Brownstone Journal

Brownstone Journal

By Brownstone InstituteNewsNews Commentary
Download on the App Store

Brownstone Journal episodes

  • Why Observational Studies Lie to You The Kale-Eating, 6 AM Jogger Effect, and the Placebo Effect The Hormone Replacement Disaster: A Cautionary Tale Statins in Healthy People: The Mirage Continues The Bottom Line: Demand the Coin Flip
    By Alan Cassels at Brownstone dot org.
    If you've spent five minutes paying attention to medical news, you've undoubtedly seen the headlines: "People who take statins have 30% fewer heart attacks!" or "Breast cancer screening makes women live longer!" or "Menopausal Hormone therapy lowers Alzheimer's risk."
    These all sound wonderful, don't they? Just swallow a daily pill, or submit to regular screening, and you'll join the ranks of the immortal. Were only life so simple.
    Yet before you rush off to demand a prescription, let me introduce you to one of the sneakiest, most persistent mirages from the world of medical research, which we call the "Healthy User Bias."
    Readers of Brownstone were recently introduced to this concept related to the Covid vaccines in an article entitled "A Hall of Mirrors of the Healthy Vaccinee Effect," which demonstrated that those who were vaccinated were not the same as those who weren't. Very frail people and those close to death were less likely to get vaccinated, which is understandable, and so those who didn't get the jab died at a higher rate than those that did. Simple, right?
    Understanding this single concept may not, overnight, elevate your medical BS detector from "gullible consumer" to "battle-tested skeptic," but to be fair, it might help.
    What is the Healthy User Bias? It's embarrassingly simple. In observational studies—where researchers merely watch what people do in the real world rather than running an experiment—the people who voluntarily take preventive drugs or pop daily supplements are fundamentally different from those who don't. No surprise there, right?
    On average, "healthy users" are wealthier, better educated, and more health-obsessed. They are seriously more obedient when it comes to vaccines (including the Covid vaccine). These sorts of people want to do the best they can within their powers, which includes things that involve some friction: they eat organic kale, jog at dawn, wear seatbelts, don't smoke, and visit their doctors regularly. They love tests of all kinds.
    A 2006 meta-analysis quantified the healthy user effect (which they called the healthy adherer effect) across 21 studies. What they found is mind-blowing in its implications. It found that those who religiously took their prescribed pills (which we call 'good adherence'), even if it was a placebo, showed a 44% reduction in mortality (which was identical to adherence to proven beneficial therapy). All this shows is that the obedient, healthy people are more likely to do what most physicians want: they take their medication as ordered by their doctors.
    When researchers observe people over ten years and notice they have fewer heart attacks and fewer strokes the light goes on. Hey, they might live longer! This is where pharmaceutical cheerleaders jump up and down, declaring: "Look! It was our pill!"
    No. Sorry, it most likely wasn't the pill. It was the person who took the pill. It was the fact that the patient was already doing 27 zillion other things to stay healthy. Maybe they had a gene that said: don't do stuff to excess that are known to be bad for you (ie: smoking, drinking, committing violent crimes, extreme sports, being grossly overweight, being a couch potato, etc)
    The pill was just along for the ride. Observational research routinely mistakes a healthy lifestyle for pharmaceutical magic.
    By now you're saying, Okay Mr. Alansmartypants, gimme some examples.
    This is a complex, decades long story but likely the biggest medical reversal in modern history: Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) prescribed for women who lived long enough to savour the nasty symptoms of menopause.
    For decades, observational studies swore that HRT was a fountain-of-youth elixir for menopausal women, claiming a 50% reduction in heart attacks. The recommendations to get every woman of a 'certain age' on hormones were ubiquitous. Doctors prescribed it to millions of women around the world, convinced they were doing God's work in prot...
    9 min
  • Our Town Is Every Town
    By Lucio Saverio Eastman at Brownstone dot org.
    In-group or out-group. Clean or unclean. With us or against us. The post-pandemic world seems dominated by themes of a society corrupted by political hatreds, born of hostile emotions constantly on the hunt for targets.
    Remember the masked and the unmasked, the vaccinated and the unvaccinated, the essential workers and the nonessential? This wasn't just a national issue. It burrowed deep into our personal lives and into our own hometowns.
    I moved from Utah to the small New England town of Peterborough, NH 20 years ago to begin a new life, a new job, and to discover new ideas and perspectives. It was a return to "home" in a way. My ancestry settled near here (Temple, Alstead, Amherst, Effingham) after my 8th great-grandfather sailed across the Atlantic Ocean on the ship Confidence and landed at the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1638.
    I chose Peterborough for its abundance of art, music, friendship, activities, and a real sense of being welcomed by neighbors and locals. Even the local politics seemed fairly tame. Granted, there were always a few hotheaded barflies, but their curmudgeonly personas were easy to ignore and chalk up to loneliness or general grumpiness. There are many wonderful people here who I call friends and consider very neighborly to this day.
    When Covid hit in March of 2020, my perspective was yanked completely out of focus. The ugliness that surfaced when power and fear combined revealed how thin the veneer of neighborliness had always been. This was a hard contrast to the ice storm of December 2008 that wiped out power for weeks. In that scenario, people stepped up and really made a difference by helping those in actual need. But with Covid, everything was very different. Dark and full of nervous suspicion.
    It's ironic that the town that inspired Grover's Corners, the setting of Thornton Wilder's Our Town and America's shorthand for small-town decency, set about casting out its own. Some people became the missionaries of compliance, then guardians of virtue, then something far worse…true believers in the righteousness of exclusion.
    It seems so odd for me to say now, but for nearly 15 years I really thought Peterborough was, as its motto (much sighed over by local English teachers) states, "a good town to live in."
    Skip forward 6 years and it seems that the same suspicious Covid-era paranoia permeates a class of individuals in town who constantly test in-group loyalty and out-group hatred. I can't help but recognize the vein of tribalism or purity politics running through the community. There's a pathos, a highly emotional connection to "my truth" within the collective that has a deep psychological drive toward this behavior. It's the same pathos that drove the Covid response.
    It's not just a Peterborough problem either. Drive an hour southwest to Greenfield, MA and you'll find Last Ditch, a small lesbian bar that has been requiring KN-95 masks "or better" since it opened. As reported in the Boston Globe, the bar is drowning in debt and the owner made masks optional one night per week. For that, her own community accused her of eugenics and "a mass disabling event." One commenter even hoped the bar would get firebombed. The collective does not care that she is one of them. It never did. That's the point.
    Barbara Oakley and her co-editors collected research on this pattern in Pathological Altruism. In chapter 16, "Genocide: From Pathological Altruism to Pathological Obedience," Augustine Brannigan shows how easily people enter what Stanley Milgram called an agentic state. They follow the orders of authority or of their in-group loyally. The scale is obviously different here; the mechanism isn't. Such obedience, Brannigan writes,
    "…suggests not a failure of socialization (the usual control approach) but that they are/were oversocialized. Pathological obedience appears to be based on the development of a mentality that reflects long-term patterns of affiliation th...
    9 min
  • The Treatment Was Worse Than the Disease Medicine's Graveyard of Good Ideas When More Treatment Meant Better Treatment When the Monitor Improved and the Patient Died A Lesson from the Intensive Care Unit When Common Sense Was Wrong When Established Medici
    By Joseph Varon at Brownstone dot org.
    On December 12, 1799, George Washington returned to Mount Vernon after several hours on horseback in snow, hail, and freezing rain. The next day he developed a sore throat and hoarseness, and in the early morning of December 14 he awoke struggling to breathe and swallow. Doctors were called, and what happened next is now one of the most talked-about medical cases in American history.
    Washington did not lack medical care. In fact, he received a lot of attention from three skilled physicians, who used the treatments they thought best for someone as sick as he was, such as repeated bloodletting and other methods meant to reduce inflammation and restore balance. Late that night, Washington died.
    Even now, more than 200 years later, we are not sure exactly what disease killed Washington. Some experts have suggested acute bacterial epiglottitis, severe pharyngitis, peritonsillar infection, or other causes of upper-airway blockage [1]. What is clear is that Washington lost a large amount of blood, by most estimates about 80 ounces, through repeated bloodletting while he was already very sick. His doctors did not mean to harm him. They thought removing blood would control the inflammation, but it made him worse. Their actions followed a long-standing medical tradition, supported by accepted theories, experience, and the authority of many generations of doctors.
    It is easy to look back at this story and feel superior because of our modern knowledge. Today, we understand things like oxygen delivery, blood volume, shock, infections, airway care, IV fluids, antibiotics, and advanced life support. Washington's doctors did not have this knowledge. But calling them primitive misses the real point. They were trained doctors using the best knowledge they had to try to save their patient. The real question is not why doctors in 1799 believed bloodletting would help. Instead, we should ask which treatments we use today with the same confidence that future doctors might find hard to believe.
    Medicine has always operated between what we know and what we do not. Patients get sick now, but clear scientific answers can take years or even decades to find. Doctors have to watch, guess, treat, and adjust as they go. This process has led to some of our greatest achievements. Anesthesia made surgery possible. Antibiotics turned deadly infections into treatable ones. Insulin changed the outlook for type 1 diabetes. Intensive care, organ transplants, dialysis, cancer treatments, and heart procedures now save people who would not have survived in the past. Admitting mistakes in medicine does not mean ignoring the real progress made.
    But history also shows many treatments once thought to be good medicine that are now known to be harmful. Bloodletting is the most famous example because it now seems clearly wrong. For centuries, it fit into the accepted theory that illness came from an imbalance of bodily fluids, so removing blood was supposed to help. Some patients got better after bloodletting simply because many illnesses get better on their own, and these cases made the practice seem effective. When patients died, doctors often blamed the severity of the illness, not the treatment. Without proper studies, doctors' experiences kept confirming what they already believed.
    Mercury provides another sobering example. Mercury compounds were used for centuries to treat syphilis and other diseases despite their substantial toxicity. Records show that mercury was used in many ways, including ointments, pills, injections, and even fumes [2]. Patients often suffered from too much saliva, mouth sores, lost teeth, nerve damage, and other serious problems. Still, some of these side effects were seen as proof that the treatment was working.
    The use of mercury lasted so long not because doctors were unintelligent, but because accepted theories, tradition, authority, and stories from practice all supported it. When a practice is new,...
    34 min
  • The Why of Food Emancipation
    By Jeffrey A. Tucker at Brownstone dot org.
    [This is the foreword to Joe Salatin's magisterial work Food Emancipation, newly published]
    Agronomy – a word no longer in much use – was at the core of the American experience from long before its Founding period through the early Progressive Era. We once had hands-on experience with the land and were shaped by everything about farm life. It's how we fed our families, neighbors, and communities. Today, we import most food, process it into edible chunks with a forever shelf life, shop at the superstore, chow down at restaurants, click to get food delivered, and grab takeout.
    As incredible as it seems, many people today haven't thought at all about food production, any more than driving gives us consciousness of car factories or wearing clothes makes us aware of cotton fields and robotic looms. When asked, people just assume food as we know it comes from some factory out there somewhere and who cares anyway?
    A laptop-class friend recently wrote, very innocently but with an air of intellectual arrogance, "How awful it would be if we still had to know how to farm!" My mind drifted back immediately to a few farm experiences I had as a kid, and the renewal of that experience recently at Joel Salatin's Polyface farm. Thank goodness someone remembers how to farm.
    The reason is that an entire way of life – a way toward health, well-being, and happiness – has been stolen from us. Not neglected, not outcompeted, but literally forced out of existence. This happened not by market forces as such, not by some impersonal mind of history, but by a labyrinth of regulations, mandates, taxes, controls, subsidies, and monopoly-creating controls, all conspiring to keep the way of life of our ancestors from returning.

    Food Emancipation
    Joel Salatin Buy on Amazon
    How and why this happened, and what to do about it right now, is the subject of this marvelous book by the farmer-philosopher Joel Salatin. It is revealing, thrilling, and destined to become a classic. It is a powerful manifesto on the production of food, a subject about which most people remain deeply confused, with real costs to health, liberty, and prosperity. It's gripping and wise, fun and serious, detailed and passionate, scientific and packed with stories, just the right combination to cause a true disruption in understanding, policy, and practice.
    You can grasp the essence in the fast-paced opening chapter, but don't stop there. The rest brims with profound insights, biography, history, and granular detail that will reshape how you see agriculture, government, big business, health, and technology.
    A few years ago, I was among the confused in thinking there were no real food issues that needed addressing, much less solving. The Covid era, with its seemingly endless layers of duplicity and propaganda, shattered many of my assumptions. I was ready to question everything.
    What if our lords and masters have done to food production what they have done to medicine and public health? Study a bit and one's worst fears are thus realized. The same class of people who managed the pandemic response have been managing our food supply for many decades.
    Today, I'm fully aligned with Salatin's vision, and I'm proud to call him my teacher. This book will likely challenge your own preconceptions just as radically.
    At its heart, Salatin calls for food emancipation: dismantling over a century of heavy regulation and cartelization that has throttled small farmers and traditional wisdom. What we face is not benign oversight but a destructive alliance between Big Government and Big Agribusiness, one that suppresses competition, diminishes quality, tramples on property rights and the right to trade, and robs consumers of knowledge and choice.
    If Salatin's agenda prevails, we won't just save existing small farms; we could spark thousands and millions of new ones, many right in our neighborhoods or on our own land. They would feed nations in healthier, more trad...
    9 min
  • Never Trust Uncle Sam on Drugs Federal Judges Need Not Apply Pseudo-Science Trumps Democracy The Specter of Emaciated Chemo Patients Obama's Great Betrayal
    By James Bovard at Brownstone dot org.
    As the Covid-19 pandemic struck this nation, many Americans were stunned to see top federal health officials brazenly lie to buttress their own power. Bureaucrats and politicians unleashed themselves by shrouding how the feds bankrolled the creation of the pathogen, sanctifying a pseudo-miracle cure vaccine that was concocted almost overnight, and denying the vast collateral damage from effectively placing hundreds of millions of citizens under house arrest.
    But there were precedents for all those crimes and follies in the federal war on drugs that began more than a century ago. That crusade established the right of federal officials to define reality and to scourge anyone who tried to reveal that federal Drug Czars were dangerous hucksters.
    Federal contortions on marijuana are Exhibit A for why Americans should never trust Uncle Sam on drugs. For more than 50 years, the federal government shamelessly pretended that marijuana had no recognized medical use.
    Last December 18, President Trump signed an executive order entitled, "Increasing Medical Marijuana and Cannabidiol Research." Trump ordered the Attorney General and the Drug Enforcement Administration to speed up rule-making to finally enable far more medical research on the benefits of marijuana. On April 23, Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche announced that henceforth all "FDA-approved marijuana-derived products" and "State-licensed medical marijuana products" are shifted from Schedule 1 to Schedule 3, a far less restrictive federal regulatory regime.
    But the long history of federal persecution of marijuana users, researchers, and growers vivified the folly of trusting federal intervention to protect Americans' health.
    During the 1920s, the US Department of Agriculture encouraged farmers to grow cannabis to boost their sagging incomes (hemp was used for such things as paper and rope). Marijuana also grew in popularity during the 1920s as a result of Prohibition, which inflated the price of alcohol by curtailing its availability.
    During the Great Depression, Mexican immigrants surged into the United States searching for work and brought marijuana with them. Hostility toward the immigrants led to the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937, which effectively criminalized the possession of marijuana and, according to Yale professor David Musto, "mostly put a lot of jazz bands in jail."
    Harvard Professor of Psychiatry Lester Grinspoon notes, "Between 1839 and 1900, more than a hundred articles on the therapeutic uses of marijuana appeared in scientific journals. As late as 1937, extract of cannabis was still a legitimate medicine marketed by drug companies." The American Medical Association testified at hearings that year urging that marijuana not be effectively banned. Unfortunately, Congress — bowing to the exhortations of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics — proclaimed in 1937 that marijuana had no medical value. Congress effectively prohibited any use of marijuana for ailing Americans. But simply because a majority of Congressmen say something doesn't make it true.
    In 1972, the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML) petitioned the federal Bureau of Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs to reclassify marijuana and recognize its medical uses. The director of the agency refused to consider the petition. NORML took the case to a federal appeals court, which issued a ruling that admonished the agency for rejecting the petition without "a reflective consideration and analysis."
    In 1975, NORML sued the Drug Enforcement Administration (the successor agency to the Bureau) to force the agency to evaluate the evidence on whether Americans should have access to marijuana strictly for medicinal purposes. The DEA held a hearing, and a DEA administrative law judge found some merit in some of NORML's positions. But the chief of the DEA overturned those aspects of the judge's decision.
    In 1977, a federal court of appeals criticized the DEA's fina...
    17 min
  • Time to Retire Slurs
    By Alan Cassels at Brownstone dot org.
    My Uncle Don had a different name for everyone.
    I had no idea where he came up with all these labels. They were often colourful, and clearly he thought they were funny. Except nobody was really laughing.
    To him, someone from South Asia was a Paki, an aboriginal person was, obviously, an Indian; a guy from Ukraine was a Bohunk; a Frenchman, a Frog. Germans were Krauts, and a Gook was someone from Southeast Asia, a name, no doubt, planted in his head from a racist epithet thrown at the Vietnamese. You get the picture.
    But looking back—this was the 1970's we're talking here—I don't think there was hate behind the labels he gave those from other countries, or those of other religions or other customs. It was mostly his way of making distinctions, as if a person's race, country of origin, or belief was everything you needed to know about that person. Slurs like these took the whole person and reduced him or her to a simple, memorable epithet. Easy. And. Efficient.
    The 1970's were a time when people also used words, even in polite company, like "homos," or "kikes" referring to gay men and Jewish people. Slurs casually hurled at entire groups of people allowed you to put them in a box, to classify them, set them apart with a label that curtailed further thought. Many times these labels would be flung without understanding that the person who was the subject of the label might feel lesser, or unworthy of respect. I don't think my Uncle Don was a racist, but looking back now, he sure sounded like one. If he was told his slurs were in poor taste, he'd probably throw up his hands and say, "Look, I'm no racist, but a dark guy is probably from Pakistan so he's a Paki," or something equally clueless.
    Uncle Don, like many working-class men of his generation, made caricatures of people based on their race or nationality or religion. He was an industrial plumber and lived in Winnipeg, a melting pot of a city where ribbons of steel converged in vast railroad yards and the trains dumped immigrants from all corners of the earth into the centre of Canada's heartland. There were Scots and Irishmen, Slavs, Asians, Blacks, and numerous pockets of Canada's indigenous people.
    Hearing the use of the term "anti-vaxxer" today gives me the same gut reaction I had when listening to Don wax on about people who were visibly different from him. "Anti-vaxx", while in vogue today and uttered without any form of introspection or understanding, is clearly a term of laziness, a mostly defensive maneuver to shield a person from having to engage with another's ideas. In short, the term is a quick way to mark that person as morally deficient, selfish, and contemptible.
    Scorning "anti-vaxxers" has become a way to signal one's inherent righteousness and correctness, telling the world in a single word that there are those of us who care about others and untrustworthy people who don't. In a nutshell, the word says: "Imagine how dumb you have to be to seriously question the safety or usefulness of injectable pharmaceutical products that are the most innovative health technology in the history of humankind?" How dumb indeed.
    As a straight, white guy, I don't think anyone has ever hurled a slur at me. Until Covid.
    The first time someone called me an "anti-vaxxer" was in 2021, after the Pfizer mRNA Covid vaccine was approved. This was before the Pfizer trial was published and everyone in my office at the University rushed to get their shots. I waited.
    I knew the likelihood of me, a healthy 58-year-old guy, developing complications and dying from Covid were miniscule. I was on record for seriously questioning previous government policies around the influenza vaccine which—because I read the company's own studies—I determined were next to useless, and coercive to healthcare workers. I believed in the precautionary principle, and Covid didn't scare me one bit. When asked by a colleague about why I was not yet vaccinated, I told him, "I'm...
    10 min
  • The Commodified Self and the Designed Collapse of Generation Z The Brand Called Girlhood The Program Succeeded Three Parties of the Psyche Products and the Womb Shame without a Law Transmission
    By Renaud Beauchard at Brownstone dot org.
    Since Covid, the "mental health crisis" has gone from background music to a deafening noise. It is said to touch every part of society, but none more than Generation Z, those born between 1997 and 2013. The French figures give the scale: compared with the previous decade, psychiatric hospitalizations in 2021–2022 rose 106 percent among 20-to-24-year-olds, 163 percent among 15-to-19-year-olds, and a staggering 246 percent among children aged 10 to 14. Researchers spent a decade arguing over datasets.
    Parents look for a single culprit they can blame or a device they can confiscate. Having exhausted the managerial and therapeutic answers of more awareness, more services, more medication, and more self-expression they offer for every modern sorrow, institutions are now itching for the stick of social networks age verification, or for AI fear porn. Two excellent books written by two Generation Z authors and published this year refuse the usual explanations and their lazy remedies. They do not deny the disastrous effects of smartphones, lockdowns, or ubiquitous pornography. They insist that these were oil poured on a well-established fire.
    Freya India's GIRLS®: Gen Z and the Commodification of Everything is the report from inside girlhood. Pierre Valentin's The Malaise of Generation Z, alas not yet available in English, broadens the perspective to the entire Zoomer generation, taking Christopher Lasch as a guide. Read together, they describe one event: the transfer of the inner life from families, churches, trades, and ordinary adult authority to a tutelary, market-therapeutic complex specialized in the production of a fundamentally dependent and weak self. In other words, the "mental health crisis" is not happening by default, but by design.
    India and Valentin's books are not interchangeable. Born in 1999, India is a British woman who was given a smartphone at eleven and later logged off to think…and to live. Her popular Substack is essential reading on what it feels like for girls to grow up as content.
    GIRLS® is personal without being a memoir and researched without being bland journalism. Born in 1998, Valentin is a French political essayist. His subject goes well beyond what screens do to boys or girls. It is a whole age group, from early adolescence to the edge of thirty, whose shared experience is no longer a war, an economic crisis, musical tastes, or a common work, but a psychiatric curve. Specialists agree that this generation is more depressed, more anxious, more fragile, and more unhappy than those that preceded it. But they completely miss the mark on what that fact means.
    India's title is the argument. Girls have been remade into GIRLS®. They are ornaments under filters, objects on dating apps, brands under management, lives packaged for an audience and priced by public rating. Her book is not another self-righteous and exasperating sermon taken from the register of luxury stoicism about "too much Instagram," like Jonathan Haidt's lazy conclusion in The Anxious Generation.
    In that book, Haidt, who is atheist, pleads for mass transnational prohibitions, particularly age verification, and, as Pierre Valentin ironically points out, ends with a utilitarian eulogy of religion! It is a minutely detailed account of how a web of industries exploited the oldest vulnerabilities of girlhood by turning them into a commodity and marketing them as empowerment. Beauty, psychiatry, pornography, dating, and tech all pull attention inward, toward appearance, feeling, and appetite. In an almost burlesque version of Mandeville's bee fable, it is vanity turned into liberation.
    GIRLS® moves through six stations. Filtered focuses on girls' anxieties over their faces and bodies, revised by apps that began with very few filters and became a permanent and unforgiving tribunal. Diagnosed is the conversion of ordinary unhappiness into a portable identity, complete with language, community, and a produ...
    24 min
  • How Bill Gates' Billions Shape US Medical Research Leveraging Investments Major Grants to Government Bill Gates Is Coming!
    By Paul Thacker at Brownstone dot org.
    Bill Gates has long been one of the most admired people in the world, especially since he stepped down from his role running Microsoft to devote himself and much of his fortune to philanthropy. That reputation has been tarnished recently, however, by revelations of the billionaire's close relation with sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, and exposés on his own fraught relationships with women.
    On the eve of Gates' private testimony with Congress scheduled for tomorrow, a trove of federal whistleblower documents provided to RealClearInvestigations is renewing questions about how Gates money has bought what critics complain is an untoward influence on government health policy. For almost a quarter of a century, his main vehicle of power, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, has donated hundreds of millions of dollars to the National Institutes of Health (NIH), allowing Gates to shape the direction of the country's health strategy in ways that have benefitted his own priorities and pet causes while polishing his image as a benevolent global do-gooder.
    At a time of growing concern about the power of billionaires such as Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Sam Altman, Gates' efforts stand out. Instead of lobbying federal agencies for specific policies, Gates leveraged his wealth to work inside the government, partnering with high-ranking NIH officials to steer taxpayer research funding and design scientific policies for several federal programs.
    The cache of several dozen emails and documents, made public for the first time by an NIH whistleblower, reinforces previous reports detailing Gates's extensive influence over U.S. biomedical research. During the height of the COVID pandemic, Kate Elder, a senior vaccines policy adviser for Doctors Without Borders, complained to Politico, "What makes Bill Gates qualified to be giving advice and advising the U.S. government on where they should be putting the tremendous resources?"
    Emails and internal plans, for example, show that the NIH – the world's largest funder of biomedical research – gave the Gates Foundation first billing for the joint workshops and meetings held on federal property.

    The Gates Foundation did not respond to repeated requests for comment. The NIH also declined to comment.
    Like most philanthropies, the Gates Foundation tries to grow its endowment through investments. Some of these efforts, especially its stake in vaccine companies, blur the lines between profit-seeking and the foundation's mission to develop and deliver vaccines around the world. This symbiotic relationship between capitalism and charity also benefits Gates, whose power and position hinge in large part on the size of his foundation's assets. Before the pandemic, The Nation magazine reported that the Gates Foundation had a $40 million stake in CureVac – this was not a grant but an investment. CureVac was one of many companies the nonprofit bought stock in that were working on COVID vaccines and therapeutics.
    Around that same period, the Gates Foundation announced that it had begun to "leverage a portion of its $2.5 billion Strategic Investment Fund" to advance the nonprofit's COVID work. The Gates Foundation also turned a $55 million investmentin Pfizer's COVID vaccine partner, BioNTech, into over $550 million when it sold stock a couple of years later after the vaccine hit the market.
    The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation was established in 2000 with an initial endowment of $20 billion and a primary focus on reducing global health disparities. Rather than working exclusively through non-governmental agencies, the Gates Foundation began contributing to the NIH through the agency's own nonprofit, the Foundation for the National Institutes of Health (FNIH). Congress created the FNIH in 1990 as a firewall between NIH officials and outside donors seeking to influence federal research.
    That firewall is not ironclad. In 2018, for example, NIH officials, funded by beer and liquor ...
    14 min
  • We Could, We Should, We Must
    By Josh Stylman at Brownstone dot org.
    A few summers ago I gave consideration to moving to Florida or Texas. This was 2021 when it felt like there was a collective madness in my hometown of New York City. If you remember that moment, you remember the destinations where people like me were fleeing. I was looking into places like Florida and Texas. The so-called free states, the escape hatches (not my framing but more of a public consciousness in a particular demographic that I had seemed to become a part of). I compiled spreadsheets about neighborhoods, school lists, and initiated other projects you do when you're about to uproot your family.
    And somewhere in that diligence I came across a company called Oxitec. They breed genetically modified mosquitoes. In May 2020, the EPA approved an experimental release permit. The two states cleared for field testing were Florida and Texas.
    I'll share what happened next in the spirit of transparency, even if it makes me look a little ridiculous in retrospect. I sat there and thought: the two states I'm considering as my escape are the two states approved for experimental GMO insect release. And then I wondered: are the escape hatches just honeypots to round up the dissidents?
    And then I thought: who and what have I become? I mean that's insane, right? Does a reasonable person wonder if Bill Gates personally zoned his retirement? I remember actually feeling embarrassed, alone in my own head. I'd spent two decades in tech. I didn't know it at the time but I played my own tiny role in helping build some of the surveillance plumbing I now write about. I am not a man who is easily spooked by an internet meme. And here I was, pattern-matching my way out of a real estate decision as if the ticks had lobbyists.
    For a variety of reasons we left NYC but stayed in the state. Partly logistics, but also because by 2021 I'd talked myself into the conclusion that whatever was happening was global, and if that was true, fleeing somewhere wasn't really an escape. Some places might have had longer runways than others, but I wasn't going to live as a man on the run. My wife and I decided it was better for us to optimize for quality of life, and we ultimately decided to stay in New York in a more rural setting. I'm not going to suggest that decision was vindicated, because it wasn't, not cleanly anyway (though we're mostly a happy family).
    In the years since, however, I kept running into pieces of that mosquito story that I couldn't quite make myself stop assembling.
    This past week Marty Bent posted something that made me revisit a lot of my research from that era.
    Two professors at a medical school in Michigan published a peer-reviewed paper in the journal Bioethics. Their argument is that it is "morally obligatory" to genetically engineer ticks to spread a disease that makes humans violently allergic to red meat.
