Ruben Amorim’s Manchester United tenure reached a new low on Wednesday night as they were knocked out of the League Cup by Grimsby Town. Critics say he is too wedded to his 3-4-3 system, but has his ideological approach bought him more time than a more pragmatic manager would get?

On today’s Libero, Rory Smith, Jack Pitt-Brooke and Jonathan Wilson discuss Amorim’s struggles and the importance of having a philosophy in the modern game.

English football has traditionally rejected abstract ideas but that looks to have changed over the last 10 years since Pep Guardiola’s arrival. Is it now possible to get a big job without a clear set of ideas? Or are we starting to see a turn back towards pragmatism through managers like Thomas Frank?

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in via [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Follow us on TikTok @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

The European club season is now underway, with the Champions League draw to follow on Thursday. James Horncastle and Miguel Delaney join John Brewin to discuss some of the key questions from the continent. The rest of Europe is taking some surprising decisions to keep up with the Premier League’s riches. Each of the so-called top-five leagues have taken different approaches. Can they work? Or are the major clubs now in control? Plus, some more logs are thrown on the PSR fire. 

Produced by: Tom Bassam

DISCLAIMER: Producer Tom experienced significant technical issues while editing this episode and as a result the audio quality is not up to the usual standard. We apologise profusely and will ensure a return to normal service for episode 048.

Email in via [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Follow us on TikTok @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

The biggest story of this summer’s transfer window is Alexander Isak. The Newcastle United striker is so desperate for a move that he has not been training with Newcastle United, and on Tuesday night he finally went public about his desire to leave.

On today’s Libero, Jonathan Wilson, Rory Smith and Jack Pitt-Brooke try to get to the bottom of the story of the summer. How outraged should we be by Isak’s conduct? Is he ‘on strike’, insulting the fans, or is he just playing one of the few cards available to him?

This summer has shown how clubs treat players, whether Manchester United with their bomb squad, or Nottingham Forest denying Morgan Gibbs-White a move to Tottenham. So in that context does it make sense for a player to try to force his way out? And how can players claw back any power in the marketplace? Is the only route for them to stop signing long-term contracts when they are at the moment of maximum leverage?

P1: (00:36)

P2: (38:08)

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in via [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

It’s the initialism on many people’s lips as the transfer window rages on. PSR, profit and sustainability rules: what are they good for? Miguel Delaney and Tariq Panja join John Brewin to pick through the weeds of surrounding what is, in reality, a rather a dry financial regulation covering accountancy to stop clubs spending beyond their means. Though, of course, as it’s modern football, where self-interest rules, it can never be that simple. Can there really be such a thing as financial fair play? Are the scales weighted to serve established elite? Why can’t everybody spend what they want?

P1: (00:59)

P2: (34:15)

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in via [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Is there a chance that Manchester City's imperial era is over, and might Arsenal-Liverpool be what replaces it? As everyone - again - waits for 'the City case' to end, there are other new uncertainties about Pep Guardiola and his team, whereas we know much more about what the champions and Arsenal are about. Could this herald a new rivalry at the top? Have Arsenal done enough? Have Liverpool done too much? And what of world champions, Chelsea?

P1: (03:46)

P2: (40:37)

Join the Libero Fantasy League: fantasy.premierleague.com/leagues/auto-join/hjjtc0 or via the code hjjtc0

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email John with your Nectar point numbers at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Jonathan Wilson sets the new season’s agenda for Jack Pitt-Brooke and John Brewin ahead of Friday’s big kick-off. The title, the drop, the transfer market coming back in a big way and (30:17) the current trend for hulking No 9s are all discussed. Every team gets a mention. Well, apart from one. Can you guess who? 

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Join the Libero Fantasy League: fantasy.premierleague.com/leagues/auto-join/hjjtc0 or via the code hjjtc0

Email John with your Nectar point numbers at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

On today’s Libero Jack Pitt-Brooke, Jonathan Wilson and Tariq Panja turn their attention to the Championship.

Is it still the most competitive league in the world? Or has that myth gone the same way as similar claims about the Premier League. With parachute payments distorting the competitive balance of the Championship so much, does it make the promotion race more predictable than ever? It’s hard to look past Ipswich Town for the top two places this season.

And given the effect of parachute payments, does it make sense for Championship clubs to make their own documentaries? Wrexham and Birmingham City both have TV shows. And while none of the three on the show have watched them, is it the only way to compete?

P1 (00:00)

P2: (38:30)

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

He’s the undoubted coaching genius of 21st century football, admired, aspired to, much imitated and rarely bettered, but this summer has been one of unusual uncertainty for Pep Guardiola. Can Manchester City be revived? Does he have the players to achieve that? Jonathan Wilson, John Brewin and Miguel Delaney share their memories of Guardiola’s 17 years at the pinnacle of the game and (37:10) wonder if he has more reinventions to come. 

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

On today’s podcast, James Horncastle, Jonathan Wilson and Jack Pitt-Brooke turn their attention to next week’s Champions League qualifiers, and particularly Jose Mourinho, who will take his Fenerbahce team to Feyenoord.

So why are we still so fascinated by Mourinho even as his career moves further away from the top of the game? Does he embody something that the modern game is short of? And why did football start moving beyond him 10 or so years ago (35:07)?

Ultimately it comes down to how you measure or assess greatness, and the episode ends with the question of where Mourinho ranks compared to Pep Guardiola, Sir Alex Ferguson et al, and what his managerial legacy is.

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

James Horncastle and Miguel Delaney join John Brewin in extending congratulations to England’s Lionesses, and handle the hot potato of patriotism. Will our brave girls really get arrested for saying they’re English?

After that (22:23), as Luis Diaz joins Bayern Munich, the stars align for Liverpool’s move for Alexander Isak. What’s brought on all this Liverpool spending? What now for Newcastle? As the picture clears on the summer of strikers, which other deals do they see happening before the window closes?

Produced by: Tom Bassam

Email in at [email protected]

Follow us on X @podcast_libero

Follow us on Bluesky @liberopodcast.bsky.social

Follow us on Instagram @liberopod

Subscribe to our YouTube channel @liberopod

Music: Kid Kodi - Blue Dot Sessions

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.