July 28, 2025

Deserted Island Survival: 6 Teens Defied Odds for 15 Months | E 176

36 minutes

In this episode of the Crux True Survival Story Podcast, hosts Julie Henningsen and Kaycee McIntosh recount the astonishing real-life story of six teenage boys from Tonga who were stranded on a deserted island for 15 months in 1965. Contrary to the dark narrative of 'Lord of the Flies,' these boys formed a harmonious and organized mini-society, showcasing the best of human nature under harrowing conditions. The hosts dive deep into the boys' journey from near-death encounters and sheer survival to their eventual rescue by an Australian sea captain. Join us for this heartwarming tale of ingenuity, camaraderie, and the indomitable human spirit.

00:00 Welcome to the Crux True Survival Story Podcast

00:28 Introducing the Real-Life 'Lord of the Flies'

01:22 The Boys' Bold Plan to Sail to Fiji

06:44 Disaster Strikes: The Storm and Shipwreck

10:32 Surviving on Ata Island

13:07 Creating a New Society

16:25 The Boys' Ingenious Solutions

19:14 Losing Hope and the Community's Desperation

20:40 A Miraculous Survival

22:27 The Rescue by Peter Warner

28:19 The Boys' Homecoming

31:22 Life After the Island

34:06 The Story Goes Viral

39:45 Lessons from the Castaways

40:51 Closing Remarks and Call to Action

Listen AD FREE: Support our podcast at patreaon: http://patreon.com/TheCruxTrueSurvivalPodcast

Email us! [email protected]

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/thecruxpodcast/

Get schooled by Julie in outdoor wilderness medicine! https://www.headwatersfieldmedicine.com/

References

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tT1C4BSRzak

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHO_RlJxnVI

Wikipedia: "Tongan castaways"

VICE: "I Spent 15 Months Shipwrecked on an Uninhabited Island"

CBS News: "A real life Lord of the Flies: The 50-year-old story of a group of teens stranded on an island"

My Modern Met: "In 1965, Six Boys Were Stranded on a Deserted Island for 15 Months—and They All Survived"

RNZ: "The true story of six Tongan teenage castaways in 1965"

The Guardian (Rutger Bregman): "The 'real Lord of the Flies': a survivor's story of shipwreck and salvation"

Wikipedia: "Peter Warner"

Matangi Tonga: "'Ata and its archaeology"

Existing Films and Media

"The Castaways" (1966)

A Channel 7 television documentary/reenactment was filmed in October 1966, just after the boys were rescued. Peter Warner arranged with Channel 7 in Sydney to film their story and used £150 (USD $203) from the sale of the rights to compensate the stolen boat's owner. The Channel 7 television crew sailed with Warner and the boys back to ʻAta to film a re-enactment of their story, which was broadcast in October 1966. WikipediaDocastaway

One 16mm film copy of the 1966 documentary survives today and is available on YouTube. The Six Tongan Castaways of Ata Island | The Real Lord of the Flies

Documentary by Álvaro Cerezo (2020)

In 2015, Spanish explorer Álvaro Cerezo spent 10 days on ʻAta island with Kolo Fekitoa, one of the castaways (by then in his mid-60s). The two men lived there alone and survived on coconuts, fish, and seabirds, exactly as the boys did back in 1965. In summer 2020, Cerezo released a documentary of his experience with Kolo and a book detailing the 15-month ordeal of the castaways. The Six Tongan Castaways of Ata Island | The Real Lord of the Flies

CBS 60 Minutes Feature (2021)

CBS News produced a detailed segment about the story for 60 Minutes, featuring interviews with survivors Mano Totau and Sione Fataua, as well as Peter Warner.

Wikipedia: "Tongan castaways"

VICE: "I Spent 15 Months Shipwrecked on an Uninhabited Island"

CBS News: "A real life Lord of the Flies: The 50-year-old story of a group of teens stranded on an island"

My Modern Met: "In 1965, Six Boys Were Stranded on a Deserted Island for 15 Months—and They All Survived"

RNZ: "The true story of six Tongan teenage castaways in 1965"

The Guardian (Rutger Bregman): "The 'real Lord of the Flies': a survivor's story of shipwreck and salvation"

Wikipedia: "Peter Warner"

Matangi Tonga: "'Ata and its archaeology"

...more

View all episodes

By Kaycee McIntosh, Julie Henningsen, Bleav

3.8

375375 ratings

July 28, 2025

Deserted Island Survival: 6 Teens Defied Odds for 15 Months | E 176

36 minutes

00:00 Welcome to the Crux True Survival Story Podcast

00:28 Introducing the Real-Life 'Lord of the Flies'

01:22 The Boys' Bold Plan to Sail to Fiji

06:44 Disaster Strikes: The Storm and Shipwreck

10:32 Surviving on Ata Island

13:07 Creating a New Society

16:25 The Boys' Ingenious Solutions

19:14 Losing Hope and the Community's Desperation

20:40 A Miraculous Survival

22:27 The Rescue by Peter Warner

28:19 The Boys' Homecoming

31:22 Life After the Island

34:06 The Story Goes Viral

39:45 Lessons from the Castaways

40:51 Closing Remarks and Call to Action

Listen AD FREE: Support our podcast at patreaon: http://patreon.com/TheCruxTrueSurvivalPodcast

Email us! [email protected]

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/thecruxpodcast/

Get schooled by Julie in outdoor wilderness medicine! https://www.headwatersfieldmedicine.com/

References

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tT1C4BSRzak

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHO_RlJxnVI

Wikipedia: "Tongan castaways"

VICE: "I Spent 15 Months Shipwrecked on an Uninhabited Island"

CBS News: "A real life Lord of the Flies: The 50-year-old story of a group of teens stranded on an island"

My Modern Met: "In 1965, Six Boys Were Stranded on a Deserted Island for 15 Months—and They All Survived"

RNZ: "The true story of six Tongan teenage castaways in 1965"

The Guardian (Rutger Bregman): "The 'real Lord of the Flies': a survivor's story of shipwreck and salvation"

Wikipedia: "Peter Warner"

Matangi Tonga: "'Ata and its archaeology"

Existing Films and Media

"The Castaways" (1966)

One 16mm film copy of the 1966 documentary survives today and is available on YouTube. The Six Tongan Castaways of Ata Island | The Real Lord of the Flies

Documentary by Álvaro Cerezo (2020)

CBS 60 Minutes Feature (2021)

CBS News produced a detailed segment about the story for 60 Minutes, featuring interviews with survivors Mano Totau and Sione Fataua, as well as Peter Warner.

Wikipedia: "Tongan castaways"

VICE: "I Spent 15 Months Shipwrecked on an Uninhabited Island"

CBS News: "A real life Lord of the Flies: The 50-year-old story of a group of teens stranded on an island"

My Modern Met: "In 1965, Six Boys Were Stranded on a Deserted Island for 15 Months—and They All Survived"

RNZ: "The true story of six Tongan teenage castaways in 1965"

The Guardian (Rutger Bregman): "The 'real Lord of the Flies': a survivor's story of shipwreck and salvation"

Wikipedia: "Peter Warner"

Matangi Tonga: "'Ata and its archaeology"

...more