Evan & Tiki

Giants fan asks the big question: should Big Blue consider trading back from No. 5 to pick up extra capital, especially without a third-round pick? The guys debate whether the smarter move is accumulating assets or staying put for an immediate-impact defender. If the right Ohio State defensive stud is there, do you just make the pick and move on?

The conversation also touches on how players are remembered, from Rob Gronkowski and his Buccaneers stint to legacy debates that shape how fans view careers.

Then it gets deeper into front office strategy. If a team truly believes it has found its franchise quarterback, is there any price that changes its mind? The crew breaks down draft value charts, negotiating leverage, and what an “overpay” really means when you are convinced a quarterback can transform your franchise. Would the Jets have to offer multiple first-rounders to move up, and would it even matter if the Raiders are sold on their guy?

It is a wide-ranging football hour that blends draft logic, fan emotion, and the chess match behind the scenes.

Spring training opens with good news for the New York Yankees. Everyone is healthy, no surprise injuries, and Aaron Boone confirms the roster is ready to go. So why is there outrage on Day One?

The debate explodes when Brian Cashman arrives in a hoodie, trucker hat, and backpack. What starts as jokes about his Starbucks order turns into a full-blown argument about professionalism, comfort, and whether the Yankees’ longtime GM has grown too comfortable in his role.

Is criticizing Cashman’s outfit fair, or does it distract from real issues like roster construction and accountability? Fans call in, tempers flare, and the show wrestles with what Yankees standards are supposed to look like in 2026.

the guys break down a Knicks loss that “won’t ruin the season,” but absolutely cannot happen against a bad, tanking opponent. They debate Jalen Brunson’s late-game hero ball, the missed Landry Shamet look that almost stole it, and how the Knicks left everything on the floor just to go scoreless for long stretches in overtime.

Then the NBA drops the punishments from the Pistons-Hornets brawl, headlined by Isaiah Stewart’s seven-game suspension, plus penalties for Miles Bridges and Jalen Duren. The key question: how does this impact the Knicks when Detroit comes out of the All-Star break, and why does it suddenly matter for seeding?

Finally, the hour turns into Jets draft chaos as Evan breaks down clips from new Raiders head coach Clint Kubiak and owner Mark Davis that hint at what Las Vegas wants to do with the No. 1 overall pick and QB Fernando Mendoza. The guys debate whether the door is even slightly open for a trade, how Todd McShay’s take on the 2026 vs 2027 draft changes the math, and why the Jets’ pile of 2027 picks makes this a rare “perfect storm” scenario. Plus, the Derek Carr breadcrumbs keep piling up.

The discussion opens with how MLB teams handle injury timelines and expectations. David Stearns insists the Mets expect Francisco Lindor to be ready for Opening Day, while other organizations take a much more conservative approach. The guys compare Lindor’s situation to Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holliday, whose season will start late after surgery, with Orioles GM Mike Elias flatly ruling him out for Opening Day. Is this honesty, gamesmanship, or simply different philosophies on setting expectations?

From there, the conversation shifts to the Knicks and the growing backlash against Karl-Anthony Towns. Why has he become the ultimate lightning rod, and why did even the MSG broadcast turn on him? With pointed criticism from Mike Breen and Clyde Frazier, the segment breaks down the nonstop complaining, bad fouls, and whether Towns needs to play more physically to change the narrative.

With Francisco Lindor’s hamate bone injury looming, the show pivots to the sudden wave of baseball injury news around the league, including Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holliday also dealing with hamate issues. The guys explain why this injury can be deceptively tricky, why power can take longer to return even after the “six week” timeline, and why Yankee fans are bracing for the next bad spring training update when Boone and Cashman meet the media.

They also revisit the original “three big stories” debate, weigh Soto’s move to left field against Lindor’s injury as the most important headline, and take early calls from fans on what the Mets should do if Lindor is not ready.

Then the conversation swings back to the Knicks, breaking down the overtime loss to Indiana, Karl-Anthony Towns disappearing, Brunson forcing it late, and the accusation that Rick Carlisle coached like he was trying to lose.

Three major stories broke after the show ended, but the conversation quickly zeroes in on the most polarizing one. Evan and Tiki debate Juan Soto’s move from right field to left field, why it actually makes sense at Citi Field, and why the timing and explanation from the Mets still feels strange.

The discussion digs into Soto’s defensive history, his split time between left and right field throughout his career, and whether the World Baseball Classic played a bigger role than the team wants to admit. Plus, questions about roster construction, fan reaction, and why this move was obvious to some long before it became official, even if it still feels awkward the way it rolled out.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): In this offseason we've seen the roster completely turn over. Fan favorites have left the building like Brandon Nimmo, Edwin Diaz and Pete Alonso. The replacements of Bo Bichette, Marcus Semien, Jorge Polanco, Luis Robert Jr. and Freddy Peralta are here. The question isn't if we like what David Stearns did. The question is "Are the Mets better?". Well, are they?

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Jets get a couple of intriguing quarterback options on the market. Spring Training gets set to start.

Is the next big football story in New York already here? The guys explain why the Giants feel “done” for now, while the Jets are just getting started with Aaron Glenn back, Frank Reich running the offense, and a full QB room rebuild ahead.

Then the conversation turns into a full-on Derek Carr deep dive after a real report says he is considering a comeback and he is throwing with zero shoulder limitations. Is Carr the perfect bridge for the Jets, or could he actually be more than a one year stopgap?

Plus, the crew weighs Carr vs Kirk Cousins, why Carr’s year away might be a huge benefit, what options truly exist for the Jets, and why Carr’s own words might be the biggest clue about where he wants to land.

On this segment of Evan & Tiki, the guys dive into the latest reports from Adam Schefter regarding potential NFL rule changes. Evan and Tiki debate the pros and cons of allowing teams to trade draft picks up to five years in advance and whether the league should finally replace the onside kick with a 4th-and-13 play from the 25-yard line.

Then, the show goes off the rails when a caller claims Patriots QB Drake Maye is already "leaps and bounds" better than Eli Manning after just two seasons. Evan loses his cool, defending Eli’s clutch legacy against what he calls "stat-padding" from the Patriots' young star.

Also in this hour:

St. John's Expectations: With the Johnnies sitting at 19-5, is it "Elite Eight or Bust" for Rick Pitino?

Posting and Toasting: The crew plays their favorite tweet game, featuring debates on parallel parking skills and Al Dukes’ bizarre requirements for watching Olympic swimming.

The Return of Adam Gase: Reaction to the news that the former Jets head coach is back in the league working with Justin Herbert—and why the framing of his resume drove Evan crazy.