Journalist Claire Hoffman unpacks Sister, Sinner, the gripping true crime story of evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson’s disappearance and miraculous return.

If you've never heard the name, Aimee Semple McPherson, you're not alone—but Claire Hoffman's Sister Sinner will ensure you never forget her name again as America's first mega-preacher.

Today, we discuss this riveting biography, which opens with the astonishing true story of Aimee, who shaped modern evangelicalism, vanished into the ocean for 35 days, and returned with a kidnapping tale so wild it led to two sensational trials.The author was the first researcher granted access to the complete court records of Aimee's grand jury trial—records that, for more than a century, the Foursquare Church has refused to share with the outside world.

Uncover her journalistic approach, which is both deeply researched and refreshingly secular. Embracing Aimee's contradictions—faith healer and showman, sinner and saint, feminist and fundamentalist creates a page-turning experience. Whether religious or not, you'll love this conversation on how charisma, celebrity, and faith collide.

In this intimate and insightful conversation, Claire and I discuss:

• Her background and five-year research process to bring Aimee's story to life
• Why Aimee's disappearance is the opening chapter, and what type of reader did she hope the true crime angle might pull in
• How Claire's background as a journalist for Rolling Stone has given her a unique lens into the world of what it means to be a celebrity
• The effort and reverence required when accessing court documents like this for a project

📚 BONUS BOOK LIST: I've curated a list of 28 incredible books about faith and churches featuring buzzworthy new releases and must-read backlist gems. Browse while you listen!

🗓 BOOK CLUB INVITE: Patrons, check your inbox for a printable version of this list and an invite to our April 25th chat with Lynda Cohen Loigman on The Love Elixir of Augusta Stern. We'll discuss her cozy, feel-good novel about finding love in your eighties. 

📝 Love this show? Leave a review on Apple Podcasts—it's a free way to support my work and help other book lovers find us.

Claire Hoffman is the author of the memoir Greetings from Utopia Park and a journalist reporting for national magazines on culture, religion, celebrity, business, and more. She was formerly a staff reporter for the Los Angeles Times and Rolling Stone. She is a graduate of UC Santa Cruz, and has an MA in religion from the University of Chicago and an MA in journalism from Columbia University. She serves on the boards of the Columbia School of Journalism, ProPublica, and the Brooklyn Public Library. Her new book is SISTER, SINNER: The Miraculous Life and Mysterious Disappearance of Aimee Semple McPherson.

Download Today's Show Transcript

BONUS BOOK LIST: 28 Books About Churches & Faith (fiction & nonfiction)

Join the April Book Club Chat (The Love Elixir of Augusta Stern)

Sister, Sinner by Claire Hoffman

Greetings From Utopia Park by Claire Hoffman

Charles Duhigg

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Claire on Instagram or her Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Sarah Damoff shares how The Bright Years evolved from an epistolary draft into a powerful multi-POV family saga exploring addiction across generations.

Every so often, a debut novel arrives so confident and assured it's hard to believe it's the author's first. Sarah Damoff's The Bright Years is one of those rare books. Deeply informed by her work as a social worker, Sarah offers readers an empathetic and profoundly immersive exploration of addiction and its reverberations across generations. Deftly weaving their family's personal history with political and cultural moments creates a layered portrait of a family navigating love and loss through the generations.

In this intimate and insightful conversation, Sarah and I discuss:

• Her savvy and scrappy journey to landing a book deal with Simon & Schuster
• How The Bright Years began as an epistolary novel and evolved into a multi-POV saga
• The challenge of writing addiction and redemption with compassion
• How setting the story across decades helped her explore shifting perspectives and memory

📚 BONUS BOOK LIST: I've curated a list of the best 19 addiction fiction books—featuring buzzworthy new releases and must-read backlist gems. Browse while you listen!

🎧 LET'S CONNECT: What's the best fiction book you've read on addiction or recovery? Tap that comment feature on Spotify—I'd love to hear your picks!

🗓 BOOK CLUB INVITE: Patrons, check your inbox for a printable version of this list and an invite to our April 25th chat with Lynda Cohen Loigman on The Love Elixir of Augusta Stern. We'll discuss her cozy, feel-good novel about finding love in your eighties. It's a face-hurting-from-smiling kind of read!

