
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Through three issues X-Force continues to improve and build on the promise of House of X. It’s one of my favorite Dawn of X titles, and issue three by Benjamin Percy and Joshua Cassarra did not disappoint!
Today on Krakin’ Krakoa #24 I’ll answer:
For all Comic Book Herald X-Men videos!
For the full Dawn of X reading order:
Issue 3 follows in the wake of the Reavers attack on Krakoa, and their successful assassination of Professor X (and destruction of his Cerebro headgear). Last issue also saw Wolverine and Quentin Quire discover the facility where the Reavers where horrifically holding a skinned and tortured Domino, using her mutant DNA in order to infiltrate the nation of Krakoa.
We now know this faction of anti-mutant terrorists is capturing and experimenting on a variety of mutants in order to implant themselves with cybernetic upgrades, which is very much in line with the Reavers we know and, well, hate.
I also have to call out the remarkably effective opening 9 panels in X-Force #3 where the creative team alternates close-ups of Domino’s torture and mission statement monologuing by “The Man with the Peacock Tattoo,” which for the record, is way less intimidating sounding than a Dragon Tattoo.
As Wolverine and Quentin are rescuing Domino from this horrific fate, the process of reviving the assassinated Professor is underway, primarily driven by Jean Grey and Beast.
Here we get Beast asking the question about the value of death in conversation with Jean Grey.
Jean answers everyone’s fears about taking the stakes out of X-Men comics:
“What I’m saying is without death life is less about me and more about us. The long game of mutantkind. That’s the dream of Krakoa.“
This is honestly the closest I’ve seen any of these – save a few hints here and there in the Hickman written issues – get to referencing the futures we’ve seen referenced in the pages of Powers of X and available to us via Moira’s lifelines.
The end result is the apparent resurrection and public announcement of Professor X’s return.
I say “apparent” because this all happens fairly quickly throughout the issue given the significance of the Professor’s role in making resurrection protocols and Cerebro backups tick. As Beast says “he’s all of us.”
So Professor X is back, but there’s a fair amount of doubt we see expressed implicitly and explicitly in this issue.
I appreciate Quentin challenging the “Kill No Humans” law of Krakoa – You have all these “villains” playing nice with X-Men but it’s down to Quentin to call out Professor X on still playing too nice.
Calling out Professor X’s mistakes seems especially relevant this issue, in both his return as if nothing went wrong (he even gets a cool sword from Magneto as a memento), and another glimpse into all the threats that remain to mutantkind, perhaps even from within Krakoa.
After a very effective and monstrous opener, the newly named XENO (all caps, all on-the-nose) has been relatively patient and clearly has nothing good planned.
The idea that XENO might have a sleeper agent on Krakoa should be terrifying to X-Men fans.
There’s also the possibility that all the awful bigots are effectively teaming up here given the language like “The shadows have gathered here” and “We are one and we are many.” I wonder if this is a combination of the likes of Reavers, Friends of Humanity, Purifiers ,etc.
All in all, I’m enjoying X-Force a great deal, and consider it the heart of Dawn of X!
———————————————————————————
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Krakin’ Krakoa #24: X-Force #3 Review – The Lives & Deaths of Professor X appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
November 27 2019 – the day before Thanksgiving – was the first new comic book day in approximately 4 months with at least three new X-Men comics released on the same day.
Appropriately, my varying reactions to the releases are a healthy reminder that more is not always better, and that one of House of X and Dawn of X’s greatest strengths has been a healthy sense of curation (Marvel as a whole is otherwise comically overproducing books these days). Big picture, New Mutants is a book I expected to enjoy, and lo and behold, nothing has changed, whereas X-Force had a make-or-break second issue actually sell me on many of the comic’s bolder first issue choices.
And then there’s Fallen Angels #2, which I’m increasingly convinced is the only absolute dud of the Dawn of X.
For all Comic Book Herald X-Men videos!
