Meredith and Ricky begin to wonder if they're being played as they watch this episode go down. Carrie's friend-o-meter sinks to an all-time low as she subjects her friends and her audience to her rants about Mr. Big, Samantha dates a sports fanatic, and Charlotte basically is just present. But there were some high points, such as Jon Bon Jovi and his incredibly petite body, milky skin and perfect nipples, plenty of walking and acting scenes, and summer-in-the-city looks galore.

Join us as we wonder: do we choose the wrong episodes to watch? Rewind with us and listen along. And join the conversation on Instagram!