Crime on Caffeine

Crime on Caffeine

By Erika Meisel & Allyson SquitiroSociety & CultureTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Crime on Caffeine episodes

  • SURVIVED: Mary Vincent

    Mary Vincent was a 15 year-old runaway when she decided to hitch hike her way to California to be a Dancer. Lawrence Singleton picked her up in his blue van and her unimaginable and awe-inspiring survival story began. Left to die in a canyon, Mary found the strength to keep going in hopes that no one else would be brutally attacked by this man again. Allyson is here to take you through Mary's struggles and triumphs in today's episode. What happened to her and where did Lawrence Singleton end up? You'll find out this week on Crime on Caffeine! All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

    36 min
  • RULED ACCIDENTAL: Kenneka Jenkins & Tamla Horsford

    In this week’s episode, Erika brings us two cases that have been heavily disputed as to whether or not they were homicides or accidental deaths. Black women experience the highest rate of homicides in the US, with only half of their killers being arrested. Though these killings are so common, they often go unheard. Erika tells the stories of Kenneka Jenkins and Tamla Horsford, two women whose deaths were ruled accidental. When the families don’t agree with the police’s decision, they become desperate for answers, and desperate for their voices to be heard. Listen to the stories of these women, and look into the following resources to amplify the stories of missing and murdered black women and men across the country. Their stories deserve to be heard.


    38 min
  • KILLER: Katherine Knight / Gabby Petito UPDATE

    Before we get into the notorious Katherine Knight. We wanted to take a moment to discuss the evolving and heartbreaking case of Gabby Petito. Things are changing quickly but we are here to bring you the information we know as of now. Autopsy confirmed the remains found are hers and Brian is still missing (possible sighting on a deer cam). 

    Katherine Knight made history as the first woman in Australia to be sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. How? Her scarring childhood created one violent and messed up woman who had a tendency to favor a pair of butcher knives. We hope you have a strong stomach because Allyson is not sparing any of the details in today's case. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

    47 min
  • SURVIVED: The Slender Man Stabbing

    Payton Leutner and Morgan Geyser had the best of friendships until the girls turned twelve and Anissa Weier joined the group. On May 30th, 2014, the three girls celebrated Morgan’s birthday at what Payton thought was just a routine sleepover. Little did she know her two best friends had been planning her murder for months - all in the name of Slender Man. The girls stabbed Peyton 19 times. What they didn’t plan for, however, was her survival. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

    44 min
  • KILLERS: The Twilight Murders

    In April of 2016, Kim Edwards and Lucas Markham became the UK's youngest murderers when their elaborate plot to kill Kim's mother and younger sister came to fruition. After the brutal stabbing and smothering of her family, the 14-year-old pair decided to stay in the home of Kim's now slaughtered family and play house. They ate ice cream and watched the Twilight Saga deeming them the infamous Twilight Killers. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

    44 min
  • ABDUCTED/KILLER: Steven and Cary Stayner

    On this week’s episode, Erika brings us down the rabbit hole that is the Stayner Family past. Steven Stayner was just seven years old when he was abducted by predator Kenneth Parnell. Steven, manipulated into thinking he was Parnell’s son, was sexually abused and brainwashed for 7 years before escaping and saving another boy in the process. We learn about Steven’s life after his escape, and about the trauma experienced by another member of Steven’s family, his brother Cary. Unfortunately, Cary Stayner took a different path in response to his trauma. All sources can be found on www.crimeoncaffeine.com. Follow us on social media @crimeoncaffeine

    1 hr 3 min
  • SERIAL KILLER: The Gainesville Ripper

    Daniel Rolling grew up in a traumatic household that left him with a world of resentment and anger. Soon after his wife divorced him, he lost his job at a local restaurant and that same night the murdering began. He would go on to murder a total of 8 people, his most notorious spree being at the University of Florida in Gainesville. He terrorized the town for days leaving behind a crime that would go on to be the muse for horror movies such as the cult classic, Scream. 

    45 min
  • UNSOLVED: Natalee Holloway

    Erika shares the first true crime case she remembers, the unsolved disappearance of Natalee Holloway. In 2005, Natalee had just graduated high school and had a bright future ahead of her. She went on a trip to Aruba with her classmates and didn’t show up for the flight back to Alabama. The case became a media frenzy as the Holloway family and Aruban police are at odds, leaving mother Beth Twitty and father Dave Holloway to take matters into their own hands. Beth was certain the three boys last seen with Natalee knew what happened to her daughter, but over 15 years later no one has any knowledge of what happened to her. Except perhaps Joran Van Zandt. 

    58 min
  • MURDERED: Donnah Winger

    In August of 1995, Donnah Winger was returning home from a trip to see her family in Florida with her newly adopted baby girl. Just a few short days later the man who drove her from from the airport murdered her in her home... The husband, Mark Winger shot the man murdering his wife and we all thought it was case closed. Allyson is here to inform you of the REAL killer, how the truth came out and where the case ended. 
    All source material available on crimeoncaffeine.com, follow us on social media for more information @crimeoncaffeine

    31 min
  • UNSOLVED: Maura Murray

    In February of 2004 21-year-old Maura Murray crashed her car in Haverhill, New Hampshire after leaving school at UMass Amherst suddenly, for reasons unknown to friends and family. When help arrived, Maura was nowhere to be found. Erika gives us a glimpse at Maura’s life and troubles before her disappearance, and talks about the theories surrounding the unsolved case. 
    All source material available on crimeoncaffeine.com, follow us on social media for more information @crimeoncaffeine

    43 min

About Crime on Caffeine

From the publisher's feed

As if our crippling coffee addiction didn't cause us enough anxiety, we're covering all things true crime while giving listeners a look into the psychological profile of each case's offender on the…