
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Hey guys, it's Anthony Bandiero. Here, attorney and legal instructor for Blue to gold law enforcement training, bring it to the roadside chat from the studio. All right. Let's start here. So the question comes from an officer in Illinois. And she's she asks, Can you transport a DUI suspect somewhere else? For field sobriety tests? And I have your answer. The answer is, if you do not have consent, and you just do it, and you order the person to go somewhere else, and you drive them somewhere else, that is going to likely be considered an arrest. Now, if it's an arrest, okay, the first question is, is do you have probable cause? If you move this person, you have probable cause, then it's not an invalid arrest. It's called a de facto arrest and arrest in fact, but then the next issue is going to come up for you is Miranda issues? Because if you did arrest them, because most courts will believe that involuntary transportation equals in arrest, because most people think that they're have been formally arrested. Now, if you bring them let's say, to the station house, because it's snowing outside, and you start asking questions, again, about, okay, confirm how much you had to drink? Well, I know I told you to, but really, it was four. And all these other things in any other testimonial type answers will likely be suppressed unless you have Miranda, but most cops are not reading Miranda, while they're doing field interviews, and so forth. And so that's the answer. Now, the way around this is to seek the person's consent. If you have a good reason, let's say that it's snowing out, and you don't want to or you're on an incline decline. It's not. There's no flat surface and area to do field sobriety tests. So you want to ask them, Hey, do you want to go to the station? Or do you want to go to the firehouse and on a flat surface and have a better opportunity to perform these tests satisfactory? Do you want to do that? And if they say, yes, then argue that, you know, articulate that the person gave you free and voluntary consent to move the traffic stop, essentially, to the fire station or the police department. But if they say, No, they do not want to move, then, basically, I would treat that as a refusal to do the tests and go from there. And the question would be okay, if you can't do the test on the location where you're at, then I would try to figure out what matter had probable cause? If you have probable cause, then if it was me, I'll just make the arrest and go from there. If I don't have probable cause, then I'm at to look, look at some other options. Right. But that's the deal here.
5
1313 ratings
Hey guys, it's Anthony Bandiero. Here, attorney and legal instructor for Blue to gold law enforcement training, bring it to the roadside chat from the studio. All right. Let's start here. So the question comes from an officer in Illinois. And she's she asks, Can you transport a DUI suspect somewhere else? For field sobriety tests? And I have your answer. The answer is, if you do not have consent, and you just do it, and you order the person to go somewhere else, and you drive them somewhere else, that is going to likely be considered an arrest. Now, if it's an arrest, okay, the first question is, is do you have probable cause? If you move this person, you have probable cause, then it's not an invalid arrest. It's called a de facto arrest and arrest in fact, but then the next issue is going to come up for you is Miranda issues? Because if you did arrest them, because most courts will believe that involuntary transportation equals in arrest, because most people think that they're have been formally arrested. Now, if you bring them let's say, to the station house, because it's snowing outside, and you start asking questions, again, about, okay, confirm how much you had to drink? Well, I know I told you to, but really, it was four. And all these other things in any other testimonial type answers will likely be suppressed unless you have Miranda, but most cops are not reading Miranda, while they're doing field interviews, and so forth. And so that's the answer. Now, the way around this is to seek the person's consent. If you have a good reason, let's say that it's snowing out, and you don't want to or you're on an incline decline. It's not. There's no flat surface and area to do field sobriety tests. So you want to ask them, Hey, do you want to go to the station? Or do you want to go to the firehouse and on a flat surface and have a better opportunity to perform these tests satisfactory? Do you want to do that? And if they say, yes, then argue that, you know, articulate that the person gave you free and voluntary consent to move the traffic stop, essentially, to the fire station or the police department. But if they say, No, they do not want to move, then, basically, I would treat that as a refusal to do the tests and go from there. And the question would be okay, if you can't do the test on the location where you're at, then I would try to figure out what matter had probable cause? If you have probable cause, then if it was me, I'll just make the arrest and go from there. If I don't have probable cause, then I'm at to look, look at some other options. Right. But that's the deal here.
226,206 Listeners
5,564 Listeners
153,924 Listeners
30,716 Listeners
10,876 Listeners
6,404 Listeners
1,207 Listeners
42,398 Listeners
3,293 Listeners
958 Listeners
99 Listeners
167 Listeners
3,234 Listeners
68 Listeners
630 Listeners