Deadly Truths

Deadly Truths

By onlydeadlytruthsTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Deadly Truths episodes

  • The Thanksgiving Day Massacre: Priscilla Ford’s Deadly Rampage in Reno

    On Thanksgiving Day, 1980, Reno was celebrating with parades and family gatherings when tragedy struck. Priscilla Ford, a woman with a long history of mental health struggles, drove her car through the crowded streets of downtown Reno—killing six people and injuring more than twenty.

    This episode dives into:

    • Ford’s troubled background and the warnings leading up to the attack.

    • The horrifying events of that November day under the Reno Arch.

    • The trial that followed, including questions of competency and justice.

    • The lasting impact this massacre left on Reno and the families forever changed.

    Was this an inevitable tragedy ignored by the system—or a shocking act of violence no one could have predicted?

    Disclaimer: This podcast discusses true crime cases involving murder, mental illness, and other disturbing topics. Listener discretion is advised. All information is compiled from publicly available records, reporting, and historical accounts.

    Season Wrap-Up
    With this episode, we close Reno Murders: Death in the Biggest Little City — Season One of Deadly Truths. Thank you for following along.

    Coming this October, Deadly Truths moves into Season Two, shifting our focus to Fort Leavenworth, Kansas—a place steeped in military history, notorious criminals, and hauntingly dark cases. It’s the perfect setting to carry us into a chilling new season.

    Subscribe so you don’t miss the premiere of Season Two.
    Like, share, and drop your thoughts in the comments.

    Resources & References

  • Associated Press (1980–1983) reporting on the Priscilla Ford case.

  • Reno Gazette-Journal archives, coverage of the Thanksgiving Day massacre and trial proceedings.

  • Nevada Supreme Court case: Ford v. State, 102 Nev. 126 (1986) – appellate review of her conviction and death sentence.

  • Lake’s Crossing Center history and Nevada mental health system reports.

  • Interviews and retrospective coverage from KOLO 8 News Now and KTVN 2 News Reno.

  • “Massacre at the Parade” – feature in Reno Gazette-Journal remembering the tragedy and its survivors.



  • 20 min
  • Tahoe's Real Estate Serial Killer - Dead State

    In the late 1970s, Lake Tahoe was a paradise on the surface — neon-lit casinos, booming tourism, and endless alpine beauty. But beneath the glitter and pine trees lurked a predator.

    This episode uncovers the chilling murders of 27-year-old Brynn Rainey and 16-year-old Carol Andersen, two young women brutally killed just two years apart. For decades, their cases went cold, their killer hiding in plain sight. The shocking truth? He wasn’t a drifter or a shadowy stranger — he was a local real estate agent, living and working among the very community he terrorized.

    Join us as we return to 1970s Tahoe, where paradise collided with horror, and the true story of Tahoe’s Real Estate Killer was buried for more than 40 years.

    Primary / Official Sources & Case Summaries

  • Case Summary: Brynn Rainey & Carol Andersen (El Dorado County DA) — PDF overview of both murders, evidence, forensic details, and how the cold case task force reopened them. gray-arc-content.s3.amazonaws.com

  • El Dorado County District Attorney — press release: “Two Separate Decades-Old Murder Cases Solved Using Genetic Genealogy” Facebook

  • El Dorado County DA: DNA evidence helped solve 2 South Lake Tahoe cold cases (Tahoe Daily Tribune) — local coverage, background, suspect info tahoedailytribune.com

  • “Investigators solve 1970s cold cases with emerging DNA technique” (CBS News) — overview of how DNA / genealogy cracked the Rainey/Andersen cases CBS News

  • “2 women were strangled in Tahoe in the 1970s” (SFGate) — journalistic coverage, linking cases, suspect announcement SFGATE

  • “DNA helps solve 2 cold-case homicides in Tahoe, El Dorado County” (Sacramento Bee) — forensic, investigative coverage Sacramento Bee

  • “New push to solve teen’s 1979 cold case murder” (CBS News) — background before the DNA break CBS News

  • “DNA links South Lake Tahoe man to 1970s cold cases” (KCRA) — local news version of the identification and DNA link to Holt KCRA

  • Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    17 min
  • The Murder of Hailey Nieto | Reno True Crime Podcast

    *Updated with corrected information from Hailey's mother April, please donate to her family below (GoFundMeLink For Hailey’s Girls, Luna & Mila⁠ )

    In March 2023, 18-year-old Hailey Nieto—a young mother of two—vanished from her apartment at the Siegel Suites Nevadan in downtown Reno. Days later, her body was found stuffed in a duffel bag off a dirt road near Cold Springs. The investigation pointed to her neighbor, 39-year-old habitual criminal Todd Tonnochy, a man Hailey had already voiced fears about.

    This episode unpacks the red flags Hailey shared before her death, the brutal details of the crime, how investigators connected Tonnochy to the murder, and the court case that ended with a life sentence. We also take time to remember Hailey—not just as a victim, but as a daughter, a dreamer studying to be a mortician, and a devoted mom to two little girls, Luna and Mila.

    Resources & Support:A GoFundMe has been created to support Hailey’s daughters, organized by her mother, April: For Hailey’s Girls, Luna & Mila.

    Reno Murders: Death in the Biggest Little City brings you the stories that reveal Reno’s shadow side—where danger can live just next door.

    News & Case Coverage

    ​KOLO 8 News Now – Suspect arrested in connection with the murder of Hailey Nieto; second suspect accused of destroying evidenceLink

    ​KOLO 8 News Now – Opening statements in murder trial of Todd TonnochyLink

    ​KOLO 8 News Now – Guilty verdict in murder of 18-year-old in 2023Link

    ​KOLO 8 News Now – Tonnochy could serve life in prisonLink

    MyNews4 – Jury deliberating murder case against Todd Tonnochy, accused of killing teen mom Hailey NietoLink

    ​MyNews4 – Todd Tonnochy sentenced for brutal murder in RenoLink

    ​Our Town Reno – New lawsuit in Hailey Nieto’s killing as sentencing days awayLink

    ​Washoe County Sheriff’s Office – Press Release: Suspect arrested in Cold Springs homicide caseLink

    Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    23 min
  • The Alphabet Serial Killer of Reno

    In this episode, we unravel the chilling case of Reno’s so-called Alphabet Serial Killer. From the eerie pattern in his victims to the strange, methodical way he stalked the streets, this story unsettled the community and left investigators scrambling for answers. We’ll dive into the timeline of murders, the victims’ stories, and how the killer earned his haunting nickname. Was it coincidence, calculation, or something more sinister? Join us as we trace the alphabet of death through Reno’s dark history.

    Resources for this episode:

    ABC7 — “Serial killer Joseph Naso calls I-Team from prison”
    This reports on Naso’s prison phone calls, his frailty, and recent investigations.
    https://abc7news.com/post/serial-killer-joseph-naso-calls-teams-dan-noyes-prison-he-faces-new-investigations-are-more-victims/17878512/ ABC7 San Francisco

    Vanity Fair — “How a Death Row Murderer Exposed One of America’s Most Prolific Serial Killers (Part 1 & Part 2)”
    In-depth narrative on Bill Noguera’s role, his interactions with Naso, and the expansion of the case.
    Part 1: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/story/death-row-murderer-exposed-serial-killer-case-part-1 Vanity Fair
    Part 2: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/story/death-row-murderer-exposed-serial-killer-case-part-2 Vanity Fair

    Newsweek — “Alphabet Serial Killer May Be Linked To More Murders”
    Covers new claims and ongoing investigation into additional victims beyond the known four.
    https://www.newsweek.com/alphabet-serial-killer-may-link-more-murders-2122664 Newsweek

    ABC7 — “Serial killer Joseph Naso linked to Daly City’s oldest cold case murder”
    Suggests Naso may be linked to a 1974 murder in Daly City, possibly his first known African American victim.
    https://abc7news.com/post/serial-killer-joseph-naso-linked-daly-citys-oldest-cold-case-murder/17837080/ ABC7 San Francisco

    ABC7 — “Joseph Naso left 2 bodies on Mt. Tam in 1977, according to new documentary”
    Reports claims by Naso regarding murders on Mt. Tamalpais and the overlapping of his list with those cases.
    https://abc7news.com/post/joseph-naso-left-2-bodies-mt-tamalpais-marin-county-according-death-row-confidential-secrets-serial-killer/17676739/ ABC7 San Francisco

    “A Cold Case Review into the Mind of Serial Killer Joseph Naso”
    An investigative article summarizing the search, diaries, photos, and forensic evidence in the case.
    https://www.ishinews.com/a-cold-case-review-into-the-mind-of-serial-killer-joseph-naso/ ISHI News

    TV Insider — “Did ‘Alphabet Killer’ Joseph Naso Murder 26 Women?”
    Looks into recent documentaries and the claims about 26 victims.
    https://www.tvinsider.com/1216419/joseph-naso-alphabet-killer-death-row-confidential-secrets-of-a-serial-killer-bill-noguera/ TV Insider

    Lion TV / “The Murder List” (Documentary / Show)
    A documentary about Naso’s List of Ten, his diaries, and the mystery behind them.
    https://www.liontvusa.com/our-shows/the-murder-list liontvusa.com

    Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    22 min
  • The Mound House Murder: Marijuana, Betrayal, and Death on Highway 395

    On June 19, 2020, 26-year-old Jered Stefansky drove from Redding, California to Mound House, Nevada for what he believed was a marijuana deal. He vanished. Months later, skeletal remains were found at Rye Patch, and a massive conspiracy unraveled. In this episode, we follow the chilling path from Stefansky’s disappearance, through stalking, paranoia, and a brutal murder-for-hire plot involving Cory Spurlock. A double murder on Highway 395, lies, betrayal, and a desperate mother’s voice that echoes long after.📚 Resources & Links

  • Department of Justice – Press Release (Sept 12, 2025):
    Jury Convicts Man of Murder-for-Hire Conspiracy, Witness Tampering by Killing, and Stalking Resulting in Death

  • KOLO 8 News Now (Sept 15, 2025):
    Man who ran Mound House drug operation convicted in murder-for-hire plot

  • Nevada Appeal (Mar 10, 2022):
    Remains of missing Redding man found in Pershing County

  • Carson Now (Mar 10, 2022):
    Missing person remains located and identified; investigation involves Carson City, Lyon County

  • Record Courier (Dec 7, 2024):
    April 2025 trial date set in Mono murders

  • Charley Project – Case File:
    Jered Ryan Stefansky Missing Person Case

  • KRCR News (Nov 2020):
    Murder in Mono County has family of missing Redding man worried about retaliation


  • Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    20 min
  • Reno’s Corridor of Death : The Truckee River

    From Sandra Whitlock in 1985 to Christopher Nyhammer in 2025, the Truckee River has carried with it more than just snowmelt from Lake Tahoe. It has carried bodies. Fourteen confirmed deaths – some murders, some drownings, some still unexplained – haunt this ribbon of water that cuts through Reno, Nevada. By day it’s a place of recreation and families, but by night it becomes a corridor of shadows. This episode dives deep into the deaths tied to the Truckee, the unsolved mysteries, and the reputation the river has earned as a place of beauty and terror.

    Hosted by Rebecca Clark, true crime researcher and storyteller based in Reno, Nevada.

    Reno Gazette-Journal – Coverage of Truckee River deaths

    KTVN 2 News – Recent body recovery reports

    Nevada Appeal – Historical cases along the TruckeeTruckee River Watershed Council – About the river itself

    FBI – National Missing Person Database (NamUs)

    Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.


