Was Alan Curbishley’s Charlton Athletic one of English football’s great overachievers?

This week on By Far The Greatest Team, hosts Graham and Jamie are joined by London football expert Stuart Burgess to unpack the remarkable rise—and quiet brilliance—of Charlton Athletic under Alan Curbishley.

From financial chaos and exile from The Valley to Premier League stability and European dreams, the episode explores how Curbishley’s calm leadership turned Charlton into a model of consistency. We revisit their epic 1998 playoff final, smart recruitment, and a youth system that helped punch above their weight. Was Curbishley’s Charlton more than just a well-run club? Or were they something closer to greatness?

🔴⚪ A story of resilience, loyalty, and ambition on a budget.

Takeaways:

• How Charlton rebuilt after years in the wilderness
• The 1998 playoff final and promotion to the Premier League
• The return to The Valley and the influence of the Valley Party
• Curbishley’s long-term vision, smart recruitment, and player development
• Reflections on legacy: Where does Charlton under Curbishley rank in football history?

🎧 Listen now as we decide how great this Charlton side truly was.

If you enjoy these podcasts, please don't forget to subscribe and give us a rating and also tell everyone about them!