For the full Dawn of X reading order:
Two issues into Fallen Angels and I have no doubt that Fallen Angels is a let down, and the only real dud of the Dawn of X. This book will of course have fans – many of them have chimed in on the Comic Book Herald Youtube channel, and I’ll encourage them to continue to do so! I’m genuinely interested in other perspectives and why people enjoy work that isn’t working for me – so it’s important to me to go beyond simply “comic=bad” and explore specific elements that I find objectionable.
Starting big picture, I respect the hell out of Hill and Kudranski’s pitch for a book about Kwannon reclaiming the Psylocke “shell” as she refers to it as truly her own. There’s conceptually a bold meditation on identity and the X-Men’s history of racial body swapping (it’s more than just Betsy & Kwannon, just ask the New Mutants “Demon Bear” saga), somewhere in the idea of Fallen Angels.
As far as I can tell though, all of this is secondary to a substantially less interesting exploration of the role of violence in a utopia. This is particularly less interesting alongside a lineup including X-Force, where the concept of peaceful Utopia is so feverishly upended. The premise doesn’t match the reality *already* and we’re only two issues into Dawn of X!
Just as messily, Fallen Angels is also sprinting headfirst into the surest way to mediocrity: It’s a ninja Hand book without a compelling leader of the Hand. It’s not like mutant-kind don’t have a history with Madripoor and the Hand – obviously this is especially true if we’re talking about Betsy Braddock and Kwannon – but to me this feels like another instance where the focal point doesn’t really tie with the rest of Dawn of X and the development of Krakoa.
In every other title we can at least see ways the book contributes to the new world. Fallen Angels is still extremely unclear.
Perhaps this is all because Fallen Angels didn’t need to be a team book. The comic Hill and Kudranski appear interested in writing is just called Psylocke. And that’s a fine, if bold choice for an X-book to launch – I mean it’s not like that would have been any less marketable than a comic book title connected to an off the wall late 80’s miniseries?
Not only do I think Fallen Angels didn’t need to be a team book, it didn’t need to be a book with *this* team. This is probably the aspect of Fallen Angels that irks the comic fan in me the most – Teen Cable and X-23 do *not* make sense for this book, and the work is not doing anything to convince me otherwise.
Bryan Edward Hill is at odds with other writers on many of the characters he’s writing. From Hickman’s off-the-rails comedic Mr. Sinister to Hickman’s goofball meathead Teen Cable, to Tom Taylor’s years of character work on X-23 (more on this in a moment), Hill’s writing them all muted and reduced to ominous talk of war and violence. Forget which version is even preferred – it’s blatantly inconsistent. This is far from the first time two writers have had different takes on their caretaking of Marvel’s property, but it’s happening in concert during a Dawn of X that is otherwise cohesive and wholly connected. It’s an approach incongruous with Dawn of X, and so is the comic book.
In order to more specifically discuss the regressive nature of Fallen Angels, I think it helps in particular to define Laura Kinney’s regression.
X-23 is a clone of Wolverine, created in a lab, born and bred in violence. When she speaks aloud the following it’s not just a return to her early 2000’s identity, it’s a nonsensical attempt to ignore the fact that literally no one understands her better than Logan, aka Wolverine: “There is an anger in me. A rage. I gave up any hope that someone could possibly understand it.” She has clones like Gabby and Wolverine, but only Psylocke can understand her rage now? Since when?!
Another piece of Fallen Angels that bugs me is the lack of a plan for all mutants on Krakoa. Like, the planners *know* Kwannon’s deal, and X-23’s. Look at X-23’s last series, she has clear missions and assignments using her skills. But on Krakoa she’s expected to just sit by the same campfire? It makes the planners look dumb and short-sighted!
Now there’s no question that historically X-23 has a lot of rage and trauma to overcome. Again, she is a young girl born and bred in violence, for no other purpose than killing at the behest of her cruel masters. What is so frustrating about this particular take though is that it immediately follows years of work to give Laura something else.
I’m referencing a particularly goofy example, but in All-New Wolverine written by Tom Taylor, Laura proves she’s more than X-23, more than the weapon, and develops a life with her sister Gabby, and yes Jonathan the Wolverine. She is angry, still, and it’s not like you just get over being made to murder, but Laura at least develops into a person with real empathy and connection to others.
