Brownstone Journal

Brownstone Journal

By Brownstone InstituteNewsNews Commentary
Download on the App Store

Brownstone Journal episodes

  • The Spindle-Proofing Business
    By Sofia Karstens at Brownstone dot org.
    Do you remember the fairy godmother Merryweather in Sleeping Beauty? She's the one who, when the evil queen curses the newborn Aurora to prick her finger on a spindle and die on her sixteenth birthday, can't undo the curse…but she can soften it. So she uses her own gift to change the ending: not death, but a deep, enchanted sleep.
    There is a whole lot of seemingly coordinated (dare I call it) panic right now around AI. I've written extensively about the legitimate, existential dangers we do need to address in technology. But my spidey sense tells me this current fever pitch isn't that.
    For one thing: why now? I'm certainly not the only person who's been writing about these issues for years or believes we've already crossed that threshold. So why the sudden, synchronized urgency? Why is someone like Bill Gates – after literally decades as AI's most prominent optimist – suddenly publishing a 6,000-word essay warning that we've "passed AI's danger thresholds," calling for new national and international regulatory bodies? What's in it for him, now, after all this time?
    A psyop is never just one thing. It's a wilderness of mirrors. A single mirror shows you one reflection you can identify and correct for. A wilderness of them means every angle you check reflects another angle, with no clean vantage point outside the hall to verify against, which is functionally what a multi-actor convergence produces, even without any one person orchestrating it. You don't need an overlord director standing behind the glass for the hall of mirrors to work. And that's the unsettling part: a single coordinated psyop presumably has an off switch, in principle, if you ever find the operator.
    A wilderness of independently-incentivized mirrors doesn't. There's no one thread to pull. You'd have to defund the labs' marketing incentive, restructure the regulatory capture dynamics, fix the media business model, and drain the political utility out of "AI-as-boogeyman" – separately, all at once – for the reflection to actually stop. It isn't one thing. It's five or six things (usually at least), each independently profitable or useful to a different party, all predictably, reliably, producing the same noise.
    The convergence looks a little something like:
    Genuine researcher concern, unevenly calibrated by a public conversation where the public-facing volume of the concern exceeds its actual epistemic certainty.
    Commercial incentive: "This is so capable it could go wrong" is also, uncomfortably, a marketing claim.
    Regulatory capture dynamics, probably the spear tip: heavy compliance regimes burden small competitors while incumbents absorb them easily, and some of the loudest voices demanding regulation run the largest labs.
    Media incentive: fear and novelty both outperform nuance for engagement, full stop, independent of subject matter. This would be true of AI coverage even if none of the other factors existed.
    And political utility: AI fear has become a genuinely useful rhetorical tool across very different political projects…It serves centralized-control arguments, deregulatory "beat China" urgency, and culture-war anxieties about job loss or loss of control all at once, depending on who's using it. Much of this predates AI entirely and would've attached to some other target if AI hadn't come along.
    None of these require a coordinating hand talking to the other four. They just currently point the same direction, for reasons specific to each actor's own incentives. It's a hat rack: real, separate, true things, all easy to hang on the same peg, creating the appearance of a unified campaign without requiring one to actually exist.
    There's a mainstream body of scholarship describing this mechanism. Gregory Dickinson, in his Harvard Journal on Legislation article "Law Proofing the Future," writes in the section "Big Tech and Regulatory Capture:" "the very platforms and app makers whose companies make prompt calls for reg...
    13 min
  • What Lessons Can We Learn from Wendell Berry?
    By Renaud Beauchard at Brownstone dot org.
    Wendell Berry died on August 31 at his farm in Port Royal, Kentucky. He was 92. For more than half a century he farmed with horses, wrote in pencil, adamantly refused to purchase a computer, and insisted that the health of a person cannot be separated from the health of a place. That faithfulness to a place is the part of his thought that the health freedom movement most needs now.
    Health, Berry never tired of saying, comes from the same root as whole, heal, and holy. To be healthy is to be whole. Health as wholeness is not a decree from the medical apparatus. It is membership to a community: belonging to other people and to a particular piece of earth. "I believe that the community—in the fullest sense: a place and all its creatures—is the smallest unit of health," he wrote, "and that to speak of the health of an isolated individual is a contradiction in terms."
    That sentence should hang over every discussion of medical liberty. The movement for health freedom has rightly fought for informed consent, against coercive public-health machinery, against the reduction of the body to a set of data to be mined by the Biosecurity State. Those fights are essential, but they are not sufficient.
    A person who has successfully kept the State out of his bloodstream can still be unwell if the soil from which comes the food that feeds him is dead, if the water he drinks is polluted, if his neighborhood is atomized, and if the food system that feeds him is a chain of distant, chemicalized abstractions. Autonomy without membership to the kind of community Berry wrote about all his life is not worthy of a fight.
    Berry made the connection explicit in an essay entitled "The Body and the Earth," collected in The Unsettling of America and later in The Art of the Commonplace. Our bodies, he wrote, "are moving particles of the earth, joined inextricably both to the soil and to the bodies of other living creatures." It is therefore unsurprising that we treat our bodies as we treat the land.
    When we treat land as an extractive resource, as something to be mined, specialized, chemically altered, and abandoned, we treat the body the same way: as a machine whose parts can be isolated, optimized, and replaced by specialists who have no interest in nutrition, agriculture, or the wholesomeness of mind and spirit. "It is therefore absurd," he wrote, "to approach the subject of health piecemeal with a departmentalized band of specialists." A doctor uninterested in the health of soil is as absurd, continued Berry, as a farmer uninterested in the health of people.
    In this view, healing is not a procedure performed on an isolated organism. "Healing is impossible in loneliness; it is the opposite of loneliness. Conviviality is healing. To be healed we must come with all the other creatures to the feast of Creation." The feast is local. It requires a place that is intimately known, cared for with affection, and kept whole enough to keep giving. Love of place is not a shmaltzy slogan. It is the condition of knowledge and of care. You cannot properly care for what you do not love, and you cannot love what you refuse to know in its particularity.
