This week, Jason and Dee of the Surely You Can’t Be Serious podcast turn their attention to one of the most successful and drama-filled bands in rock history: Fleetwood Mac and their legendary album Rumours.

Serving as the perfect companion piece to their recent discussion of Hotel California by Eagles, the guys break down every unforgettable track from Rumours—exploring the stories behind the songs, the emotional performances, and the timeless appeal that helped make the album one of the biggest sellers of all time.

Along the way, Jason and Dee dive deep into the complicated history of Fleetwood Mac, discussing the relationships, breakups, betrayals, and personal chaos happening inside the band while these songs were being written and recorded. Somehow, out of heartbreak, tension, and emotional exhaustion came an album packed with some of the most iconic songs ever recorded.

From “Go Your Own Way” and “Dreams” to “The Chain” and “Don’t Stop,” the guys examine how deeply personal experiences became universal anthems that still resonate decades later.And after spending time with both albums, Jason and Dee finally deliver their ultimate verdict in this classic matchup: Rumours vs. Hotel California. Which album truly deserves the crown?

You’ll have to tune in to hear the final judgment.