararz and Marte Gracia’s ability to bring demonic and supernatural creatures to life.

      Apocalypse brings his schemes to the Quiet Council, and Krakoa acknowledges he gave Apoc approval for all this. Apocalypse doesn’t really have council approval for all this though, with Magneto in particular deeply questioning his actions. Again, Summoner giving us his account of what happened with no backup (banshee is in a coma in the healing gardens) should raise some eyebrows.

      Small detail but weird that Professor X calls Apoc En Sabah Nur, and not his mutant name

      For the most part, the Council is opposed to Apocalypse leaving the External gate open and maintain access to alternate realms (and in this case near direct access to the Starlight Citadel of Otherworld). As Kate points out – for the first time we’ve seen in a council meeting! – they still have access to Avalon.

      I did also find it interesting here that the enemies of Krakoa that are named – Homines Verendi, The Flower Cartel, Xeno, and Orchis – leave out The Children of the Vault, who have been named the most dangerous threat to mutants by Professor X himself.

      Hell yeah Krakoa: Council votes to destroy the External Gate since it leaves them vulnerable, but Krakoa tells Doug “You need to understand you are guests here. Our coexistence is collaborative and wonderful. It’s a union of shared interests, but I am the land. And the land is mine.“

      This was actually something I brought up in the Live Krakin’ Krakoa X of Swords prediction party, but we have not gotten a lot of insight into how Krakoa feels about mutants! This is a great start.

      Apocalypse has to gather volunteers, leading to an interesting hodgepodge team, which has been one of the more interesting components of Krakoa – since all the mutants are together all the time, the team’s are less standardized than they’ve been in the past.

      The fellowship: Apocalypse, Summoner, Rockslide, Rictor, Siryn, Beast, Angel, Polaris, Havok, Monet

      There’s a really nice quote about what’s coming for Apocalypse in “Memory is long. History is longer. And the truth will outlast both.“

      One of the joys of the Dawn of X is given the scale of mutants that can be in any story, there are all kinds of long lasting relationships that still haven’t been explored more than a year into the Hickman era. One such is Angel and Apocalypse.

      In the midst of this build-up, we have even more exciting news: We’re Hickman/Mueller mapping Otherworld baby! This is quite fun, and I think going to go a long way to making Excalibur even more interesting, as one detractor I’ve felt in that book is a chaotic sense of place as the Mutant team makes its way through the realm.

      We’ve either seen most of these realms before, or find out some more info about the Otherworld Kingdoms in the next data pages in this issue, but the one real interesting callout is  #13 – Mercator – Highlighted in blue.

      Absalom Mercator, otherwise known as Mister M, is one of two Omega Level Mutants we still haven’t seen in the Dawn of X (the other is Legion), and that sure doesn’t seem like an accident. Mercator projection is also a whole school of cartography, which is an intriguing connection to this map of Otherworld, although I won’t pretend to understand maps literally at all – I can barely make it home from work without my GPS rolling.

      The page that made me the happiest of anything in this entire comic comes from The Otherworld Kingdoms map where we’rehitting Otherworld history, and in particular the Alan Moore / Alan Davis Captain Britain work hard! In the span of one page on the Fair Courts and Foul Courts, we get The Fury, Mad Jim Jaspers, Roma, Merlyn

      The main reason this is thrilling is I have a Krakin’ Krakoa coming this weekend (it’ll be Krakin’ Krakoa #95) on the Alan Moore and Alan Davis run on Captain Britain and it’s connections to the Hickman era of X-Men, and this data page cements that relevance in ways I yet again totally precogged.

      So given I’m covering this in depth in another video, I’ll just say that these are all absolutely crucial, historical elements in the history of Otherworld and the pages of Captain Britain, with Jaspers and the Fury offering serious threats to mutantdom in the future. I’m also fascinated by the presence of Roma and Merlyn here, who I thought had fallen prior to Saturnyne’s ascension (in the past Opal Luna has effectively reported up to them, although now that relationship is inversed).

      Apocalypse is genuinely emotional upon the sight of his long lost children, and I buy that this is actually a huge poignant moment for him. This is definitely the softest we’ve seen Apocalypse – and he pays for it – but honestly his arc through both Excalibur and X-Men has justified these feelings.

      Of Genesis, the horsemen tell Big Daddy A: “Gone. Destroyed. She fell under the twilight blade.” If anything, this frankly confirms my theory – growing in size and strength – that Genesis and Annihilation are still actually the same person, and that the Summoner’s story was a ruse.

      I still love my theory that Annihilation could be Rasputin. But again if we look back to the Genesis and Annihilation showdown in X-Men #12, and we consider what we know now about our pal Summoner, the changes that this story lies somewhere between half truth and metaphor is a distinct possibility.

      Unsurprisingly, horsemen and Summoner stab apocalypse, in a sudden betrayal of their father and grandfather. We learn about the same time that Summoner betrayed Banshee and Unus (nobody touch poor sweet Unus!), not shocking there either!

      While the story definitely sets us up to think this might be coming, the important thing here is that Apocalypse does not see it coming at all.

      “I am a Summoner of many things… Most of all lies”

      Really feel for Rockslides Arakkon chess game with Summoner.

      Everything goes absolutely to hell for the Krakoan party

      One aspect that goes overlooked throughout the series, and really throughout Excalibur to this point is just how powerful Saturnyne is in her domain of Otherworld, and as the ruler of protecting all realities. The comic’s opening quote supports her power, stating: “All I see, I own. And I am unsatisfied with the state of things.”

      With a snap of her fingers Saturnyne freezes both Krakoan and Arrakan, and gets to have a conversation and set up the rest of the event on her own terms.

      Saturnyne plays matchmaker setting up the duel between Arakko and Krakoa, after first flexing her power and turning Death into a cute lil wolf pup.

      All the swords get named. On the X side of things we have

      • Muramasa – Wolverine
      • The Sword of Might – (Brian Braddock ?)
      • The Starlight Sword – (Betsy Braddock ?)
      • Grasscutter & Godkiller – Gorgon
      • Warlock – Doug Ramsey
      • The Soul Sword – Magik
      • The Scarab – Apocalypse
      • The Light of Galador – Cable
      • Skybreaker – Storm
      • The items that most get my attention on the Amenth side are 1) The Twlight Blade – is this the same thing as the Twilight Sword Surtur has wieleded in Thor comics? 2) Pogg Ur-Pogg being both crocodile monster AND a sword himself, with the implication that the swords are wielding a Crocodile monster 3) Muramasa listed on both sides of the aisle! Marvel’s been teasing Solem as Wolverine’s new archenemy, and remember, Apocalypse talks of the God-like mutants he had to banish to Amenth. Solem could be of Earth before Wolverine, potentially an ancestor, wielding the same kind of blade.

        If folks are interested in a Krakin’ Krakoa deep dive on the swords specifically, let me hear it in the comments, as most of them tend to have fairly interesting comics histories on their own.

        As Cable and Rachel read Banshee’s mind for clues about what really happened, Saturnyne tells Cable / Rachel of something that can help. Scott knows what it is. My initial guess given AIM bodies is something with The World? But it appears to be more about space travel to specific space station.

        Scott, Jean, Cable plunge Cable’s dope sword into a trans space teleportation platform, which powers up SWORD orbital space station.

        Given the official confirmation of a S.W.O.R.D. ongoing by Al Ewing and Valerio Schiti (which, I will not for the last time, mention I totally called in my How Hickman’s X-Men Will Conquer the GalaXy video!), this is incredibly exciting.

        Intriguingly, all we learn of the SWORD station at this point is that it’s like totally out of action.

        So why would Saturnyne send them SWORD? Well, she’s corralling alien entities, perhaps that’s where answers lie? My guess here, would be contact made with the other faction of Arakko natives who took a different approach like Summoner mentioned in his story to Grandaddy A in X-Men #12.

        Now, early in the oversized issue, we actually get a return to the 2020 Free Comic Book Day Tarot Card teasers. Reprint the X-Men FCBD pages of catching a star-beast in context of the event. Literally reprinting the FCBD pages in their entirity… kind of disappointed initially, but the text is completely different.

        Importantly, too, The X-Office (of course) remembers there’s an original Hellion named Tarot! She does reading data pages! Tarot readers the world over – mutant and not – are pulling the same cards as Saturnyne.

        In the original: Eight of Cups card presents two different women, with Genesis feeling disullionsment and abandonment, and Annihilation’s side reading “That which was once the harmonious lifting of voices is now a mocking echo-then silence.”

        The updated reading of the card is recontextualized given what we know from the X-Men #12 prelude issue. “Someone’s heart has been left empty” “She has been waiting for something more. Will she turn away? Will she be turned away? A woman like this keeps her cup close.”

        New theories? From Tini Howard interview, Tarot is another kind of sequential art. So I think the card readings are in the order they’ll occur in the event. Tarot’s own readings are very interesting.

        The sequence of events:

        1. Judgment – “Final judgment and the rebirth of all in heaven.” A couple thoughts here – this could allude to the apocalypse they bring and the rebirth of Arakko mutants on Krakoa, and on our Earth-616. Looking at the talk of rebirth, the cover of X-Factor #4 (pt 2 of the event, signifies resurrection literally on fire), and the December solicits for X-Factor call resurrection into question.
        2. Four of Wands – Returning to something, with an image of the horsemen. “The Xorn brothers would consider four quite an inauspicious number” – In Chinese numerology, the number 4 is considered unlucky because it is extremely similar to their word for “death”
        3. The Hanged Man – Kill Your Darlings. Apocalypse. Beast’s sacrifice. Rockslide is certainly imperiled. Rictor would be the sweetheart to Apocalypse.
        4. Eight of Cups. Genesis/Annihilation. Feels like she’s already decided!
        5. Ten of Swords. The worst pain you have ever felt and then you will feel it no more. I think something is going to change the availability / resurrection process. Apocalypse is going to come back without these memories. Will that mean the loss of him as a Krakoan ally?
        6. Next Time: The Krakoan Reads – A New Death

          The post Krakin’ Krakoa #93: X-Men X Of Swords Pt. 1 – Creation Review! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

          25 min
        7. Creannotators #18: “Old Head” Interview With Cartoonist Kyle Starks!

          This week on Creannotators, I talked with cartoonist Kyle Starks about his work on Old Head, one of my favorite graphic novels of 2020, a comedic masterpiece about a retired NBA player taking on Dracula and the monsters in his neighboring castle. Oh, also we talk NBA. Like, a lot.

          On Comic Book Herald’s ‘Creannotators’ I’ll be interviewing some of my favorite creators in comics about specific runs, graphic novels or series, looking for their insights on the inspirations behind the work and ideas or hidden material readers may have missed. Creannotators is an audio/visual annotative guide to enjoying the intricacies and thinking in the art. Thanks for listening, and enjoy the comics!

          Old Head Is:

          Cartoonist: Kyle Starks

          Colorist: Chris Schweizer

          ——————————————————————————————————-

          Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

          Subscribe on iTunes

          Subscribe on Android

          To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

          For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

          The post Creannotators #18: “Old Head” Interview With Cartoonist Kyle Starks! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

          55 min
        8. Krakin’ Krakoa #91 Live! X-Men: X of Swords Prediction Party (with Blerd Without Fear & The Cerebros!)

          This weekend marked the first ever Comic Book Herald Youtube livestream, and it went pretty well! I got to talk X-Men with Verno of The Cerebros podcast, and Ernie of Blerd Without Fear, and we dove into our X-Men: X of Swords event theories before kickoff on 9/23/2020! If you’re excited for the X-Men event, check out the (spoiler heavy!) conversation below.

          Spoilers for discussed comics will follow!

          It was a lot of fun and I hope to have more livestreams on the Krakin’ Krakoa youtube work coming in the future.

          Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

          Subscribe on iTunes

          Subscribe on Android

          To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

          For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

          The post Krakin’ Krakoa #91 Live! X-Men: X of Swords Prediction Party (with Blerd Without Fear & The Cerebros!) appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

          1 hr 7 min
        9. Creannotators #17: “Chasin’ The Bird” Interview With Creator Dave Chisholm!

          This week on Creannotators, I talked with creator Dave Chisholm about his work on the excellent Chasin’ The Bird, a graphic novel about the life of jazz legend Charlie Parker. We talk jazz history, bringing Parker’s mythology to this moment in time, and the distinct visual challenge of conveying music in comics.

          On Comic Book Herald’s ‘Creannotators’ I’ll be interviewing some of my favorite creators in comics about specific runs, graphic novels or series, looking for their insights on the inspirations behind the work and ideas or hidden material readers may have missed. Creannotators is an audio/visual annotative guide to enjoying the intricacies and thinking in the art. Thanks for listening, and enjoy the comics!

          Chasin’ The Bird is easily one of my favorite graphic novels of 2020, and one I expect we’ll be seeing on a lot of year-end best-of lists.

          Chasin’ The Bird Is:

          Creator: Dave Chisholm

          Colors: Peter Markowski

          You can find more from Dave Chisholm here:

          Thomson Heller Detective Interstellar

          Tyranny of the Muse

          ——————————————————————————————————-

          Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

          Subscribe on iTunes

          Subscribe on Android

          To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

          For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

          The post Creannotators #17: “Chasin’ The Bird” Interview With Creator Dave Chisholm! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

          48 min
        10. Krakin’ Krakoa #86: Why Does Sexuality in X-Men Comics Matter?

          Following my review of 2020’s X-Factor #1, I saw a fair amount of commentary from listeners and readers wondering why there’s all this focus on character sexuality in the book, specifically with queer X-Men. Hot on the heels of Marauders #12 and Kate Pryde’s same-sex kiss, the question is of course resurfacing, making it a good time to really dig into the relevance and importance of sexuality in the world of Marvel’s X-Men.

          Up front, I’ll admit this is a sensitive issue and I don’t pretend to have all the answers. This is my own attempt to wrestle with these recurring questions, and dissect them in the context of X-Men comics. While I think it would be nice, I don’t anticipate this conversation will change hearts and minds regarding perceptions of sexuality and gender in our world, but I do hope it will specifically address how these issues are integrated into Marvel’s X-Men comics, and why, at the end of the day, it makes sense and is a substantial net positive.

          The Question: Why All This Focus On Sexual Identity?

          First, it’s useful to clarify what readers mean by “all this focus on sex.” Notable examples from the Dawn of X, the era of X-Men comics following writer Jonathan Hickman’s return to Marvel with House of X / Powers of X, include the following:

          • The implication that Jean Grey / Wolverine / Cyclops may be in a polyamorous relationship (and the confirmation that Jean and Wolverine are in a relationship).
          • Reiterating Mystique and Destiny’s same-sex relationship, with Mystique angrily yelling “Give me back my wife!” at Professor X and Magneto.
          • A majority queer cast of mutants in the Leah Williams written X-Factor series launch
          • Emma Frost including “Trans” among the oppressed minorities she references in Marauders #10, and Kate Pryde kissing her female tattoo artist in Marauders #12.
          • As you can likely gauge from the examples, the conversation is less around the general horniness of the X-Men on their Krakoan island paradise (although certainly that gets a lot of discussion as well!), and more targeted toward queer or minority identity now being included in the pages of these comics.

            A Brief History of Sex

            The fact of the matter is that members of the LGBTQIA+ community in particular have been long withheld from X-Men Comics, and Marvel comics.

            Historical reasons to avoid making queer relationships explicit are due to societal pressure, and for Marvel Comics specifically, due to editorial pressure. According to an article on “Prism Comics,” during Jim Shooter’s late 70’s into 1987 tenure as Marvel’s Editor-in-Chief, there was an alleged “No gays in the Marvel Universe” policy. This can partially be assumed to reflect the desire to follow the Comics Code Authority, the Red Scare/McCarthyist propaganda directive that arose out of Frederick Werthem’s “Seduction of the Innocent” in 1954.

            According to History.com, it wasn’t until 1989 when the Code would allow for an openly gay character in Marvel or DC superhero comic books! There are creators who work in characters coded as gay prior (JM Dematteis work with Arnold Roth in the pages of Captain America comes to mind), but Marvel’s Northstar was the first to come out as openly gay in 1992’s Alpha Flight #106, a momentous declaration that was then largely ignored for years.

            Even after this, equating queerness with “sexual perversion” persisted, as Marvel has often labeled any books featuring actual queer characters as “adult” or “for mature audiences only.” This was the case in 2002 when Marvel announced the Rawhide Kid would come out as gay in a Marvel MAX comic.

            Following this announcement, in a (far from perfect) appearance on Crossfire in 2002 with host Tucker Carlson (for real), the strongest argument Stan Lee could muster was the following Seinfeldian point:

            “Let me just mention that Marvel Comics, we are entertainers. And we do books for everybody. And the characters in our books represent everybody. In the “X Men,” we have characters from all nationalities. We have both sexes. I didn’t write this book. I only learned about it yesterday. But I think it’s fine. Among us today, there are gay people. We have one gay hero. There’s nothing wrong with that. I’m sure there are gay heroes who exist.”

            Fear of accepting queer characters on the page is historically met with cowardice, to the everlasting failure of Marvel and the industry at large. Even the aforementioned Rawhide Kid’s coming out party (and I don’t want to oversell the importance of that book because it stinks!) was walked back only a few years later. That’s very recent history, and it’s far from the progressive uncompromisingly agenda-driven radical Marvel gets painted as by some of the angrier voices in this conversation.

            The last decade has decidedly improved on this deeply unbalanced past, from the first same-sex wedding in the pages of Astonishing X-Men #51, to the very recent 2020 wedding of Wiccan and Hulkling in Empyre: Avengers Aftermath.  Still, I think it’s crucial to acknowledge Marvel’s playing catch-up after decades of failure to represent queer communities. And there’s still plenty of work to be done.

            The History of the X-Men and the Mutant Metaphor

            Historically, the X-Men exist as a representation of oppressed minority groups across the board, born (to a degree) out of the Civil Rights movement of the 60’s, and growing in scope and scale since. The mutant metaphor is flexible, and the perspective you bring from your own life can often shape what you’re going to get out of a story. When you feel your own oppression in these stories, that is true for you as a reader. Pretending that’s not true just means that’s not a part of your perspective. And it’s ok to miss things! I miss elements of comics all the time! Listening to other voices, though, can help expand that awareness.

            Again, X-Men is particularly well-suited to metaphorically capture struggles for equality, with a group of mutants sworn to protect mankind, even those who fear and hate them. As Sara Century puts it in a Syfy.com article, “This franchise is a rarity in how consistently it has focused on highlighting the fallacy of bigotry as a major obstacle in its character’s lives, and portraying all forms of intolerance as being deeply wrong. That is what has drawn such a wide audience to X-Men, and it is what makes it stand out for so many readers. Outsiders have always flocked to this concept, and for very obvious reasons.”

            One of the clearest examples of the X-Men standing in for real world minorities comes in 1982’s Marvel original graphic novel #5, God Loves, Man Kills, by Chris Claremont and Brent Anderson. In “God Loves, Man Kills” Christian evangelical preacher William Stryker launches a massive religious movement centered around his absolute hatred of mutants. The combination of religion-fueled intolerance, and a congregation full of protesting humans with signs like “Go Home Mutie!” makes for a distinct, all too familiar connection to real-world bigotry. X-Men comics have varied in their approach to tackling these issues since, but the modernization of X-Men as a metaphor for oppressed minority is firmly cemented in the Marvel canon.

            In recent years, the mutant metaphor has more deliberately extended to LGBTQIA+ communities. One of the most frequent talking points lately is how modern depictions of known character’s sexuality may differ or seemingly run counter to their comics history. We saw this a lot with Iceman over the past 5 years, when writer Brian Michael Bendis revealed – in classic comics fashion, through time travel and mind-reading! – that Bobby Drake has been suppressing his gay sexuality. A thing that gets lost in a Marvel character coming out as queer later in their life is the idea that unless they were “Out and Proud” in the shared history of these properties prior to this point, the *new direction* simply doesn’t match up. But even in reality, this is simply untrue.

            When discussing Iceman’s sexuality, writer Anthony Gramuglia says, “That rings true for a deeply suppressed gay man. A person suppressing their sexuality that intensely would appear to everyone else like an average straight person because that’s what the role they’re convincing themselves they occupy. They aren’t JUST trying to fool everyone around them. They’re trying to fool themselves.”

            It’s not the same thing, but I’d also note that as comics fans we’re accustomed to big bold new changes that present the possibility for new stories. We accept these things as readers constantly; they are what keep a decades running universe occasionally fresh. Just look at Moira X! Prior to Hickman’s X-Men, Moira MacTaggert was a human ally to mutantkind, and one time love interest of Charles Xavier. Now she’s a mutant replaying lifelines, and the single most compelling concept in superhero comics. There’s a conservative type of reader who rejects these changes in favor of “staying true to the good ol’ days,” but for me, these are the ideas and new angles I live for.

            With Iceman, I will fully admit, the character as a gay man works best when understanding him as a closeted individual trying to pass, rather than retroactively arguing these were the intentions of the creators. Because for all their positive contributions to social justice, Stan Lee and Jack Kirby – I don’t believe – created Bobby Drake with the intention to show he was gay. If you’re interested more in retroactively examining the character’s history for clues that *are* there, I’d recommend the “Out Cold’ series of essays on Shelfdust.com.

            The History of Queer Kate Pryde

            In the more recent example of Kate Pryde in the Dawn of X, there’s a long history of bisexual subtext that is unquestionably part of the creator’s intent. From an interview with Chris Claremont on Jay and Miles X-Plain the X-Men: “With Kitty, the basic idea was, while she dated lots of people when she was an adolescent, the primal love of her life has always been Rachel.” That’s actually part of the creator’s intent he never quite made explicit.

            I don’t think this is Claremont retroactively trying to pull a JK Rowling either. Again, from Century on SyFy.com, “Well into the ‘80s, more and more queer subtext was played out on the pages: Illyana Rasputin and Kitty Pryde wrestling with each other in bed; Storm and Yukio’s fling; Mystique and Destiny appearing only in tangent to one another; Northstar’s lack of interest in women; Rachel Summers in her entirety… there was a lot of implied queerness in Claremont’s X-Men run.”

            The young Kitty Pryde joins the X-Men as a young teenager in Uncanny X-Men #129, a comic with a release date of January 1980 and a story that kickstarts the official “Dark Phoenix Saga.” Kitty would go on to become a central POV character in the X-Men’s Claremont-verse, bridging the gaps between X-Men, New Mutants, and Excalibur more than any other character in the world. Kitty’s journey – again starting as a fourteen year-old mutant coming to terms with her powers – is very much about finding her place, and understanding the Jewish mutant woman she’s becoming.

            This extends to sexuality as well, as it does for so many in their formative adolescent years. The most prominent (and permitted) example is Kitty’s flirtation with Piotr Rasputin, Colossus, a character she’s had romantic ties to as recently as 2018’s fake-out wedding issue. At the same time, there are recurring examples of Kitty’s closest female friends suggesting deeper connections, bordering on romantic. These examples can be found in Claremont written issues from the mid-80s into the 90’s and all the way through to 2002’s all-but-forgotten Mechanix miniseries. Most famously, in order of chronology:

            Kitty Pryde & Illyana Rasputin

            There’s an undeniable bond between Kitty and Illyana who become fast, extremely close friends at the Xavier Institute. From Kitty’s literal – generally unexplained – bond to Illyana that causes her to take on Illyana’s Soulsword armor when the New Mutants are seemingly killed by the Beyonder in New Mutants #36, to their now infamous tickle-fight (alone in their bedrooms) in New Mutants #63, Kitty and Illyana are a consistent subtextual reference.

            Kitty Pryde & Rachel Summers

            Kitty and Rachel are very close throughout the entirety of Excalibur, and while of course characters can just be friends, there are enough moments in these comics to suggest there’s more to it. As already mentioned, Claremont has since declared Rachel “The love of Kitty’s life.”

            Kitty Pryde & Courtney Ross (Sat-Yr-Nine)

            One of the absolute most deliberate examples occurs in the pages of Excalibur, when Brian Braddock’s love interest Courtney Ross makes clear seductive overtures to Kitty. In his own online forum, long-time Excalibur artist and Chris Claremont collaborator Alan Davis said of Kitty and Courtney, “although I knew Chris had some plan for Sat-Yr-9 to corrupt Kitty and that the various Cross-time versions of Saturnyne were attracted to Kitty, I had no idea what, if any, the goal of this relationship was to be. I just played it as a lesbian affair.” You can criticize the intent or execution, but there’s no denying this was meant to yet again show Kitty as interested.

            Kitty Pryde & Karma 

            The X-Treme X-Men mini Mechanix is a general footnote in the canon of Claremont written X-Men comics, but it focuses wholly on Kitty trying to find herself in college after the death of her father in the New X-Men destruction of Genosha. During this time, Kitty reconnects with longtime New Mutant Xi’an Coy Manh, aka Karma, an out lesbian. The two share several tender touches, conversations, and glances.

            To be clear, it’s not like this subtextual queerness is without problems. Nola Pfau writes for the Eisner-Winning comics website Women Write About Comics, “Chris Claremont is a straight man, and while his attempt to push for queer inclusion in the ’80s was admirable, every single potential relationship involving the character contains a level of age-inappropriateness; Illyana Rasputin is a decade younger than her, artificially aged up, Rachel Summers is older and fresh out of a relationship with an even older future version of Kate herself, and “Courtney Ross” (actually the villainous Sat-Yr-9) is an adult improperly seducing her on her fifteenth birthday. Even her primary male crush, Piotr Rasputin, is approximately five years older than her, putting him above the age of twenty-one to her fifteen.”

            Nonetheless, it’s all very much there, even if culturally Marvel refused to admit it. In her excellent essay, “Kitty Queer,” Sigrid Ellis writes, “Ego-dystonic homosexuality was removed from the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in 1986. New Mutants #36 was published in February 1986. When it was written, lesbianism was legally and medically a perversion. Chris Claremont and Bill Sienkiewicz, the writer and artist of New Mutants at the time, could not say that Illyana came to the rescue of her some-time girlfriend Kitty who had been defeated by a demon with a penchant for classic bondage porn. But they could write it, and draw it, without ever acknowledging that is what they were doing.”

            The Value of Representation

            The primary reason I think these moments and others like them are essential to X-Men Comics – and frankly comics in general – is that representation matters enormously.

            I’ve been watching a lot of Hamilton since it released on Disney+ on July 4th, including some interviews with the immensely talented cast. And one thing I’ve talked about with family is the merit and value of “Story of Tonight.” As a song, it’s less upbeat, less instantaneously catchy, it wasn’t ever a favorite. It’s fine. Listening to an interview with Leslie Odom Jr, who plays Aaron Burr, though, he’s talking about that song specifically as an eye opening moment for him in terms of diversity – and I’m paraphrasing – “I had never seen four people of color on stage just talking about friendship.” He had never seen that in the arts before, and it was powerful. That gives me a different perspective on the merit of that moment in the show. That’s what diversity and representation can do in comics like X-Factor, Marauders, and across the Dawn of X. It lets oppressed groups see themselves in places they never have before.

            An enormous part of X-Men fandom is deeply engaged with the soap operatic structure and the romantic entanglements of these characters that we become so attached to. The part that’s easy to take for granted is that historically most of these plotlines – for example Rogue and Gambit, in a cyclical will they/won’t they – are standard heteronormative relationships. In the gazillion variations on Rogue and Gambit’s romance, I’ve ever seen anyone ask “Why does their sexuality matter?” It’s taken for granted this is quote-on-quote “normal.”

            The same goes for the love triangle between Scott Summers, Wolverine, and Jean Grey. That’s been a huge part of the comics, the animated series, the movies, every X-Men story ever told! Their sexuality, and romantic partners absolutely matters to readers, and has for generations. It’s inarguably a part of the X-Men narrative.

            Why should that not extend to queer characters? Why should that be withheld from them? This absence is damaging to the X-Men’s central thesis of creating a fair world for the oppressed and the different. As Gramuglia writes, “The lack of [queer] parallels leads to two negative results: it lessens the relevance of the X-Men’s metaphor and it weakens the discussion of oppression in the real world. Both of these problems keeps the X-Men saga from resonating with its queer audience, which is increasingly confronted with bigotry in the form of harassment, hate crimes, and governmental oppression. ”

            One of the leading realities for avoiding queer relationships in comics is of course fear, hate and bigotry. It should go without saying that those are unacceptable rationales.

            A lot of people, I suppose, are smart enough to mask this prejudice with the suggestion that it’s not the sexuality that’s the problem, so much as the focus on the “woke” agenda over a “good story.” Again, the sarcastic turn of “woke” into a pejorative as opposed to the literal “wake up” call it’s meant to be – as if that was a bad thing, taking in new information and waking up to your surroundings, and heaven forbid learning from others – this is all odd to me.

            This focus on reducing all thought to “make good story” is deeply misguided, and woefully inadequate criticism. On Comic Book Herald, I rank and evaluate and discuss thousands upon thousands of comics. I’m able to do this through a site I created and a platform I’ve built, but I make no bones that clearly my definition of “good” is going to lead to plenty of readers who disagree with me! I talk about this a lot on the My Marvelous Year podcast I do, but in the first few years of running the reading clubs on CBH and MMY, there are a billion examples of people telling me “hey this story you love, it stinks, or didn’t work for me at all!” And nobody should be shocked or surprised about this!

            Now certainly, there can be critical consensus or even popular consensus around a work’s quality, but let’s not sit here and pretend this is easily and universally defined. Your definition of good is probably not mine, is not probably not your neighbor’s, is not your family’s, etc. We all recognize this and yet there are all these caveman cries for “make good story.” The fact that it doesn’t work for you alone does not make it a “bad story.”

            It’s Never ALL About Sexuality

            There’s an implication in loudly decrying stories inclusive of queer sexuality that *this is all Marvel publishes now*. The absolute irony of this is as Marvel slowly works to make up for decades of completely absent representation, they are called out for *too much sudden representation*. For the most vocal critics, the only acceptable solution would be if Marvel attempted to catch up at a rate so glacially slow that they never really came close to making up for lost time at all. Given the historical context, the desire to see Marvel tell stories like they “used to” is a desire to see Marvel never broach these topics at all.

            There’s also a willfully oblivious nature to these comments – especially when bandied about at the publisher level – that ignores the fact if I look across the Dawn of X, there are plenty of titles that aren’t really digging into queer relationships *at all*: X-Men (mostly), X-Force, Hellions, Giant-Size X-Men, Cable, X-Men / Fantastic Four, Wolverine, Fallen Angels and New Mutants. It’s a vast majority of the line!

            This is of course true for the majority of Marvel Comics throughout history as well. The attempt to paint modern efforts of representation as “sudden” and “forced” is really just an excuse to say you preferred the absence of queer characters in Marvel’s history. And that history is not equitable. Not by a long shot.

            If it feels like Marvel is cashing in on a modern trend by making characters queer, that’s because that’s the direction the world is moving. According to a summer 2020 Gallup poll, American support of same sex marriage is at an all time high, approximately 67% or 2 out of 3 people. This isn’t a fad, it’s the gradual bent of a nation fighting for equality. Marvel has always been the world outside your window, so it’s only right that public perception could shape character’s fictional realities as well. This doesn’t really absolve Marvel’s failures, but it’s disingenuous to pretend this is something a corporation is peddling irrespective of significantly positive cultural trends.

            When all the comics you loudly don’t like have a perceived agenda of diversity, it’s worth examining those common threads and really considering whether you’re open to new perspectives. Why do these additions stand out *so much* as a reader?

            As an example, Leah William, David Baldeon and the creative team’s X-Factor #1 is a highly engaging first issue, exploring aspects of life on Krakoa, the 5, resurrection protocols, and several characters we haven’t seen much of in the Dawn of X. You can talk about this issue extensively – and I *did* in my review – without focusing extensively on the queer relationships. It’s a facet of the fabric, and for all the reasons I’ve outlined, a force for good, but it’s only one piece of a multi-faceted story! Criticisms that the comic is lost to a social justice agenda are deliberately obsessing over fictional character sexuality in a way the story isn’t even doing!

            When the comic does make mention of character’s sexual identity, it’s to showcase the variance and variety of queer individuals in the world, to showcase different personalities and different interests to avoid singular stereotypes across communities. Daken is super different than Prodigy, and yes, they’re both bisexual. This is a deeper level of representation, and a logical progression from the simplicity of Stan Lee’s earlier implication that Marvel’s “one gay hero” was a real nice effort to hit a quota.

            At the end of the day, explicitly putting queer characters on the page is enormously important. It can’t just be left to the background, it can’t just be subtext, and pretending that’s enough. It’s not enough. It matters for people in the minority who are now reflected, it matters for other minority groups who are not reflected that can now one day see themselves reflected, and it matters for non-minority readers who are otherwise less familiar or exposed to the existence of these groups. It matters.

            It’s a way of saying this exists, this is real, and it exists in our world too. In other words, you are real, you matter, and you exist. All of you.

            Sources:

            https://web.archive.org/web/20100316054502/http://prismcomics.org/display.php?id=1304

            https://edition.cnn.com/2002/ALLPOLITICS/12/13/cf.opinion.rawhide.kid/

            https://www.history.com/news/how-the-code-authority-kept-lgbt-characters-out-of-comics

            https://news.gallup.com/poll/311672/support-sex-marriage-matches-record-high.aspx

            Out Cold: Iceman’s Queer Subtext in Chuck Austen’s X-Men

            https://web.archive.org/web/20081025052645/http://www.advocate.com/issue_story_ektid63952.asp

            https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/x-men-as-a-queer-metaphor

            The Performative Horniness of Dawn of X

            https://medium.com/reflections-of-a-grown-up-fan/why-arent-there-more-lgbtqa-x-men-ff3d5b4619c6

            “It came out of nowhere” pic.twitter.com/E4oYw0rLuc

            — tycon ⊗ (@aliastager) September 10, 2020

            100 – Unexpected Wonder, with Chris Claremont

             

            The post Krakin’ Krakoa #86: Why Does Sexuality in X-Men Comics Matter? appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

            22 min
          • Creannotators #16: “A Map To The Sun” With Sloane Leong

            This week on Creannotators, I talked with creator Sloane Leong about A Map To The Sun, the graphic novel’s incredible colors, studying the game of basketball, and her sci fi Image series Prism Stalker.

            On Comic Book Herald’s ‘Creannotators’ I’ll be interviewing some of my favorite creators in comics about specific runs, graphic novels or series, looking for their insights on the inspirations behind the work and ideas or hidden material readers may have missed. Creannotators is an audio/visual annotative guide to enjoying the intricacies and thinking in the art. Thanks for listening, and enjoy the comics!

            A Map to the Sun from First Second books is one of my favorite new comics of 2020, a poetic exploration of five girls of color forming a women’s basketball team in their underprivileged high school. Sloane Leong’s expressive artwork and inventive use of color creates a vivid emotional journey well worth reading.

            ——————————————————————————————————-

            Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

            Subscribe on iTunes

            Subscribe on Android

            To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

            For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

            The post Creannotators #16: “A Map To The Sun” With Sloane Leong appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

            32 min
          • Creannotators #15: “Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed” Interview With Artist Leila Del Duca!

            This week on Creannotators, I talked with artist Leila Del Duca about Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed, her creator-owned work like Shutter and Afar, and the process of working on a DC graphic novel compared to monthly ongoing comics.

            On Comic Book Herald’s ‘Creannotators’ I’ll be interviewing some of my favorite creators in comics about specific runs, graphic novels or series, looking for their insights on the inspirations behind the work and ideas or hidden material readers may have missed. Creannotators is an audio/visual annotative guide to enjoying the intricacies and thinking in the art. Thanks for listening, and enjoy the comics!

            Leila’s latest graphic novel, Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed, is a part of DC’s young adult graphic novel series, looking at a 16 year old Wonder Woman as she leaves Themyscira for the first time and tackles issues likes immigration, refugees, and child trafficking (among others) in her first visit to the world of humans.

            You can find Leila’s creator interviews via the Helioscope PDX channel.

            Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed Is:

            Writer: Laurie Hals Anderson

            Artist: Leila Del Duca

            Colors: Kelly Fitzpatrick

            Letters: Saida Temofonte

            ——————————————————————————————————-

            Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

            Subscribe on iTunes

            Subscribe on Android

            To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

            For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

            The post Creannotators #15: “Wonder Woman: Tempest Tossed” Interview With Artist Leila Del Duca! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

            29 min
          • Krakin’ Krakoa #80: The X-Men’s Secret School For Omega Level Mutants!

            I was caught by surprise recently when Krakin’ Krakoa listener Xavier D pointed out the children sitting around Krakoa campfires led by longtime X-Men villain Exodus look like kid versions of omega level mutants. The more I’ve thought about the observation, the more potential I find, and now I’m convinced Hickman’s X-Men is secretly telling us exactly what Krakoa’s plans are for Omega Level Mutants.

            Today I’ll answer:

            • Is there a secret school for Omega Level mutants on Krakoa right under our noses?
            • Why would this be a part of Krakoa?
            • What does the theory of omega level mutant children mean for X-Men comics moving forward?
            • In X-Men #7, we are introduced to Exodus (one of the 12 members of the Krakoan council) and his very cultish campfire stories with Krakoa’s youth. It’s actually not the first time we’ve seen Exodus telling kids stories around a campfire (there’s a panel in House of X #6), but the details begin to matter here.

              Exodus takes on the role of teaching these children about the Krakoan way of life, but as a literal former Crusader, he naturally does so with zealotry, pomp and unwavering conviction. Whether you but it or not, he’s a minister of propaganda, indoctrinating these kids into what it means to be Krakoan, and to be mutant.

              Again in X-Men #11, we see Exodus back at the campfire, with many of the same children. And this is the point when the repetition of the same kids, and Hickman’s use of this framing device begins to raise a series of questions. Now, the simplest answer here is just that Exodus and these mutant kids is a way to show another aspect of Krakoan life, to breath some of the culture into comics that are otherwise focused elsewhere.

              Accepting that possibility, though, it feels like way too big of a coincidence to me that the children – especially the child with a wee pink mohawk and glasses – look like omega level mutants we already know. If Leinil Francis Yu and company were designing new mutant kids, they could make them look like literally anything. So the fact that I’m able to make these connections makes me wonder if that’s absolutely intentional and meant to tell us what’s really going on here.

              Before I run some side by sides to consider which Omegas might be involved, here’s what we know about Omega Level mutants in the Hickman X-Men era, and the full list of who we can consider.

              It’s the language in the Omega Protocol that really catches my eye in retrospect too. “All efforts are to be expended in order to secure the future of the state.” Compare that to the common refrain that “children are the future” and you can see the foundation laid for Krakoan protocols that would support creating and rearing versions of omega level mutants, perhaps even starting as children.

              So who are the kids we see, and how do they compare to their omega level counterparts?

              Again, we have two real visions of these kids, in X-Men #7 and X-Men #11, and only three of the children appear with any real frequency. So yes, I’m definitely stretching a bit in spots to make this theory fit, and I think it’s important to caveat throughout that some of these kids could not fall into the “omega babies” category, and maybe they’re not even supposed to. Alternatively, and I’ll talk about this as well, but we also should consider the very real possibility of Baby Chimeras via Mister Sinister, and the fact that this would distort the kids’ looks as well.

              Quentin Quire – Omega Level Telepathy

              Literal Kid Omega definitely feels like the strongest argument for omega level kids on the island. The hair, the glasses, the style, it all certainly brings to mind a young Quentin Quire. While the elder Q is off getting killed Kenny style every single issue of X-Force could baby Q be in training on Krakoa?

              Of course if this all turns out to not be the case, I also think it’s conceivable that the kids of Krakoa would hold up Omega Level mutants as their celebrities. This could explain dressing like poor Quentin, right down to the flathawk.

              Jean Grey / Hope Summers

              After Quentin, we pretty quickly get into wildly speculative territory, but with some solid clues. There are only three women among the Omega Level list, so our options are Jean Grey, Hope Summers, and Ororo Monroe. The young girl arguably looks a bit like either Jean or Hope, too!

              Jean Grey is an omega level telepath and Hope Summers is omega level at power manipulation.

              The most interesting connection for this possible Jean / Hope version, though, is to Mister Sinister. The prominent circle on the girl’s forehead doesn’t really match with Jean or Hope, but it is reminiscent of what we saw in Giant-Size Fantomex, in the very opening pages of the issue.

              The forehead circle and diamond are used to denote clones created in a Weapon Plus lab, and as many Krakin’ Krakoa listeners observed in that Fantomex issue, the diamond immediately signifies the presence and involvement of Mister Sinister. To be clear, I’m now theorizing based on a theory, or as I like to call it, we’ve now entered the realm of theory squared.

              So why does it matter to connect all of this to Mister Sinister? For starters, we’re talking about cloned replicants of mutants, so there’s no pretending he’s not involved. If it’s Jean, we also know Sinister has had a particular interest in the Summers / Grey bloodline for a long time.

              1. We’re clearly dealing with cloned/resurrected mutants, and
              2. We could already be dealing with Sinister genetic Chimeras. Remember, in Powers of X, in Moira’s 9th life, Sinister is responsible for creating mutant Chimeras, pits on Mars full of genetic experiments blending various mutant DNAs. I’m arguing here that these kids are already Sinister’s Chimeras in action, on Krakoa, being raised to defend mutantkind. And who knows what else.
              3. It makes a lot of sense to me that Professor X in particular would want to initiate these protocols sooner. Remember, he and Magneto are the ones who bring in Sinister so early (against Moira’s better judgment), and bring to Moira’s attention that in this lifeline Sinsiter’s first chimera is brought to fruition decades earlier, and it’s injecting himself with John Proudstar’s DNA.

                To reiterate, the exact look of the kids here might not be that telling, or really demand a 1×1 match. And that’s because of the Chimera mash-up potential.

                The issues where these children appear all have potential clues about this. For example, in X-Men #7, Kurt and Scott have a conversation about mutants wanting to be resurrected with someone else’s powers, with omega level Magneto mentioned as a possibility. Nightcrawler says “Why stop there? Why not combine two? Why not add a third to the mix?” And Cyclops responds “Like I said, it’s going to be a problem.”

                Another clue that this might matter more than stated, is the inclusion of an Omega Level Mutants section of the Quorum Captain’s memo that is almost entirely redacted. Why even include that here?

                From the Omega Protocols: “It is believed that a greater dynamo is possible through collective means.” This war council section is talking about the possibility of combining mutant combat techniques, and Omega Level combinations would be the most powerful type of combination they could consider. Obviously a possible Chimera mix of two omega level powersets is the ultimate efficiency towards that end.

                The Other Omega Kids

                Hopping back for a moment to consider the other children we do get to see, in order of how likely the comparison holds up.

                Proteus – omega level reality manipulation / psionic

                Iceman Temperature manipulation – negative

                I’ll admit my first thought with the black child with glowing eyes was Mister M, but I actually re-read District X recently and it turns out my dude Absalom is suuuuper white.

                So literally our only black omega level is Storm, which means we’re considering Short haired Ororo Monroe? Now, the lit up eyes actually do make this interesting, although Storm’s hair has historically also been very very white, even as a child.

                I don’t expect it’s necessarily a part of the narrative here, but the child could also bring to mind Kymera – yes, literally named Kymera – the alternate Earth child of Storm and T’Challa from the Bendis written Battle of The Atom.

                The most vexing child has some marks on his face that I can’t really fit to any of the known omega levels. The most probable guess for me is Elixir.

                If you have theories on how this kid might fit, definitely let me know in the comments.

                What Does It Mean If Omega Level Kids Are In Training On Krakoa?

                If we then take it as a very real possibility that Exodus is training clones of Omega Level mutants as children… what are the relevant questions?

                Why is Exodus teaching them?

                He’s Omega Level himself, and without question one of the most fervent believers in mutant superiority. I do think it’s interesting to keep in mind that narratives told by Exodus are soaked in his truth which tends to fall short of a balanced perspective. Things like Magneto “hero of Empyre” from X-Men #11 could actually play out differently in reality than in Exodus’ fable. The Scarlet Witch demonizing as a representation of humanity.

                Exodus is definitely a good fit for this role, full of the mutant religion bombast and absolute lack of doubt to turn these omega Kids into the Krakoan loyalists the island needs.

                We don’t really see schooling taking place elsewhere – I actually think a Wolverine and the X-Men style book would go a long way in the Krakoa era – but I don’t really think Exodus is straight up in charge of education. My guess would be he’s leading these specific omega kids, like a Boy Scout leader, through his own special blend of unflinching belief. Actually a better analogy is probably a Sunday School teacher.

                When is this happening? It’s worth considering – truly with so many moments that we’ve seen in the pages of th Hickman written X-Men so far – that the timing of the events, and even where it fits into Moira’s lifelines is up in the air. There’s a deliberately non-linear approach to these pieces of story and given that we’ve already seen Hickman pull this trick in Powers of X, I think it’s fair game to at least consider the possibility.

                The only real context clue we’re given is in X-Men #7 when Cyclops and Kurt walk by the conversation on their way to Krakoa’s first Crucible.

                This also potentially answers the “who knows about this?” with Cylcops and Kurt walking right by Exodus and the kids. Unless we’re in for some real chronal whiplash – and I’m not ruling it out – this suggests the Exodus Omega Club is in place on Krakoa quite early in the new nation’s life.

                I’m not ruling out the idea that Exodus and the kids are in some sort of holographic training either, and that the visual of Kurt and Cyclops isn’t literally happening in front of them. They’re reviewing an event after the fact.

                The omega level army theory

                I think it makes an infinite amount of sense that Krakoa would already be building up an army of omega level mutants. The only consideration that might hold them back is the ability to do so somewhat safely. Consider threats like Child of the Vault, with an ability to manufacture threats at a rate mutant procreation probably can’t keep up with (despite the best intentions of the horniest X-Men fans). Or the ultimate threat of the Phalanx. Make more mutants should be something we as readers take more literally.

                Throughout the Dawn of X, Krakoa has been far too open to attack, and failure. I’m interested in ideas that we’re less exposed to in the narrative that actually display more forward thinking.

                Kids, though? Why like this?

                Before it was on this seemingly eternal hiatus, Children of the Atom #1 was a “red issue.” It’s my theory that these connections would be / will be present in that narrative whenever it reaches our eyes!

                What do you think of this theory? Let me know in the comments

                The post Krakin’ Krakoa #80: The X-Men’s Secret School For Omega Level Mutants! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

                22 min
              4. Creannotators #14: “Exorsisters” Interview With Artist Gisele Lagace!

                This week on Creannotators, I talked with artist Gisele Lagace about her work on the Image Comics series Exorsisters, her creator-owned webcomics careers, and the benefits of funding comics through Kickstarter.

                On Comic Book Herald’s ‘Creannotators’ I’ll be interviewing some of my favorite creators in comics about specific runs, graphic novels or series, looking for their insights on the inspirations behind the work and ideas or hidden material readers may have missed. Creannotators is an audio/visual annotative guide to enjoying the intricacies and thinking in the art. Thanks for listening, and enjoy the comics!

                Exorsisters is the story of two “sisters” with a connection to hell, demons, and a business helping people out with those pesky exorcisms they may need. It’s a light-hearted supernatural look at heaven, hell, and family.

                You can find more from Gisele’s webcomics at https://www.pixietrixcomix.com/.

                Exorsisters Is:

                Writer: Ian Boothsby

                Artist: Gisele Lagace

                Colors: Pete Pantazis

                Letters: Taylor Esposito

                Editor: Branwyn Bigglestone

                Production: Carey Hall

                ——————————————————————————————————-

                Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.

                Subscribe on iTunes

                Subscribe on Android

                To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald

                For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com

                The post Creannotators #14: “Exorsisters” Interview With Artist Gisele Lagace! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

                39 min
              5. Krakin’ Krakoa #77: X Of Swords (X of Storms) Theory: Who Is Ashake?

                I get a fair amount of Krakin’ Krakoa sleuths sending me theories and links about X-Men, which is a really fun way to see that people are engaging with the comics and with my own obsessing about them. In response to my X-Men FCBD 2020 video review, and theories about X of Swords and the mysterious Swordbearers of Arakko, a listener sent me their theory on the “Classified” apparent leader of the bunch. I stored the link away for later, but now that I’ve looked into it, I’m 98% certain their theory is spot on – I can’t for the life of me determine exactly who sent me this, so I just want to be clear I take zero credit for unearthing this, and want to thank everyone who sends me wild X-men theories to get my wheels spinning!

                X of Storms

                In my X of Swords Chapter 1 video, I theorized that the Swordbearer since titled “Classified” (for the record, it would be hilarious if that’s just her Swordbearer name) was Storm. My rationale was first that the half visible personage of the character on the “Eight of Cups” is a black woman with all white eyes, but second that the text ties to Storm’s journey:

                “That which was once the harmonious lifting of voices is now a mocking echo –then silence.”

                In House of X #5, as we learn about Krakoa’s resurrection capabilities, it’s Storm who introduces the resurrected X-Men team to the island of mutants. This to me signifies her “harmonious lifting of voices,” literally leading the island in a chant of “Mutant!” with each new lineup introduction. We’ll know more for sure following Giant-Size X-Men: Storm #1, but the “mocking echo” potentially signifies the Children of the Vault corruption of Storm taking place across the “Giant-Size” specials.

                A bunch of listeners have been asking why it’s a big deal that Storm has 30 days to live following Giant-Size X-Men: Jean Grey & Emma Frost, since mutants can just be resurrected. Aside from the flippant, it still probably sucks to die, I think the bigger problem here is that Storm is threatened with a kind of infective transformation *like* death, but not equal to it. It’s conceivable to me that the Vault’s infection could take root, and Storm could be transformed into an “enemy,” which given her commitment to the X-Men and mutantkind throughout her life, would be a kind of waking death.