There’s definitely blame to throw Marvel’s way as well, for forcing the regression to begin with. Following All-New Wolverine and X-Men Red (both Tom Taylor written productions), Laura moving back to an X-23 series is inherently regressive, taking the clone name.
So, no, I don’t put this all at Hill’s feet because Marvel as a whole clearly saw the return of OG Wolverine as a mandate to restore Laura to her late 2000’s/early 2010’s days on X-Force.
As a real fan of what Laura Kinney was becoming, though, it feels a lot like one of the worst parts of superhero comics, a blatant and unconvincing character regression in order to maintain a perceived status quo. It’s every time Spider-Man’s relationships fall apart, or every time Daredevil’s identity goes back under wraps, or every time Thor, Captain America, and Iron Man return to lead the Avengers. Progress is often on a clock lest boundaries get pushed too far.
It’s really not that different than ignoring the decades of character work that have made Wolverine the character fans know and love today. In 2019, Logan’s been an X-Man, a husband, a father, a teacher, an Avenger, and a man in grieving more times than we can count. If you strip that away and return to his late 70’s ferocity and rage, it’s just not the same character. The work that’s been done is an asset, not an albatross, and should be treated as such.
———————————————————————————
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Krakin’ Krakoa #23: Fallen Angels #2 Review – The Regression of Laura Kinney By The Coward Fallen Angels appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
Absolute Carnage wrapped up this week: I’ll review the full event, complete with tie-ins, and discuss what it means for the Marvel Universe!
Spoilers for Absolute Carnage follow!
For the video:
For the full Absolute Carnage reading order:
Comics Discussed Include:
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Best Comics Ever #60: Absolute Carnage – Post-Game Report – Full Review! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
DC’s six issue “Event Leviathan” comes to a close, with the final chapter in Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev’s frustrating superhero mystery. I’ll review the full event, complete with tie-ins, and discuss what it means for DC’s 2019.
For the video:
For the full Event Leviathan reading order:
Comics discussed include:
+ Action Comics by Brian Michael Bendis & Steve Epting
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Best Comics Ever #59: DC’s Event Leviathan Post-Game Report – Full Review! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
This month John & Dave tackle Doomsday Clock by Geoff Johns and Gary Frank in relation to HBO’s Watchmen and the original limited series by Alan Moore, Dave Gibbons, and John Higgins.
For previous Deep Dives:
For more, check out the full guides on Comic Book Herald:
Watchmen
Doomsday Clock
I also recommend checking out HBO Watchmen’s Peteypedia!
Comics discussed include:
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Deep Dives #4: World of Watchmen – How Doomsday Clock & HBO Watchmen Approach Sequels appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
This week on “Previously On,” I’m digging into New Mutants #1 and answering questions about the comics role in Dawn of X, and some theories about Marvel Cosmic connections.
The New Mutants debuted in 1982 in a graphic novel (Marvel Graphic Novel #4) by Chris Claremont and Bob McLeod.
The original lineup includes Cannonball (Sam Guthrie), Wolfsbane (Rahne Sinclair), Karma (Shan Coy Manh), Psyche / Mirage (Dani Moonstar), Sunspot (Bobby Da Costa), Illyana Rasputin (Magick), Dough Ramsey (Cypher), Warlock and some Magma here and there.
This is the next generation of young mutants in the world of X-Men, and it’s an important development to return the Xavier Mansion to a school for gifted youngsters and to re-instill the team’s purpose of helping *new* mutants find their way in the Marvel Universe.
The series really takes off though when Chris Claremont is joined by revolutionary artist Bill Sienkiewicz, delivering such stone cold classics as “The Demon Bear” saga and the debut of Charles Xavier’s son, Legion aka David Haller. The duo is so strongly tied to New Mutants, that they even regrouped for a “War Children” one-shot special in 2019, and lo and behold, it’s quite good!
Following Louise Simonson’s excellent work writing the title, the original lineup has been somewhat scattered since the 90s – the X-forcification of New Mutants began when Rob Liefeld was brought on as artist, and introduced the likes of Cable and Deadpool through the pages of New Mutants, before bringing many of those elements over to X-Force – which was the other X-Men first issue that came out this week!
