Finish Lines and Milestones

Episode 166: Peter Merante - Gritty, Not Pretty


Listen Later

Peter Merante ⁠and I first officially met in person at the 2025 Carmel Marathon Expo. Since then, I've run into him on the Monon Trail, at local races, and at ⁠Athletic Annex⁠, where he's worked for three-plus years.

During this episode, sponsored by ⁠Goodr⁠ and ⁠HUUG⁠, we talk about:

  • Growing up in Cold Spring, New York — a Hudson Valley town of 3,500 people right across the Hudson River from West Point
  • Being born in Japan and how his Japanese mother made every effort to acclimate to American life — and why he took Japanese in college as a way of honoring her
  • How he discovered running about 20 years ago, dropped 40-plus pounds doing it, and eventually worked his way through Couch to 5K on an original iPod
  • His one and only marathon — Monumental 2013, just under five hours
  • ⁠Back on My Feet⁠ — a national nonprofit that uses movement to help people experiencing homelessness become independent and self-sufficient — and his years volunteering with the Indianapolis chapter at Wheeler Mission and Progress House
  • The equalizing power of running side by side — and the heartbreak of losing members along the way
  • Running the Selma to Montgomery route (~40 miles from the Edmund Pettus Bridge to the state capital in Alabama)
  • Hood to Coast and a Colorado Ragnar — both fundraisers for Back on My Feet — including a 2 AM leg that had him briefly convinced a train was a UFO, and a van-decorating situation that required polishing compound and a coin-op car wash
  • 31 half marathons, five relays, one full, and one eight-hour endurance race
  • Three-plus years at ⁠Athletic Annex⁠ in Fishers and a deep dive into running shoe foam technology (ATPU, PEBA, dual-density, etc.)
  • His dream of a "Parks and Rec"-style run specialty TV show
  • June being Men's Mental Health Month — and his experience with individual therapy, couples therapy, and ADHD testing (including a surprise: he's Mensa eligible)
  • Being an internal processor and what identifying that has meant for his relationships
  • His mantra: Gritty, Not Pretty — and the song he wants removed from all race playlists
  • His next finish line: the CNO Indianapolis Monumental Half Marathon, an entry he won in a social media contest

Previous Guests Mentioned

  • ⁠Maury Plambeck⁠⁠ - Episode 105
  • ⁠Jim Patton⁠⁠ - Episode 71
  • ⁠Timmy Howard⁠⁠ - Episode 54
  • ⁠Wes Doty⁠⁠ - Episode 79
  • ⁠Jason Noel⁠⁠ - Episode 62
  • ⁠Jennifer Conner⁠⁠ - Episode 57
  • ⁠Lindsey Hein⁠⁠ - Episode 100
  • ⁠Eileen Poore⁠⁠ - Episode 17

Sponsor Details

  • ⁠Goodr⁠ - Use ALLYB for $10 off
  • ⁠HUUG⁠ - Use ALLYB for 15% off

Other Links

  • Follow me on Instagram ⁠@allytbrett_runs⁠
  • ⁠Subscribe to Finish Lines & Milestones weekly newsletter⁠

This is a ⁠SandyBoy Productions⁠ podcast.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Finish Lines and MilestonesBy SandyBoy Productions

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

40 ratings


More shows like Finish Lines and Milestones

View all
Marathon Training Academy by Angie and Trevor

Marathon Training Academy

1,504 Listeners

I'll Have Another with Lindsey Hein Podcast by SandyBoy Productions

I'll Have Another with Lindsey Hein Podcast

2,047 Listeners

The Strength Running Podcast by Jason Fitzgerald

The Strength Running Podcast

1,343 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

111,948 Listeners

Ali on the Run Show by Ali Feller

Ali on the Run Show

4,131 Listeners

The CITIUS MAG Podcast | A Running + Track and Field Show by CITIUS MAG

The CITIUS MAG Podcast | A Running + Track and Field Show

1,833 Listeners

Road to the Trials by Peter Bromka, Lindsey Hein, and Matt Chittim

Road to the Trials

180 Listeners

SmartLess by Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett

SmartLess

58,066 Listeners

The Drop by Believe in the Run

The Drop

379 Listeners

Giggly Squad by Hannah Berner & Paige DeSorbo

Giggly Squad

15,472 Listeners

Fuel for the Sole by Fuel for the Sole

Fuel for the Sole

14 Listeners

The Mel Robbins Podcast by Mel Robbins

The Mel Robbins Podcast

19,524 Listeners

Nobody Asked Us with Des & Kara by Des Linden and Kara Goucher

Nobody Asked Us with Des & Kara

1,783 Listeners

Tread Lightly Running Podcast by Amanda Brooks and Laura Norris

Tread Lightly Running Podcast

365 Listeners

Relay by Relay

Relay

126 Listeners