    My first reaction was the natural one, in my opinion. It had to be an Onion or Babylon Bee headline someone laundered through a fake citation. People don't really write ideas like this down, do they? They certainly don't get them reviewed by their peers.
    So I checked and it turned out to be real. Bioethics, volume 39, issue 8, pages 772 through 781. Published online July 2025. It's indexed in PubMed. You can pull it up on Wiley right now. The authors are Parker Crutchfield and Blake Hereth, both at Western Michigan University's Homer Stryker MD School of Medicine. The paper is called "Beneficial Bloodsucking."
    The author's actual argument – and remember this is not satire – is that alpha-gal syndrome (AGS), the tick-borne red meat allergy, is a "moral bioenhancer." Their logic: if eating meat is morally wrong, and the allergy makes you stop eating meat (because it will now kill you), then the allergy makes you a better person. From there they build what they call the Convergence Argument, which in plain English means "multiple different ethical frameworks all happen to point at the same conclus...
    33 min
  • From Baric's Blueprint to SV40 and Back Again Synopsis Short Summary of Paper The Covid Con: Biodefense or Biowarfare? N.B on Fear SV40 – Past and Present Final Thoughts
    By Jessica Rose at Brownstone dot org.
    Ralph Baric's 2007 paper stands as a foundational reference in synthetic viral genomics, demonstrating how a SARS-like coronavirus could be de novo assembled from published sequence data alone. Framed as a risk assessment for synthetic biology in the context of biodefense, the paper provides a detailed technical roadmap for constructing infectious chimeric coronaviruses using seamless reverse-genetics techniques. This work exemplifies dual-use (civilian and military) research of concern: the very same tools developed for pandemic preparedness and biodefense can be readily applied to engineer viruses with enhanced pathogenicity, transmissibility, or immune evasion.
    With the unexpected discovery of SV40 promoter-enhancer-origin sequences in the Pfizer Covid-19 mRNA injectable products, it becomes apparent how biodefense can become bioterrorism very quickly. These powerful mammalian regulatory elements, retained from a standard pcDNA3.1-type production plasmid, were never intended for human administration. Their detection in commercial vials links a synthetic biology framework directly to the manufacturing process of the "countermeasures" themselves – turning a theoretical dual-use discussion into a concrete, real-world example of how synthetic tools and legacy genetic elements entered hundreds of millions of people under the banner of biodefense.
    Ralph S. Baric's 2006 paper entitled: "Synthetic Viral Genomics: Risks and Benefits for Science and Society" reviews how synthetic genomics and reverse genetics has transformed virology, both for good and ill. It details the Baltimore classification of viruses and explains established reverse-genetics techniques from infectious cDNA clones and bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) vectors for large DNA viruses, to seamless assembly methods (ie: "No See'm" sites using type IIS restriction enzymes) for RNA viruses like coronaviruses.
    These tools have already enabled resurrection of extinct pathogens (ie: 1918 influenza) and construction of chimeric viruses, allowing precise manipulation of virulence, transmissibility, host range, and immune evasion genes. Baric catalogs select agents across virus families, noting which are synthesizable from published sequences, and highlights barriers like sequence accuracy, genome stability in bacteria, and technical expertise – barriers he predicted would erode rapidly as DNA synthesis became cheaper and more accessible.
    If you read the paper, you will have seen that it provides a detailed, practical framework for de novo synthesis and reverse genetics of SARS-CoV specifically, including seamless full-genome assembly, in vitro transcription to RNA, and recovery of infectious virus. The paper repeatedly notes that synthetic genomics allows reconstruction of viruses like SARS-CoV from sequence data alone, without needing the natural virus, and discusses how this could be used for both 'legitimate' research (vaccines, pathogenesis studies) and misuse.
    In addition, the methods Baric outlines in the paper are directly applicable to SARS-CoV-2 (also ~30 kb), which is even more clearly laid out in Peter Daszak's DEFUSE proposal: a collaborative how-to guide for "defusing bat-borne coronaviruses" (Figure 1). Post 2019 implementations have used yeast recombination, Gibson assembly, or similar seamless techniques, but the core principles (synthetic DNA fragments full-length cDNA RNA transcripts infectious virus) are the same. As mentioned, Baric's lab and collaborators had already demonstrated this for the original SARS-CoV in 2003.

    The paper is eerily prescient in terms of laying out the infrastructure for both "pandemic preparedness" and "dual-use" procedures. Synthetic approaches enabled rapid response: once a new pathogen's sequence is known, genes or full genomes can be synthesized for diagnostics, vaccines, and therapeutics, without waiting for natural isolates. This paradigm was used during SARS-CoV-2. We are all...
    20 min

About Brownstone Journal

From the publisher's feed

Daily readings from Brownstone Institute authors, contributors, and researchers on public health, philosophy, science, and economics.

More shows like Brownstone Journal

Peak Prosperity by Chris Martenson

Peak Prosperity

569 Listeners

Wise Traditions by Weston A. Price Foundation

Wise Traditions

2,384 Listeners

Gold Goats 'n Guns Podcast by Tom Luongo

Gold Goats 'n Guns Podcast

327 Listeners

Coffee and a Mike by Michael Farris

Coffee and a Mike

421 Listeners

The Delingpod: The James Delingpole Podcast by James Delingpole

The Delingpod: The James Delingpole Podcast

454 Listeners

American Thought Leaders by The Epoch Times

American Thought Leaders

1,252 Listeners

DarkHorse Podcast by Bret Weinstein & Heather Heying

DarkHorse Podcast

5,436 Listeners

The Sharyl Attkisson Podcast by Sharyl Attkisson

The Sharyl Attkisson Podcast

1,803 Listeners

Bannon`s War Room by WarRoom.org

Bannon`s War Room

16,571 Listeners

THE MCCULLOUGH REPORT by Dr. Peter McCullough

THE MCCULLOUGH REPORT

2,436 Listeners

Facts Matter by The Epoch Times

Facts Matter

1,266 Listeners

Man in America Podcast by Man in America

Man in America Podcast

597 Listeners

Doc Malik by Ahmad Malik

Doc Malik

121 Listeners

The Tucker Carlson Show by Tucker Carlson Network

The Tucker Carlson Show

17,921 Listeners

Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words by Victor Davis Hanson | The Daily Signal

Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words

1,846 Listeners