    12 min
  • Hungry Valley’s Suspected Serial Killer - Dead State

    In 1979, two young women vanished in Reno, Nevada. Their bodies were later discovered in Hungry Valley — less than a mile apart — sparking fear and mystery that haunted the community for decades. Julia Woodward was 21, and Jeannie Smith only 17, when their lives were cut short. For forty years, their murders remained unsolved.

    Then in 2019, advances in DNA technology pointed investigators toward Charles Gary Sullivan, a man in his seventies living in Arizona. Was he a hidden serial predator in Reno’s past?

    This episode unpacks:

  • The cases of Julia Woodward and Jeannie Smith, and how their murders were finally tied to Sullivan.

  • Other suspected victims, including Linda Taylor, a 23-year-old who disappeared in March 1979 — her car was abandoned near Reno, and although Sullivan admitted dating her, her fate remains unknown. investigationdiscovery.com+1

  • Sullivan’s earlier brushes with the law, such as the 2007 case involving a woman hitchhiker in California, which helped investigators build a pattern. https://www.kolotv.com+2investigationdiscovery.com+2

  • We’ll dig into what investigators found, how new forensic tools finally cracked open the cold cases, and ask: how many more victims might still be waiting for their stories to be told?

    Resources & Further Reading

  • KOLO 8 News Now – “Arrest in 40-Year-Old Reno Area Cold Case Murder” (2019)
    Read here

  • Las Vegas Review-Journal – “Man Arrested in Reno Murder May Be Serial Killer” (2019)
    Read here

  • Investigation Discovery – “Arizona Man Charged in Cold Case Slaying Could Be a Serial Killer” (2019)
    Read here

  • KTVN 2 News – “DNA Evidence Leads to Arrest in 1979 Cold Case Murder” (2019)
    Read here

  • RGJ (Reno Gazette Journal) – Local reporting on Julia Woodward & Jeannie Smith murders (archival, paywall may apply).

  • Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    24 min
  • The Murder of Julia Bulette: Queen of the Comstock - The Frontier is Dead

    In 1867, Julia Bulette, Virginia City’s most famous courtesan and the so-called Queen of the Comstock, was brutally murdered in her cottage. Strangled and left for dead, her killing shocked the booming mining town built on the riches of the Comstock Lode.

    This episode of Deadly Truths explores Julia’s extraordinary life, the crime scene, and the sensational trial that followed. The controversial conviction and public hanging of John Millain raised questions that linger to this day: was justice really served, or was he a scapegoat?

    From the silver boom of Virginia City to the early days of Reno, Julia’s story is more than a true crime case—it’s a piece of Nevada history that reveals the darker side of the Wild West.

    Step back into 19th-century Nevada for one of the state’s earliest and most infamous murder cases—the death of Julia Bulette, the Queen of the Comstock.

    📚 References & Sources

    Nevada Historical Society – Julia Bulette Case Files & Archives. Documentation of her life, death, and the trial of John Millain.
    https://www.nvhistoricalsociety.org

    Virginia City Historic District – Comstock History Resources. Local archives on Bulette’s murder and the 1867 trial.
    https://visitvirginiacitynv.com/history

    Nevada Magazine – Julia Bulette: Queen of the Comstock. Narrative feature on her life, role in Virginia City, and lasting legend.
    https://nevadamagazine.com

    Comstock History Center – The Trial of John Millain. Archival summaries of proceedings and public reaction.
    https://comstockfoundation.org

    Reno Gazette-Journal Archives – Coverage of the Julia Bulette case and its place in early Nevada crime history.
    https://www.rgj.com

    PBS Nevada / “Nevada Experience” – Virginia City and the Comstock Era. Context on the mining boom and Julia’s place in society.
    https://pbsreno.org

    Historic Reno Preservation Society (HRPS) – FootPrints: Julia Bulette. Local history publication detailing Bulette’s legacy.
    https://www.historicreno.org

    The Comstock Chronicle – Local reprints and retrospectives on Bulette’s murder and Virginia City legends.
    https://comstockchronicle.com

    Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.