Hickman himself is no stranger to the classic New Mutants – In addition to Sam and Bobby’s role in his Avengers run (bigger than anyone could have anticipated!), Hickman and artist Nick Dragotta also have a lesser known six issue miniseries series, Astonishing Tales: Mojoworld, that stars Sam & Bobby.
Unsurprisingly, then, it’s Bobby’s desire to take the team to space to recover Sam that operates as the driving action in New Mutants #1.
A) New Mutants: Dead Souls
I don’t want to get too in the weeds on these 2018 through 2019 comics because frankly New Mutants #1 is pretty clear that while they *happened* Hickman, Brisson, Reis and company are all looking to move forward from page 1 panel 1.
Long story short both the New Mutants Dead Souls mini and Uncanny X-Men (particularly issues #11 to #22… the first 10 are really Age of X-Men prelude) build to a situation where the New Mutants are all taken over by Warlock’s techno-organic virus. Team carries forward into the pages of Uncanny X-Men where some of them are brutally killed. Frankly, Uncanny X-Men devolved into a poorly executed murder-fest, and writer Matt Rosenberg has pretty publicly apologized, in particular for how upsetting many fans found the death of Wolfsbane.
Which again, brings us back to the cathartic release of hope found on Page 1 Panel one of Dawn of X New Mutants #1.
B) Cannonball can’t stop going missing in space
The other recurring thread in the world of New Mutants is that Sam Guthrie can’t stop going missing in space. At the end of the day, this kind of makes sense, because the Hickman era of Avengers develops a romance between Sam and the Sh’iar imperial guard’s Smasher. They even have a kid together!
Most memorably, Sam Guthrie is lost and imprisoned on the Skrull world where the Skrulls all pretend to be mobsters (from Stan Lee and Jack Kirby’s Fantastic Four!) in the pages of the Al Ewing written U.S.Avengers.
At this point we have to consider that Sam simply prefers space!
A) Renewal of hope. Renewal of younger generations in the world of mutants. This is in both a literal (resurrection) sense, and in a broader metaphor. We don’t see it much in this issue, but the early understanding is that the more Ed Brisson focused work will revolve around non-OG new mutants like Armor and Glob Herman. The kids are the future, and this is the book to deliver that message.
B) Expanding our understanding – or at least the mystery – of Krakoa. This is part 1A of why I see Jonathan Hickman wanting to take a hand personally in this title, planting seeds – puns puns puns – for the future of Krakoa and mutantkind.
It makes sense to do this in New Mutants, where we have Doug Ramsey as a central character, basically experimenting on Generation X’s own Mondo and his own connections to the sentient island nation.
There are two major learnings from New Mutants #1:
Skrulls, Sh’iar and Brood oh my!
Most up my alley, New Mutants #1 is also the book that connects the World of X to Marvel Cosmic!
A) History of New Mutants and Brood
I talked about the New Mutant’s original graphic novel debut in 1982 – importantly, that same publication year and into the next, Uncanny X-Men #162 to #167 by Chris Claremont, Paul Smith, and a returned Dave Cockrum gave us a new memorable alien for the X-Men to fear and battle, the Brood.
The Brood are not so terribly different from The Phalanx – they infect a host with an egg, and pass hive mind memories between hatched broodlings.
The Brood are somewhat interesting as cosmic races go because they seemingly harbor little ill will towards mutants specifically, instead more interested in bonding with “powered individuals” and leveraging those powers for more conquering. Importantly, the Brood are not merely mindless alien predators, and are intelligent beings capable of wielding technology and even sending their offspring to join Wolverine and the X-Men in the form of Broo!
B) History of Brood – Brood Queens. Have we ever seen a “King Egg” before?
Historically, the Brood follow the model of Ants or Bees, where a Brood Queen is ruler of the community. To my knowledge there have been no “Brood Kings” in Marvel before, or if they were out there, they were more or less the worker/prime-warrior drones.
For The New Mutants, Brood and Brood Queens are intrinsically tied to their origins. The New Mutants crew actually meets the X-Men when the team returns from space in Uncanny X-Men #167 and busts into the X-Mansion to beat the stuffing out of a brood infested Professor X. Charlie is actually infested by the Brood Queen!
This is the issue that leads to a moment I’ve liked talking about on Krakin’ Krakoa, the need for Moira and the Sh’iar to clone a new body for Professor X after his was Brooded out. The end of the issue is when Xavier tells the X-Men he’ll be training the New Mutants now!
In modern Marvel Cosmic, the Brood were actually decimated during the Annihilation Wave, and are a shell of their former power.
One thing we’ve seen a lot is that Hickman likes to connect to his own previous Marvel work, which I am all for. Well, as it turns out, this isn’t the first time he’s teased the Brood (in both SHIELD #1, and technically Infinity #3 as part of the Galactic Council), nor is it the first time he’s teased deep and meaningful cosmic eggs! (Phoenix Egg in Secret Wars).
While it’s interesting to theorize what the egg might mean moving forward (I personally quite like the idea of Bobby as a Brood King and transforming the Brood in a similar way he transformed A.I.M.), I actually think there’s a more interesting question:
Why the hell are the Sh’iar keeping a King Egg in a space station?
This says more to me about the Sh’iar acting strangely, and preparing weapons (possibly for those invasive Krakoan flowers), than anything about the future of the Brood in X-Men.
Are there other Sh’iar installations out there protecting cosmic eggs (perhaps of a Phoenix variety)? Isn’t it likely that the Starjammers are acting at least in conjunction with the basic wishes of Corsair’s son Cyclops? There’s a lot here to explore, and I can’t wait to see how it unfolds in the rest of New Mutants!
The post Previously On #90: How Does New Mutants #1 Fit Into X-Men Dawn of X? appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
This was a big week for X-Men comics, as it’s the first week since House of X #1 launched that Marvel published two separate X-Men titles on the same day.
First up, I put together my video review and theories for X-Force #1 by Benjamin Percy, Joshua Cassarra and Dean White.
For all Comic Book Herald X-Men videos!
For the full Dawn of X reading order:
For the full X-Force reading order:
Comics discussed include:
The post How Does X-Force #1 Fit Into X-Men Dawn of X? appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
Marvel’s bringing back the Annihilation event title for a mini-crossover this December 2019, Annihilation Scourge! I’m breaking down what comics set the stage for Annihilation, and what characters like Nova, Annihilus, Beta Ray Bill, Silver Surfer and the Fantastic Four have been up to setting the stage for this event.
For the Video:
For the full Comic Book Herald reading order:
Annihilation Scourge reading order
Comics discussed include:
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Best Comics Ever #58: The Road to Annihilation Scourge! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
I explore what’s become of the Ultimate Universe since Secret Wars (2015), how Marvel’s quietly bringing it back before our eyes in 2019, and my theories for the best way to renew the Ultimate Universe imprint!
For the Video:
For the full Ultimate Universe reading order:
Ultimate Marvel Universe Reading Order
For Ultimate Universe comics after 2015:
Ultimate Universe Comics After Secret Wars (2015)
Comics discussed include:
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Best Comics Ever #57: Will Marvel’s Ultimate Universe Return in 2020? Is it Already Back?! appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
In Krakin’ Krakoa #13, my analysis of House of X / Powers of X, I’m considering why Jean Grey is wearing her Marvel Girl costume, and what it means for the Phoenix Force and the X-Men!
For the Video:
For the full reading order:
Hickman X-Men reading order
Phoenix reading order
Comics discussed today include:
+ House of X / Powers of X
Music for Best Comics Ever by Anthony Weis. Check out more music at anthonyweis.com.
Subscribe on iTunes
Subscribe on Android
To learn how you can support Best Comics Ever and receive more exclusive content from Comic Book Herald, check out the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/comicbookherald
For the Comic Book Herald reading club through every year of Marvel Comics, check out mymarvelousyear.com
The post Krakin Krakoa #13: What Does Jean Grey’s Costume Tell Us About Phoenix in Dawn of X? appeared first on Comic Book Herald.
From the publisher's feed

54 Listeners