Evan & Tiki

From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): The Run It Back ‘26 puzzle added another piece when the Yankees re-signed 1B Paul Goldschmidt. Is Brian Cashman actually right about this team?

Also, is it a possibility that Jasson Dominguez starts the season in AAA?

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Everyone called Super Bowl 60 boring, but Evan and Tiki explain why watching the Patriots get embarrassed by the Seahawks was actually a thrill ride. The guys break down the game, including Drake Maye’s playoff struggles, the dominance of Kenneth Walker, and the irony of Sam Darnold getting a ring.

Later, the show goes off the rails regarding a broadcast moment that enraged Jets fans: Mike Tirico calling Adam Sandler a Patriots fan "as per usual." They debate who is more at fault Tirico for the lazy research, or Sandler for wearing a hat with the Patriots logo on it.

The guys break down the most baffling coaching decision of the Super Bowl and celebrate a massive weekend for New York sports.

Topics discussed include:

The 2-Point Conversion Debate: Why Mike Vrabel’s decision to kick the extra point down 19-6 made absolutely no sense to the crew.

Drake Maye "Seeing Ghosts": Reacting to the rookie quarterback’s struggles against the dominant Seahawks defense, now dubbed "The Dark Side."

Knicks > Celtics: The guys gloat about the Knicks' blowout win in Boston and roast the Celtics' excuse that the "start time was too early."

Halftime Show Reviews: Was Bad Bunny’s performance a hit or a miss? Plus, the crew makes their long-term predictions for next year’s performer.

Sandler & Tirico: A quick reaction to Mike Tirico confusing Adam Sandler’s fandom during the broadcast.

In this post-Super Bowl breakdown, the guys dive into the "unprecedented" nature of a game where the kicker was the MVP favorite for three and a half quarters. Evan is forced to face the music (and wear a literal "L") after a year-old take on Super Bowl champion Sam Darnold comes back to haunt him. Plus, the crew ranks their favorite (and least favorite) commercials—including a heated debate over a patriotic Pegasus—and discusses the sheer audacity of Jordan Hudson’s "Orchids of Asia" t-shirt.

Was it a defensive masterclass or just a boring dud? And why is Tony Gonzalez wearing a Falcons jersey in a prostate cancer commercial? We’re getting to the bottom of it all.

In the final hour of the show, Evan, Tiki, and Sean look ahead to next year by predicting the matchup for Super Bowl 61 in Los Angeles. The guys break down the current betting odds, debate whether the Baltimore Ravens are the team to beat in the AFC, and discuss if the Washington Commanders or Dallas Cowboys are legitimate NFC contenders. Plus, the crew reacts to the shocking news of Adam Gase returning to the NFL with the Los Angeles Chargers and tackles the "controversy" surrounding Mets pitcher Luke Weaver showing up to Spring Training with a Yankees bag.

Super Bowl 60 is in the books, and Adam Sandler may be the only controversial thing to have come out of the game.

Evan and Tiki debate who the Super Bowl champion Seahawks will host to kick off the 2026 NFL season. With the Rams and 49ers heading to Australia, the guys analyze the remaining options including the Chiefs, Chargers, and Bears and argue whether the John Harbaugh led Giants are ready for the prime-time spotlight. Plus, the crew discusses the lack of cold-weather Super Bowls and Tiki sets his price tag for the Jets to acquire Mac Jones.

Evan and Tiki rank their top 5 Super Bowl commercials, debating the merits of humor versus heart—including a heated argument about the Clydesdales versus Ben Stiller's "slapstick" moment. The guys also discuss the "Orchids of Asia" t-shirt worn by Bill Belichick's girlfriend, Jordan Hudson, and whether it crossed a line in trolling Robert Kraft. Plus, a look at the confusing new MLB streaming paywall, a nostalgic trip through 80s movies like Real Genius and Weird Science, and why Tony Gonzalez in a Falcons uniform just felt wrong.

Evan and Tiki debate whether Seahawks kicker Jason Myers deserved the Super Bowl MVP over Kenneth Walker given the unique, low-scoring nature of the game. The guys discuss the historical rarity of a Super Bowl MVP potentially leaving in free agency and fact-check if it has ever happened before. Later, the crew reacts to Sam Darnold winning a championship after years of criticism, debates the nostalgia of Blockbuster Video versus Amazon rentals, and discusses if K-Pop is the future of the Halftime Show.

The conversation spirals from unforgettable Super Bowl halftime shows to the ones nobody remembers, with everything from Dre and Snoop to dancing sharks and post 9/11 U2. The crew debates whether comedy belongs at halftime, why vulgar humor usually lands the hardest, and how easily people get offended during the biggest TV event of the year. Bad Bunny’s lyrics spark a surprisingly awkward moment, leading into a larger discussion about shock value, culture, and where the NFL draws the line. The segment wraps with bold, way-too-early predictions for next year’s halftime performer, including Miley Cyrus, Beyoncé, Jelly Roll, and a few wild cards, plus classic sports radio detours that only make the debate better.