    7 min
  • Cannibalism at Donner Pass | The Frontier is Dead

    In this episode of Reno Murders: Death in the Biggest Little City, we uncover the chilling history of the Donner Party tragedy at Donner Pass. Stranded in the Sierra Nevada during the brutal winter of 1846–47, dozens of pioneers faced starvation, desperation, and the ultimate taboo—cannibalism for survival.

    We’ll explore the journey westward, the fateful decisions that trapped them in the snow, and the haunting rescue attempts that revealed one of America’s darkest survival stories. More than just a tale of hunger, the Donner Party’s ordeal shaped how settlers viewed the Sierra Nevada and set the stage for Reno’s role as a safer crossing point in the decades to come.

    Join us as we connect the legend of Donner Pass to Reno’s shadowed past, where survival, tragedy, and human desperation echo through history.

    References & Sources

  • Hardesty, Donald L. (1997). The Archaeology of the Donner Party. University of Nevada Press.
    👉 Publisher link

  • Wallis, Michael (2009). The Best Land Under Heaven: The Donner Party in the Age of Manifest Destiny. W.W. Norton.
    👉 Publisher link

  • McGlashan, C. F. (1879). History of the Donner Party. Truckee Republican. (Public Domain).
    👉 Archive.org link

  • Univ. of Nevada, Reno – Special Collections. Donner Party Collection.
    👉 UNR Library link

  • PBS: American Experience (1992). The Donner Party (Documentary).
    👉 PBS Episode page

  • History.com Editors (2023). “Donner Party.” History Channel.
    👉 History.com article

  • Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    40 min
  • The Reno State Fair Serial Killers - Dead City

    Killer Couples: Love, Control, and Murder Across the West

    When love turns lethal, the story takes a darker twist. In this episode of Deadly Truths, we investigate one of America’s most notorious killer couples—partners bound not just by romance, but by a shared appetite for control, manipulation, and murder.

    Behind the façade of an ordinary relationship, they plotted abductions, sexual assaults, and killings that stretched from Reno to Sacramento and along the highways of the West. Together, they became more dangerous than either could have been alone.

    We’ll explore how they met, what drew them together, and how their toxic bond fueled a wave of crimes that terrified communities. From the psychology of domination to the chilling details of their crimes, this is the portrait of love gone monstrous—a true crime case where trust became the deadliest weapon of all.

    📚 References & Resources

    FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin (2000). Killer Couples: The Dynamics of Dual Offenders. Analysis of psychological factors behind partner-based violent crimes.
    https://leb.fbi.gov

    Hickey, Eric W. (2015). Serial Murderers and Their Victims. Cengage Learning. Key profiles of killer couples in American true crime history.

    Los Angeles Times (1983–1990). Archival reporting on California “killer couple” cases, including crimes linked to Reno and Sacramento.
    https://www.latimes.com

    Radford University / FGCU Serial Killer Database (2015). Profiles of killer couples and their interstate crimes.
    https://maamodt.asp.radford.edu

    Sacramento Bee Archives (1980s). Regional coverage of West Coast abductions and killings tied to known killer couples.


    Disclaimer & Listener Warning
    This podcast discusses sensitive and potentially disturbing topics, including murder, sexual assault, domestic violence, and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. All information presented has been compiled from publicly available records, news reports, archival sources, and historical accounts. While care has been taken to ensure accuracy, details may vary depending on source material.

    If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out for help through your local crisis hotline or support services.

    Support the Show
    If you enjoy Deadly Truths, please rate, follow, and share the podcast. Your support helps bring these stories to more listeners and keeps us exploring the darkest chapters of history and true crime.

    40 min

About Deadly Truths

From the publisher's feed

Deadly Truths exposes the crimes, cover-ups, and institutional failures buried in American history. From forgotten murders and cold cases to Hollywood myths, mob violence, and frontier bloodshed—this…