Stone Shields and Craig Sandlin react to the Bengals' breaking news of the day: Cincinnati declining Myles Murphy's fifth-year option.

The Cincinnati Bengals’ decision not to pick up Myles Murphy’s fifth-year option is less about giving up on the player and more about financial strategy and long-term roster planning. On the surface, it might look surprising—especially coming off Murphy’s most productive season—but the context makes the move more understandable.

Today's video is presented by QC Kinetix! Call (513) 655-3356 or visit qckinetix.com to learn more

First, the economics played a major role. Murphy’s fifth-year option for 2027 would have cost roughly $14.5 million, fully guaranteed . For a player who has shown flashes but hasn’t yet become a consistent elite edge rusher, that’s a significant commitment. While Murphy posted career highs in 2025 with 52 tackles and 5.5 sacks, his production still falls short of top-tier pass rushers who command that level of salary . From a value standpoint, the Bengals likely felt that number didn’t align with his current impact.

However, declining the option doesn’t mean Cincinnati wants to move on. In fact, reports indicate the team is interested in negotiating a long-term extension instead . This approach gives the Bengals more flexibility. Rather than locking into a one-year, fully guaranteed deal at a fixed price, they can structure a multi-year contract that better reflects Murphy’s role and potential while managing salary cap space.

Cap management is especially important given Cincinnati’s recent investments across the roster, particularly on the defensive line . By declining the option, they avoid a large future cap hit and retain the ability to allocate resources more efficiently.

There’s also a timing element. Murphy is still just entering his prime, and the Bengals may want another season to evaluate whether his late-2025 surge is sustainable. If he takes another step forward, they can extend him as a core piece. If not, they maintain flexibility without being locked into a premium salary.

Ultimately, this decision reflects a calculated bet: the Bengals believe in Murphy’s upside, but they prefer to control the terms of that investment rather than commit to a fixed, high-cost option too early.

#Bengals #ChatterboxBengals #BengalsNews

Craig Sandlin and Stone Shields give their grades for every move the Cincinnati Bengals made during the 2026 NFL Draft and their overall grade on the class! The Cincinnati Bengals entered the 2026 NFL Draft without a first-round pick after trading the No. 10 overall selection to the New York Giants for star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence. This aggressive preseason move upgraded the interior defensive line immediately, setting the tone for an offseason focused on bolstering a defense that ranked near the bottom of the league in 2025 (second-worst total defense and third-worst scoring defense). With seven picks remaining, the Bengals prioritized pass rush, secondary depth, and offensive line/tight end support for quarterback Joe Burrow. The resulting class earned strong reviews.

Craig Sandlin breaks down the Bengals day 3 draft picks with a focus on round 7 picks Jack Endries and Landon Robinson! The Cincinnati Bengals finalized their 2026 NFL Draft class by focusing on high-upside value and positional depth in the seventh round, selecting Texas tight end Jack Endries (No. 221 overall) and Navy defensive tackle Landon Robinson (No. 226 overall). These picks aimed to bolster Joe Burrow’s offensive weaponry and add disruptive energy to the defensive line, respectively.

Craig Sandlin breaks down the Cincinnati Bengals selection of Brian Parker II, an offensive lineman from Duke, with the 189th overall pick in the sixth round of the 2026 NFL Draft. The selection represents a homecoming for Parker, a Cincinnati native who played high school football at St. Xavier.

Craig Sandlin and Andrew Collinsworth discuss the Bengals 4th round draft pick, 140 overall, Colbie Young, WR, Georgia. The Cincinnati Bengals bolstered their receiving corps in the fourth round of the 2026 NFL Draft, selecting Georgia wide receiver Colbie Young with the 140th overall pick. Standing at 6-foot-4 and 218 pounds, Young represents a high-upside developmental addition for a Cincinnati offense looking to add depth behind stars Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins.

Craig Sandlin and Andrew Collinsworth discuss the Bengals 4th round draft pick, Connor Lew. In a move aimed at bolstering their interior offensive line depth, the Cincinnati Bengals selected Auburn center Connor Lew in the fourth round of the 2026 NFL Draft. Considered a highly technical and intelligent center, Lew brings extensive SEC experience to Cincinnati, having broken into the starting lineup as a true freshman and starting 25 games over his three-year career with the Tigers. This selection aligns with the Bengals’ strategy to fortify the trenches in front of Joe Burrow, ensuring long-term stability and contingency for their offensive line.

Craig Sandlin and Andrew Collinsworth break down the surprising pick by the Cincinnati Bengals when they selected CB, Tacario Davis with the 72nd overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. The guys discuss Davis' athletic profile and his lack of significant production at the collegiate level. They also discuss how he fits into the Bengals and why he was the pick over Jermod McCoy.

Craig Sandlin and Stone Shields break down the Bengals selection of Texas A&M Edge Cashius Howell with the 41st overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. They discuss his collegiate stats, film breakdown, and his former teammate Shemar Stewart. Additionally, look ahead to some names that could be intriguing to the Bengals in the 3rd round.

The Chatterbox Bengals crew breaks down the Bengals acquisition for DT Dexter Lawrence. Cincinnati sent the New York Giants the 10th overall pick in the upcoming NFL draft in exchange for Lawrence. The gang reacts to the trade, what it means for Dexter Lawrence, and the signal it sends to the team and the entire NFL.

Reid and Craig talk about the proposition of the Bengals selecting LSU All-American Mansoor Delane in the draft.