    This is the lesson the health freedom movement must take from Berry without abandoning its core commitments. Medical freedom is a necessary defense against the Machine, but it is of little use if we don't know where our food comes from, who grows it and how, what a neighborhood looks like when the soil is alive, or what care looks like when it is not outsourced to distant systems that treat both land and body as inputs.
    Berry's answer was never a set of slick policies. It was faithfulness to a place and to the kind of labor that the love of a place requires. Berry left his native Kentucky to study at Stanford and teach in New York City, but he returned to Henry County, farmed it, wrote about it, and refused the careerist mobility that treats every locality as interchangeable.
    The ...
    8 min
  • Food Labeling Should Not Be This Hard
    By Daniel Nuccio at Brownstone dot org.
    Knowing what's in your food or whether what you're about to eat comports with a medically prescribed diet can be difficult. There's no reason why the government should make it harder. But that's exactly what the United States Department of Agriculture and Food and Drug Administration are doing when they prohibit companies from conveying information about FODMAP content on food labels.
    Although not inherently harmful to most people, FODMAPs are a broad category of short-chain carbohydrates and sugar alcohols believed to trigger gastrointestinal symptoms in individuals living with irritable bowel syndrome and possibly several other functional gastrointestinal disorders.
    In technical terms, FODMAPs are fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols. More practically, people with IBS might want to be careful around most standard dairy items, honey, several cereals and artificial sweeteners, and a cornucopia of fruits, vegetables, legumes, and spices.
    When consumed, these items can lead to luminal distension by causing increased amounts of water to enter the gastrointestinal tract and increased gas production by bacteria living in the colon. In some individuals with IBS and other functional gut disorders, this may trigger or exacerbate certain symptoms of their condition (e.g., intense pain and changes in intestinal motility), possibly through neurons in the gut responding abnormally to these physiological responses to FODMAP consumption.
    Hence, some patients with these conditions choose to limit their FODMAP intake or are encouraged to do so by their health care provider. Some go on strict low-FODMAP diets long term. Others temporarily do so for two to eight weeks then work to reintroduce specific FODMAP-containing foods into their diet to determine what they can tolerate. Broadly speaking, a lot of patients with relevant conditions find that the diet helps alleviate their symptoms.
    Low-FODMAP diets though are generally considered sort of bland. They also tend to require a certain amount of time and education to be effective. Looking at a table of high- and low-FODMAP foods to make decisions about what to eat may not require an advanced degree in nutrition, but it is not difficult to imagine how having to break out such a table to evaluate every item you consider purchasing at the grocery store could become rather burdensome, especially if you're new to the diet.
    Fortunately, there are organizations and companies out there to help. Monash University, for example, has labs that both study the effectiveness of low-FODMAP diets and test food items for FODMAP content. Monash also offers several resources to help those on low-FODMAP diets make informed meal choices and works with companies that wish to offer low-FODMAP food options. If a company wants to submit a product to Monash for evaluation and Monash determines the item is low in FODMAP content, the company can then use a trademarked label to convey this information to consumers.
    However, as one US company learned, even if one of the world's leading FODMAP research facilities tells you your food is low in FODMAPs, this isn't exactly the kind of thing you can just put on a label in the United States.
    In 2018, Ketan Vakil, after dealing with his own digestive issues involving FODMAPs, saw an opening in the market to cater to customers on low-FODMAP diets by offering diet-compatible broths and spice blends that could safely add some flavor to this notoriously bland diet. Hence, he founded Gourmend Foods, and, after getting a chicken broth and some spice blends low-FODMAP certified by Monash, Vakil and Gourmend proceeded to sell those items online and in retail using Monash's trademarked label.
    However, in 2022 when Vakil expanded Gourmend's product line with a low-FODMAP beef broth, he learned from the USDA while going through a pre-approval process for the beef broth's label that it would be illegal for him to in...
    9 min
  • The Cocooning Racket Needs to End
    By Jeffrey A. Tucker at Brownstone dot org.
    An email arrived from a reader that posed a serious problem, a general one of which I was only vaguely aware. It deals with an issue deeply intimate to all family life. It affects the crucial cultural matter of the prolongation of legacy and human life itself.
    Her niece is expecting a baby. The child is due in three weeks, which means that it will be around for Thanksgiving holidays. Instead of treating this as a glorious opportunity for the extended family to marvel with delight over new life, hearts lifted all around, the mother is treating family as nothing more than walking and talking disease vectors.
    On the advice of her pediatrician, she is banning anyone from getting near the baby unless they have fully four shots: D-Tap, Covid, flu, and RSV. This is because the baby cannot be vaccinated with D-Tap for two months. The entire family is being told this and people are trying to figure out what to do.
    Some will refuse and be relegated to Zoom contact. Some will be masked and gloved. Others will go along and risk injury to themselves for absolutely no reason.
    The practice is called cocooning. It makes no sense at all. Cocooning is different from nest building, which is a normal sense of wanting time to bond and learn and care. This is different. It is a pharmacological innovation that implies that the basic immune system is deeply flawed without the injection of industrial products and therefore a newborn can only be around other maximally injected people.
    The Covid and flu shots are known to register negative efficacy. None of these shots can prevent transmission, an indisputable fact. Moreover, every pharmaceutical carries risks. Four at once carries more risk than one.
    In effect, the new mother is exercising soft power, blackmailing her family by denying joy to them unless they give money to the shotmakers. Think of it as an informal vaccine passport imposed by cautious new moms who have no idea they are being manipulated by powerful industrial interests.
    I was shocked by this email but apparently this is very common. It's a policy. Incredibly, the CDC itself recommends this: "A baby's family members and caregivers should be up to date on their vaccinations to help form a circle of disease protection around the baby."

