
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Send us Fan Mail
This week, we discuss Hannah Olson’s 2023 HBO docuseries, Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God, the story of Amy Carlson, a former McDonald’s manager and mother of three who abandoned her children, declared herself a 19-billion-year-old divine being, and with help from Robin Williams and Carrie Fisher, convinced a group of vulnerable people that she was Mother God.
Through interviews and livestream footage, the docuseries follows Amy’s transformation into Mother God, the revolving door of boyfriends known as Father God, and the increasingly disturbing behaviour of followers who surrendered their money and identities in pursuit of spiritual ascension. There are UFOs that are definitely clouds, an alarming number of dead celebrities dispensing cosmic wisdom, a shameful quesadilla, and décor choices reminiscent of a Lisa Frank Trapper Keeper. We discuss the similarities between Love Has Won and Heaven’s Gate, the role of conspiracy theories and the internet in recruiting followers, the horrors of 1990s diet culture, the dangers of unregulated wellness supplements, and why ingesting colloidal silver is a terrible idea unless turning permanently blue is your goal.
Spoiler Alert and Trigger Warning
We spoil Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God, and discuss childhood trauma, sexual abuse, rape, torture, domestic and psychological abuse, child neglect and abandonment, addiction, alcoholism, drug use, eating disorders, extreme weight loss, and of course, cults.
Spoiler alert!
This documentary also includes graphic footage of Amy Carlson's severely emaciated, blue and mummified body, including police body-camera footage of its discovery. Proceed with caution.
Recommendations
Palate Cleanser
Beach Too Sandy, Water Too Wet - Caroline has finally discovered this podcast, which features hilarious dramatic readings of ridiculous online reviews.
Homework
Next up: Midsommar, directed by Ari Aster.
We're continuing our exploration of cults with a horror film about vulnerability, belonging and the appeal of finding a new family when your world falls apart. Both Love has Won and Midsommar feature a Pele, and extreme releases of grief.
And get started reading and maybe watching Under the Banner of Heaven by Jon Krakauer. If you're planning to listen to the audiobook, consider borrowing it through Libby or supporting an independent bookshop through Libro.fm.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this Halloween episode of Drawn to Darkness, we're going back to where it all began with John Carpenter's iconic 1978 slasher Halloween. And we've brought along a special guest, Steve from Horror Makes Us Happy, to help us decide whether Michael Myers is still terrifying nearly 50 years later.
We discuss the birth of the modern slasher, Laurie Strode as the ultimate Final Girl, the rules of surviving a horror movie, and whether Michael Myers is more frightening with or without a motive. We also unpack the Boogeyman as a figure of social control, the sexual politics of horror, the representation of mental illness, suburban fears, incompetent authority figures, and Carpenter's simple score and slow-building dread. Along the way, we question the babysitting practices of 1970s teenagers, Dr. Loomis's psychiatric qualifications, how on earth Michael learned to drive and move impossibly heavy gravestones, and why nobody in Haddonfield seems particularly interested in helping a screaming teenage girl.
And, most importantly, if you stab a masked murderer, WHY WOULD YOU DROP THE KNIFE?
Content & Spoiler Warning:
Murder, stalking, stabbing, violence against teenagers, sexual activity and nudity, dog deaths, institutionalisation, stigmatising representations of mental illness, references to real-life serial killers, child sexual abuse, and discussions of violence and self-defence.
And, as always, we spoil Halloween (1978) completely, along with some discussion of its sequels and other horror films.
Palate Cleanser:
Caroline recommends Canadian Bacon, a surprisingly relevant comedy and the standout from her rainy-weekend movie marathon.
Recommendations:
Halloween H20: 20 Years Later - for Josh Hartnett's questionable haircut, Michelle Williams' pencil-thin eyebrows, and our favourite LL Cool J.
The Thing - Annie and Steve's favourite John Carpenter film, but please, leave the dogs alone John!
The Fog, Escape from New York and Big Trouble in Little China - more Carpenter classics.
What Went Wrong - the podcast episode about the making of Halloween, its shoestring budget, and how a low-budget independent film became a horror phenomenon.
Psycho – for mother daughter scream queens Jamie Lee Curtis and Janet Leigh.
Friday the 13th and A Nightmare on Elm Street, Alien, Scream, You’re Next, X, MaXXXine and Heretic for both classic and original takes on the final girl.
Men, Women, and Chainsaws by Carol J. Clover - for an academic exploration of gender, violence, and the Final Girl.
Morbid: Let's Boogie - The Boogeyman Around the World, Volume I - for folklore about the figures we invent to frighten children into behaving themselves.
I Am Legend by Richard Matheson - for a brilliant exploration of what happens when the monster turns out to be you. Read the book, because the adaptations miss the point!
Widow's Bay - for Boogeymen, Patricia's excellent survival instincts, and making sure the bad guy is actually dead.
Exhumed by Aaron Mahnke - for the Mercy Brown vampire panic, corpse medicine, and the strange things humans have believed about the dead.
Joseph Campbell's The Four Functions of Mythology - for why societies create and perpetuate myths, including the Boogeyman.
The Cask of Amontillado - for the five stages of grief, courtesy of Edgar Allan Poe.
Trading Places, A Fish Called Wanda, True Lies and Freaky Friday - for more Jamie Lee Curtis, and the vintage John Cleese Schweppes commercial - because Steve remembers it from the A Fish Called Wanda VHS, and apparently it has never left him.
Anything involving Christopher Guest, because apparently he and Jamie Lee Curtis are married! Always Best in Show.
Star Trek - because Michael Myers's terrifying white mask began life as a Captain Kirk mask.
Star Wars - for Christopher Lee, Peter Cushing, and Annie's childhood Jawa costume.
The Peanut Butter Solution - for neighbourhood houses that children are terrified of. Check out our guest appearance on Grave Tone Podcast.
Annabelle - because Laurie's Raggedy Ann doll reminded Annie of another unsettling doll.
When Harry Met Sally - because Harry is from Haddonfield, New Jersey, which is a good enough excuse to recommend a classic rom-com.
And, of course, Horror Makes Us Happy - Steve and Chris's podcast exploring the lives, experiences, and lifelong horror obsessions of horror creators. Check out Annie's September 2026 interview and their conversations with other horror writers and filmmakers.
Homework:
Watch Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God, the HBO documentary series about Amy Carlson and the extraordinary beliefs and practices of the Love Has Won cult. We're returning to the themes of motherhood, reincarnation, and spiritual belief from Incidents Around the House, only this time the horror is real. Caroline has watched a lot of true crime documentaries, and this might be the wildest one yet.
Don't forget. Cardio is key, trust your instincts, don't trap yourself in a closet, and if you've managed to stab the Boogeyman, FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, DON'T DROP THE KNIFE.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode of Drawn to Darkness, we dive into Josh Malerman’s shiver-inducing 2024 horror novel Incidents Around the House, a deeply unsettling story about a relentless entity known as ‘Other Mommy’ who asks again and again “Can I go into your heart?” In this episode, we unpack the child narrator, Bella and the effectiveness of horror seen through a child’s limited perspective, parental guilt, bad parenting decisions, the traumatising consequences of family secrets, infidelity, exorcisms, what exactly Other Mommy is, and how this book somehow manages to pull off an actual jump scare.
Content & Spoiler Warning:
Supernatural horror, demonic or paranormal entities, possession, a child in danger, stalking, death, infidelity, family secrets, references to sexual coercion and grooming, guilt and emotional manipulation, exorcism, religion, and references to real-life deaths associated with exorcisms.
There are dogs, but don’t worry. Nothing happens to them.
And, as always, we spoil Incidents Around the House completely.
Palate Cleanser:
Go see a band or artist you loved when you were younger, preferably with the friends you originally listened to them with (Caroline recently saw Salt-N-Pepa with her high school friends).
And we are both currently enjoying Dungeon Crawler Carl!
Recommendations:
For more Josh Malerman:
Bird Box - both the novel and the Sandra Bullock adaptation.
The Talking Scared and Horror Makes Us Happy interviews with Josh Malerman.
For creepy children, possession and things in the house:
Poltergeist
The Exorcist
The Exorcist TV series - for another persuasive supernatural entity that slowly reveals how monstrous it really is.
Hereditary — for things lurking in corners, possession, and family trauma
Midnight Mass, The Haunting of Hill House and The Haunting of Bly Manor – for long monologues (basically anything by Mike Flanagan).
Come Closer by Sara Gran - another unsettling exploration of demonic possession.
Gerald’s Game by Stephen King - for one of the only other books Annie can remember genuinely jump-scaring her.
For relentless supernatural threats and curses:
It Follows and The Ring
For creepy things pretending to be something safe:
The “Humans Can Lick Too” urban legend, which has probably permanently damaged several generations of children.
For difficult mothers and complicated families:
Devil in the Family: The Fall of Ruby Franke - especially because family members participated in the documentary.
Sins of Our Mother - about Lori Vallow, featuring her son Colby.
For women, motherhood and being allowed to be flawed human beings:
Greta Gerwig’s Barbie and Little Women
Random Connections:
Othello - no Drawn to Darkness episode is safe from Shakespeare!
Beetlejuice - because surely the supernatural world should come with some kind of instruction manual.
The Little Mermaid – Ursula knows to get your supernatural contracts in writing!
Inside Out - for Grandma Ruth’s idea that we decide which emotions and grudges we allow to take up permanent residence inside us.
Monsters Inc – for monsters in the closet, obviously.
Never Let Me Go - for children accepting deeply abnormal circumstances because they have never known anything else.
Now and Then - for parents who throw a lot of parties.
The Birdcage, The Birds, and Portlandia’s “Put a Bird on It,” solely because once Bird Box entered the conversation, we got silly about birds.
Disney’s Robin Hood - for vultures, who deserve better representation and are actually useful members of the ecosystem.
Homework:
Watch John Carpenter’s original 1978 Halloween. We’re doing a horror double header and heading back to where Michael Myers and Laurie Strode began, with relentless stalking, an inescapable presence, and the Boogeyman coming home.
Don’t forget. Communication is key, you can’t stab a demon, and don’t thin the veil. And if you are going to make a sandwich, take the extra two minutes and make a good sandwich.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
This week, we discuss Oxygen’s The Lady of the Dunes: Hunting a Cape Cod Serial Killer. For almost 50 years, the woman found brutally murdered in the dunes outside Provincetown in 1974 was known only as the Lady of the Dunes. Three generations of investigators became obsessed with giving her back her name, surviving lost evidence, institutional resistance, red herring suspects. Eventually, forensic genetic genealogy did what decades of traditional investigation could not: identified her as Ruth Marie Terry. And once Ruth had her name back, the mystery of who killed her became considerably less mysterious. Because, once again: it was probably the husband. We discuss his suspected crimes, his unhinged cookbook and why you don't want to marry a sociopath. We also focus on the detectives who wouldn't give up, like Meredith Lobur, whose determination to identify The Lady of the Dunes cost her her career.
There are plenty of detours along the way: Tony “Chop Chop” Costa, Hadden Clark, Whitey Bulger, a woman who apparently sawed her way out of prison and vanished forever, outrageously expensive 1970s dental work, a possible connection to Jaws, why you should never throw away cold-case evidence in the name of minimalism, and whether genetic genealogy is an incredible crime-solving tool and/or a dystopian privacy nightmare.
More than anything, though, this is a story about what it means to restore someone’s identity. Ruth Marie Terry spent almost five decades reduced to a nickname based on the place where her body was found. The documentary finally gives the story back to her, ending with the family, journalists and investigators gathering to remember the person behind the mystery.
Spoiler Alert and Trigger Warning:
In addition to spoiling the documentary and revealing the identity of both the Lady of the Dunes and her suspected killer, we discuss domestic violence, murder, disappearances, unidentified bodies, decomposition, dismemberment, decapitation, mutilation, sexual assault, abuse, child abuse, serial killers, missing children, suicide, wrongful convictions, homophobia, misogyny, racism and failures within law enforcement and the justice system.
The documentary repeatedly shows crime-scene images of Ruth Marie Terry’s body, and we discuss the extreme injuries inflicted on her, including damage to her skull and the removal of her hands.
Recommendations:
Palate Cleanser:
Billy Madison, Although it has aged as gracefully as you would expect from a 1990s Adam Sandler comedy, but Caroline's kid declared it the best movie he had ever seen.
Homework:
Next up: Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman.
The upcoming adaptation, Other Mommy, is on the way, so now is the time to meet Bela, Other Mommy and one of the creepiest imaginary friend horror novels ever. Warning: if you listen to the audiobook, you might struggle with the child narrator (or it might enhance the scares).
