Cold Case Unsealed

Cold Case Unsealed

By AC WilsonTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Cold Case Unsealed episodes

  • The 30-Year Hunt for Sarah Yarborough’s Killer
    This source details the decades-long investigation into the 1991 murder of Sarah Yarborough, a high school student killed on her school campus. For over thirty years, the case remained cold despite DNA evidence and eyewitness descriptions of a "boogeyman" suspect. The narrative highlights how forensic genetic genealogy eventually linked the crime to Patrick Nicholas, a serial predator whose prior release from prison allowed the tragedy to occur. After a trial featuring powerful emotional testimony from Sarah’s loved ones and a surviving past victim, Nicholas was finally convicted and sentenced. Ultimately, the episode explores the profound trauma experienced by the community and the persistent advocacy for advanced DNA legislation to prevent future systemic failures.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    49 min
  • Business Cards Left at a Murder Scene—Solved 38 Years Later
    This episode chronicles the decades-long investigation into the 1982 murder of Regina Reynolds, a nineteen-year-old student who vanished while hitchhiking in New York. Although detectives discovered business cards belonging to a local carpenter named Donald Sigby near the victim’s body, a lack of physical evidence prevented an initial arrest. The case remained unsolved for over twenty years until cold case investigators utilized modern DNA technology to re-examine biological samples preserved from the original crime scene. By covertly trailing Sigby to a restaurant, authorities secured his genetic profile from a discarded drinking straw, which directly linked him to the killing. This breakthrough led to a guilty verdict in 2005, finally securing a life sentence for the elderly murderer nearly a quarter-century after his crime.



    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    37 min
  • The Murder of 9-Year-Old Debbie Randall
    In 1972, the small community of Marietta, Georgia, was devastated by the abduction and brutal murder of nine-year-old Debbie Lynn Randall. Despite an extensive search and decades of investigation, the case remained cold for nearly fifty years as numerous false confessions and leads proved fruitless. The mystery was finally unraveled through the persistence of a dedicated cold case unit and revolutionary advancements in forensic genetic genealogy. By testing degraded DNA samples against ancestry databases, investigators identified William Bradford Rose as the perpetrator. Although the killer committed suicide in 1974, the discovery provided long-awaited closure for the victim’s family and the local community. This resolution highlights the critical importance of preserving original evidence to ensure that justice can eventually be served through modern science.






