On overmedicalisation and the crisis of authority.

Amber Trotter, practicing psychologist and an editor at Damage magazine, and George Hoare tell Alex about their co-written article in the print issue of Damage on "the pre-political".

What is driving the explosion in mental health diagnoses? Why are people seeking diagnosis?

How is it the product of the subjective and the purely scientific?

Does capitalism make us ill? Is blaming 'capitalism' abstractly part of the problem?

What is the crisis of authority? Whose authority?

Can we solve pre-political problems with politics? And political problems with pre-political approaches?

Damage, Issue 5: The Pre-Political

On post-woke strategies.

Ryan Z is back on, talking to Alex and George about the US Democrats' attempt to respond to Trump/MAGA.

In association with Damage magazine.

Can the Democrats escape the shadow of woke?

Is Big Woke dying? Everywhere?

Who are the groups and think-tanks pushing for a reorientation, and what are they proposing?

Will the Dems adapt to Trump’s challenge or pretend nothing is happening? 

We then take listener questions and comments on transport infrastructure, left-wing gatekeeping, and the crisis in education everywhere, high and low.

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

Links:

Can the Democrats Escape the Shadow of Woke?, Ryan Zickgraf, Damage

Inside the Democratic identity crisis, Ryan Zickgraf, UnHerd

On legitimacy and chronic crisis.

Benjamin Studebaker talks to Alex and Lee about his book, Legitimacy in Liberal Democracy – and why the absence of the threat of revolution makes the crisis drag on.

What's wrong with 20th century accounts of legitimacy crises? What's changed?

Why is contemporary politics so stuck? Is it inescapable?

How does the breakdown of consensus make the emergence of a social majority so difficult?

Is there no common programme we can agree on, focused on bread-and-butter issues?

Do we need to stare despair in the face? Is catastrophe the only way out?

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

Links:

Legitimacy in Liberal Democracy, Benjamin Studebaker, Edinburgh UP

UNLOCKED: /361/ A Nightmare on the Brains of the Living ft. Benjamin Studebaker

Debilitated democracy: When the legs get ripped off, Dirk Jörke and Benjamin Studebaker, European Journal of Social Theory

On the crisis in literacy.

Poet, podcaster and teacher, C. Derick Varn – who has taught in Mexico, Korea, Egypt and the US, at various levels – joins Alex and George to interrogate the coming "post-literate society".

What do we mean when we say 'post-literate'?

This seems a global problem – so is it a problem of the education system?

Is it as simple as blaming smartphones?

How else has education become degraded? How have progressives and conservatives combined to do this?

Are we becoming on oral culture again? What are the consequences?

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

Links:

Are we becoming a post-literate society?, Sarah O'Connor, FT

Have humans passed peak brain power?, John Burn-Murdoch, FT

Visible Learning (synthesis of meta analyses), John Hattie

Why Knowledge Matters, ED Hirsch, Harvard

Seven Myths about Education, Daisy Christodoulou

Insensitivity Readers!, Nina Power

In this special episode, we present talks given by contributing editor Catherine Liu and co-host George Hoare on the paranoid style at a recent conference at UC Irvine, co-hosted by the Palm Springs School for Social Research.

00:01:23 – Catherine Liu: Opening Remarks, on Richard Hofstatder’s classic essay “The Paranoid Style in American Politics”

00:12:18 – George Hoare: The Paranoid Style in British Politics

00:36:06 – Catherine Liu: "Zombies Clowns and Gangsters"

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

On the middle classes and cultural compression.

For the concluding episode of the 2024/25 Reading Club, we discuss C. Wright Mills' White Collar, plus some additional short texts on what mass culture is like today.

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

What about their "political psychology"?

What is the state of White Collar trade unionism today?

Is there no possibility of the middle class leading a political movement?

Do the distinctions of high- middle- and low-brow still make sense today, in our era of levelling-down and slop?

Should we defend democracy in the economy and elitism in culture?

