The Search & Seizure Show

Can you lie to a homeowner about your reason for searching their home?


Listen Later

The following is a computer-generated transcription, some grammar and spelling errors may be inherent

How you doing, law enforcement officers. It's Anthony Bandiero. Here, Senior Legal instructor with Blue to Gold law enforcement training.

I just read a case and I want to share it with you because it's really has some really good teaching points. The case is pagane Gonzalez V. Marino, it's out of the First Circuit. And essentially what happened here is this. FBI agents were interested in a suspect because they believed that he had child pornography on his laptop. Instead of getting a search warrant, they came up with a clever idea. They went to his house, and they said, Hey, your laptop is sending malicious signals to Washington, DC. But guess what? We're with the government; we're here to help, we'll fix it for free. If you if you let us look at the laptop. We'll find out what's kind of going on. And we'll fix it for free the suspect consents for the entry and the search of the laptop for the malicious software. The FBI agents then find what they were looking for. And they said that they'll do some more work on the computer at the office, they take the computer, they write up a search warrant for the home and arrest one for the suspect. Right. And the suspect says, Look, that's not fair. You can't do that. You told me you're I got malicious software, that I'm the victim of malware. And you're trying to help me with this. And instead, you're looking for evidence of child pornography, in the First Circuit agreed. Right. And let's look at why. First of all, the general principle here is that when uniformed officers, uniform doesn't mean always mean uniform, but known officers when known officers create an emergency in order to enter a home to search. That is that is not good. You cannot do that. Because it invalidates the consent, because what reasonable person what's what not agree? Under those circumstances? Right? It's kind of like, it's kind of like this if police went to somebody's home and said, Hey, we believe that there there's a kidnap victim, a little girl that got kidnapped Jesse, A witness said that she's in your house? And can we go look around? I mean, most people are gonna like, especially because they didn't, this is a lie, they didn't connect anybody, they're gonna allow the police to come in and look for the for the kidnap victim. And instead, if the police are looking for a marijuana grow operation, that is going to, you know, invalidate the consent because they created an emergency for the kidnap victim. So that's what happened here, right? The agents are saying that we're looking for this malicious software that's coming from your computer, a reasonable person is going to allow them to get rid of that software so that they're not breaking the law and so forth. The other issue with uniformed officers is you cannot claim to have an authority that you don't have, right? You can't say, Hey, I have a search warrant for your home. But you know what, I'd really like your cooperation, if you do cooperate, I'll let you know, the prosecutor know that you cooperated and so forth. And they're like, Okay, come on in, that is going to completely invalidate the consent. Because basically, what you're telling a person is, I'm going to search anyway, whether you consent or not, but can you will you consent, that is not a freely, involuntarily involuntary consent. So you don't want to do it that way; those things will invalidate consent. And that's what happened here. But while we're on the topic of lying in order to search somebody's home, and I want to make sure that we're talking about deception to search a home, right, we're not talking about general principles regarding lying and relying on interviews and interrogation or lying to a suspect on the side of the road.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Search & Seizure ShowBy Anthony Bandiero

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

15 ratings


More shows like The Search & Seizure Show

View all
The Joe Rogan Experience by Joe Rogan

The Joe Rogan Experience

226,206 Listeners

The Glenn Beck Program by Blaze Podcast Network

The Glenn Beck Program

25,596 Listeners

REAL AF with Andy Frisella by Andy Frisella #100to0

REAL AF with Andy Frisella

32,596 Listeners

Drinkin‘ Bros Podcast by Tetherball Academy Media

Drinkin‘ Bros Podcast

7,883 Listeners

Jocko Podcast by Jocko DEFCOR Network

Jocko Podcast

30,719 Listeners

Men in the Arena - Christian Men's Podcast by Jim Ramos

Men in the Arena - Christian Men's Podcast

367 Listeners

The Matt Walsh Show by The Daily Wire

The Matt Walsh Show

28,059 Listeners

Things Police See: Firsthand Accounts by Steven Gould: Police Officer, Background Investigator

Things Police See: Firsthand Accounts

1,207 Listeners

The Charlie Kirk Show by Charlie Kirk

The Charlie Kirk Show

49,268 Listeners

Shawn Ryan Show by Shawn Ryan

Shawn Ryan Show

42,482 Listeners

Street Cop Podcast by Street Cop Training

Street Cop Podcast

958 Listeners

Shots Fired Podcast by Kyle Shoberg

Shots Fired Podcast

167 Listeners

The Antihero Podcast by The Antihero Podcast

The Antihero Podcast

544 Listeners

The Tucker Carlson Show by Tucker Carlson Network

The Tucker Carlson Show

15,386 Listeners

Borderland: Dispatches with Katarina Szulc by IRONCLAD

Borderland: Dispatches with Katarina Szulc

38 Listeners