Big Muddy Mayhem

Tracey shares the haunted tails of two theaters in St. Louis Missouri and then Janet shares the awful story of the murders that happened in the Love Cottage that Frank Lloyd Wright built.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Theaters: KSDK.com, seeaghost.com, Stifeltheatre.com, Laduepublications.com, FabulousFox.com, Wikipedia, Beststeakstl.com

Frank Lloyd Wright: history.com, crimemuseum.org, pbs.org, wikipedia, wisconsinfrights.com

Janet tells about the strange story of Stephani, the Weep Voice Killer and his awful phone calls to the police about the murders he committed and then Tracey shares the awful tale of Jary Atadero's missing son and how you shouldn't trust anyone.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Stephani- Wikipedia, criminalminds.fandom.com, www.inforum.com

Jaryd Atadero- The Vanished Podcast, "Missing While the Son Sets", by Jaryd Atadero, National Parks after Dark, Deverpost.com, Alternative Interests Podcast, thecolorado.com, wikipedia

Tracey talks about the man who was a visionary but did things maybe a little too well, Edward Gardner Lewis, who brought us University City, Missouri, and then Janet tells the story about Sam Sheppard, who had everything and then lost it all when his wife was found dead!

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Edward Gardner Lewis: "Keep your Face to the Sunshine, life of a Visionary", film by City of U City, Calop, Wikipedia, Savor St. Louis, UCitymo.org, St. Louis Crimes and Mystery, by David Linzee

Sam Sheppard: Nova Online and Wikipedia

Janet talks about the history of the United States, the first-ever, General Strike that took place in St. Louis Missouri, and how it created an anti-labor movement group that still exists today. Then Tracey talks about the life of Clara Rector, the murder, and how she almost got away with it!

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

St. Louis Commune: Wikipedia, jacobin.com

Clara Rector: Snapped(tv series), The Kansas City Star, Dailymail.uk, Columbia Tribune

Tracey tells a wild story about the strange journey of Elmer McCurdy during his life and death and then Janet shares the stories and eventual Great Train robbery of 1924 in Ronout Illinois where the Newton Boys were eventually caught.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Elmer McCurdy: Drift and Ramble Podcast, Wikipedia, NPR.org, Atlas Obsura

Newton Boys: www.drloihjournal.blogspot.com, Wikipedia, www.historyillinois.org

Janet shares stories surrounding the club owner and pimp Al Swearengen and other tales from the town of Deadwood and then Tracey tells the unsolved case of the Cleveland Torso Murderer.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Al Swearengen: Wikipedia, legendsofamerica.com, deadwood.com, nickbrumbywesterns.com

Cleveland Torso Murderer: Wikipedia, cleveland.com, theclevelandpolicemusuem.com, The Unrsoloved Podcast

Tracey tells the tale of the disappearance of Steven Kubacki and the unknown story of what actually happened, and then Janet follows up with a well-documented case of "little green men" near Hopkinsville Kentucky.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Steven Kubacki: ellenkilloran.substack.com (Cold Dead Hands Blog), tv.com, stevenkubacki.com, YouTube channels, Missing Enigma and The Lore Lodge

Hopkinsville Goblins: Wikipedia.com, kyforky.com/blogs, countryliving,com

Tracey shares the story of river pirates on the Ohio River and the story of Samuel Mason and his gang of pirates, which included the infamous Harpe Bros along with other characters. Then Janet weaves the tale of Belle Gunness, widower who was a serial killer and may have faked her own death to get away.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Samual Mason: Wikipedia, historycollection.com, weelunk.com, richlandroots.com, legendofamerica.com, "Between the Rivers: A West Carroll Chronical", by F.S. McKoin

Belle Gunness: Cracked

Janet starts with a story about a Masseuse that turns to murder in Madison Wisconsin, which in turn, becomes the first fully televised Murder Court Case on National TV. Tracey then tells the tail of the unsolved mystery and disappearance of The Springfield Three and about the various suspects who may have been involved.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us an suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Barbara Hoffman: Cracked and New York Daily News

The Springfield Three: ozarksfirst.com, wikipedia, fbi.gov, people.com, Hollywood Crime Scenes(podcast)

Story of the Town Bully, Ken McElroy of Skidmore, Missouri and his unsolved murder and the tale of Ann Bilansky convicted of Arsenic poisoning and eventual historical conviction as the first person to be publicly executed in the state of Minnesota.

Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

You can email us an suggestions for ideas at: [email protected]

You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

References to today's stories:

Ken McElroy: Wikepedia, Buzzfeed Unsolved, Weird History, Rural Instint

Ann Bilansky: Wikipedia, Magazine.atavis.com, twincities.com, startribune.com