Cody tells the story of the life and unsolved murder of luxury call girl and expert businesswoman, Rosemarie Nitribitt, in German during the late 1950's. Ashley recounts the heartbreaking details of 8 year old Cherie Mahan's disappearance, 50 yards from her home in Pennsylvania in 1985. 

Ashley opens the episode with the disappearance of Ann Marie Shaw Godbey, and the clues that might bring closure to what happened. Cody covers the case of two bodies found in a lake, one with a crucifix inside its mouth. This would be the "solved" case of Sharon Shaw and Rhonda Johnson's murders, unless you look closely at the details. The perpetrator could have gotten away after all.  

Cody begins the episode with the bizarre deaths of Don Henry and Kevin Ives, and the debated cause that would puzzle us since they passed in 1987. Ashley covers the disappearance of former NCIS and Nuclear Regulatory Commission employee, Eugene Fish. 

Join us for episode 40! Ashley starts with the disappearance of Donamae Bayerl and the stellar concern by her husband, John. We cover a bittersweet headline, then Cody unravels the details of the unsolved murder of Lindsay Buziak, who met mysterious buyers for a million dollar home against her better judgement. 

Join us for episode 40! Ashley starts with the disappearance of Donamae Bayerl and the stellar concern by her husband, John. We cover a bittersweet headline, then Cody unravels the details of the unsolved murder of Lindsay Buziak, who met mysterious buyers for a million dollar home against her better judgement. 

Happy Halloween! This episode has both personal stories, several headlines, and even some horror movie discussion. Cody starts the episode by discussing the brutal and unsolved murder of James Adamski. After several headlines, Ashley tells the brief summary of the disappearance of Shaun Ritchie in Aberdeenshire, Scotland. 

Everyone be safe out there and have a great Halloween!

crow noise: Crow Call, Single, A.wav  by InspectorJ (www.jshaw.co.uk) of Freesound.org

In episode 38, Ashley starts us off with the case of Stephanie Lyn Crane, whose disappearance quite possibly ties in with the case of Amber Hoopes in episode 37. Our "Between the Cheeks" headline this week felt too close for comfort, and Cody details the case of Suzanne Nahuela Jovin, who had been left to die just outside her Yale University Campus. 

One of our most delirious episodes. Cody covers the murders of Steve Harkins, Ruth Cooper, Diana Robertson, and Mike Riemer. Multiple similarities tie the two separate cases together, one item being the most bizarre. Ashley covers a disappearance in "Idowa." In Idaho Falls, in 2001, a family begins the search for Amber Hoopes. 

Ashley and Cody visit the Garden of Eden, in a most unexpected manner. We delve into the disappearance of Alesha Brookshier. Plus an uplifting headline, and Cody's bananas Philadelphia "unsolved" murder of Tony 'Bananas.' 

We're back! Same podcast, same shitsticks. First, we delve into the the unsolved murder case of Susanne (not Susan) Lindholm from Helsinki, Finland. There may or may not be something about anal beads and chess, thanks to Cody. Ashley covers the disappearance of Tracey Leigh Gardner-Tetso, who went missing the same day she was meant to see a Motley Crue concert. She never made it to the venue.