    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    39 min
  • The Genetic Search for Christina Castiglione’s Killer
    The episode details the 1983 cold case of Christina Castiglione, a Michigan teenager who was abducted, sexually assaulted, and murdered. Although investigators collected biological evidence and developed a psychological profile at the time, the case remained unsolved for nearly four decades. The narrative highlights the recent breakthrough achieved through investigative genetic genealogy, which utilized advanced DNA testing to identify Charles David Shaw as the killer. Though Shaw died shortly after the crime, forensic science confirmed his guilt by matching DNA from his living relatives. This discovery not only provided answers for the victim's sister but also linked the deceased suspect to the unsolved murder of another young woman, Kimberly Louiselle. Ultimately, the sources illustrate how the synergy between traditional detective work and modern forensic technology can resolve decades-old crimes.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    1 hr 2 min
  • An Entire Town Fell Under Suspicion After Her Murder
    The episode reviews the 25-year pursuit of justice following the brutal 1989 murder of 18-year-old Shannon Siders in Newaygo, Michigan. After the teenager’s body was discovered in a local forest, the investigation languished for decades until a cold case task force and a determined civilian reopened the files. Detectives utilized victimology, a difficult exhumation, and hundreds of interviews to dismantle the false alibis of the last people seen with her. The breakthrough came when eyewitness testimony linked brothers Paul and Matt Jones to the crime, revealing a sexually motivated attack that ended in Shannon’s death. This account highlights the persistence of a grieving father and law enforcement's dedication to solving a crime that haunted a small community for a generation. The case finally concluded with the arrest and conviction of the brothers, providing long-awaited closure for the victim's family.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    41 min
  • Justice for the Nameless - Solving Cold Case Jane Does
    These episode review from a documentary series examine three distinct cold cases where unidentified victims were eventually linked to their killers through DNA technology and persistent detective work. The first case details the hunt for Wilson Chiest, a serial offender identified decades later via genetic evidence and witness testimony regarding two murdered women. The second narrative focuses on the tragic death of Francine Megan, an infant whose remains were discovered in the Arizona desert after a failed adoption scheme led to her murder by her father. Lastly, the text chronicles the 1973 disappearance of Kathy Divine, whose killer, William Cosden Jr., was brought to justice nearly thirty years later using semen samples preserved from the original crime scene. Together, these accounts highlight how forensic advancements and modern databases allow investigators to provide closure for families of "Jane Doe" victims.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    42 min
  • The Shocking Murder of Janet Stallcup
    This episode details the 1976 cold case of Janet Stallcup, a 19-year-old nursing student who was kidnapped, raped, and murdered in Garden Grove, California. For over four decades, her death remained a mystery alongside a similar assault on a neighbor and the 1975 killing of Guadalupe McClelland. The narrative illustrates how modern Investigative Genetic Genealogy (IGG) allowed detectives to overcome the limitations of older DNA databases by building extensive family trees from distant relatives. Through this forensic breakthrough, authorities identified Terry Dean Hawkins as the predator responsible for these heinous crimes. Although Hawkins died in jail in 1977, the discovery provided long-awaited closure for the victims' families and the sole survivor. The sources emphasize that the resolution was made possible by the meticulous preservation of evidence by police over many decades.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    49 min
  • The Serial Killer Who Linked Florida & Virginia Cold Cases
    The episode highlights the critical role of forensic anthropology in solving cold cases where only skeletal remains are left to tell the story. It contrasts a Virginia homicide investigation struggling to identify a nameless victim with a Florida case involving a confessed serial killer whose victim's body was hidden in a swamp. Scientists like Dr. Douglas Owsley and Dr. William Maples utilize skeletal analysis to determine age, sex, and trauma, providing essential evidence that confessions alone cannot offer. The episode also describes the University of Tennessee’s Body Farm, where researchers study human decomposition to help law enforcement pinpoint time of death. Ultimately, these sources illustrate how the intersection of biology and criminal justice works to ensure that even the most calculated crimes do not remain perfect.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    1 hr 2 min
  • 15-year-old found buried in shallow grave at vineyard identified in 1978 cold case
    After nearly five decades, authorities have successfully identified the remains of Michelle Louise Collier, a fifteen-year-old girl discovered in a California vineyard in 1978. For decades, she was known only as Arvin Jane Doe until a partnership between law enforcement and a private laboratory used forensic genetic genealogy to bridge the gap between skeletal evidence and living relatives. The breakthrough provided long-awaited answers for her surviving family, who were finally able to reclaim her remains for a proper burial. While the identification marks a major milestone in the cold case, the investigation into her homicide remains active as detectives now possess new leads. This case highlights the transformative power of modern DNA technology in restoring identities to long-unidentified victims. Progress in the investigation continues as authorities seek the person responsible for her death.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    44 min
  • The Trailside Killer: Terror on Mount Tamalpais
    This source chronicles the investigation and eventual capture of David Carpenter, a notorious serial killer recognized as the Trailside Killer who terrorized Northern California hiking trails. The narrative details how Carpenter utilized his knowledge of remote terrain to stalk and execute numerous victims through gunshot wounds and stabbings between 1979 and 1981. Although initial law enforcement efforts were hindered by conflicting witness accounts, specialized FBI profiling eventually accurately identified the suspect as a socially awkward man with a severe speech impediment. The episode highlights how a crucial tip from a former acquaintance and subsequent forensic links, such as matching ballistics and prison-issued eyewear, led to his arrest. Despite his death row status and modern DNA evidence confirming his guilt in cold cases, the source notes that Carpenter continues to maintain his innocence. These excerpts provide a comprehensive overview of the psychological profile, criminal history, and legal proceedings associated with one of the region's most prolific predators.

    This episode includes AI-generated content.
    51 min

About Cold Case Unsealed

From the publisher's feed

Cold Case Unsealed is a gripping true crime podcast that reopens forgotten investigations, unsolved murders, and mysterious disappearances that never received the answers they deserved. Each episode…