On the night of August 20, 1989, brothers Lyle and Erik Menendez committed a crime that would send shockwaves through the American public—a double homicide that was as brutal as it was inexplicable. In this episode, we examine the chilling events surrounding the murders of their wealthy parents, José and Kitty Menendez, inside their Beverly Hills home.

With a staggering level of violence, José was shot multiple times in the back while sitting on the couch, and Kitty was gunned down as she attempted to escape. Yet, it wasn’t just the grisly nature of the crime that made headlines—it was the shocking reactions of the brothers in the hours and days that followed.

Rather than fleeing or showing immediate signs of distress, Lyle and Erik’s behavior seemed remarkably unphased. Lyle’s frantic 911 call, his attempt to play the role of a devastated son, contrasted with Erik’s seemingly detached demeanor. The brothers gave conflicting statements to police, and their actions—going on shopping sprees, taking a trip to the movies, and even laughing with friends in the days after the murders—left many wondering: were they truly in shock, or was there something darker at play? In this episode, we explore the initial aftermath of the murders.

Support the show

Disclaimer: Jeannine and Natalie are commentators on publicly sourced information. Any case information and opinions are based on records in the public domain and are purely speculative in nature. Their comments are not meant to diagnose or treat any condition for listeners, and they are not functioning as licensed therapists providing services on the show. Any information shared based on general client experiences is coincidental and not meant to identify current or past clients. If you or someone you love is having a mental health crisis, please contact 911 or the National Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988.