Crime Corner With Jessie Wiseman

The three mustaches dust off their Sunday best to cover the shocking murder of a pastor's wife. On February 16th, 2026, Caleb Flynn called 911 to report the senseless and seemingly random murder of his wife, Ashley. Just a few days later, Caleb himself was arrested and charged for the crime. But, did this church leader with no history of violence really murder his beloved wife in cold blood? Or, was her death truly the result of a random act of violence? Well, there's only one being that can cast judgement on a man of God, and that is God himself... or Keith Urban... or Nicki Minaj... or Mariah Carey...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches don their corpse paint and brush up on their Finnish as they prepare to cover a Scandinavian slaughter. In 1960, a group of teens were attacked on the shores of Lake Bodom, near Espoo, Finland. What followed was a symphony of speculation, unfounded accusations, and a decades-long investigation that continues to this day. The murders also laid the groundwork for one of the greatest covers of a Britney Spears song to ever grace your ears. Bundle up for this one, kids, because it's going to be chilly under this freezing moon.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches take a trip back to the 1950s to explore a case that sounds strangely familiar. In 1954, Carl Fisher came home from work to find his three children dead at the hands of his wife, Constance. After a few years in a mental hospital, Constance was released and the couple began rebuilding their family. Then it happened again. Get ready for a deep dive into the mind of a madwoman.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches take a trip to the dentist to make sure their smiles can still light up a room. There's just one problem... someone almost cut the dentist's head off. When Dr John Yelenic turned up dead in midst of a contentious divorce, the police investigated anyone and everyone with a connection to the victim. Almost everyone, that is. For some reason, the seemed to avoid looking into the most obvious suspect. Something about this case stinks, and it's not halitosis.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches decide that they're going to solve a crime from Delaware, and there's nothing that will stand in their way. In June of 1991, Charles Holden called the police with one hell of a wild story. When they went to investigate, they found Holden's 70-year-old mother, Dorothy Donovan, dead in her own bed. From the beginning, the investigators are certain that it was Holden himself behind the crime. Unfortunately for the detectives, they just can't seem to find any evidence to prove it.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches cave to peer pressure and cover the case that has driven the nation to the brink of madness. In January of 2023, Lindsay Clancy took the lives of her three children. The details of the case were then combined with the ever-growing tensions of the times and fermented in the cesspool we call social media, eventually turning this heart-breaking tragedy into a high-proof liquor that we, as a society, have gotten drunk on. Now it's up to Jessie and Coop to talk some sense into everyone before this madness rips the country apart. Buckle up buckaroos, because we're about to take you on one hell of a trip.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches grab their chemistry sets to help solve a medical mystery in Springfield, Missouri. In 2013, Diane Staudte rushed her 24-year-old daughter, Sarah to the hospital after she came down with a mystery illness. Then, a tip from a concerned member of the community led to a shocking revelation: Sarah wasn't the first member of the family to battle this peculiar sickness. Now, Diane and her other daughter, Rachel, have some difficult questions to answer...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches put on their lab coats and grab an extra chromosome for the road as they travel to Michigan to help with some lab work. After Andrea Eilber was murdered in 2011, authorities were quick to pin the blame on her boyfriend, Kenneth Grondin. But, 10 years later, a new, exciting suspect named Chadwick Mobley caught their eye and now they can't decide who they want to throw in prison. Why not both?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches touch up their dating profiles and set the mood lighting to cover a case from the lonely heart ads. When Patricia Hall vanished without a trace, her husband Keith thought he'd never find love again. But sometimes, when one chapter closes, an even better one begins — in the personals section of a Yorkshire newspaper. But, if Keith wants to keep his new love interest from disappearing like his wife, he'll have to find the courage to say those three words every woman wants to hear... "I killed her"

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches tackle a frustrating case out of Pennsylvania that will leave you wondering whether forgiveness is divine, or criminal negligence. When Aimee Willard disappeared in June of 1996, the police had no shortage of suspects to investigate -- some of whom came from their very own ranks. But, the target of their search was eventually revealed to be a ghost from their past that kept coming back to haunt them. If you miss this episode, we forgive you. Just promise not to let it happen again...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices