Craig & Carla have been sequestered but they've come back with The Verdict! They discuss all-time favorite performances, how cute Craig was at age 14, and Carla proposes brand-new podcast, The Merylthon!

Our special guests Hrishikesh Hirway and Lindsey Mortensen join us to discuss Craig's 63rd favorite movie, Michel Gondry and Charlie Kaufman's 2004 Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind. Also, Hrishi and Lindsey's Science Of Sleep story! Craig and Carla's Science Of Sleep story! And Carla's Top 5 Places To Cry!

Craig & Carla discuss his 64th favorite movie, Robert Altman's very Altmanesque Nashville (1975). Also, Carla explains The 'Burbs and Batteries Not Included to Craig, and Craig reveals the story about his alter ego, Hannibal Z. Jethro.

Craig & Carla welcome special guest Ben Blacker (Thrilling Adventure Hour, Nerdist Writers Panel) to discuss Craig's 65th favorite movie, 1982 comedy classic Tootsie, as well as how it was never a comedy, why Tracy Letts is now America's asshole, and Carla's Dustin Hoffman story!

Craig & Carla discuss his 66th favorite movie, Stanley Kubrick's Paths Of Glory, as well as Carla's lunchdate plans, all the E-mails Carla sent while Craig watched this movie, and all the things Carla would rather talk about than Paths Of Glory.

Craig & Carla discuss Woody Allen's The Purple Rose of Cairo with special guest Brian Shortall, as well as why waiting tables should be a high school class, Craig's imdb credits, and Carla's Glenn Headley story.

Craig & Carla welcome special guest Liz Cackowski (too many Cackowskis?) to discuss QT's 1994 classic Pulp Fiction, as well as whether you're allowed to wear a choker again, how hot and how old Bruce Willis is in this movie, and whether the devil takes your soul from the back of your head.

Craig & Carla welcome special guest Nancy Hayden to discuss Wim Wenders' 1987 world cinema classic Wings Of Desire, as well as Craig's agnosticism, Carla's sideboob, and Nancy's affinity for Love, Actually.

Craig & Carla discuss his 70th favorite film, 1962's To Kill A Mockingbird, as well as how the Bangles came up with Walk Like An Egyptian, whether Gregory Peck really shot that dog, and why Carla is so cranky.

Craig & Carla welcome special guest Jennifer Marie Kelley to discuss his 71st favorite film, problematic Hollywood classic Gone With The Wind, as well as Erica Kane, team Jacob vs. team Edward, and Clark Gable's bad breath.