📝 Love this show? Leave a review on Apple Podcasts—it's a free way to support my work and help other book lovers find us. And to my Book Gang patrons: you've given me bright years I didn't know were possible. Thank you!

Sarah Damoff lives in Texas with her husband and children, where she is a social worker. Her work has appeared inPorter House Review, Ruminate Magazine, and Open Global Rights, among other publications. The Bright Years is her debut novel. 

Download Today's Show Transcript

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: 19 Addiction Fiction Books to Read Now

Join the April Book Club Chat (The Love Elixir of Augusta Stern)

The Bright Years by Sarah Damoff

Young Park

The Best Debut Novels of 2023 with Thao Thai

Banyan Moon by Thao Thai

Lost Children Archive by Valeria Luiselli

Claire Lombardo 

A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith

Lisa Genova

Broken Country by Clare Leslie Hall

Barbara Kingsolver

Maggie O'Farrell

Dani Shapiro

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Sarah on Instagram or her Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Sarah Harman shares the journey behind All the Other Mothers Hate Me, from journalism to fiction, a fierce book auction, and its upcoming FX adaptation.

You'll know immediately if this book is for you from the opening line: "The missing boy is ten-year-old Alfie Risby, and to be perfectly honest with you, he's a little shit."

That audacious beginning sets the tone for All the Other Mothers Hate Me, a compulsively readable thriller perfect for fans of Big Little Lies and Finlay Donovan.

Sarah Harman's journey to publication is just as gripping as her novel. A former foreign correspondent for NBC News, Harman's background in breaking news reporting brings a sharp, fast-paced edge to her storytelling. Her debut became the subject of a fierce bidding war, ultimately securing a major deal—and soon, it'll hit the screen, adapted for FX by The Bear's Christopher Storer.

In this episode, we discuss:

• How All the Other Mothers Hate Me subverts the missing-child thriller trope
• The surreal experience of a nine-way auction for her book deal
• Her involvement in adapting the novel for television
• The cultural and feminist themes woven into her story

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: This week's book list features 30 Amateur Sleuth Novels that will keep you on your toes. From upcoming releases to backlist gems, we've got plenty of whodunits to explore.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION!

Who is your favorite amateur sleuth in fiction? Drop a comment on Spotify—I'd love to hear your recommendations!

Sarah Harman is an American journalist-turned-thriller writer living in London. Before making her fiction debut, she spent over a decade covering major global news stories. Her novel All the Other Mothers Hate Me is out now from Putnam, with translation rights sold in 15 countries and a TV adaptation in the works.

Download Today's Show Transcript

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: 30 Unlikely Amateur Sleuths Are On The Case In This Book Stack

Join the March Book Club Chat (Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson)

All the Other Mothers Hate Me by Sarah Harman

Professional Book Nerds: Spring's Best New Books with Amy Allen Clark

Emancipation of Mimi

Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn

Sorrow & Bliss by Meg Mason

Fleabag

Young Adult

Bad Teacher

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Sarah on Instagram or her Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Jinwoo Chong celebrates food, family, & finding love in his cozy novel, I Leave It Up To You. Learn how this project helped him fall in love with writing again.

What if you fell asleep in 2019 and woke up in 2021? That's the reality for Jack Jr., who emerges from a two-year coma to find his life unrecognizable. His job is gone, his apartment is lost, and his partner has moved on. But in his return to his childhood home and his family's struggling restaurant, he begins to rebuild—rekindling relationships, rediscovering love, and redefining what home truly means.

Jinwoo Chong shares the beautiful inspiration behind this poignant and tender slice-of-life novel, which seamlessly blends a swoon-worthy love story with a cozy family drama. We discuss how I Leave It Up to You evolved from a short story, the impact of the pandemic on its themes, and the role of food as both a comfort and a metaphor for resilience.

BONUS BOOK LIST: Don't miss our Captivating Books About Nurses Book List, featuring 28 incredible new and backlist titles celebrating caregivers.

Meet Jinwoo Chong

Jinwoo Chong is the author of Flux, a finalist for the PEN/Hemingway and VCU Cabell First Novel awards, and a New York Times Book Review Editors' Choice. His work has appeared in The Southern Review, Guernica, The Rumpus, and more. His latest novel, I Leave It Up to You, is now available from Penguin Random House.

