In February of 2009, Christine Ross and her dog found a bone while going for a walk in Albuquerque, New Mexico. This would lead investigators to digging up the remains of 11 different women, and it would take them an entire year to identify each one. To this day, the West Mesa bone collector has still never been caught. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

We've covered the case that inspired the movie Scream, but we're here to tell the unfortunate story of Cassie Jo Stoddart, who was killed by two boys from her High School that were inspired by the movie Scream. Torey Adamcik & Brian Draper had a kill list and Cassie's name was on it. She was house sitting for her aunt & uncle alone the night the two boys came in through the basement to play out their slasher film fantasies. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

In September of 1982, the city of Chicago was under great distress when seven people mysteriously dropped dead in the span of just a few days. Investigators from all over came together to find the common denominator that was responsible for killing their city’s citizens. The unlikely culprit? Tylenol. To this day, the person walking around Chicago and tainting bottles of Tylenol with Cyanide has never been found and the case has never been solved. Erika walks us through the timeline of the case, the suspects and all of the theories. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

30-year old Annie Borjesson's body was discovered on Prestwick Beach in Scotland face down next to her belongings. The incident was quickly ruled suicide and authorities refused to look any further into it. There are twists and turns about her mysterious death that will make your jaw drop...and to this day, we have NO answers on what truly happened - only the theories that have stirred. Buckle up, this week's episode is going to take you for a ride. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

Florida men Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos went missing within three months of each other in 2003/2004 and to this day their disappearances are still unsolved, without a trace of evidence. The two men did have one thing in common: the last person to see both of them alive was one Steve Calkins, a deputy at the Collier County Sheriff’s Office in East Naples. To this day, Calkins maintains his innocence and the families of both men are still looking for answers. Erika walks us through the case, the theories and the history of policing and the cities working to make it a just system.  

In Davenport, Iowa 10-year old Breasia Terrell went missing in early July of 2020 after spending the night at her half brother's dad's apartment...Henry Dinkins soon became the primary suspect in the case of her disappearance after surveillance footage and an extremely sketchy track record clearly indicated his involvement. Allyson is here to explain what happened to Breasia and where the case stands currently in this week's episode. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

On the outside, Dennis Rader's childhood seemed completely normal. But inside his head were demons that couldn't stay repressed for very long. Rader's fantasies of bondage and "having his way" with women became reality when he began "trolling" for victims and murdering them after tying them up. With ten victims, multiple cooling off periods, and playing games with the media, it would be 30 years before authorities would piece together who was behind the identity of "BTK". 

All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

On the outside, Dennis Rader's childhood seemed completely normal. But inside his head were demons that couldn't stay repressed for very long. Rader's fantasies of bondage and "having his way" with women became reality when he began "trolling" for victims and murdering them after tying them up. With ten victims, multiple cooling off periods, and playing games with the media, it would be 30 years before authorities would piece together who was behind the identity of "BTK". 

All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

The urban legend of the 1946 Phantom Killer has been told around campfires and depicted in movies for years, but this was no tall tale. The town of Texarkana was terrorized by a man with a white sack over his head that was targeting young couples enjoying quality time at local "lover's lanes" around the area. After the deaths of 4 and 2 others in critical condition...The Phantom Killer turned his victimology upside down and kept going. Allyson will give you all the details on this spooky and sinister case on this week's episode! All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

Since it's October, we decided to focus on some cases that have a spooky element. Today, Erika will take you through the case of Austin Harrouff... a Florida State University sophomore that claimed he was half man, half wolf the day he committed one of the most shocking crimes we've seen! With a 40 page evaluation of Harrouff, there are SO many things we need to dive into to see WHY and HOW this happened. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine