The five root causes of underperformance have nothing to do with laziness, attitude, or bad hiring — and in four out of five cases, the fix isn't a write-up. In this solo episode, Kerri Roberts walks through the root cause analysis you need to do before any performance conversation, how to set expectations that hold up legally, three feedback models for different situations, and the four-part performance rhythm that makes the annual review a confirmation instead of a surprise.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- Five root causes of underperformance — skill gap (training problem, not discipline); will gap (they know how but aren't doing it — the one that can lead to discipline); capacity overload (reprioritize, don't write up); role misalignment (wrong person or role evolved past them); and personal life interference (grace + clear timeline + EAP resources)
- Three defined markers every role needs — what does good look like, what does great look like, what does not meeting expectations look like; if employees don't know what winning looks like, they can't win; verbal expectations don't hold up in a wrongful termination case — document every step
- Four performance tiers — support task expert (accurate, timely, follows process); subject matter professional (problem-solving, initiative, expertise); management tier (team output, delegation, coaching); leadership tier (strategic alignment, cultural impact, revenue accountability); one-size-fits-all reviews fail
- Three feedback models — SBI: situation, behavior, impact; COIN: context, observation, impact, next step (Kerri's preferred — adds the committed action); Feed Forward: future-focused for employees who would be crushed by backward feedback
- Four-part performance rhythm — monthly one-on-ones (build trust; the reason you have no data for the annual review is because you skipped these); quarterly check-ins (accountability; start/stop/continue); optional biannual; annual (tiered, five-point Likert scale, attached to compensation); monthly = trust, quarterly = accountability, annual = documentation
CHAPTERS:
00:00 Performance Management Is Not About Reviews — It's About Clarity
00:44 You Probably Have Someone Underperforming Right Now
04:03 Most Performance Issues Are Systems Problems, Not People Problems
04:44 Three Defined Markers Every Role Needs
06:00 Four Performance Tiers
08:30 Set Expectations at Hiring, Reinforce in Onboarding
10:16 Diagnose the Root Cause Before You Write Anyone Up
11:00 GWC Framework From Traction by Gino Wickman
11:07 Root Cause 1 — Skill Gap (Training, Not Discipline)
12:13 Root Cause 2 — Will Gap (Motivation Issue)
12:39 Root Cause 3 — Capacity Overload
13:19 Root Cause 4 — Role Misalignment
13:27 The CFO Example — Promoted Beyond Skills
14:54 Only the Will Gap Leads to Discipline
15:52 Root Cause 5 — Personal Life Interference
18:58 The Diagnostic Conversation Framework
19:24 State Behavior and Impact — Then Ask Curious Questions
20:01 Most Managers Skip Curious and Go Straight to Dictator
21:13 Top Performers Are Watching — And They're Judging
22:38 Three Feedback Models
22:44 SBI — Situation, Behavior, Impact
24:59 COIN — Context, Observation, Impact, Next Step
25:56 Feed Forward — Future-Focused Feedback
28:10 The Four-Part Performance Rhythm
28:27 Monthly One-on-Ones — Build Trust
32:00 Quarterly Check-Ins — Start/Stop/Continue
33:17 Annual Review — Tiered, Formal, Tied to Compensation
34:52 Five-Point Rating Scale
37:49 Three Rating Biases — Leniency, Recency, Comparison
38:52 Calibration Meetings
39:35 Action Item — Schedule the Conversation With Your Underperformer Now
If your team is underperforming and you're not sure which root cause you're dealing with, the free HR Audit shows where your people foundation needs structure: saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
🎯 Take the free HR Audit — Score your HR systems in 5 minutes and see exactly where your gaps are.
👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
🎙️ Listen to Don't Waste the Chaos — The podcast for small business owners building strong people operations.
👉 kerrimroberts.com/podcast
📖 Get The HR Easy Button — Kerri's book on building HR systems that actually work for small businesses.
👉 https://amzn.to/4cPyrFh
✉️ Subscribe to the newsletter — Weekly HR insights for founders, in your inbox every Monday.
👉 saltandlight.myflodesk.com/saltandlightadvisors
—
Need fractional HR support or want to talk through a specific challenge?
👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/contact
Ready to build foundational HR systems on your own?
👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/hrfoundations
RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE:
- Traction by Gino Wickman — GWC framework
- HR Operating System course ($69) — saltandlightadvisors.com/hr-operating-system
- The HR Easy Button by Kerri Roberts — Amazon; amzn.to/4cPyrFh
- Free HR Audit — saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
📝 Full show notes + transcript: https://kerrimroberts.com/dontwastethechaos/5-root-causes-of-underperformance
Support the show