Today's Show Transcript

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: 28 Captivating Books About Nurses

Join the March Book Club Chat (Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson)

I Leave It Up to You by Jinwoo Chong

Flux by Jinwoo Chong

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Jinwoo on Instagram or his Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Eowyn Ivey joins us from Alaska to discuss her latest magical realism novel, Black Woods Blue Sky. Prepare to be transported by one of my favorite storytellers!

The queen of magical realism, Eowyn Ivey, joins us to share intriguing insights into her third novel, Black Woods Blue Sky, and how her deep connection to Alaska continues to shape her storytelling.

She also discusses the challenges of writing through a difficult personal season, the impact of reuniting with her longtime editorial team, and the immersive research that took her to a remote hunting camp on Kodiak Island.

Discover her ties to the character Emmaleen, how Birdie's contradictions capture the realities of relatable motherhood, and what stereotypes about rural Alaska she wanted to challenge through her character's bookish adventures.

Don't miss this week's Fairy Tale Retellings Book List featuring 27 magical books to escape with this weekend. I hope you love it!  

Patrons can join us for a bonus spoiler-filled conversation! Eowyn will share her thoughts on Blackwood's Blue Sky ending and the fine line she teetered between reality and imagination in her moving story. Get your tissues- it's a beautiful bonus chat.

Meet Eowyn Ivey

Eowyn Ivey is the bestselling author of The Snow Child, a Pulitzer Prize finalist, and To the Bright Edge of the World. Born and raised in Alaska, she draws inspiration from its rugged landscapes and folklore. Black Woods Blue Sky is her highly anticipated third novel, which is now available on store shelves from Random House.

Today's Show Transcript

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: 27 Fairy Tale Retellings to Enchant Your Reading Life

Join the March Book Club Chat (Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson)

Black Woods Blue Sky by Eowyn Ivey

The Snow Child by Eowyn Ivey

To the Bright Edge of the World by Eowyn Ivey

Ruth Hulbert

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Eowyn on Instagram or her Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Erin Crosby Eckstine discusses her debut novel, Junie, and how her family history transformed her life from English teacher to chosen GMA Book Club novelist. 

In this episode, Erin Crosby Eckstine shares the moving inspiration behind her debut novel Junie, a profoundly personal story rooted in her own family's history.

Erin reveals how Junie's character is inspired by her great-great-great-grandmother, Jane Cotton, who escaped slavery and became one of the Black founders of Coosada, Alabama. We discuss the importance of balancing joy and trauma in narratives like these and why it is essential to bring both to readers and those represented in these stories.

You can also discover Erin's unconventional publishing methods, which led to her becoming a GMA Book Club pick, and how her family legacy catalyzed her going from Google Docs to a finished novel.

BONUS BLACK HISTORY MONTH BOOK LIST:

Don't miss this week's Black History Month book list, featuring 36 phenomenal books by Black authors to celebrate this historic month. All books purchased from today's list will be fulfilled through Brain Lair Books, a Black-owned bookshop that has been financially struggling and needs your support to keep its doors open.

Patrons can join us for a bonus spoiler-filled conversation with Erin Crosby Eckstine, where we discuss the surprising plot twists in Junie and the details of this story that she has always wanted to share with her readers.

Meet Erin Crosby Eckstine

Erin Crosby Eckstine is an author of speculative historical fiction, personal essays, and anything else she's in the mood for. Born in Montgomery, Alabama, she grew up between the South and Los Angeles before moving to New York City to attend Barnard College. She earned a master's in secondary English education from Stanford University and taught high school English for six years. Erin lives in Brooklyn with her partner and their cats. JUNIE is her debut novel.

Today's Show Transcript

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: Black History Month Books You Need to Read Now

Join the February Book Club Chat (The Queen of Sugar Hill by ReShonda Tate)

Junie by Erin Crosby Eckstine

The Queen of Sugar Hill by ReShonda Tate

Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell

Sarah Madden

Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte

Jane Austen

Erin as Lady Catherine de Bourgh

The Favorites by Layne Fargo

Kindred by Octavia Butler

Danya Kukafkamo

Notes on an Execution by Danya Kukafka

Good Morning America Book Pick

The Celebrity Book Club Deep Diver Episode You Need

Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Sing, Unburied, Sing by Jesmyn Ward

Isabel Allende

The House of the Spirits by Isabel Allende

The Neapolitan Novels by Elena Ferrante

Pachinko by Min Jin Lee

Our Share of Night by Mariana Enriquez

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Erin on Instagram or her Website

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Paging library lovers- Joe from the Libby team is back to share the exciting app updates and his top five horror book recommendations from 2024 to read now.

In this All-Star Book Influencer series installment, we’re thrilled to spotlight Joe Skelley, cohost of The Professional Book Nerds podcast and a member of the Libby team. Joe shares his favorite features of the Libby app, lesser-known tips for maximizing your library experience, and exciting updates on the horizon for readers.

What You’ll Learn in This Episode:

• Sneak peeks at upcoming Libby features and enhancements.
• How to manage packed holds lists and uncover hidden library gems.
• Tips for new Libby users to get started and make the most of the app.

In the second half of the episode, Amy and Joe dive into the world of horror literature. Joe shares:

• What first drew him to horror and why he loves the genre.
• How horror reflects societal fears and captures anxieties relevant to today.
• Advice for readers hesitant to try horror, including recommendations that focus on atmosphere and psychological tension over gore.

Discover five of Joe’s must-read horror recommendations that range from chilling novellas to groundbreaking works by authors redefining the genre.

Whether you’re here for the horror or want to optimize your library experience, this episode has something for every reader.

Meet Joe

Joe Skelley is one of the co-hosts of the Professional Book Nerds podcast. He is also a Marketing and Events Specialist at OverDrive, where he leads the coordination of the Library Vehicle as it tours around the US and Canada, contributes to the Check Out Your Library movement, and works on special events for OverDrive’s Digipalooza conference.

When he isn’t working, Joe loves to listen to audiobooks and podcasts, get too involved in a craft or DIY project, and (most importantly) spend time with his Boston Terrier, Roscoe!

NEW BONUS BOOK LIST: 5 New Horror Books to Read Now

Join the January Book Club Chat (How to Read a Book by Monica Wood)

Professional Book Nerds Podcast

Get the Most Out of the Libby App (Podcast Episode)

Libby App

How The StoryGraph Can Enhance Your Reading Life (Podcast Episode)

Jackal by Erin E Adams

The House in the Pines by Ana Reyes

Horror Movie by Paul Tremblay

Bury Your Gays by Chuck Tingle

Pounded In The Butt By My Own Butt by Chuck Tingle

Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle

The Honeys by Ryan La Sala

Beholder by Ryan La Sala

Clay McLeod Chapman

Cackle by Rachel Harrison

The Return by Rachel Harrison

A Cosmology of Monsters by Shaun Hamill

One’s Company by Ashley Hutson

Diavola by Jennifer Thorne

So Thirsty by Rachel Harrison

Black Sheep by Rachel Harrison

We Used to Live Here by Marcus Kliewer

The Strangers

Coup de Grace by Sofia Ajram

Kanopy

A24

A Mask of Flies by Matthew Lyons

Monstrillo by Gerardo Samano Cordova

Tomie by Junji Ito

Longlegs

Lisa Frankenstein

Letterboxd App

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Joe on the Professional Book Nerds Podcast and Instagram

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

We read a total of 482 books and are excited to share fifteen of our favorite titles from our 2024 reading list. Explore these new releases alongside our favorite backlist books for your best reading year yet.

We invite you to browse our book lists featuring 25 of our favorites. Patrons will receive a printable checklist with today's book titles and some of our honorable mentions. 

SUPPORT MY WORK through Patreon!

Larry's Top 25 Books of 2024 (Including Honorable Mentions)

Amy's Top 25 Books of 2024

The God of the Woods by Liz Moore

Cleopatra and Frankenstein by Coco Mellors

Blue Sisters by Coco Mellors

Family Family by Laurie Frankel

Real Americans by Rachel Khong

Here One Moment by Liane Moriarty

Beautiful Ugly by Alec Feeney

PS I Hate You by Lauren Connolly

The Women by Kristin Hannah

The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah

Honey by Isabel Bonta

Cinema Love by Jiaming Tang

The Wedding People by Alison Espach

Wish You Weren't Here by Christy Schillig

Friends with Secrets by Christine Gunderson

Things Don’t Break on Their Own by Sarah Easter Collins

James by Percival Everett

The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain

Wicked by Gregory Maguire

Dear Fang, with Love by Rufi Thorpe

Don’t Forget to Write by Sara Goodman Confino

She’s Up to No Good by Sara Goodman Confino

Crafting a Killer Redemption Story With Heart (Rob Hart Interview)