Readings:

White Collar: The American Middle Classes, C. Wright Mills, 1951 (esp final two chapters)

Highbrow, Middlebrow, Lowbrow, Russell Lynes, Wilson Quarterly, 1976 reprint of 1949 article (pdf attached)

Post-Mass Culture, Dylan Riley, Sidecar

Unionizing the “Cultural Apparatus”, Nelson Lichtenstein, Jacobin

On technology, transhumanism, and progress.

James Hughes (Exec Director, Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies) and Eli Sennesh (postdoc, Vanderbilt) present a futurist approach to Alex and contributing editor Leigh Phillips.

What is wrong with the acronym TESCREAL?

Why is it wrong to worry about future transhumanism when we need to grapple with the technologies of now?

What are the limits of bourgeois futurism? What is an alternative futurism?

Has AI changed everything? Will it?

Are we actually living in an age of rapid technological advance?

Links:

Conspiracy Theories, Left Futurism, and the Attack on TESCREAL, James Hughes & Eli Sennesh

/306/ AI Capitalism: Inhuman Power

/335/ AI & the End of the End of History

/446/ The Techno-Fantasy of Perfect Freedom ft. Amber Trotter

/488/ Homo-Techno, Homo-Solo ...Post-Homo? ft. Alex Gendler

The Obama-to-Yarvin Pipeline, Geoff Schullenberger, Compact Substack

On free speech, the tech right, and politicisation.

Geoff Shullenberger, managing editor at Compact, joins Alex and George to talk about Peter Thiel, René Girard, victimhood and the antichrist.

Does it make sense to talk of "right-wing cancel culture"? Is it different from the left's?

Is countercultural trolling in tension with "defending Western civilisation"?

What does René Girard argue about mimesis and scapegoating? Why have his theories become popular?

Is right-populism still politicising? How does it relate to libertarian anti-politics and hard-right militarisation?

How has Silicon Valley libertarianism adapted to the new state-capitalist disposition?

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

Links:

René Girard and the Rise of Victim Power, Geoff Shullenberger, Compact

The Real Stakes, and Real Story, of Peter Thiel’s Antichrist Obsession, Laura Bullard, Wired

The Faith of Nick Land, Geoff Shullenberger, Compact

On places of ritual.

Architect Pier Paolo Tamburelli talks to Alex about his project to catalogue modern wonders – structures that are very big, that pretend to be ancient, and are mostly ugly.

For the full episode subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

How has architecture lost its ritual dimension?

Why are these "modern wonders" kitsch? And why are they found the world over, from Munich to Malaysia, South Dakota to Dakar?

Do 'wonders' speak to a world where places remain distinct, and where conflicts and history seem to have returned?

Are disillusioned and cynical postmodern subjects searching for wonder?

Can architecture rebuild society?

Links:

Wonders of the Modern World, Arch+, issue 259

Wonders of the Modern World: Notes for a Research Programme, Pier Paolo Tamburelli, Arch+ (pdf attached in patreon)

What's wrong with the primitive hut?, Pier Paolo Tamburelli, San Rocco (pdf attached in patreon)

On 20 years since the 2005 riots.

Fred Lyra, philosopher and musicologist based in Paris, joins Alex to talk about France through 4 moments: 1995 – the last moment of classic class struggle; 2005 – riots in the banlieues; 2015 – Islamist terror; 2025 – government collapse.

For the full episode, subscribe at patreon.com/bungacast

How were the riots normalised? And what was the state's response?

Why did the riots prompt debates about "models of integration"?

Why is there an "excess" of state in the banlieues, and an absence of state in left-behind smaller cities?

How did France go from the Nuits Debouts protests to the Gillet Jaunes – and how did they differ?

What about Bloquons Tout protests and the repeated fall of governments today?

Links:

The Peripherisation of France, Fred Lyra, A Terra É Redonda

Two, Three, or More Fractures in French Society?, Fred Lyra, A Terra É Redonda

Bonapartist Solutions, Dylan Riley, Sidecar

Nuits Debout: Up All Night, Fred Lyra, Lavra Palavra