This week is a little different as we take a short break from episode recaps and look back at Season 1 as a whole! We mourn the DVD-ROM game that will never know the light of day, make fun of Scully’s fake pilot boyfriend, and briefly become a Toby Lindala fancast. We unveil more Deep Throat/Sally Kendrick relationship lore, discuss Deep Throat’s upcoming role in Succession Season 3, and lament our abandoned Grunge Teens. We answer some listener questions, take a look back at our favorite one-off characters, and wrap up with some yearbook superlatives. We also fight to the death over our ranking of Season 1 episodes. We’d like to leave you with executive producer Glen Morgan’s wise words: Mulder’s insane!

Amanda's List:
24. Young at Heart
23. Space
22. Shadows
21. Born Again
20. Roland
19. Lazarus
18. Ghost in the Machine
17. Miracle Man
16. Gender Bender
15. Shapes
14. Fire
13. Conduit
12. The Jersey Devil
11. Pilot
10. Eve
9. Deep Throat
8. Squeeze
7. Tooms
6. E.B.E.
5. Fallen Angel
4. The Erlenmeyer Flask
3. Darkness Falls
2. Ice
1. Beyond the Sea

Ella's List:
24. Born Again
23. Shadows
22. Lazarus
21. Space
20. Young at Heart
19. Roland
18. Ghost in the Machine
17. Miracle Man
16. Gender Bender
15. Eve
14. Conduit
13. The Jersey Devil
12. Shapes
11. Deep Throat
10. Fire
9. Tooms
8. Fallen Angel
7. The Erlenmeyer Flask
6. Darkness Falls
5. E.B.E.
4. Squeeze
3. Pilot
2. Ice
1. Beyond the Sea

Send us an email at [email protected] or follow us on Twitter and Instagram!