    If you believe that, I've got a closet full of potions to sell you.
    It's a wonder humanity has survived so long without such exhortations! It's "social distancing" applied to pediatrics, without the same evidence in support, which is to say none.
    A maker of one D-Tap shot is GlaxoSmithKline. Ten years ago, they put out an advertising campaign for their shot called Boostrix. It featured a wolf holding a baby. The campaign was called Big Bad Cough. The message was that no young mother should let anyone without Boostrix near her newborn child.

    A class-action lawsuit was launched on grounds that the potion does not actually protect against spread. The company settled the lawsuit. Disbursements are now going out to people who took the shot under the advertising campaign's influence.
    The plaintiffs in the lawsuit had claimed "physical and emotional injury, the injection creating in their bodies a defective immunity to pertussis that will last the remainder of their lives, receiving a painful injection of various substances into their bodies that they would not have received otherwise, expending time and resources to seek out and obtain Boostrix, paying, directly or indirectly, in whole or in part, for Boostrix, and after GSK led them to fear that without Boostrix they were in danger of spreading pertussis, receiving the product has actually rendered them more likely to spread pertussis and hence only increased the fear created by GSK."
    The courts did not ultimately rule. The company settled to prevent that for good reason. The jabbed accepted the payout rather than take the challenge all the way.
    We've only begun to discuss the complete fraudulence of the entire co...
    9 min
  • A Hall of Mirrors of the Healthy Vaccinee Effect Introduction Try to Explain HVE to a Professor Three Illusions of Vaccine Effectiveness Model 1: A Sanity Check Model 2: Healthy Vaccinee Effect How to Get It published …Conclusion
    By Tomas Fürst at Brownstone dot org.
    The following is the result of joint work with Jaroslav Janosek, Tadeas Frycak, and Robert Straka.
    Since the registration trials of the Covid-19 vaccines, there have been no randomized studies to track the efficacy of these vaccines. The virus kept mutating and the convalescent fraction of the population has been growing. Thus, the original efficacy figures reported in the registration trials – dubious to start with – were clearly not valid when the mass vaccination campaign started in early 2021. Moreover, in the meantime we learned that the registration trials tested a different product than the one used in the mass vaccination campaign. This cast further doubt on the advertised 95% efficacy against symptomatic infection.
    The Israel 2021 summer wave of infections clearly demonstrated to the whole world that the "vaccines" do not protect against symptomatic infection in any meaningful way. Consequently, the goal posts were moved and the authorities started claiming that the "vaccines" may not protect against infection but they protect against severe course of infection, hospitalisation, and death from Covid. However, there were (and there still are) no data from randomized trials to support this causal claim.
    This embarrassing gap in evidence was filled by a trove of papers that estimated the effectiveness of the "vaccines" from observational data. Most of these studies claimed the vaccine effectiveness was very high, often close to 100%. Rogue governments all over the world used these studies to force people into vaccination.
    Readers of this forum know very well that observational data are loaded with the so-called Healthy Vaccinee Effect. This is a type of indication bias that originates from healthy people having easier access to the vaccine. For example, people on their deathbed are usually not vaccinated, which means that deaths tend to concentrate in the unvaccinated group, making the vaccinated group much "healthier."
    At the same time, those frailest individuals who are close to the end of their lives are also those most susceptible to die from/with Covid. Healthy Vaccinee Effect (HVE) thus causes observational studies to vastly overestimate vaccine effectiveness against any endpoint (and vastly overestimate vaccine safety as well). The now legendary paper by Tracy Hoeg, Ram Duriseti, and Vinay Prasad showed that the reported 95% effectiveness of Covid vaccines against Covid-related death in Israel in 2021 was entirely due to HVE. In other words, had HVE been removed, the true vaccine effectiveness would have been zero. I still can't figure out how they got this published in the New England Journal of Medicine.
    We first noticed HVE in the middle of 2021 when Angelika Bazalova – an investigative journalist – had the brilliant idea to FOIA her way to the records on all-cause mortality of the clients of several health insurance companies in the Czech Republic. Readers (with an AI translator from Czech) can still see our initial confusion as we were reporting the data and proposing possible explanations (one of the articles was titled "The elixir of youth"). After some time, we made sense of all the data and reported it in a paper for the International Journal of Infectious Diseases and in a further paper in a Polish journal.