The Wishing Game by Meg Shaffer

How Braving a Literary Seminar Shaped The Lost Story (With Meg Shaffer)

The Best Escapist Island Books Podcast with Meg Shaffer

The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin

The Chronicles of Narnia by CS Lewis

Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle

Everything Beautiful Began After by Simon Van Booy

We Could Be So Good by Cat Sebastian

The Nix by Nathan Hill

The Matchmaker’s Gift by Lynda Cohen Loigman

Redefining the Missing Girl Narrative With Emiko Jean

The Kennedy Ryan Phenomenon: Inclusive Narratives With Heart (Kennedy Ryan Interview)

Bookshop.org pays a 10% commission on every sale and matches 10% to independent bookstores!

Browse Our 2025 Book Club Books

Connect with Larry on Instagram

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Uncover the Agatha Christie beginner's guide with Victoria from The Reader's Couch! Explore her best-underrated gems and find new modern authors like Christie.

Deep dive into Agatha Christie's legacy with Victoria Wood from The Reader's Couch podcast! In this episode of the All-Star Book Influencer Series, we uncover what makes Christie's mysteries so enduring, why her storytelling resonates across generations, and how contemporary authors like Sophie Hannah and Louise Penny have taken cues from her genius.

Takeaways include:

• Victoria's introduction to Christie through The Body in the Library.
• Christie's masterful use of red herrings in stories like And Then There Were None.
• Underrated gems like Crooked House that deserve the spotlight.
• The timeless appeal of the universal themes in Christie's work.

We also discuss how personal connections to literature enhance our reading experiences from other well-known authors and the evolution of Christie's legacy through modern adaptations.

BONUS CONTENT: Be sure to check out Victoria's article, "Beginner's Guide to Agatha Christie Books," which helps new readers explore Poirot, Miss Marple, and her standalone novels.

Victoria Wood hosts The Reader’s Couch Podcast. She is a reading enthusiast who has successfully guided self-proclaimed “non-readers” into cultivating and sustaining reading habits and assisted readers in fostering more intentional and fulfilling reading lives. She hosts conversations with authors to learn more about their writing and reading lives.

The Reader's Couch Podcast

Bibliolifestyle's Booktube Channel

Bibliolifestyle

Salem's Lot by Stephen King

Salem's Lot

The Perfect Couple by Elin Hildebrand

The Perfect Couple

Lady in the Lake by Laura Lippman

Lady in the Lake

Disclaimer by Renee Knight

Wicked by Gregory Maguire

Letterboxd app

Dead in Long Beach, Californiaby Venita Blackburn

The Body in the Library by Agatha Christie

The Secret History by Donna Tartt

Hercule Poirot's Christmas by Agatha Christie & Sophie Hannah

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie 

The ABC Murders by Agatha Christie 

A Pocketful of Rye by Agatha Christie 

Crooked House by Agatha Christie

The Pale Horse by Agatha Christie 

Conclave

Join the Book Gang Patreon

Connect with Victoria on The Reader's Couch Podcast, Instagram, and YouTube

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Get the Daily Kindle Deals Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)

Join the NEW 2025 MomAdvice Book Club and discover 12 incredible novels together along with many interactive author discussions for this year’s festivities.

It's my favorite day of the year (CUE THE CONFETTI) and I'm so excited to invite you to the 2025 MomAdvice Book Club! This year, we're mixing things up to make your book club experience even more immersive and engaging.

As I've done in years past, I've curated twelve fantastic reads spanning genres like historical fiction, romance, contemporary fiction, and even a touch of horror—there's something for everyone this year!

To discover this year's selections, you can head to today's post, which includes all the details, including the recommended format, the reading mood of the novel, and pacing information. Each description also offers the accompanying reader experience, which is PRETTY EPIC this year. After discussing what changes you want to see this year, I hope you'll be excited to experience this with me.

I've also uploaded a podcast going through each of these books for those of you that prefer an audio experience with some behind-the-scenes details. I hope you'll join me on this reading adventure!

Connect With Me:

JOIN THE 2025 MomAdvice Book Club

Connect with Amy on Instagram, TikTok, or MomAdvice

Get My Happy List Newsletter

Buy Me a Coffee (for a one-time donation)