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode of Drawn to Darkness, we head to the foggy shores of Widow’s Bay with very special guest Liz Sower of Ghosts in the Burbs. This Emmy-winning Apple series follows widowed mayor Tom Loftus, who is determined to transform his economically struggling New England island into the next Martha’s Vineyard. Unfortunately, local fisherman Wick insists the island is cursed, Tom’s teenage son Evan is sassing him, and the town appears to be cursed as increasingly bizarre supernatural events suggest that Wick may be right.
We discuss why Widow’s Bay somehow manages to be spooky, hilarious and strangely cosy all at once; its wonderfully specific New England setting; and the enormous collection of horror influences lurking beneath the weathered shingles. There is Jaws, The Fog, The Shining, Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, haunted hotels, slashers, sea hags, creepy clowns, small-town folklore and possibly something Lovecraftian living beneath the island. We talk about the show’s strange relationship with time, anachronistic old televisions and video cameras, board games nobody should ever play and why this town feels simultaneously like somewhere you should absolutely flee and somewhere we would quite like to attend a cocktail party. Expect discussion of Evan’s teenage snark, Patricia’s party anxiety and status as the most sensible final girl in horror, and Ruth’s unexpectedly complicated place at the centre of the island’s history.
Content & Spoiler Warning:
This episode includes discussion of fraught father-son relationships, traumatic childbirth and pregnancy complications, suicide, a woman being committed to a mental asylum, being buried alive, accidental consumption of psychedelic drugs, vomiting, ritual sacrifice, supernatural violence, frightening clowns, haunted hotels, slashers, witchcraft and the various horrors associated with living on a cursed island.
And, of course, we spoil Widow’s Bay extensively, including the finale. Go watch it.
Palate Cleanser:
Caroline recommends Ted Lasso as part of that lovely category of heartwarming comedy that gives you a little faith in humanity and hopefulness.
Liz’s current happy place is Dungeon Crawler Carl, which involves aliens stripping Earth of its resources while the surviving humans are forced to compete in a televised reality-game-show-style dungeon crawl.
Recommendations:
Homework:
Keeping with the New England setting, we are moving into true crime with a three-part docuseries Lady of the Dunes about the longest cold case in Massachusetts history, which was solved very recently thanks to genetic genealogy (and has a Jaws connection)
Coming Up After That:
Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman. So start reading!
And remember: keep your taser charged, stick together, talk to each other, trust your gut, maybe stop keeping horrible family secrets, question suspicious self-help books, and stay out of the water.
Send us Fan Mail
This week, we swap fictional scientists playing God for a very real doctor doing harm as we dive into Dr. Death, the TV series based on the Wondery podcast about Christopher Duntsch, a Dallas neurosurgeon who, over roughly two years, operated on 38 people, maimed 33 and killed two. And no one stopped him.
Joshua Jackson trades Pacey Witter's charm for terrifying narcissism as Duntsch, who was charismatic but catastrophically bad at surgery. But the question hanging over the entire series is even more disturbing: was he unbelievably incompetent, or or a sociopath trying to do harm? Luckily, Christian Slater's cowboy-boot-wearing Dr Randy Kirby and Alec Baldwin's far more restrained Dr Robert Henderson become the medical world's answer to Brody and Hooper, one politely making phone calls while the other is looking for a scalpel to stop Duntsch from ever operating again.
We dig into Baylor Plano's letter that allowed him to move on, the Texas Medical Board's painfully slow response, the hierarchy that made nurses struggle to be heard over surgeons, tort reform that left victims with few avenues for compensation, and a healthcare system where hospitals are businesses and neurosurgeons are money. Duntsch may be the monster in the operating room, but a disturbing number of people and institutions helped keep the door open.
Spoiler Alert and Trigger Warning
In addition to spoiling the show, we discuss surgeries gone catastrophically wrong, blood, scalpels, bones being hammered and broken, severed nerves and spinal structures, paralysis, permanent disability, surgical equipment and materials being left inside patients, infected wounds, pus, death, domestic abuse, narcissistic and abusive behaviour, depression following life-changing injuries and the wider emotional impact on victims and their families. Some of the descriptions venture firmly into body-horror territory.
Recommendations
Palate Cleanser:
Caroline recommends jumping straight into Season Three of The Comeback for a surprisingly lovely story about a good person while also exploring AI's arrival in Hollywood.
Homework:
For our next episode, we're heading to Widow's Bay. There's a cranky doctor, a character using drugs to supposedly open his mind (giving Christopher-Duntsch-doing-“stem-cell-research”-while-high) and the series has received 19 Emmy nominations.
Even better, we'll be joined by Liz Sower from Ghosts in the Burbs.
And if you want to get ahead on future homework, start looking for Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman. The upcoming Other Mommy adaptation looks horrifying, and the book is scary enough to make nighttime trips to the bathroom a serious strategic decision.
As always, send us your recommendations for TV shows, podcasts, movies or books you'd like us to cover. Find us on Instagram, Facebook and Threads; like, subscribe and review us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify; or email us at [email protected]. Most importantly, tell a like-minded friend who is also drawn to darkness.
Until next time: research your doctors, listen to nurses, trust that bad vibe, take the trip, and never order a red wine milkshake.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode of Drawn to Darkness, we dive into Renny Harlin’s gloriously ridiculous, surprisingly good 1999 shark thriller, Deep Blue Sea. We talk genetically modified super-smart sharks, questionable science, the ethics of experimenting on animals, the film’s connections to Jaws and Jurassic Park and whether the sharks are actually the villains, or prisoners staging an elaborate escape from “Alcatraz for sharks”. Expect discussion of Samuel L. Jackson’s legendary mid-speech demise, Stellan Skarsgård’s extraordinarily no good very bad day, Thomas Jane’s unexplained shark-wrangling skills, whether Saffron Burrows deserved her fate, and Michael Rapaport’s unconvincing claim that he spent four years at Caltech. And let’s not forget about sharks who can read blueprints, recognise guns and cameras, predict mechanical failures, and operate ovens. Perhaps most importantly, we also celebrate LL Cool J’s lovable Preacher and his two-egg omelette philosophy.
Content & Spoiler Warning:
Severed limbs, bloody injuries, a character deliberately slicing open her palm, prolonged underwater sequences and breath-holding, claustrophobia, shark attacks, people being eaten, a parrot being eaten, animal experimentation and captivity, sharks being killed, including one being stabbed in the eye, and discussion of dementia and dying with dignity. And of course we will be spoiling Deep Blue Sea, including one of the movie’s most famous and shocking deaths. So go see it!
Palate Cleanser:
Hacks Season 5 (though trigger warning for anyone affected by terminal illness)
The TikTok empty chair trend: “When Netflix calls me for a documentary about…”
Sheep Detectives if you want to laugh, cry, and laugh so hard you cry.
Recommendations:
For More Deep Blue Sea and Shark Talk:
Deep Blue Sea: The Podcast -if one movie simply is not enough and you would like an hour of discussion for every few minutes of Deep Blue Sea.
Evolution of Horror has an episode on Deep Blue Sea.
How Did This Get Made? is a must listen to get the origin for Stellar Skateboard.
See Jurassic Right with Steven Ray Morris for episodes interviewing shark scientists
The Chris Hemsworth and Anthony Mackie shark documentaries on Disney, especially if you like the idea of Chris Hemsworth surfing and staring pensively at the Australian ocean.
Toys and Lip Sync Battle for Tom Holland performing “Umbrella” for more LL Cool J.
Andor and Good Will Hunting because of Stellen Skarsgard
The Mist, The Punisher, and Arrested Development for more Thomas Jayne.
You Season 3 – the best season stars Saffron Burrows.
The Island of Sea Women by Lisa See - historical fiction about the matriarchal society of Korean divers who can really hold their breath for a long time
The Exorcist – for crucifix clutching
For Survival, Disaster & Nature Trying to Kill You:
Yellowjackets
Alive
The Perfect Storm
Titanic
The Poseidon Adventure
The Rich Man’s House
FantasticLand
Stranded by Nikki Shannon Smith - a middle-grade survival novel about a Black girl from New York who loves nature despite pushback from her family and friends.
Chef and The Bear – for Chefs
Homework:
In keeping with the episode’s themes of neuroscience and science crossing ethical boundaries, the next discussion will focus Season 1 of Dr. Death, the TV miniseries starring Joshua Jackson, Christian Slater and Alec Baldwin.
And remember: Don’t genetically modify apex predators to make them smarter. Don’t stand too close to the edge of a shark tank. Don’t dangle your feet in shark-infested water. Don’t slice open your palm when you need blood.And, most importantly, do not put milk in your omelette.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode, we enter the unsettling world of Radio Rental, the horror anthology podcast that presents supposedly true encounters through the fictional setting of a video rental store. Presiding over the tapes is Terry Carnation, played by Rainn Wilson who breaks up stories of serial killers, possible stalkers, doppelgängers, disturbing childhood memories and glitches in reality with comments on rewinding tapes, Jane Fonda workouts and Hot Sauce for Tots. We cover Volume One, episodes one through seven, examining why stories such as “404 Not Found”, “Laura of the Woods” and “The Babysitter” linger long after they end. Along the way, we discuss unreliable narrators, the fallibility of memory, the Mandela Effect, simulation theory and why unresolved dread is often more frightening than seeing the monster itself. We also examine the privilege involved in responding to strange encounters with curiosity rather than caution, particularly when several of the male storytellers ignore warning signs that many women are conditioned to recognise immediately.
Content and Spoiler Warning
Discussion of serial killers and their victims, stalking, being stalked, followed, and watched, terrorism, child death, grief, possible abduction or organ harvesting, homophobia, threatened hate crimes, murder, unreliable memories, doppelgängers and an existential discussion of simulation theory. We also spoil the major stories Radio Rental Volume One, season 1 and discuss plot details from several horror films, television series and books.
Palate Cleanser
Desperately Ever After by Laura Kenyon, a comic novel imagining the lives of familiar fairy-tale heroines after their supposed happy endings. Think princesses, friendship problems, romantic chaos, sleepovers and Desperate Housewives or Sex and the City energy.
Recommendations
As Terry Carnation reminds us: trust your paranoia. Dread can be a powerful intuitive tool.
Homework
The attempted plane bombing in Radio Rental ties in to Snakes on a Plane with Samuel L. Jackson, who stars in Deep Blue Sea. So that's what we're covering! Prepare yourself for smarter sharks, questionable science and LL Cool J’s omelette recipe.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for the podcast cover art. Find her on Instagram at @nancyazano.
Thanks also to Harry Kidd for the opening and closing music. Find him on Instagram at @harryjkidd and on Spotify.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode of Drawn to Darkness, we continue our accidental-but-now-definitely-intentional basement series with Scott Derrickson’s 2021 supernatural horror-thriller The Black Phone, based on the Joe Hill short story. We unpack the film’s very Stephen “Kingian” mix of coming-of-age trauma, small-town fear, ghostly intervention, and very bad decisions approaching weirdos in windowless vans. We discuss Finney and Gwen’s bond, the horror already inside their home, the 1970s stranger-danger atmosphere, Ethan Hawke’s deeply unsettling performance as The Grabber, and why the film works so well by leaving some of its worst horrors implied rather than shown. We also talk about how clever this film is in the way the many failed escape attempts become useful later, and why every clue in this basement escape room matters.
Content & Spoiler Warning:
This episode includes discussion of child abduction, family violence, alcoholism, bullying, physical violence involving children and teenagers, murder, grief, suicide references, ghosts, confinement, implied harm to children, and frightening basement imagery. We also discuss domestic abuse and substance use in a way that recognises the harm caused without reducing those issues to simple villainy or suggesting that one dramatic event can magically “fix” addiction. And of course, we spoil The Black Phone.
Palate Cleanser:
For sports fans, keep hope alive. Sometimes the Knicks win, sometimes Lewis Hamilton wins his first race with Ferrari, sometimes Queensland wins State of Origin, and sometimes your team actually gives you a reason to believe in something other than dread, basements and serial killers.
Also, go back and watch The Hills or The Soup for a dose of early-2000s pop culture chaos.
And for something more meaningful, read “Millions of Women Are Left Out of Menopause’s Moment” from The New York Times, written by a friend of Caroline’s.
Recommendations:
For more Ethan Hawke:
Reality Bites
Sinister
The Purge
Before Sunrise, Before Sunset and Before Midnight
Dead Poets Society
Gattaca
Boyhood
For more Scott Derrickson horror:
The Exorcism of Emily Rose
Sinister
Black Phone 2 - not as clean or strong as the first film, but still worth a watch if you want more of Ethan Hawke as the Grabber.
For more basement horror, kids with powers, and “beneath the surface” dread:
See our earlier episodes on Mindhunter, The Silence of the Lambs, Penpal by Dathan Auerbach, The Devil in the White City, The Cask of Amontillado, The Sixth Sense, and Stranger Things.
We haven’t covered these yet (all on the list), but they fit the theme:
The Babadook
The Orphanage
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
The Shining
It
Toy Story 4 — yes, somehow, for the creepy doll energy.
For coming-of-age survival stories with Stephen King or Spielberg energy:
Stand by Me
E.T.
The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon by Stephen King
Boy Swallows Universe — novel or Netflix series, with bonus Brisbane connection.
For more true crime and profiling connections:
Dateline’s “True Confession” episode on the Angie Dodge case
Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart
The Witness
Cases connected to John Wayne Gacy, Jacob Wetterling, Etan Patz, and the Rochester Alphabet Murders (trigger warning: these are real cases involving children).
Random Connections:
Home Alone for basement fear and sprinting up the stairs like something is behind you.
Dazed and Confused for the 1970s atmosphere and very punchable bullies..
Return to Oz and The Secret of NIMH for childhood films that had no business being as scary as they were.
The Wire for a more grounded depiction of substance use and recovery.
Homework:
Listen to Radio Rental, Volume One (episodes 1-6). We are moving from supernatural basement phones and 1970s child abduction into true creepy stories, eerie encounters and the kind of “this happened to a friend of a friend” dread that makes you check your locks twice.
And remember: do not approach the black van. Do not help the magician with his groceries. Do not go to the second location. And if a disconnected phone starts ringing in a murder basement, answer it.
Send us Fan Mail
In this episode of Drawn to Darkness, we examine David Fincher’s tragically incomplete Netflix series Mindhunter. Set in the late 1970s, the show follows FBI agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench, along with Dr Wendy Carr, as they begin interviewing imprisoned serial offenders in an attempt to understand patterns of behaviour, develop the science of criminal profiling, and prevent future violence. We discuss why Mindhunter remains one of the most frustrating cancellations in television history, how the show turns conversations into scenes of dread, and why its slow-burn tension is more unsettling than most on-screen violence. We also unpack our feelings on Holden (is he a narcissist?) the 1970s period details, the sickly yellow lighting, the motel rooms, the click of Dr. Carr’s heels, the Quantico basement, the rise of true crime culture, and the difficult question at the centre of the series: what happens to the people who spend their lives studying human cruelty?
Content & Spoiler Warning:
This episode includes discussion of serial murder, sexual violence, violence against children, child abduction, domestic abuse, coercive control, suicide, animal death, misogyny, stalking, racism, institutional failure, abusive parenting, trauma, and the psychological impact of investigating violent crime. We also discuss real crimes and real victims throughout the episode, including the Atlanta Child Murders, Ed Kemper, the Son of Sam, and other historical cases. And of course, we spoil both seasons of Mindhunter.
Palate Cleanser:
For something lighter after all that behavioural science and basement dread: The MCU, especially if you want a long, familiar, superhero-heavy reset. Also rewatching Stranger Things with someone who has not seen it before, because introducing people to things you love remains one of life’s great joys.
Recommendations:
Homework:
Watch The Black Phone.
We are continuing the basement series with Scott Derrickson’s 2021 supernatural horror-thriller, based on the Joe Hill short story. It is set in the 1970s, stars Ethan Hawke, and follows a child abducted by a masked killer and trapped in a basement with a disconnected phone that may not be as disconnected as it seems.
And remember, stay away from the Pacific Northwest (joking), don't hitchhike, store your glasses upside down to avoid dust, and don't trust strangers with record deals and modelling contracts.
Special thanks to Nancy Azano for our cover art (Instagram: @nancyazano) and Harry Kidd for our music (Instagram: @harryjkidd, Spotify).
From the publisher's feed
Do your friends think you're weird because you rattle off facts about serials killers and watch horror movies to relax? We're here for you! Drawn to Darkness is a biweekly podcast where two best…
Our cover art is by Nancy Azano. You can find her work on instagram @nancyazano.
Our intro and outro music is by Harry Kidd. Check him out on instagram @HarryJKidd.