    My original conclusion that "this paper invalidates all estimates of vaccine effectiveness based on observation data" was changed to "In view of the presence of HVE, the baseline difference in the frailty of vaccinated and unvaccinated populations in periods without COVID-19 must be taken into account when estimating COVID-19 vaccine effectiveness from observational data." But that is the Newspeak we all had to learn during the past years in order to get anything published in official journals.
    Since then, we have been trying to explain HVE to medical professionals, policymakers, researchers, and the public. It has been frustrating. Most people think that the v...
    18 min
  • Medicine Has Forgotten How to Touch the Patient The Patient Before the Data The Screen between Us The Physical Examination Is Not Primitive Technology We Are Losing the Teachers Too Touch Is Also Communication Covid Accelerated the Distance And Now Comes
    By Joseph Varon at Brownstone dot org.
    When was the last time your doctor actually examined you? I do not mean when someone checked your blood pressure, copied your medication list, looked at your laboratory results, or listened briefly through a shirt before returning to the computer. I mean examined you. Looked at you. Watched you breathe. Felt your pulse. Looked at your eyes. Examined your neck. Listened carefully to your heart and lungs. Palpated your abdomen. Watched you walk. Noticed the color of your skin, the movement of your hands, the expression on your face, and the thousand other small pieces of information that a human body offers to someone who has learned how to observe it.
    For most of the history of medicine, this was not an optional ritual performed before ordering the "real tests." This was medicine. Today, increasingly, it is treated as something quaint, inefficient, or unnecessary.
    I have spent most of my professional life taking care of very sick people. Critical care is one of the most technologically intensive areas of medicine ever created. I love technology. I have watched mechanical ventilators breathe for patients who could no longer breathe for themselves. I have used ultrasound, CT imaging, sophisticated hemodynamic monitoring, extracorporeal technologies, molecular diagnostics, and laboratory measurements that physicians a generation before me could only have dreamed about.
    I would never want to return to a world without these tools. But after decades at the bedside, I have also learned something that becomes more obvious, not less, with experience: technology is most powerful when it extends the physician's senses. It becomes dangerous when it persuades the physician that those senses are no longer necessary.
    Experienced clinicians understand something that is remarkably difficult to teach in a lecture hall or classroom. Sometimes you walk into a room and know immediately that something is wrong. You may not yet know what it is, but you know it before the laboratory does. The patient is breathing differently. His skin looks different. She answers a question a fraction of a second more slowly than she did several hours earlier. Posture, speech, facial expression, respiratory effort, or level of attention changes. None of these observations is magical. They are data, collected by a biological instrument trained through thousands and thousands of encounters: the physician.
    When I round in an intensive care unit (ICU), I can learn an enormous amount before touching the computer. I can see whether a patient is fighting the ventilator. I can hear secretions from the doorway. I can see accessory muscles contracting. I can recognize when someone who looked reasonably comfortable earlier suddenly looks exhausted. I can see peripheral perfusion, diaphoresis, agitation, abdominal distension, or a subtle change in mental status. None of this means I should ignore the arterial blood gas, the chest radiograph, the CT scan, or the monitor. Of course I need them. The mistake is believing that because those measurements are more technologically sophisticated, they are necessarily more real than what is happening directly in front of me.
    Medicine once began with the patient and proceeded toward testing. Increasingly, it begins with testing and eventually works its way back toward the patient. Abraham Verghese and colleagues have described this inversion of the diagnostic process, in which clinicians may encounter an image or electronic representation of a patient before encountering the patient himself. That change sounds subtle. It is not. Once the CT scan, laboratory panel, consultant note, medication list, and previous diagnoses have entered our minds, we no longer approach the patient without preconceptions. The data have already told us what we are supposed to see.
    This is one reason the physical examination should never be reduced to nostalgia. Its value is not that physicians once carried black bags and ...
    26 min
  • Why I Don't Trust Legacy Media Written Testimony of James E. Erdman III Before the U.S. Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee Full Committee Hearing: Whistleblower Testimony on the COVID Coverup May 13, 2026
    By Paul Thacker at Brownstone dot org.