                Plus, given that the now fully revealed cover of Marauders #14 is an incredible Russell Dautermann and Matt Wilson depiction of Storm dancing with Death (of Apocalypse Horsing fame), it remains very possible that my gut instinct was correct and good ol’ “Classified” is, in fact, Ororo Monroe. Of course this could also just be a fun allusion to the adage “a dance with death,” but I’m sticking to my theory!

                X of Storms Past

                Like I said at the start, though, there’s a literally related theory that works even better! And it’s that “Classified” is Ashake!

                If you’re not familiar with the character Ashake, don’t worry, I didn’t know her by name either. Ashake first appeared in New Mutants #32 in 1985, during a saga that found Magik and Mirage, aka Dani Moonstar, transported approximately 5,000 years into the past in Ancient Egypt (unrelated to this theory, but the issues through around #34 are pretty interesting for my renewed interest in Shadow King!).

                For approximately 1 page and 1 panel, a mysterious sorceress named Ashake appears to the time-lost New Mutants and provides them sanctuary. Illyana and Dani are struck by how similar Ashake looks to their X-Men mentor Ororo Monroe, Storm, and Ashake is able to divine across time that Storm is a future descendant of hers! Wildly, this entire meeting is over in a flash, and Ashake helps Magik and Dani travel back to the future (naturally, they overshoot the present, and hijinX ensue).

                This is an extraordinarily brief appearance, and would be even more of a deep cut reference if that’s all we had, but Ashake actually made a return 23 years later in the 4 issue 2008 miniseries Mystic: Arcana. This is where things *really* get compelling, in a flashback story written by Louise Simonson, set during the events of the aforementioned New Mutants #32.

                Mystic Arcana: Magik #1 explores the full-fledged adventure Magik and Ashake experience in the past in an untold tale.

                A couple thoughts right off the bat —

                Tarot Cards play a major role throughout Mystic Arcana, which pretty seamlessly connects possible relevance to the Tarot based upcoming crossover event X of Swords. Indeed, the term Arcana is used in the “Major Arcana” which references the 22 trump cards (for our non card players, no, this has nothing to do with American politics, thank heavens) in a standard 78 card Tarot pack. Ashake quite literally makes her own Tarot cards with painted images on sheets of bone.

                I also love how Simonson and the team are able to dig back into this all too brief moment from an issue of New Mutants nearly a quarter century in the past and give it new life, and breath new character into Ashake. It’s a cool reflection of some of comic book’s most unique properties, that these stories and universes are intertwining and connected across decades of real world time, and that something seemingly as tossed-aside as Storm’s long lost great great great great (etc) grandmother could be a major plot point in the future.

                In Mystic Arcana, Illyana and Ashake are effectively forced to retrieve the Sword of Bone, one of the 4 cornerstones of creation, which eventually becomes the sword of Ashake, as her purity of will is the only capable of tapping into the swords energies. At the conclusion of the four part mini, Ashake returns to aid the forces of good, and then effectively goes her own way in the mystic dimensions, freeing her up to basically anything any storytellers would want to do next. Things like make her a focal point of X of Swords.

                It’s a tangential detail, but I’ll also note that the second cornerstone of creation is found in the possession of Morgan Le Fey, who of course is currently being held experiment-prisoner by Apocalypse as he uses her magics to make connections from Otherworld to wherever we’re going in X of Swords.

                The Stormbearers of Arakko

                Ok, so there are some pretty cool connections here, but a couple major questions remain. First let’s back up a second to look at what we know about the Swordbearers of Arakko. The most relevant info to date is that the first Horsemen of Apocalypse are among the Swordbearers, and until we knew there were 10 Swordbearers, it was my understanding that Apocalypse was primarily planning a rescue mission solely for these four most favored. While it’s not just this, a rescue mission for Apocalypse’s first horsemen is what I’ve been predicting X of Swords would be about literally since it was announced.

                Intriguingly, while War and Death are named among the Swordbearers, Pestilence and Famine are not. Bei The Blood Moon looks like the character *could be* one of the 4 based on the limited images we’ve seen of the group, but the horsemen with an eyeball head is nowhere to be found. Whatever the reason – they haven’t survived the eternal war standing in the gap, the character designs have changed since launch, somebody told Hickman and company that Eye design was way too similar to Jason Aaron’s love for Orb – we know the first horsemen are a part of this group, but most of the group (up to 80%) is from *somewhere else*. So if “Classified” is Ashake, it’s likely she would know Apocalypse, but she is not necessarily one of his first horsemen.

                For what it’s worth, we first meet Ashake during an era of BC Ancient Egypt which doubles as the approximate timeframe of the “Rise of Apocalypse” in civilization. So I haven’t seen any direct interaction, but it’s not impossible that they could have met and established a relationship during this time period. My gut feeling, though, is that Ashake / “Classified” is not one of the first horsemen. Given her ties to magic and mystical dimensions – Ashake worships the Egyptian goddess Ma’at, also known as Oshtur, the mother of Agamotoo (of “eye of” fame) – it seems quite believable that Ashake’s path would have taken her to the mystical realms beyond Otherworld that are converging upon everyone leading up to X of Swords.

                It’s also tantalizing to consider that while Ashake may not be a ‘horsemen’ she could fall into a “Mother Akkaba” role similar to what we see Moira inhabiting in her ninth life as revealed in the pages of Powers of X.

                Tying it all back to the character’s appearance on the Tarot ‘8 of Cups’ tease in the FCBD special, the ‘8 of Cups’ most common interpretation effectively boils down to a rousing rendtion of the Clash’s “Should I Stay or Should I go?” She’s been in limbo fighting for who knows how long, and now she has this choice.

                Bonus Theory: X of Storms That May Yet Pass

                A variation on the Ashake theory that I’m quite proud of is that the “Classified” lead swordbearer is in fact Storm, but from a different future. And this would be the sorceress Storm that Illyana thought she killed in Limbo during the Magik four issue miniseries.

                The story of Magick, Illyana Rasputin, is timey-wimey and complicated, and I’ve recapped elsewhere on Krakin’ Krakoa, but the general idea is that a version of the X-Men that traveled to the realm of Limbo were stuck behind, including a version of Storm who grew older and became a fairly advanced sorceress. This Storm rescues Illyana from Belasco’s hellish clutches for a time, and teaches her – or attempts to teach her – some of the magic she knows to try and help Illyana. Ultimately, Illyana is kinda forced to kill Storm in order to prevent her soul from being taken by the Elder Gods.

                BUT – Limbo is timey-wimey as hell, and it would be more than possible to bring Limbo-Storm back through magic-time shenanigans. This actually feels like a best of both worlds outcome because it ties in Limbo, Illyana, and Storm heavily to X of Swords. All of which, of course, helps pave the way to a good ol’ Inferno 2.0 event coming in 2021.

                The post Krakin’ Krakoa #77: X Of Swords (X of Storms) Theory: Who Is Ashake? appeared first on Comic Book Herald.

                15 min

              About Best Comics Ever

              From the publisher's feed

              The official podcast of Comic Book Herald.

              More shows like Best Comics Ever

              AIPT Comics by AIPT

              AIPT Comics

              54 Listeners