Ellen Brodsky is the owner of the blog Newshounds.us and was a researcher for the film Outfoxed. We mentioned research that shows that torture doesn’t work in the podcast.
A lot of people made fun of the questions Mark Zuckerberg was asked when he went to Congress last week, there were all sorts of gags of how it would be like having to set up your grandparents’ wifi, but Senator Dick Durbin, I think, made a good point with a simple question
That was fun, turning the tables a bit, but this, I think, was a much more important exchange.
That was Senator Brian Schatz asking the questions. And I’m suspicious of the answers there.
But before that I want to go back to a young southern governor who was an unlikely candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination more than quarter of a century ago. Back then, any association with drugs was a serious issue for any candidate.
Some enterprising journalist had the bright idea of sending a questionnaire to all candidates, which included a question about whether they had ever taken drugs. This candidate answered, apparently, clearly. He said that he had never broken our country’s drug laws. Case closed.
Except, not quite. The candidate in question was then-Governor Bill Clinton. He was later questioned more closely about his drug-taking and he said this:
But, he hadn’t lied. When asked about ever taking drugs, he reframed the question and answered something else, and nobody noticed. So, when caught, he could claim that he was telling the truth that he had never broken US drug laws.
This is called a non-denial denial. You’re asked if you did something. You answer in the negative, you say you didn’t do the thing, but within your answer, you subtly reframe the question, so that you are denying something that isn’t quite what you were asked about.
The average listener takes away a flat denial, but you have left open whether you actually did what you were accused of. By the way, when you use a non-denial denial, it’s really risky to do it in person, because if you phrase something wrongly, you might end up stepping over the line and actually lying, which is bad,