    During a bombshell Senate hearing last week, CIA officer, Jim Erdman III testified under oath that the CIA's scientific analysts determined that the Covid pandemic started from a lab leak, but their scientific conclusions were hidden from Congress and the American public, in what Erdman called "a coverup."
    "Public policy would have been very different had the American public been made aware that a virus from a lab in China was going to serve as the foundation for an Emergency Use Authorization of mRNA products being mandated by the former administration," Erdman said, questioning the validity of the Covid vaccine approval process.
    Erdman also indicted Tony Fauci, the then-director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), for inserting himself into the Intelligence Community's (IC) assessment of the Covid origins, on two documented occasions. In both instances, Fauci steered IC discussion toward a natural origin and away from declaring that the pandemic started from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which Fauci had funded via US government grants.
    "Dr. Anthony Fauci influenced the IC's analytic process and COVID origin's findings by leveraging his position to ensure the IC consulted with a conflicted list of curated Subject Matter Experts (SME), public health officials, and scientists. This included the authors of the paper 'The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2' and other public health experts and scientists who have been in his orbit for 20+ years, many of whom have and did receive funding from NIAID, as well as scientists working under IC contract. This contradicts Dr. Fauci's 2024 testimony to Congress, when he answered 'not to my knowledge' when asked if he had briefed any intel agency concerning viral research."
    — Testimony of James E. Erdman III before the US Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee
    Such explosive charges—a CIA coverup, Fauci's complicity, and the misguided approval of Covid vaccines—should have ignited a media inferno; instead we got a cold frost. No front-page headline from the New York Times, no angry Washington Post editorial, no story of horror from NPR. And frozen silence from Science Magazine, Nature, Scientific American, and The Atlantic. Not even an icy tweet.
    Now why is that? The answer is rather obvious.
    From the pandemic's beginning these media outlets have promoted the fairy tale that lab accident talk is paranoid conspiracy theory and anyone questioning the efficacy and safety of Covid vaccines is a lunatic who hates science, the laws of physics, and arithmetic taught in kindergarten. Evidence to the contrary, such as a CIA official testifying under oath to the Senate, leaves these writers only two options to preserve both the narrative and their own threadbare journalistic credibility:
    1. Knock it down – find someone willing to call newly uncovered facts a "conspiracy theory" and dash out your narrative enforcing news piece.
    2. Hard ignore – pretend newly uncovered facts don't exist, keep your powder dry, and pray like hell the public gets distracted by oil prices and foreign conflict.
    Erdman was too credible for legacy media to skewer, and his testimony forced them to pick the second option.
    A week after he testified, not a single reporter has managed to float a flimsy critique that aims to dent Erdman's story with rumors from unnamed sources that he once brushed up against an intern in the CIA's halls or stole a stapler from the agency's office supply closet. Nothing even from the downtrodden Rolling Stone which only exists because people now on Medicare have faint memories that this corpse of a magazine once published news with a faint regard for accuracy.
    Nonetheless, I get up every morning, and after dropping my daughter off at school, sit in a café and scroll though the New York Times and Washington Post, reading as many stories as I can in the hour it takes me to down two cups of coffee. I do this bec...
    44 min
  • Inside the Safety Record Behind Israel's Early Myocarditis Warning to Global Health Authorities What Happened to the Warning? Was the Official Reassurance Justified? What Was at Stake?
    By Yaffa Shir-Raz at Brownstone dot org.
    On February 28, 2021, Israel's Ministry of Health alerted health authorities on both sides of the Atlantic to an emerging cardiac safety signal following the Pfizer Covid-19 vaccine.
    The warning came just over two months after Israel had launched one of the fastest vaccination campaigns in the world, placing the country at the forefront of the global rollout.
    That day, the Ministry informed the European Medicines Agency that it was investigating a "safety signal of myocarditis/peri-myocarditis in the younger population (16–30 years old)" and had already received reports of around 40 cases. A CDC internal tasking memo from the same day recorded that Israel was seeing "a large number of reports of myocarditis, particularly in young people," and was seeking contacts at the CDC and FDA to discuss the issue. The message was marked "Importance: High."
    Three days later, Dr. Roee Singer, Deputy Director of Epidemiology at Israel's Ministry of Health, wrote directly to the CDC: "We are seeing a large number of myocarditis and pericarditis cases in young individuals soon after Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. We would like to discuss the issue with a relevant expert at CDC."

    It was, in every sense, a "Houston, we have a problem" moment.
    The alarm had been sounded. But what, exactly, had Israeli health officials seen that prompted it? And when, and how, was that warning communicated to physicians and the public?
    Our newly published study in EXCLI Journal discloses and analyzes an internal Israeli Ministry of Health pharmacovigilance dataset that had never been made public. The dataset was provided to us by a whistleblower whose identity we are protecting. The file itself was titled, in Hebrew, "Reports of Hospitalizations and Deaths to Pfizer," and contains detailed case-level reports documented by the Ministry of Health during the vaccination campaign.
    The record was not reconstructed years later, after vaccine-associated myocarditis had become an established safety concern. It was being built in real time as the signal emerged.
    The dataset provided to us comprised eight cumulative versions, all sharing an original creation date of March 25, 2021. The record was updated repeatedly for more than a year as new cases were added and existing reports were revised with additional clinical information. The final version extends through May 9, 2022.
    Already on March 25, just over three weeks after Israel first sounded the international alarm, the record contained 157 hospitalization reports and 46 death reports. Sixty-five of the hospitalization reports involved myocarditis or pericarditis.
    By the final version of the dataset, myocarditis or pericarditis appeared in 250 of 531 hospitalization reports, nearly half. Among patients under 30, it appeared in 151 of 211 reports, more than 70%.
    The dataset has no population denominator, so it cannot tell us how frequently these events occurred among vaccinated people, and the reports themselves cannot establish causality. However, these were not simply reports sitting in a passive reporting system.
    They documented serious events involving hospitalizations and deaths, with detailed clinical information compiled into an internal Ministry of Health record, updated over time, and reported to Pfizer for assessment. Their inclusion in this record and transmission to Pfizer indicate that the cases were considered sufficiently temporally or clinically relevant to vaccination to warrant pharmacovigilance documentation and assessment, even though causality had not been established. The Ministry itself had already identified and reported a cardiac safety signal, and the reports continued to accumulate after that warning was issued.
    We analyzed the reported events, reconstructed the communication timeline, and examined when and how the signal was communicated to health professionals and the public. To enable independent examination and reproduction of our analyses, we publishe...
    19 min
  • Dear Colleagues: A Documentary History Communication with the Administration on the College's Testing and Vaccine Policies The Comically Grotesque Coda at the End of It All
    By Thomas Harrington at Brownstone dot org.
    On April 29, 2020 as the College was beginning its discussion of whether it should reopen for in-person classes in the fall of that same year, I submitted the following post to the Faculty Listserv.
    I thought some of you might be interested in yesterday's statistics from the CDC regarding total Covid fatalities for various age tranches of the US population to date.
    The 15-24 age cohort—which presumably includes most of our students— and is made up of 42,970,800 individuals has seen 33 Covid deaths.
    So, based on these numbers, the chances of someone in this age group dying from Covid are, if my feeble arithmetic skills are accurate, is:
    0.00007679%
    In the 25-34 group there have been:
    233 deaths out of a cohort of 45,697,774 people
    In the 35-44 group there have been:
    599 deaths out of a cohort of 41,277,888 people
    In the 45-54 group there have been:
    1,649 deaths out of a cohort of 41,631,699 people
    In the 55-64 group there have been:
    3,970 deaths out of a cohort of 42,272,636 people
    So, when we take all the numbers of people between 15 and 64 in the US, which presumably includes almost all those who might find themselves working in and around a college campus, we get:
    6,484 deaths out of a total number of 213,850,797 people
    So again, if my feeble math skills are correct, then the following is the current death rate from Covid for all people from 15-64
    0.003%
    The figures here were taken last evening from this page.
    No one on the Listserv challenged my statistics. However, a number did try to reframe this seemingly straightforward matter. One stated by saying that lethality was the wrong measure to be talking about as there are other damages from exposure.
    However, this person provided no facts or even anecdotes to back up the claim.
    Another told us about a friend who is a nurse in New York who said lots of people were dying there. Again, however, no statistics were adduced.
    Finally, another said lethality in the general population was not the right measure as we should be talking about deaths among the infected. When I responded that since we don't know who is infected, we cannot determine that number and thus this was the best we could do, no response was forthcoming.
    Later that same day, I sent the following note to the Listserv in response to a colleague who, after referencing the statistics from the Diamond Princess and the Santa Clara study, and admitting that the levels of infections and fatalities were quite low in that ship of mostly senior citizens but concluded, without providing any evidence, that this meant that the testing must be faulty. In other words, he just somehow knew—media conditioning is indeed a powerful thing—that the virus had to be much more lethal than the Diamond Princess and Santa Clara studies had shown it to be. Here is my response.
    Dear XXX
    Fine. But you can't have it both ways. Either, as has been suggested, we are all in danger because the virus has not spread and will eventually get to everybody and we thus need to be vigilant for the coming wave of sickness is produced.
    Or as the cruise ship numbers—derived from what which is I presume is a pretty ideal venue for infection— demonstrate, and the Santa Clara study you mention also shows, that infection does not necessarily spread as rapidly or as extensively as once thought.
    So, which assumption are we working with?
    In the end, given the heavy reliance on differing, but as yet unproven assumptions regarding the extent and rate of spread of the disease in the absence of testing, the most stable indicator would appear to be deaths caused over time.
    On another note, both Spain and Italy are generally viewed as being considerably ahead of the US in terms of the development of the epidemic and well ahead of the US in deaths per million.
    Or to use ZZZZ's metaphor, they are in March or April or June of the car driving accident season.
    And yet, in their death numbers by age group, in their tendencies in the ...
    1 hr 11 min
  • The PREP Act: Unchecked Power, Zero Accountability, and a Path Forward The PREP Act: Unchecked Power, Zero Accountability, and a Path Forward Summary Key Points Prep Act Powers and Responsibilities of the Secretary of HHS Analysis of PREP Act Powers Under
    By Robert Malone at Brownstone dot org.
    "The PREP Act and COVID-19, Part 2: The PREP Act Declaration for COVID-19 Countermeasures Updated January 3, 2025" can be found here.
    This Congressional Research Service document explains how the federal government granted sweeping legal immunity to pharmaceutical companies, healthcare providers, and others involved in Covid-19 responses.
    This Congressional Research Service document details how the federal government granted unprecedented legal immunity to pharmaceutical companies, healthcare providers, and others involved in Covid-19 countermeasures through the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness (PREP) Act. Beginning in February 2020, the Secretary of Health and Human Services declared that Covid-19 warranted sweeping liability protections, meaning that if someone was injured or died from a Covid-19 vaccine, treatment, or related product, they generally cannot sue for damages in court.
    The only exception is for "willful misconduct" causing death or serious injury—an extremely high legal standard that is very difficult to prove. Instead of accessing the traditional court system, injured individuals must seek compensation through a government program that has historically been difficult to navigate and provides limited relief.
    The scope of these immunity protections expanded dramatically over time, with at least 12amendments issued during both the Trump and Biden administrations. What began as emergency protections for Covid-19 vaccines and treatments eventually encompassed routine childhood vaccines, seasonal flu shots, respiratory protective equipment, and even telehealth consultations conducted across state lines. These declarations also represented significant federal overreach into state authority by explicitly preempting state licensing laws and allowing pharmacists, pharmacy technicians, students, and providers with expired licenses to administer vaccines and medications in ways that state laws wouldn't normally permit. States effectively lost control over regulating medical practice within their own borders, all in the name of expanding the "pool" of vaccine administrators.
    Perhaps most concerning from a conservative perspective is that these immunity protections continue well beyond the end of the public health emergency. While the federal Covid-19 emergency declaration terminated in May 2023, the liability shields for manufacturers and providers remain in effect through December 31, 2029—more than six years later. This arrangement prioritized rapid deployment and corporate interests in enabling medical products to be rushed to market while being shielded from normal liability standards.
    Broad Immunity from Lawsuits: Starting in February 2020, the Secretary of Health and Human Services invoked the PREP Act to shield manufacturers, distributors, and administrators of Covid-19 countermeasures from virtually all legal liability. If you were injured by a Covid-19 vaccine or treatment, you generally cannot sue for damages in court.
    Limited Recourse for Victims: The only exception is for "willful misconduct" causing death or serious injury—an extremely high bar to meet. Instead of courts, injured individuals must seek compensation through a government program (CICP) that historically has been difficult to access and provides limited compensation.
    Scope Expanded Repeatedly: The Trump and Biden administrations amended this declaration at least 12 times, continually broadening who and what received immunity. This eventually covered not just Covid-19 vaccines and treatments, but routine childhood vaccines, influenza shots, protective equipment, and even telehealth consultations across state lines.
    Federal Overreach on State Authority: The declarations explicitly preempted state licensing laws, allowing pharmacists and others to administer vaccines and medications in ways that state law wouldn't normally permit. States lost control over who could practice medicine within their b...
    30 min

About Brownstone Journal

From the publisher's feed

Daily readings from Brownstone Institute authors, contributors, and researchers on public health, philosophy, science, and economics.

More shows like Brownstone Journal

Peak Prosperity by Chris Martenson

Peak Prosperity

571 Listeners

Wise Traditions by Weston A. Price Foundation

Wise Traditions

2,384 Listeners

Gold Goats 'n Guns Podcast by Tom Luongo

Gold Goats 'n Guns Podcast

326 Listeners

Coffee and a Mike by Michael Farris

Coffee and a Mike

378 Listeners

The Delingpod: The James Delingpole Podcast by James Delingpole

The Delingpod: The James Delingpole Podcast

447 Listeners

American Thought Leaders by The Epoch Times

American Thought Leaders

1,252 Listeners

DarkHorse Podcast by Bret Weinstein & Heather Heying

DarkHorse Podcast

5,430 Listeners

The Sharyl Attkisson Podcast by Sharyl Attkisson

The Sharyl Attkisson Podcast

1,804 Listeners

Bannon`s War Room by WarRoom.org

Bannon`s War Room

16,569 Listeners

THE MCCULLOUGH REPORT by Dr. Peter McCullough

THE MCCULLOUGH REPORT

2,436 Listeners

Facts Matter by The Epoch Times

Facts Matter

1,267 Listeners

Man in America Podcast by Man in America

Man in America Podcast

514 Listeners

Doc Malik by Ahmad Malik

Doc Malik

121 Listeners

The Tucker Carlson Show by Tucker Carlson Network

The Tucker Carlson Show

17,911 Listeners

Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words by Victor Davis Hanson | The Daily Signal

Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words

1,846 Listeners