Welcome back to First Impression, our brand-new Girls Gone Hallmark series where we’re revisiting pilot episodes - sometimes Hallmark, sometimes just Hallmark-adjacent - and giving you our hot takes. This week, Megan and Wendy dive into Carter, the Canadian mystery-comedy starring Jerry O’Connell. From cast chemistry and quirky clues to whether this lighthearted procedural passes the all-important Hallmark Test, here’s our First Impression: Carter.