The three mustaches put on their lab coats and grab an extra chromosome for the road as they travel to Michigan to help with some lab work. After Andrea Eilber was murdered in 2011, authorities were quick to pin the blame on her boyfriend, Kenneth Grondin. But, 10 years later, a new, exciting suspect named Chadwick Mobley caught their eye and now they can't decide who they want to throw in prison. Why not both?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches touch up their dating profiles and set the mood lighting to cover a case from the lonely heart ads. When Patricia Hall vanished without a trace, her husband Keith thought he'd never find love again. But sometimes, when one chapter closes, an even better one begins — in the personals section of a Yorkshire newspaper. But, if Keith wants to keep his new love interest from disappearing like his wife, he'll have to find the courage to say those three words every woman wants to hear... "I killed her"

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches tackle a frustrating case out of Pennsylvania that will leave you wondering whether forgiveness is divine, or criminal negligence. When Aimee Willard disappeared in June of 1996, the police had no shortage of suspects to investigate -- some of whom came from their very own ranks. But, the target of their search was eventually revealed to be a ghost from their past that kept coming back to haunt them. If you miss this episode, we forgive you. Just promise not to let it happen again...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches prepare to slip the surly bonds of Earth and touch the face of God as they cover a case from Cape Canaveral. In February of 2007, Air Force Captain Colleen Shipman narrowly escaped with her life after she was attacked in an airport parking lot by an unidentified woman. When the police located the culprit soon afterwards, they were shocked to find that she wasn't some random lunatic, she was a real-life American hero... who was also a lunatic. Everyone be sure to use the bathroom before we leave. We've got a long trip ahead of us.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches grab a case of Molson's and put on their toques to cover a case from our maple-scented neighbors to the north. In 2010, the death of a woman named Jessica Lloyd kicked off an investigation that eventually led to the capture of one of Canada's most bizarre and brutal criminals: the Tweed Creeper. For nearly two years, this nocturnal ne'er-do-well terrorized an Ontario town until a seemingly benign piece of evidence put detectives on his trail. Don't miss this episode because it's guaranteed to get your panties in a bunch.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches circle around the campfire to tell some hunting stories about the one that got away. One that definitely DIDN'T get away was Kirt Stubbins. In 2023, he took his girlfriend's 17-year-old son, Trenton, out to do a little bonding and, hopefully, bag a record-breaking buck. Unfortunately for Kirt, he was the one that ended up in the crosshairs.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches keister some shanks and put on their scary faces because they're going to the big house. In 2015, a pair of cons from New York orchestrated a prison break so complex that it rivaled that of Andy Dufresne in the Shawshank Redemption. What followed was the single largest manhunt in the history of New York state. Did the cons reach Zihuatanejo, or did they crawl through all those yards of foul smelling pipes for nothing? Listen to find out!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches don their trench coats and fedoras to solve a few cases with the hardest dick in New York history, Albert Seedman. Whether they were a murderer, a mafioso, or a mob of religious fanatics, there was no crook too tough for the man they called "the Cigar". But surprisingly, the most difficult case of his entire career didn't involve any mobsters or zealots. Instead, it involved a young woman named Nancy McEwen, a yellow Camaro, and a bullet that seemingly appeared out of thin air...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches tackle a spicy and sensational case that has all of our favorite things, and more. In 2023, a bizarre home invasion gone wrong in Herndon, Virginia resulted in the deaths of both the victim, and the alleged perpetrator. But, as detectives started trying to make sense of the senseless crime, it began to look as though the victim may have inadvertently orchestrated their own murder. Now it was up to the investigators to determine whether this really was a random act of violence, or one of the most brilliant murder plots they had ever seen.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The three mustaches head to rural Oregon to help track down a guy named Robert Haney. According to his enchantingly beautiful landlord / employer, Susan Monica, he went hog wild a few months ago and she hasn't seen him since. Robert's son, on the other hand, thinks Susan knows exactly where his father is and she's just being pig-headed about it. All we know for sure is wherever Robert went, he's definitely not living high on the hog without his EBT card. Brace yourselves for this one because this tale has more twists than a pig's tail.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices