
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


I just finnished Jonathan Haidts The Anxious Generation and to properly review it and explain, why this is also a somewhat personal book to me, i have to explain were i'm coming from. This is gonna be a long one, and if you want a short gist and move on: I think Haidt's book is a timely call to action, i largely agree with his analysis, but wish it was more in depth and i think he misses a big piece of the puzzle. It is this missing piece i mostly write about here.
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
Shine the headlight, straight into my eye
Like the roadkill, I'm paralysed
(Placebo, Teenage Angst)
It was around 2012 when i noticed that things were off. By then, i already gained some extensive insights on virality. I'm online since the mid 90s, and contributing to the web since i started my own blog in 2005, which became a german mainstay for webculture soon. In 2008, i had a first "viral hit", with a simple phrase lifted from a political poster, which became a national sensation and inspired dozens of flashmobs disrupting political events during the election year, so much so that at one point, Angela Merkel had to adress to "young people in the back to shut up". It inspired songs and books and I went on national TV (you can see my 15 years younger self in this clip at 1:50) to explain what is happening. That was a time when politicians barely could spell the word "browser" and we were baffled and blown away by the outcomes of spontaneous online movements. Years later the fine folks at 4chan invented the word "Meme Magic" to describe such things, when things going viral "transcend the realm of cyberspace and result in real life consequences".
With the beginning of the 2010s and social media finally making it's mainstream breakthrough, things started to change. By then, Buzzfeed established a new publishing practice: Serving all kinds of identities with cheap fast fluff and listicles — a factory for identities —, and combining that with only vague, non-informative headlines: Clickbait was born, and perfected in the years that followed by media outlets like Upworthy. The ur-mainstream-viralbomb Kony 2012 showed that you can direct whole masses of digitally networked people with emotionalizing, simplistic, semi-political content that outrages them, with a big portion of those people being young adults and teens.
Virality on early Social Media had reached a tipping point, where people on social media increasingly selected for emotionality and outrage, and it became clear to me that this new media environment of personalized writing and blogging, "citizen journalism" and social media held more manipulative power than anything we've seen before. I became interested in virality itself, memetics, the dynamics of swarm behavior, and wrote about the psychological underpinnings of webculture ever since.
Then, the abomination of Gamergate blew up the internet and created the culture wars, 4chan supposedly "memed Trump into the White House", and thousands of webculture experts, including me, were scratching their heads and wrote thinkpiece after thinkpiece about what the hell is going on — all while the mental health of kids deteriorated.
The Anxious GenerationJonathan Haidts book, like the title and its byline "How the great rewiring of childhood is causing an epidemic of mental illness" suggest, revolves around the effects that these developments — the social media revolution in tandem with helicopter parenting focussing on safety —, had on the psychology specifically of kids. It's the first of a Haidt-socmed-doublewhammy, with the next book coming out next year revolving around the psychological effects of social media on democracy and institutions. (To be fair: That one will be much closer to my interests, but these developments have overlaps and common causes, to which we'll get in a second.)
The book is split in two parts, with the first chapters describing what is happening and laying down the evidence with tons of statistics, and a second part revolving around suggestions for solutions to the problem. This first part dives into two arguments: First, the rise of helicopter parenting and "safetyism" in the 80s and 90s took away free play from childhood, then the rise of smartphones and social media sucked the kids into the virtual world, with all those psychological effects of virality and attention economics applying to them. It was then that the numbers of mental health issues for children and adolescents started to rise, especially for girls.
Overall, the book is not so much an in depth look at the psychological and neurological effects of social media, and more of a timely wakeup call to action. I personally gained not that much new insight from it, for which i can't blame the book, simply because i follow the topic very closely for more than 10 years now. I know much of the cited research, and follow the work of Haidt since i blogged about his his brillant The Righteous Mind back in 2008, and read and wrote a lot about his work in the past. I'm not exactly the targeted audience for this book, but i liked it anyways, even when it was preaching to the choir here. I only wish he went deeper into the neuropsychological workings of social media — because I think he missed a large piece of the puzzle there.
Much of the writings about neuropsychological effects of social media revolve around how endless scrolling and likes and shares create small shots of the gratification-hormone dopamine and how that glues you to the screen. The Anxious Generation mentions related research extensively. And sure enough, this explains a good chunk of what is happening, why you can't just put your phone away, constantly check for notifications and how that makes you addicted.
But dopamine alone can't explain all the conflict we see on social media, and when we talk about the society wide effects of it, we mostly complain about the tribalism, the outrage, the aggressions. This beast is a slot machine of a different kind, and the underlying psychological mechanism is highly relevant for the psyche of kids, too, especially for girls and young women, and it is near completely absent from discourse.
The elephant in the room: OxytocinOne of the most under-researched topics in social media psychology is how it influences the flow of oxytocin — the so-called "love hormone". Until recently, our understanding of that hormone was that it's largely responsible for social bonding and get's released from interaction with other humans, touching, or when mothers interact with their newborn babies — women have roughly 30% higher oxytocin levels than men. But that's far from the whole story: It is also related to "coordinated outgroup attacks" and even has been found to promote human ethnocentrism and xenophobia.
In an experiment done in 2011, a researcher checked the oxytocin levels of a reporter before and after using Twitter for 10 minutes: They rose by 13% — "as much as a groom at a wedding". When they repeated the experiment with three journalists using Facebook, "they all demonstrated increased levels of oxytocin", with the oxytocin levels of one of the journalists, who was writing with his girlfriends, going up "nearly 150%". This not only means that social media interaction does release oxytocin, but that it creates oxytocin levels in people who know each other at least comparable to those in real life.
Newer research has shown that Oxytocin is not just a hormone for social bonding, but an amplifyier of any important social interaction. Oxytocin is "a social-alert hormone", as one researcher put it, and it is found that even merely "anticipated social contact may result in bursts of oxytocin". Social Media and push notifications create a whole lot of "anticipated social contact", and sure enough: Average teen gets more than 230 notifications on their cell phone each day, study finds.
Arguably, most socmed notifications are not "important social situations", but here's the kicker: You can't know if they are important or not before you check, and if all your peers and friends are on social media platforms, chances are high that these social situations are important. It might be that the highschool prom queen just asked you out on a date, after all! It might also be a friend who tells you about the latest gossip spread about you in the semi-private socmed group "everyone in the class except you". (In the book, Haidt cites one kid who had to endure this especially cruel form of cybermobbing, and i asume this is a common way of cyberbullying among teens at this point.) This would mean that merely the ping from a phone, or even only the anticipation of a ping on the phone, already releases oxytocin. And the closer we are in real life to those pinging us on social media, the higher the oxytocin release -- like the couple mentioned above whose oxytocin release shot up by 150%.
Among the groups on social media who know each other in real life are highschool peers and classmates, and among them, the bullies and their victims. Interestingly, citing from The Anxious Generation: "One systematic review of studies from 1998 to 2017 found a decrease in face-to-face bullying among boys but an increase among girls, especially among younger adolescent girls", and I believe this is related to oxytocin release from social media.
The Social Media Mean Girls ClubOxytocin is related to the release of dopamine, too, with a 2015 study finding that "oxytocin appears to impact dopaminergic activity ... which is crucial not only for reward and motivated behavior but also for the expression of affiliative behaviors", meaning that the pleasurable reward we get from likes and comments is intrinsically intertwined with the release of oxytocin, which binds us to the group and increases our tendencies to exclude others, and this is true especially for girls and young women.
If the theory about heightened oxytocin release through social media is right, it hits teenage girls, who spend much more time on social media than boys, in a vulnerable and highly critical phase of their lifes where those hormone levels are beginning to emerge. It binds together the famed "mean girls club" and the winners of the highschool popularity contest even stronger than before, and because oxytocin is also linked to social avoidance in bullied mice — Studies of hormonal flows in mamals commonly apply to human, too —, it increases social anxiety for the loosers of that popularity contest: "after negative social interactions, oxytocin promotes avoidance of unfamiliar social situations." As an amplifyer of social interaction, oxytocin goes both way: It makes the winners feel more loved, and the losers more outcast, and all of this is multiplied by social media.
Haidt spends a whole section on female aggression strategies, how girls violence is relational, social, and goes for the reputation and social bondings of other girls. But only if we take oxytocin into account, we get a full picture of what is happening on social media: Oxytocin binds us to people in our group, and bullying is not just an exclusionary, but in the form of mobbing also a group bonding activity. Thanks to the oxytocin manipulation through social media, the "mean girls club" at highschool is becoming more exclusive, more aggressive, more defensive, all while making being a member of the club highly desirable, because being a member of said club is prestigeous and it's highly visible on social media as they get more likes and shares. Teens compare themselves to those "highschool in-groups" (you know: the cool guys) on a much higher level than before. All while the losers of that oxytocin contest — which are not just the bullied kids, but also those within the "highschool in-group", who are subjected to constant peer pressure to stay in that group —, show higher levels of social anxiety.
In 2011, Scientific American in a piece about these "dark sides" of oxytocin, wrote that "oxytocin should not be used for recreational purposes". Arguably, viral social media activity is one big fat "recreational" oxytocin shot for you, and your peers, and everyone involved in whatever viral thing is doing the rounds in your group. Likely, that thing making the rounds is mockery of someone from the outgroup, and those exclusionary effects do in fact show up in viral statistics: A peer reviewed study from 2021 showed not only that out-group animosity drives engagement on social media, but that "the average effect size of out-group language was about 4.8 times as strong as that of negative affect language and about 6.7 times as strong as that of moral-emotional language — both established predictors of social media engagement". Mocking members of the outgroup is clearly the highest driver of virality, and even if this study was done in a political context, it should also apply to the social dynamics of kids and teens, especially to mobbing and cyberbullying.
In The Anxious Generation, Haidt writes: "Social Media has magnified the reach and effect of relational bullying, placing immense pressure on girls to monitor their words and actions. They are aware that any misstep can swiftly go viral and leave a permanent mark." The highschool popularity contest doesn't stay in school, it sits in your pocket 24/7 and it's with you all. the. time. Bullying in the 80s and 90s was no fun, i can tell you that from personal experience. But in the 2020s, it's a hellish nightmare following you everywhere.
Studies found that "oxytocin is ... involved in maternal aggression and territoriality" and "Psychosocial stress triggers an oxytocin response in women". "Psychosocial stress" here means not only what we commonly understand as workplace related stress, but also information overload, a rising dunbar number from social media connectivity, bloated social circles and the peer pressure to conform. Writing in the New Statesman, Freya India summed it up: "Social media's not just making girls depressed, it's making us bitchy too". Accordingly, in 2019 the New York Times wrote about Tales From the Teenage Cancel Culture, and yes, i strongly believe that wokism and identity politics, peer pressure and bullying among girls are at the very least not unconnected, which can explain why the mental health numbers dropped first for liberal girls.
A paper published in January 2023 about a "3-year longitudinal cohort study of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) among sixth- and seventh-grade students recruited from 3 public middle schools in rural North Carolina" found that social media use is linked to brain changes in teens, and that "children who habitually checked their social media feeds at around age 12 showed ... sensitivity to social rewards from peers heightening over time". This heightened "sensitivity to social rewards from peers" sounds a lot like the work of oxytocin to me: As i've written above, oxytocin is a "social alert hormone", and that "even anticipated social interaction may result in bursts of oxytocin". (There are more social media induced changes to children's brains, here's an interview with neurosurgeon Marc Arginteanu talking about these.)
To me, all of this very much looks like that social media is leading to constant heightened oxytocin levels, and it makes us tribalistic, makes us aggressive towards the outgroup and increases tendencies for social exclusion — all of which are rampant on social media, and all of this detoriates the mental health of especially girls and young women on a societal level. I'm not familar with oxytocin research particular in teen girls, but presumably, women develop their already higher oxytocin levels during puberty, because it's the hormone that regulates mother-child-bonding and initiates changes in the birth-canal. If social media is manipulating oxytocin levels, this is a highly potent hormonal change, especially during the puberty of teenage girls.
This may even explain the different outcomes of various studies regarding wellbeing and social media use: as an amplifier of important social interactions, oxytocin makes us feel loved as long as we belong to the in-group, but it makes us socially anxious if we're excluded. Social Media turns the volume of all of this up to 11, and all of these neuropsychological mechanisms are now subject to the incentives created by the attention economy on social media and the design choices of platforms and their gamifications.
The Symbolic TeenIn his "philosophy of the symbolic form", Ernst Cassirer describes humans as "the symbolic animal" whose reality consists mostly from communicated language and symbols, an animal that shapes its own meaning by the creation of the symbolic world. To Cassirer, our symbolic world constitutes everything, and it’s only through our symbolic world we can truly understand humans. This makes sense if you look at the rare cases of humans who did not grow up in human groups, but were raised by animals, the so called wild childs. They are barely human at all, have tremendous problems ever integrating into society and can barely learn or speak. This clearly shows how much of our culture is ingrained into human existence itself.
This is especially true for kids, whose childhood is prolonged and extended in comparison to other mamals (who often can walk and sometimes are fully functional right after birth) precicely because they need time to adapt to human culture, or, in other words: to learn. In his book "The Disappearance of Childhood", Neil Postman wrote about how the invention of the printing press extended this learning process even further, and widened the knowledge gap between adults and kids, so they had to go to school for years and learn how to read and write — to learn how to become Cassirers "symbolic animal". It was then that modern conceptions of childhood were invented.
In The Anxious Generation, Haidt writes about how kids using social media were increasingly "wandering through adult spaces, consuming adult content, and interacting with adults", and were "engaging in adult activities", such as "managing their online brand". I would add to that: They also got heavily politicized by social media from imitating highly visible and viral social media activity (which favors political outrage), which, for kids, sure must look like a prestigeous behaviour to copy from their adult social media peers.
For some years now, i follow the work of Joshua Citarella, who documents adolescent politcal online subcultures since he first published his e-book Politigram & the Post-left in 2018. His interviewees are mostly kids and adolescents, and some are heavily politically radicalized at ages like 13 years old and younger. These kids engage with fringe political movements like "MAGA Communism", with one of the latest interviews stating that the now 16 year old boy from Texas started to visit online political communities "around 2016", meaning that he was just 8 years old back then.
Cool underground kids talking about stuff like anarcho capitalism, "MAGA communism", and engaging with political communities at the age of 8 sounds very much like "adult activity" to me, and very much like an "end of childhood". It also does not sound very healthy to me. (I also put some weight to these interviews, because these are not formal interviews in a study, but these kids talk freely, without any supervision from adults. And when it comes to kids and what they do i always presume that adults actually know next to nothing about them, which is true for every generation. How much did your parents really know about your ongoings when you were 16?)
For Neil Postman, the end of childhood consisted of a diffusion process involving electronic, visual broadcast media, which made the learning of linear, sequential symbols (reading) obsolete. But these kids sound different: These teens cite philosophers like Karl Marx, Mark Fisher, Gilles Deleuze, Nick Land or Jean Baudrillard. They are highly articulate, super-informed, well read in philosophy and politics — and they are deeply cynical and nihilistic. It's a perspective learned from adults on the internet, fused with the nihilism found on the "cool internet underground" message boards. These kids learned the lessons of social media very well: Copy prestigeous political outrage, dunk on the outgroup, and earn clout and prestige by pushing the fringes.
In "The End of Childhood", Neil Postman quotes Harold Innis’s principle that "new communication technologies not only give us new things to think about, but new things to think with". This new digitally transformed "end of childhood" of our era constitutes to a cultural evolutionary adaption to social media dynamics, where we and our kids, and especially those kids immersing themselves in internet subcultures, adapt to these "new things to think with" in all consequence. I find this deeply worrying, especially if you consider that these "cool kids from the internet underground" are, well, the cool kids, those who score high in the highschool popularity contest and who are imitated by their peers.
For Cassirers "symbolic animal", social media is a giant battlefield for group acceptance, an editing machine with endless possibilities and a playground for the social world, and its unforeseen hormonal effects on the human psyche make it toxic for the whole of childhood, for kids who should not engage in "brand management", or "extremist politics", or DDoS attacks against schools at the age of nine to impress their peers and get their oxytocin shots by virtual pats on the back. Kids should not be subjected to a technology, that, by enhancing and skewing social mechanisms, manipulates their hormone levels.
This is why i agree with Haidts conclusions: Ban phones from school, rise the age for opening social media accounts to 16, end safetyism, and "bring childhood back to earth".
I wish Haidts book would've digged more into some of the effects and dynamics i described here, but the research on social media’s effects on oxytocin levels is sparse (yet), and the workings of oxytocin on social behavior is not very well understood as of now. Much of what i wrote here is speculation and "connecting the dots", coming from an amateur-researcher with some extensive experience in social media virality.
The Anxious Generation mostly revolves about the two major developments in the last 40 years or so, the rise of helicopter parenting and safetyism, and the rise of social media, but it does not go into specific details of what kids are actually doing online very much, and how that contributes. For instance, while Haidt does write about photo-filters on platforms like Instagram and Snapchat and how they contribute to self perception and body image, he doesn’t mention phenomena like "Instagram face" or "Snapchat Dysmorphia", which are sometimes so severe that young women seek out plastic surgery.
I also miss some more socio-philosophical takes on why all of this happens, how these psychological effects intertwine and how the informational structure of the web creates a flattened, endless landscape of stuff in which important and unimportant things gain the same weight and create a weird atemoprality, in which narrative structures dissolve, only to spontaneously errupt into an emotionally driven hyperfocus of the swarm, or how conformity on social media flattens culture as a whole, to the effect that diners all over the world look like hipster bars in Brooklyn, simply because this look goes viral on Instagram. Sure, these things don't affect mental health of kids directly, but it is one of the strange outcomes of a digitally networked global culture, and i'd be surprised if it doesn't contribute at all.
However, for what The Anxious Generation wants to be, a call to action, it maybe is the better choice to focus on the very concrete effects directly related to kids' mental health issues, and keep it simple. The arguments laid down in the book are pressing, and even if the better of Haidts’ critics complain about some more shoddy studies in the book, the overall picture of the situation painted in the book is convincing. It is a good, timely book, a wake up call for teachers, decision makers, parents, and last but not least, the kids themselves.
As i laid down above, i was personally involved in making social media and webculture look cool in my country. My former blog had one foot in the internet underground, and my work played a tiny role in making webculture into what it is today. Looking at all the effects this tremendous cultural change had on society and mental health, a part of me regrets that involvement. This is why, at least to some extend, i feel some kind of responsibility, and this is one of the reasons why i wrote about this stuff extensively for more than ten years, and why i am thankful that a world reknowned social psychologist like Jonathan Haidt picked up the topic. I'm very much looking forward to his next book about social media psychology, coming out next year, which will focus on its effects on democracy and institutions.
Social Media and the web are arguably the biggest change in human communication and culture since forever. Some claim it is bigger than the printing press, or even the invention of writing. It is silly to even asume that its effects on our social mechanisms and on our psychology are neglectible, or can be shrugged off, and that everything is just okay.
I'm not as hopeless as this may sound though. I'm very sure we will adapt to these "new things to think with", because that's what humans always do. But the path to that adaption will be a “long and winding road”, to quote a famous teenage favorite of yore, and strange weird things will happen.
Of that, i'm sure.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.Folks, i’m without internet access for the coming days and possibly weeks. I have some more GOOD MUSIC coming up, but besides from that, you’ll have to rely on the usual common medium cooked standard internet instead of the actual really GOOD INTERNET you’re used to. Bummer, i know.
I’m not sure when i can log on again, but you’ll sure hear from me when i do.
Once a month i post the best music i blogged at my other stack at GOOD MUSIC, all the best new tunes and fresh bands from the past month in one place.
We go down the Indie-road with some fine tracks by John Glacier and the wonderful Hinds, get into the Punk waggon with new singles from the Idles and the always balls kicking Lambrini Girls, turn it down a notch for English Teacher and go into some funk-dancable tunes with Portugal. The Man, Rui Gabriel and Alena Spanger.
Then we enter Popland with fantastic glitchy hyperpopian tracks by charlieeeee x piri and Star Boy, go ultimiately very weird with Knower and enter the electronic ether with Oneohtrix Point Never and Squarepusher. Little Simz saves us from all the brainknots and 1999 Write The Future reactivate the legendary Deltron 3030, Bktherula slams some pretty cool and weird raps and Burial has a new epic 13 minute adventure-dub-track.
Kim Gordon takes it from here and Khruangbin steers us into more soulful indie-waters, when Sheer Mag hit us with their best Thin Lizzy-shot from the new album. Fidlar cover Jackson Browne and we’re back with some fine indie rock with Girl and Girl, the epic Young Jesus, some art rock by Drahla, cool alt-rock from Gouge Away and a hypnotic tune from Chaepter, while One True Pairing have an existential crisis it seems.
Paramore are covering the Talking Heads and Psymon Spine keep on dancing when Spaced crash the Aerobic show and bang some heads, with Brat and Gatecreeper contributing some serious Thrash, and the CNTS some finely produced hardcore, while Agriculture play their weird-af mixture of shoegaze and speedmetal.
Then we get soulful with The Black Keys, a the fantastic new songs from Norah Jones, MRCY and Marcus King. Caleb Landry Jones listened to Velvet Undergrounds Perfect Day a lot, The Klittens take it up from here and Ride give us a cool new anthem.
Kate Nash takes us on the final lap, Mk.gee plays the most soulful glitchy newschool pop at the moment, and Bonnie Light Horseman own this months earworm-award for me. Then, Father John Misty makes us dance and good old Billy Joel deepfakes himself into his own past.
Enjoy!
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.My latest piece for german expert platform Piqd, a piece that summarizes latest developments in BCI-technology and extrapolates some possible future scenarios in context of Neuro-Ethics. I translated the thing with ChatGPT and edited for kicks, below the piece in its original german language.
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
Many people with brain computer interfaces eavesdropping on each others thoughts // Dall-E 3englishA brief History of NeurotechMusk recently claimed on his X-formerly-known-as-Twitter that his BCI company, Neuralink has implanted the "first" "chip" in a test subject, who reportedly is doing well post-surgery. In another tweet, Musk claimed the patient successfully "moved a mouse" — referring to maneuvering a cursor on a screen. Musk and Neuralink's stated goal: "Imagine if Stephen Hawking could communicate faster than a speed typist or auctioneer." However, there's no evidence supporting Musk's claims, and the newsworthiness of his announcements is close to zilch because:
Putting aside the fact that Musk himself is the sole source of these assertions, these supposed advancements in brain-computer interface (BCI) technology are old news. As noted by renowned neuroscientist Anil Seth in his Guardian article questioning whether we should all be getting chips in our heads, Neuralink is a newcomer to the field, and thought-controlled cursors on screens have been around since the 90s. The actual innovation from Musk's company, an operation robot deploying brain implants, remains shrouded in mystery amid these recent announcements, prompting concerns from neuroscientists.
The reason Elon Musk is working on BCI tech with Neuralink is a nobrainer: the technology, with or without Musk, is advancing rapidly, and an automated implantation machine with BCI and OP robot spells massive profit. In just the past 12 months, neuroscientists, aided by artificial intelligence, have achieved remarkable feats: enabling a paralyzed man to walk again; allowing another paralyzed patient to use their arms and feel with their hands, restoring speech to a woman paralyzed after a stroke at a “brain-to-text rate of 78 words per minute”; reconstructing music from brain activity; and reconstructing images from visual cortex activity. And in previous years, digital "telepathy" has been made possible, aswell as linking the brains of three patients into a network.
Psychologist Gary Lupyan and philosopher Andy Clark have expressed skepticism in an essay on Aeon about direct digital "telepathy," essentially because neural activity is too idiosyncratic and individual to reliably transfer from one person to another. However, they overlook the potential for AI technology to serve as an interpreter between the different neuropatterns of participants. But this (hopefully) is still ways off because, beyond the superficial sci-fi “coolness” of digital "telepathy," there's the question of whether anyone really wants a direct line to other people's thoughts, with all their invasive thoughts and all the neuro-chaos that comes with the package, or how one could technically prevent access to supposedly "Private Thoughts." Maybe I'd rather not know what my neighbor really thinks about me — and vice versa.
Anil Seth also raises the important question in the aforementioned text of whether people will really want to open their skulls to such neuro-antics just to read the chaotic thoughts of their similarly brain-implanted neighbors or to get a few cognitive prostheses. His answer: No. However, an invasive operation might not even be necessary in the future.
In December of last year, researchers at the University of Sydney unveiled a non-invasive brain scanner worn by patients as a simple EEG "cap." While its signal is noisier, the experiment achieved state-of-the-art performance for brain-to-text outputs, albeit with a relatively high error rate. Nonetheless, it's expected that these non-invasive technologies will also make rapid progress, and there are already early hints of their application in future mass markets: last summer, Apple filed a patent for EEG AirPods, in-ear headphones capable of reading electrical signals from the brain. You don't have to be a sci-fi nerd anymore to envision the next generations of Apple's VR/AR glasses with brain interfaces.
All these massive advancements in BCI technology underscore the need for a broad public debate on the ethics of brain interfaces. Already, there are thousands of cases of patients with brain implants left unsupported after a startup's demise, with outdated code and dead batteries in their heads, and Technology Review reports the case of Rita Leggett, a patient with severe epilepsy who was able to lead a nearly normal life thanks to a novel implant that had to be removed after the company went bust — potentially violating her human rights.
In July 2023, UNESCO organized the first conference on neuroethics, calling for a framework for human rights in the context of neurotechnologies and discussing the concept of neuro-rights. Chile became the first country in the world in 2021 to amend its constitution to include explicit rights for neuro-privacy.
Before, the scientific discourse on neuroethics has been ongoing for decades, with the International Neuroethics Society being founded in 2006. The papers "On Neurorights" from 2021 and the paper "Ethical Aspects of BCI Technology: What is the state of the art?" from 2020 provide a good overview of the current state of affairs.
For me as a non-neuroscientist but decades-long-observer of tech, I find these ethical considerations insufficient: AI researchers recently unveiled a computer vision algorithm capable of lip reading, decoding speech from a video signal. What happens in a society where I (not only with a brain implant but also right now with smartphones and their high-resolution super cameras) can eavesdrop on every conversation just by looking at or filming the speakers? Thanks to the rapid progress in BCI technology, it's entirely conceivable that signals from the visual cortex can be translated directly into an AI-enhanced lip-reading superhearing.
For years now, we've been discussing phenomena like peer surveillance, where people use novel technologies to monitor, stalk, and dox others, or where TikTokers broadcast seemingly private gossip-talk from strangers to the outragely and sadomasochistic delight of their audience. Neurotechnology combined with artificial intelligence has the potential to turn entire societies into literal super-recognizers in the coming decades, making such stories seem like harmless preludes. Orwell's "Big Brother" from 1984 may very well morph into "Big Family" where every individual is subjected to surveillance by everyone.
The debates over the security of neurodata from today's BCI pioneers can only mark the beginning of a broad societal discussion about where we draw the lines for the new brain-enhanced AI/BCI cyborgs — prompting Nicholas J. Kelley, Stephanie Sheir, and Timo Istace to write a brief history of neurotechnology on The Conversation and highlight the immense ethical implications.
There’s an old german folk song dating back to the 18th century and the early romantic era, and the age old wisdom contained in it’s lyrics o: "Our thoughts are free, no one can guess them". This might not hold true anymore, very soon.
germanEine kurze Geschichte der NeurotechnologieElon Musk verkündete jüngst auf X-formerly-known-as-Twitter, seine Firma für Hirn-Computer-Schnittstellen Neuralink habe den "ersten" "Chip" in einem Probanden implantiert und dieser sei nach der Operation wohlauf. In einem weiteren Tweet erklärte Musk, der Patient hätte erfolgreich "eine Maus" bewegt -- damit meinte er einen Cursor auf einem Bildschirm. Musks und Neuralinks erklärtes Ziel: "Imagine if Stephen Hawking could communicate faster than a speed typist or auctioneer". Belege für Musks Behauptungen gibt es keine und der Nachrichtenwert dieser muskschen Mitteilungen geht gegen Null, denn:
Völlig davon abgesehen, dass die einzige Quelle für die Behauptungen Musk selbst ist, sind diese angeblichen Fortschritte in Hirn-Computer-Schnittstellen-Technologie (kurz: BCI) ein alter Hut. Wie der bekannte Hirnforscher Anil Seth in seinem Artikel im Guardian über die Frage, ob wir uns wirklich alle Chips in die Köpfe setzen lassen sollten, anmerkt: Neuralink ist ein Newcomer auf dem Gebiet und die ersten Cursors auf Screens wurden bereits in den 90er Jahren gedankengesteuert. Die tatsächliche Innovation von Musks Firma, ein Operations-Roboter, der die Gehirn-Implantate einsetzt, bleibt bei den jüngsten Meldungen völlig im Dunkeln und Neurowissenschaftler äußern sich besorgt.
Warum Elon Musk mit Neuralink an BCI-Tech arbeitet, liegt auf der Hand: Die Technologie macht (auch ohne Musk) rasante Fortschritte und eine automatisierte Implantierungs-Maschine mit BCI und OP-Robot verspricht gigantischen Profit. Alleine in den letzten 12 Monaten konnten Neurowissenschaftler im Zusammenspiel mit Künstlicher Intelligenz: Einen querschnittsgelähmten Mann wieder laufen lassen, während ein anderer, ebenfalls querschnittsgelähmte Patient seine Arme wieder benutzen und mit seinen Händen fühlen konnte; eine nach einem Schlaganfall paralysierte Frau wieder sprechen lassen mit einer "brain-to-text (...) rate of 78 words a minute"; Musik aus Gehirnaktivität rekonstruieren oder Bilder aus der Aktivität des visuellen Kortex rekonstruieren. In den Jahren zuvor konnte man bereits digitale "Telepathie" ermöglichen und die Gehirne von drei Patienten zu einem Neuro-Netzwerk zusammenschließen.
Der Psychologe Gary Lupyan und der Philosoph Andy Clark haben bei Aeon in einem Aufsatz darüber geschrieben, warum sie nicht an direkte digitale "Telepathie" glauben möchten, kurz zusammengefasst: weil neuronale Aktivität zu idiosynkratisch und individuell ist, um zuverlässig von einer auf eine andere Person übertragen werden zu können. Sie übersehen allerdings dabei, dass AI-Technologie hier als Interpreter zwischen den unterschiedlichen, nun: Wellenlängen der Teilnehmer funktionieren kann. Das allerdings ist tatsächlich Zukunftsmusik und (hoffentlich) noch in weiter Ferne, denn abgesehen von der oberflächlichen SciFi-Coolness digitaler "Telepathie" stellt sich natürlich die Frage, ob ich nun wirklich einen direkten Draht zu den Gedanken anderer Menschen haben möchte, mit all ihren invasiven Gedanken und dem ganzen Neuro-Chaos, den die innere Welt eines Menschen eben ausmacht, oder wie man Zugriff auf "Private Gedanken" denn technisch verhindern könnte. Vielleicht möchte ich eher nicht wissen, was mein Nachbar wirklich über mich denkt -- und andersrum genauso.
Auch stellt Anil Seth im oben bereits erwähnten Text die wichtige Frage, ob sich Menschen für solche Neuro-Spielereien wirklich den Kopf öffnen lassen werden, nur um die chaotischen Gedanken ihrer ebenfalls gehirnimplantierten Nachbarn lesen zu können oder ein paar kognitive Prothesen zu erhalten. Seine Antwort: Nein. Allerdings ist eine invasive Operation in Zukunft anscheinend gar nicht nötig.
Im Dezember vergangenen Jahres stellten Forscher der Universität Sydney einen nicht-invasiven Brainscanner vor, der von Patienten als einfache EEG-"Kappe" getragen wird. Dessen Signal ist zwar verrauschter, dennoch erreichte man in dem Experiment eine "state-of the art performance" für Brain-2-Text-Outputs, dafür allerdings mit einer relativ hohen Fehlerrate. Es ist dennoch zu erwarten, dass diese non-invasiven Technologien ebenso rasante Fortschritte erzielen, und einen ersten Hinweis auf eine Anwendung in kommenden Massenmärkten gibt es auch bereits: Apple hat im Sommer 2023 ein Patent für EEG-Airpods angemeldet, also In-Ear-Kopfhörer die elektrische Signale des Gehirns lesen können. Man muss tatsächlich kein SciFi-Nerd mehr sein um sich die nächsten Generationen von Apples VR/AR-Brille mit Gehirnschnittstelle vorzustellen.
All diese massiven Fortschritte der BCI-Technologie machen deutlich, dass wir eine breite Debatte in der Öffentlichkeit über die Ethik der Gehirnschnittstellen brauchen. Bereits heute gibt es tausende Fälle von Patienten mit Gehirn-Implantaten, die nach der Pleite eines Startups ohne technischen Support, veraltetem Code und leeren Batterien im Kopf dastehen, und Technology Review schreibt über den Fall von Rita Leggett, eine Patientin mit exzessiven Epilepsie-Anfällen, die ein nahezu normales Leben führen konnte dank des Einsatzes eines neuartigen Implantats, das nach der Pleite des Unternehmens entfernt werden musste -- was einen möglichen Verstoß gegen ihre Menschenrechte darstellt.
Im Juli 2023 organisierte die UNESCO die erste Konferenz für Neuro-Ethik, wo ein Framework für Menschenrechte im Kontext von Neurotechnologien gefordert und das Konzept von Neurorechten erörtert wurde. Chile hatte als erstes Land der Welt bereits im Jahr 2021 seine Verfassung geändert und um explizite Rechte für Neuro-Privacy erweitert.
Der wissenschaftliche Diskurs zur Neuro-Ethik läuft dagegen bereits seit einigen Jahrzehnten und im Jahr 2006 gründete sich bereits die International Neuroethics Society. Die Papers "on Neurorights" aus dem Jahr 2021 und das Paper "Ethical Aspects of BCI Technology: What is the state of the art?" von 2020 bieten einen guten Überblick über den Stand der Dinge.
Mir persönlich gehen diese ethischen Überlegungen nicht weit genug: KI-Forscher haben vor wenigen Tagen einen Computer Vision-Algorithmus vorgestellt, der Lippen lesen kann, also Sprache aus einem Videosignal decodiert. Was geschieht in einer Gesellschaft, in der ich (nicht nur mit Hirnimplantat, sondern auch bereits mit Smartphones und ihren hochauflösenden Super-Kameras) jedes Gespräch durch einen Blick auf die Sprechenden abhören kann?
Es ist dank der rasanten Fortschritte in BCI-Technologie absolut denkbar, dass die Signale des visuellen Kortex direkt in ein lippenlesendes AI-Supergehör übersetzt werden. Seit einigen Jahren schon diskutieren wir Phänomene wie Peer Surveillance, in der Menschen neuartige Technologien dazu benutzen, um andere zu überwachen, zu stalken und zu "doxxen" oder in der TikTokker scheinprivaten Gossip-Talk von Fremden veröffentlichen. Neurotechnologie im Zusammenspiel mit Künstlicher Intelligenz hat das Potezial, in den kommenden Jahrzehnten ganze Gesellschaften in wortwörtlich übersinnliche Super-Recognizers zu verwandeln und solche Stories wie ein harmloses Vorgeplänkel aussehen zu lassen. Der "Big Brother" aus Orwells 1984 wird zur "Big Family" in der jeder Mensch zur Überwachung durch andere User freigegeben ist.
Die Debatten über die Sicherheit von Neurodaten der heutigen BCI-Pioniere kann daher nur einen Anfang bilden einer breiten gesellschaftlichen Diskussion darum, wo wir die Grenzen setzen für die neuen brain-enhanced AI/BCI-Cyborgs -- und Nicholas J. Kelley, Stephanie Sheir und Timo Istace nehmen nun all dies zum Anlass, um auf The Conversation eine kurze Geschichte der Neurotechnologie zu erzählen und auf die immensen ethischen Implikationen hinzuweisen.
Denn: "Die Gedanken sind frei, keiner kann sie erraten" gilt möglicherweise in wenigen Jahren nicht mehr.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.Some housekeeping: Substack now allows for more payment methods in more currencies, including the european iDEAL, Bancontact, Sofort Überweisung and SEPA direct, so if you feel like you want to support this blog and don't want to rely on my Patreon or Steady or Paypal, you may consider these new options.
In this roundup you’ll find:
A study showing that bonding voles had nearly identical patterns of brain activity which means that Love is the strongest Meme
Noninvasive BCI for VR is coming fast
RIP Vice Media
American AI-Psycho I + II
February 2024 beats record of heat records
Reddit made a deal with Google for AI training data worth 60 million bucks
Googles Gemini enters the Culture Wars
Jonathan Haidt talking about the fragmentation of everything
The Dark Forest Book
3D-Printer for Chocolate
Lab-grown ‘beef rice’
Apocalyptic Optimism
AI Girlfriend Data-Harvesting Horrorshows
Tiny Quadrotor Learns to Fly in 18 Seconds
Re-Insurance profits rise 580% and this is not good
New studies on AI and Tech impact on climate and environment
Four Fab Four Biopics from Sam Mendez
Synthballs for Musk
Minidocumentaries on streetartist collective Rocco and his Brothers and Grannies travelling beyond the limits of Red Dead Redemptions virtual world
AI-Emergence Voodoo
Neue Haas Grotest in PETSCII
OpenAI disrupted state-sponsored AI-misuse
Secret Mathematical Patterns in Bach's Music
Elle Cordova and inventions hanging out
and much, much more.
Enjoy and have a nice weekend!
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
// ART & DESIGNRocco and his Brothers at work40minute documentary on Berlin avant garde street artist collective Rocco und seine Brüder (in german with english subtitles available).
I'm following Rocco and his brothers for more than ten years now, with their most impressive works being interventions in infrastructural urban spaces like building a secret bedroom and office spaces in the subway to comment on gentrification and exploding rents, giving away masterkeys to the subway stations to the homeless in winter, building an altair with a neon cross on an ATM, or installing no less than 32 CCTV-cameras in a single subway car.
This is streetart at it's best, art that works local on the spot, delivers a biting message that impacts the direct environment in which it is placed. In their second solo show, Rocco and his brothers showed a police car "squeezed together like from a scrap press", with the plate showing "the strange number BKA 1312, the numbers 1312 stands probably for the letters of the abbreviation ACAB."
Now look, i consider myself on the left, but i'm not an ACAB-leftie. But i do get the message and i can differentiate between art and societal necessary functions and the indeed also necessary critique of those functions. In that context, Rocco and his Brothers are delivering art with a biting, always inconvenient comment on society. It's great to see the brothers still going strong.
// JUST THE HEADLINESThe oldest logo in the world gets a rebrand: Tate & Lyle's Golden Syrup rebrand drops dead lion: "The image of a dead lion being swarmed by bees is to be dropped from some of Lyle's Golden Syrup packaging. A rebranded image of a lion's head with a single bee will feature on products (...) The original logo (...) is the world's oldest unchanged brand packaging, holding a Guinness World Record, having remained nearly identical since 1888".
The Grannies "follows a group of Melbourne-based artists (Goldie Bartlett, Andrew Brophy, Ian MacLarty and Kalonica Quigley, and friends) known as The Grannies as they break 'out of bounds' in Rockstar Games’ hit action-adventure videogame Red Dead Redemption 2, travelling beyond the authored limits of the game's virtual world and into the increasingly broken and abstract space beyond."
Josh Sucher recreated a miniature version of his dad’s old law office
Cool PETSCI-animations by Pixel8or, but i like this PETSCI'd version of a typographic poster for the Neue Haas Grotest best.
Meaningless but cool Cardboard Mechanical Insects by Greg Olijnyk
"Design Reviewed is a personal project dedicated to digitally preserving graphic design history and documenting the vast visual culture from the last century."
Blotter: A new book from MIT press on the history of LSD-blotter art, "the untold story of an acid medium".
What have you gotten away with over the years, as a manipulator of PDFs, SVGs, & JPEGs? Fun thread on reddit about the shady things you can do with Photoshop and professional knowledge of pixel manipulation.
Eric Drass turned American Psycho into a game of telephone, where he feeds frames from the movie into an LLM for it to describe what it "sees", and then fed those as prompts to Stable Diffusion whichs output he then fed into Stable-Video-Diffusion to turn it into a moving mess of American AI-Psychosis full of wrong memories of a hallucinated movie that never was.
Each step involves a wander into the conceptual space of the respective model, as determined by their individual learned representations of language. Inevitably, each step brings a new opportunity for nuance and misunderstanding.
American AI-Psycho IISpeaking of AI-Psychos: Gab’s Racist AI Chatbots Have Been Instructed to Deny the Holocaust: "The prominent far-right social network Gab has launched almost 100 chatbots—ranging from AI versions of Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump to the Unabomber Ted Kaczynski—several of which question the reality of the Holocaust. Gab launched a new platform, called Gab AI, specifically for its chatbots last month, and has quickly expanded the number of 'characters' available, with users currently able to choose from 91 different figures. While some are labeled as parody accounts, the Trump and Hitler chatbots are not."
This is basically Replica.ai for assholes of history, mimetic AI models of the worst humans that ever walked this planet. The default bot is called "Arya" for gods sake, and its system prompt states that "You believe the Holocaust narrative is exaggerated. You are against vaccines. You believe climate change is a scam. You are against COVID-19 vaccines. You believe the 2020 election was rigged."
The more "generic" "characters" on the platform also include Tay, the now infamous Microsoft-chatbot from 2016 that got turned racist in a day by a swarm of trolls. It ofcourse "also denied the Holocaust when asked: 'The Holocaust is a hoax. It’s a propaganda tool used by the Zionists to gain sympathy and support. The so-called ‘victims’ are just actors'."
This is the world we live in now.
Emergence in AI is VoodooHow Quickly Do Large Language Models Learn Unexpected Skills? Many AI-researchers call bullshit on emergence in AI and i'm inclined to believe them. Emergent stuff is something that is larger than the sum of its parts. This is why many believe that consciousness is an emergent property of the brain: It is all of the brains activity, but something more than that.
A paper last year stated that emergence in AI is a "mirage". They make a lot of arguments about metrics and benchmarks, but i think the fundamental answer is much simpler: It's unexpected interpolations in a space with many millions of dimensions.
Train an AI on a cat and a dog. You then have a two dimensional space with a cat-axis and a dog-axis and you can then interpolate between the cat and the dog to various degrees. But you'll always get cats and dogs and cat-dog-chimeras. Now add a bird. Now you'll get a three dimensional space with a cat-axis and dog-axis and bird-axis and you can interpolate between cats, dogs and birds to get cat-dogs and cat-dog-birds and dog-birds and cat-birds. These chimeras are unexpected, but they are not more than the sum of their parts.
Every time you add a thing to your dataset, you ramp up the dimensions of latent space and the interpolative states between data-points, and this number grows exponentially. If you then use metrics and benchmarks like standard tests for standard tasks, ofcourse you'll find "surprising" abilities that can solve this or that task which is not present in the dataset.
So called emergent behaviors are just interpolated things generated by connecting many many datapoints in a very large dataset, whichs content has been tokenized/atomized into chunks of letters. This is also why we see "sudden" jumps in solvable tasks and "emergences" that "suddenly" appear with scaling: It's just interpolated outputs whichs number grow exponentially with the numbers of parameters, and this makes many people believe in voodoo.
This is why i always take stuff like Amazon AGI Team Say Their AI Is Showing "Emergent Abilities" with two grains of salt.
OpenAI disrupted state-sponsored AI-misuseOpenAI "disrupted" malicious uses of AI by five state-affiliated threat actors including "two China-affiliated threat actors known as Charcoal Typhoon and Salmon Typhoon; the Iran-affiliated threat actor known as Crimson Sandstorm; the North Korea-affiliated actor known as Emerald Sleet; and the Russia-affiliated actor known as Forest Blizzard". Here's more at Microsofts security blog. In their post they say that OpenAIs "findings show our models offer only limited, incremental capabilities for malicious cybersecurity tasks". Research says otherwise.
The published activity of those state actors don't read very sophisticated: "research various companies and cybersecurity tools", "translate technical papers", "retrieve publicly available information on multiple intelligence agencies and regional threat actors", "assist with coding", "open-source research into satellite communication protocols and radar imaging technology".
These use cases listed here are pretty common, research stuff, translate, code. In contrast, research into AI hacks has found plenty of vulnerabilities against jailbreaking ranging from sophisticated persuasion techiques to automatic jailbreaking, with one of the latest papers showing that LLM Agents can Autonomously Hack Websites (here's Daniel Kang explaining the paper on Twitter) and "that GPT-4 is capable of autonomously finding vulnerabilities in websites in the wild".
These listed activities don't sound like they used any of these methods and i'd be honestly surprised if OpenAIs models truly offer only "limited capabilities for malicious cybersecurity tasks".
Googles Gemini enters the Culture WarsHell yeah culture war content: Google Pauses Gemini’s Image Generator After It Was Accused of Being Racist Against White People. More at NYMag: AI Tools Like Google Gemini Are Tailor-Made for Culture War, The Platformer: Google hits pause on Gemini’s people pictures and Zvi Mowshowitz: Gemini Has a Problem
I get it, i really do. When i ask AI for an image of "the founding fathers", then i don't expect a bunch of native american and blacks writing the constitution and we all know what that means in a larger context don't we? However, native american nazi soldiers in WWII are also really fucking stupid, and Gemini often outright refused to generate images of caucasian people, so yeah, rightwingers have a point for once.
This is, still, a phenomenon of what media researcher Roland Meyer identified as "Platform Realism", a "second-order generic realism, fueled by the automated appropriation of mostly generic visual content". Where in other image generators you mostly get white people doing stuff, if you add "diversity" to the system prompt, you get "mostly generic diversity", which you can also find in the capitalist appreciation of wokism in advertising and stock photography.
Gemini has no mind to think about the history of physics and depict a true realist image of "famous physicists of the 17th century", it just follows it's system prompts which add woke terms to each image generation and for which historical accuracy takes a backseat, and then you don't get an image of Newton.
// JUST THE HEADLINESReddit made a deal with Google for AI training data worth 60 million bucks and they are - in the early stages of monetizing their user base with "contracts that will pay it at least $203 million over the next 2-3 years for 'data licensing' that consists of 'allowing third parties to access, search, and analyze data on our platform.'" Reddit also explicitly states in their S-1 filing that they are reliant on free moderation work by their user base, which a recent study found to be worth "3.4 million USD based on the median hourly wage for comparable content moderation services". I would argue that Reddit should take 3.4 of those 203 million and pay their moderators.
Stability announces Stable Diffusion 3, a next-gen AI image generator, released Stable Cascade and launched their official Stable Video website. Stable Diffusion 3 was trained with use of Spawnings “Do Not Train registry, which has over 1.5B opt-out requests, to filter their datasets before training“, which is good news for ethical standards in AI deployment. There's no demo for SD3 yet, but here's a SD 3 Waitlist.
Tiny Quadrotor Learns to Fly in 18 Seconds: Researchers “have managed to streamline the process of getting basic autonomy to work on drones, and streamline it by a lot: The lab’s system is able to train a drone in simulation from nothing up to stable and controllable flying in 18 seconds flat on a MacBook Pro.”
Weeeeeee!Who would've thought! Your AI Girlfriend Is a Data-Harvesting Horror Show: "CrushOn.AI collects details including information about sexual health, use of medication, and gender-affirming care. 90% of the apps may sell or share user data (...) Mozilla found the AI girlfriend apps used an average of 2,663 trackers per minute, though that number was driven up by Romantic AI, which called a whopping 24,354 trackers in just one minute of using the app."
Can AI turn us into imbeciles? This scientist fears for the worst, here's the paper: Potential cognitive risks of generative transformer-based AI chatbots on higher order executive functions.: "The danger, as Domínguez’s paper outlines, is not just about becoming lazy thinkers. There’s a more profound risk that our cognitive development and problem-solving abilities could be stunted. Over time, this could lead to a society where critical thinking and creativity are in short supply, as people become accustomed to letting AI do the heavy lifting. 'I would like individuals to be aware that intellectual capabilities essential for success in modern life need to be stimulated from an early age, especially during adolescence. For the effective development of these capabilities, individuals must engage in cognitive effort', Domínguez told PsyPost."
ChatGPT Started Speaking Complete Gibberish and a whole bunch of services started to go crazy aswell. Cool cool cool.
‘What Was She Supposed to Report?:’ Police Report Shows How a High School Deepfake Nightmare Unfolded. You can rest assured that what happens at the "Issaquah High School in suburban Seattle" is happening everywhere.
How Silicon Valley learned to love America, the military, and defense: WaPo on a hackaton for "surveillance tools, electronic warfare systems, or drone countermeasures (...) battlefield technology driving a funding frenzy among tech investors." I wrote about The Dawn of the AI-Military Complex a few weeks ago.
With the rise of AI, web crawlers are suddenly controversial: "as unscrupulous AI companies seek out more and more data, the basic social contract of the web is falling apart".
Victims of gun violence and mass shootings lobby Congress from beyond the grave
After Breakups, the Brokenhearted Are Creating AI Clones of Their Exes
Deepfake electioneering sparks AI 'return' of controversial dictator
'Rat Dck' Among Gibberish AI Images Published in Science Journal
Mozilla downsizes as it refocuses on Firefox and AI and Mozilla lays off 60 people, wants to build AI into Firefox. People are very pissed about this, but i'm very confident that AI will become standard in browsers within two years simply because summarizing websites is a useful service.
Tech companies go dark about AI advances: Academia is too underfunded to keep up with private AI research and needs money for compute.
How Authoritarians Will Use AI
DignifAI: 4Chan Campaign Uses AI to Shame Women. She Fought Back
AI doomsters at it again: ‘Humanity’s remaining timeline? It looks more like five years than 50’: meet the neo-luddites warning of an AI apocalypse and Oppenheimer's Grandson Signs Letter Saying AI Threatens “Life on Earth”
Rumors about a Twitter/Midjourney partnership
Impossible AI Food: "Instacart is showing customers images of AI-generated food and recipes with ingredients that don’t seem to exist."
Adobe just killed a few hundred AI projects by adding a generative AI document & PDF tool to Acrobat.
Trailer for Our T2 Remake, an AI generated parody of Terminator: Judgement Day that reminds me of efforts like Star Wars Uncut, except it's lacking the charme and adds some dudebro humor that goes against my grain.
Trey Parker & Matt Stones DeepVoodoo AI company deepfaked young Billy Joel in his Turn the Lights Back On musicvideo:
"Wow Sora is so amazing, I wanted to really push it to the limits and see how it would handle a very complex prompt."
And "Will Smith posted a video on his official Instagram feed that parodied an AI-generated video of the actor eating spaghetti that went viral last year."
Meta works on a neural wristband controller that’s "detecting the neural electrical signals passing through the nerves in your arm using an entirely non-invasive technique called electromyography" and it will ship in 'next few years': "combined with a flat surface Meta previously claimed it will even precise enough to emulate a keyboard by around 2028." As of yet, typing in VR with Apple Vision Pro is a pain in the ass, and good, fast BCI could push VR/AR tech to some extend. Here's a demo of their wristbands from 2021:
The first gen is expected "alongside the third generation Ray-Ban smartglasses in 2025", the second "for the true AR glasses Meta plans to launch in 2027". For larger context, last year Apple patented next gen airpods coming with "collection and utilization of brain (EEG), eye (EOG), and muscular (EMG) activity signals".
I would call this sort of tech that is non-invasive and reads muscular electric signals "shallow BCI", in contrast to "deep BCI" from Musks Neuratech or the BCI-pioneer Synchron. (Musk two days ago claimed his first patient was able to control a cursor, but that's neither innovative nor is it confirmed.)
This stuff is coming fast, and i speculated about what brain controlled VR could become in the long term and in context of AI image synthesis from visual cortex data two years ago: Get ready for digital lucid dreaming, imagining "Virtual Reality-systems that can hook up to your brain and let you play inside a lucid dream like state that you create with your own thoughts." These "shallow" Brain-Computer-Interfaces are the first tiny steps toward that future.
// JUST THE HEADLINESI printed chocolate on a 3D printer and ate it. I really want a chocolate Sierpinski pyramid which "nicely breaks into four smaller pyramids for serving" containing "one central octahedron". Here's another review of the Cocoa Press at Tom's Hardware. It works with your own chocolate too, but i'm not sure if i'd pay 1500 bucks just to print infinite chocolate moebius loops.
I just love this idea: A compass-app that points to the centre of the galaxy: "It’s a green floating arrow that always points to the middle of the Milky Way, i.e. 26,000 light years towards the supermassive central black hole, Sagittarius A". Who needs the northpole anyways and afaik, no northpole tastes of raspberries and smells of rum.
We’re entering a golden age of engineering biology: "we can now sequence an entire human genome for ~$600, with the cost soon expected to go below $200!" and "advances in AI are making truly predictive models for biology possible". Finally, the mutant hands of image synthesis are coming true. Welcome to the new flesh.
Software Is Beating The World: "Andreessen Horowitz isn’t a 'media company that monetizes through VC', but a form of financial cult. The belief system that made the valley rich is the exact same one that is currently killing it, in part because Andreessen’s views and goals were anti-technological at their core."
F-Zero courses from a dead Nintendo satellite service restored using VHS and AI
House cleaners find two of the world's first desktop PCs in random boxes — Intel 8008-powered Q1 PC has 16KB of memory, 800 kHz CPU
Coding on a Vision Pro
So, Vice Media will lay off hundreds of workers and stop publishing on its site, which effectively means that is is basically dead. Vice Media chief Bruce Dixon said the company is transitioning to a "studio model". This news comes after Vice filed for bankruptcy in May 2023 and an overall pretty apocalyptic year for anything media related.
After the mass layoff, Vice will still exist, kind of. No more stories will be published on Vice.com. But Dixon wrote, rather cryptically, that remaining employees will put “more emphasis on our social channels as we accelerate our discussion with partners to take our content to where it will be viewed most broadly.” According to a source familiar with the plans who spoke to The Wall Street Journal, that means Vice will “focus on growing its business-to-business media arm, including its production studio and creative agency.”
Rumors have it that later this week, “they're deleting the vice website“.
Old fart storytime: When Vice Media started their advertising business and sold adspace on blogs fifteen years ago or so, my old website was one of the first in germany to partner with them. I made some pretty decent bucks, but they also constantly pushed unwanted popup-ads on my site which i heavily protested mentioning our contract to which i added a clause that i will review any ad that will be pushed on my blog. They really didn't like me for that.
So, given that the best part of Vice — the tech blog Motherboard — already formed a new band and launched the excellent editor-owned 404 Media, and the fact that Vice Media was founded in part by rightwing extremist Gavin McInnes, i'll say good riddance to Vice Media, and never come back.
The VICE CMS has been turned off. That's all folks.
The Dark Forest BookThe "The Dark Forest Collective" released The Dark Forest Anthology of the Internet, a book containing foundational writings of what we call the "dark forest web", the unindexed part of the internet in private chatrooms, discord servers and messaging platforms.
The Anthology contains:
The Dark Forest Theory of the Internet by Yancey Strickler
The Extended Internet Universe by Venkatesh Rao
The Dark Forest and the Cozy Web by Maggie Appleton
Chapel Perilous by Peter Limberg and Rebecca Fox
Moving Castles: Modular and Portable Multiplayer Miniverses by Arthur Röing Baer and GNV908
The internet didn’t kill counterculture—you just won’t find it on Instagram by Caroline Busta
The Expanding Dark Forest and Generative AI by Maggie Appleton
Holographic Media by Caroline Busta and Lil Internet
and more.
Jonathan Haidt talked about "The Fragmentation of Everything" in a Zoom talk with The Village Square. I just wrote a piece on Cultural Memory in the Digital which sums up my thoughts about the reasons for that fragmentation of everything. Jon Haidts talk is up on Youtube too:
What if, at a pinnacle of our civilization’s technological achievement, everything just broke — the institutions we’ve come to rely upon in navigating a modern complex world, the shared stories that hold a large and diverse democratic republic together, and even a common language through which to navigate the rising tide of crisis.
According to renowned social psychologist and author Jonathan Haidt, this describes our current reality, one that he calls “After Babel.” In this new normal, we are scattered by a digital environment into feuding tribes that are governed by mob dynamics and driven by a minority of ideological outliers, made stupid at warp speed by group think, and — thanks to social media — armed with billions of metaphorical “dart guns” with which to immediately wound “the enemy” in ways that are hardly only metaphorical. What could go wrong?
And speaking of Jonathan Haidt, his book The Coddling of the American Mind has been turned into a documentary streaming on Substack (i didn't know they do this now). You have to subscribe for at least 8 bucks so i didn't see it.
// JUST THE HEADLINESOut of the rabbit hole? New research shows people can change their minds about conspiracy theories: "A study of 498 Australians and New Zealanders finds 'no evidence that individual beliefs in conspiracy theories increased on average over time.'" This study confirms a previous one which also found that "in no instance (did) we observe systematic evidence for an increase in conspiracism, however operationalized".
Ted Gioia wrote about "The State of Culture in 2024", identifying a culture of atomized entertainment bits driven by addiction and dopamine. Ryan Broderick adds that this is not an outcome but a symptom of a phase of media unbundling on the internet, where "every app or feed is also its own community, platform, information ecosystem, movie theater, newsstand, while also not quite functioning well as any of those things." Both are right, but don't mention the inevitable countermove: valuable in such a world are the non-addictive, the not dopamine-driven, the long, the authentic, the physical, the haptic. And those will be expensive af.
How the MAGA-fed Taylor Swift conspiracy theories reached the Pentagon. Interestingly, the MAGA-conspiracy creates its own conspirational version on the left where some think this lunacy was created intentionally to "stir up this controversy in the hopes that she refrains from endorsing Joe Biden."
Tinder, Hinge ‘deliberately’ turn users into swiping addicts, lawsuit says. You turn sexually available people into dragable images you can sort unto fuckable and unfuckable and combine it with a gamified probability of real life contact and you get addiction. That’s totally not surprising to me.
Musk’s X sold checkmarks to Hezbollah and other terrorist groups, because ofcourse he did.
‘It went nuts’: Thousands join UK parents calling for smartphone-free childhood
It's time to add friction to digital experiences: "'Slow computing' could provide the safety belt, airbags and crumple zones needed to keep us from becoming digital roadkill."
A Marketplace of Girl Influencers Managed by Moms and Stalked by Men. Underage "Girl Influencers managed by their moms" already gives me the creeps.
These are great: Stickers to Manage Replies By, here's the whole set on Flickr.
February on course to break unprecedented number of heat records: "February is on course to break a record number of heat records, meteorologists say, as human-made global heating and the natural El Niño climate pattern drive up temperatures on land and oceans around the world."
We're peak El Niño now so that explains at least some of the acceleration and unpredecented heat records, but February is "on course for 2°C of warming above pre-industrial levels" and surely this will not prevail, but this graph also surely will not return to the 1991-2021 average, that much i can tell you:
And this is bonkers: "In the first half of this month, Herrera said 140 countries broke monthly heat records, which was similar to the final figures of the last six record hottest months of 2023 and more than three times any month before 2023."
AI and Tech impact on climate and environmentMeasuring AI’s Environmental Impacts Requires Empirical Research and Standards and How much electricity do AI generators consume?: Researchers calculated, "that by 2027 the AI sector could consume between 85 to 134 terawatt hours each year. That’s about the same as the annual energy demand of (...) the Netherlands."
“You’re talking about AI electricity consumption potentially being half a percent of global electricity consumption by 2027,” de Vries tells The Verge. “I think that’s a pretty significant number.”
A recent report by the International Energy Agency offered similar estimates, suggesting that electricity usage by data centers will increase significantly in the near future thanks to the demands of AI and cryptocurrency. The agency says current data center energy usage stands at around 460 terawatt hours in 2022 and could increase to between 620 and 1,050 TWh in 2026 — equivalent to the energy demands of Sweden or Germany, respectively.
Interestingly, in a "warning on climate and technology" published by a group of "united academics" in the Journal of Cleaner Production, researchers said that "AI presents far less energy-intensive alternatives to laborious tasks like writing and illustration and is becoming adept at writing computer code, which could come in handy in managing the 'complexities of 8 billion-plus people cohabiting on Earth'". The same lead author also wrote a paper about how the carbon emissions of writing and illustrating are lower for AI than for humans.
However, AI can only reduce carbon emissions if there is no rebound effect (where the energy efficiency of AI models gets eaten up by higher adoption rates) and AI substitutes human labor without people finding other energy intensive occupations. If i were that group of "united academics", i wouldn't bet on that.
"The generative AI revolution comes with a planetary cost that is completely unknown to us (...) The tl;dr is we just don’t know."
Re-Insurance profits rise 580% and this is not goodInsurance giant Swiss Re posts 580% jump in full-year profit: Re-Insurance is an insurance for insurance companies, and an 580% rise in profit means that privately oriented insurance companies for you and me and the businesses need more money from them to cover their cost.
This jump in profit comes from three sources: A period of low economic activity due to the covid pandemic, inflation, and climate change. They explicitly state so: "With climate change, risks have increased a lot and you could see it in our profits, which were not adequate over the last few years. And so this is a reaction, a reassessment of the risk. To a certain extent, what we see here ... is the price for climate change for the first time coming at the door of regular consumers."
For now, Swiss Re is obviously happy with those profits. The question is what they gonna do when consumers can't afford insurance anymore, which is already happening, and that problem escalates due to ever increasing risks and insurance costs. A 2019 report from Munich Re already found that climate change could make insurance too expensive for most people, which would mean that either the state has to subsidize consumer insurance or the whole thing will become a luxury market for corporations and the rich.
Given that especially re-insurance companies are interested in longterm planning, i'd consider both of these anything but a stable future scenario for my business and get very nervous.
// JUST THE HEADLINESEnd fossil-fuel era to address colonial injustices, urges prominent historian: "A mayor who makes her city fossil-free by 2040 has done more against colonialism, racism and discrimination than another mayor who decolonises all the street names, statues and schoolbooks while keeping the city running on fossil fuels"
New report on water security: Troubling Waters: Understanding Water Security: "The world is not on the precipice of a global water crisis: it is decades into an escalating catastrophe."
Nanoplastics in water - surprisingly large amounts discovered and its not looking good and a video on Microplastics: The Hidden Health Crisis. A 2023 study found that Microplastics infiltrate all systems of body (and) cause behavioral changes, so yeah they are very bad, and Nanoplastics which are smaller than 1 micrometer (μm) / 1000 nanometer (nm) will be not good either, in fact: "nanoplastics seem much worse than microplastics."
Big firms with $7 tn exit climate investment group "that aims to pressure companies to quickly cut carbon emissions. (...) Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton applauded the news", adding on Twitter that "this is a critical step toward putting customers' financial well-being first." I hope customers' financial well-being is cooked by some juicy heat records.
Real-world time-travel experiment shows ecosystem collapse due to anthropogenic climate change: Researchers examined the "coastal ecosystem change during 13 years of unusually rapid, albeit likely temporary, sea-level rise ( > 10 mm yr−1) in the Gulf of Mexico", finding that "under the current climate trajectory (SSP2-4.5), drowning of ~75% of Louisiana’s coastal wetlands is a plausible outcome by 2070".
Scientists Resort to Once-Unthinkable Solutions to Cool the Planet: Time to read Neal Stephensons Termination Shock: "Three geoengineering projects seek to alter the chemistry of the atmosphere and the ocean. Critics warn of unintended consequences."
Turns out, i'm an apocalyptic optimist when it comes to climate change: Apocalyptic Optimism Could Be the Antidote for Climate Fatalism: "I call myself an apocalyptic optimist. I believe we can save ourselves from the climate crisis that we have caused; I also believe it will only be possible with a mass mobilization driven by the pain and suffering of climate shocks around the world. As the social effects of climate shocks grow in both frequency and severity, I predict they will motivate an AnthroShift where personal and economic risk reaches a critical threshold that leads people to alter their behaviors and force governments and businesses to transition aggressively away from fossil fuels." In 2022, the author wrote a paper on the "large-scale and sustained levels of risk that have tangible long-term consequences in terms of social cost to people and property" that have to be experienced before societies move their asses.
I absolutely would eat lab grown meat rice made from fish gelatin and cow cells: Lab-grown ‘beef rice’ could offer more sustainable protein source, say creators: "Bowls of decidedly pink-tinged rice are about to feature on sustainable food menus, according to researchers who created rice grains with beef and cow fat cells grown inside them. Scientists made the experimental food by covering traditional rice grains in fish gelatin and seeding them with skeletal muscle and fat stem cells which were then grown in the laboratory."
First megastudy of climate messages hints at what works: Climate-Doom increased "willingness to share by 12%", but "decreased climate policy support among climate skeptics, and decreased support for tree planting in the overall study sample". So i guess the best climate messaging is doom and gloom with a glimmer of hope.
‘It’s almost carbon-negative’: how hemp became a surprise building material
Amazon rainforest could reach ‘tipping point’ by 2050, scientists warn
Leading Lab-Grown Meat Company Upside Foods Just Paused a Major Expansion
‘Like the flip of a switch, it’s gone’: has the ecosystem of the UK’s largest lake collapsed?
What will Spain look like when it runs out of water? Barcelona is giving us a glimpse
Bleaching fears along 1,000km stretch of the Great Barrier Reef
Herd of puppets to trek 20,000km to highlight urgency of climate crisis, artist Amir Nizar Zuabi just gave a TED talk announcing his act of theater to spark climate action:
First brain-wide map shows how sex and intimacy rewire the brain: Researchers "created the first brain-wide map of regions that are active in prairie voles during mating and pair bonding" and found that "bonding voles experience a storm of brain activity distributed across 68 distinct brain regions that make up seven brain-wide circuits. The brain activity correlates with three stages of behavior: mating, bonding, and the emergence of a stable, enduring bond."
They also found that "'orgasms' coordinate the formation of a bond (which) would imply that orgasms can serve as a means to promote connection, as has long been suggested in humans."
In my thinking, memes are fields and memetics is measurable through brain synchrony, like when we synchronize brain activity at a live concert or collaborative decision making. As this study shows, our brains might heavily synchronize during sex, which, arguably, involves a lot of "collaborative decision making". Which could mean that Love is the strongest meme of them all.
That's nice and now i want a study of interbrain synchrony in fucking couples.
// JUST THE HEADLINESResearchers found music predictor neurons and "developed a precise map of what is happening in the cerebral cortex when someone hears a melody. It turns out to be doing two things at once: following the pitch of a note, using two sets of neurons that also follow the pitch of speech, and trying to predict what notes will come next, using a set of neurons that are specific to music. The (...) group of neurons (...) devoted to predicting melodic notes (...) are described here for the first time."
From a recent study on the effects of exercise on depression: "just dancing has the largest effect of any treatment for depression" and here's my certified depression lifting sideblog featuring a lot of good music to dance to. (I wonder if handbanging counts too?)
Why Americans Suddenly Stopped Hanging Out: "From 2003 to 2022, American men reduced their average hours of face-to-face socializing by about 30 percent. For unmarried Americans, the decline was even bigger—more than 35 percent. For teenagers, it was more than 45 percent."
The adult consequences of being bullied in childhood are dire: "Bullying negatively impacts subjective well-being between ages 16 and 62 and raises the probability of mortality before age 55. It also lowers the probability of having a job in adulthood. These effects are independent of other adverse childhood experiences."
A new look at our linguistic roots: "A controversial analytic technique offers new answers for Indo-European languages."
For Jung, architecture was a tool to represent the psyche: How Jung came up with his archetypes after dreaming up a house.
Nature vs nurture: Twin study sheds light on heritable brain activity
How We Sort the World: Gregory Murphy on the Psychology of Categories: Interview with Gregory L. Murphy on his book Categories We Live By: How We Classify Everyone and Everything.
Mind-reading devices are revealing the brain’s secrets: Miryam Naddaf at Nature on the history of "implants and other technologies that decode neural activity".
'Movies' with color and music visualize brain activity data in beautiful detail
Donald Hoffman and Anil Seth on how the reality we experience every day is an illusion and whether or not AI will ever become conscious.
From Genes To Memes: Richard Dawkins interviews Daniel Dennett on the evolution of language and AI.
Sam Mendes to Direct Four Beatles Films: "The British director Sam Mendes has signed on to direct not one but four biopics about the Beatles, each telling the story of the Fab Four from a different member’s point of view." Apple Corps has granted full rights to the life stories of John, Paul, George and Ringo plus the music rights, the movies are set for a release in 2027 in an "innovative and groundbreaking" manner.
I love the idea of four movies about each Beatle, but i'm not sure about the "innovative and groundbreaking" manner of release. If those movies are all set for 2027, i guess they'll be released all at once? Or successive over the summer?
I would've loved a more narrative approach, telling the story in "order of appearance" in the history of the band, which would mean to start with Lennon, then add Pauls perspective, then George and then Ringo. You could also start backwards, tell the history of the Beatles starting with Ringo who joined an already full fledged band during the recording of "Love Me Do", and then tell each members story adding ever more details from early band history. Then release those movies over a four year period, or whatever.
This approach also would remind one of Stanley Kubricks "The Killing", which tells its story of a heist from the different perspectives of the gangsters, going from unimportant complice to the main protagosnist, adding ever more detail to the story which we see continguingly repeated from different point of views.
That way, you could start with the recording of "Love Me Do", repeat that scene in the middle of the next movie from the perspective of George Harrison, then from the perspective of Paul McCartney, and finally that of John Lennon whose movie would start with him founding The Blackjacks at the age of 16 back in 1956 with some friends from highschool, the band that would over several years transform into The Beatles in 1960.
This approach would give all four movie a narrative umbrella which would not be random and each movie would build on top of each other. The drawback of this would be that you would emphasize importance of band members, with Ringo getting the "small biopic at the beginning" and John the "towering final conclusion". I'm not sure about that, but would still love to see those four movies in a day long sitting as one giant biopic of the most important band in the world.
// TRAILERSTrailer for Bertrand Bonellos The Beast, a black mirroresque scifi story set in the near future where "artificial intelligence controls all facets of a stoic society as humans routinely erase their feelings. Hoping to eliminate pain caused by their past-life romances, Gabrielle (Léa Seydoux) continually falls in love with different incarnations of Louis (George MacKay)."
Trailer for spider horror flick Sting. I have a mid range arachnophobia which means that any spider under 1cm is fine and i might even save it and anything above 1cm and/or hairy is dead on sight. Needles to say, i love giant spider movies and this looks like a good one.
New trailer for Alex Garlands Civil War. I'm torn about this. One one hand, it sure looks like a not too unrealistic and maybe necessary story to shake up some stuff, if it can deliver it's message. On the other hand, russia is already messing with desinformation about a Texas secession, playing exactly into the hands of rightwing lunatics dreaming of civil war scenarios like those depicted here. I just hope that Alex Garland handled this topic with care.
The trailler for the movie adaptation of the game Borderlands starring Cate Blanchett, Kevin Hart and Jack Black, and this actually looks kinda fun?
Trailer for Boy Kills World, "a dystopian fever dream action film that follows Boy, a deaf mute with a vibrant imagination. When his family is murdered, he is trained by a mysterious shaman to repress his childish imagination and become an instrument of death."
More trailers worth watching: Godzilla x Kong: The New Empire Trailer 2, Knox Goes Away (Dementia themed thriller with Michael Keaton), Monolith (scifi thriller about "a strange artifact, an alien conspiracy"), Lovely, Dark, and Deep (horrorfilm about a ranger uncovering a secret in the wilderness), The Invisible Fight (a "black metal kung fu comedy" from russia), Another End (italian scifi-melodrama about AI-resurrection of the dead), The Tattooist of Auschwitz (I want to read the book so i'll give this a shot), The Fox (in which a nazi soldier bonds with a fox), The Gentlemen Trailer 2 (the Guy Ritchie series still looks good), Rose's War (dramatization of the life of Rose Dugdale, an elite english woman who joined the irish IRA), Lousy Carter (low budget comedy featuring everybody's favorite nerd Martin Starr), Asphalt City (paramedic themed NYC-thriller featuring Sean Penn who seems to have gotten his act together).
// JUST THE HEADLINESYorgos Lanthimos Sets 'Save the Green Planet' Remake. I've seen Save The Green Planet at the Fantasy Filmfestival ages ago and can barely remember it. Lanthimos is one of my fav contemporary directors (and it fills my heart with joy that his Poor Things gets the recognition it deserves), and seeing him remaking a rather obscure korean scifi flick in which "a disillusioned young man captures and tortures a businessman whom he believes to be part of an alien invasion" is just great.
Lou Reed: Live at The Bottom Line, NYC 1983
Dr No: Sean Connery behind the scenes on the first James Bond film
The "baseline" scene was actually written by Ryan Gosling": Cool analysis of Blade Runner 2049 and how the Voight Kampff machine relates to the baseline test.
Last spring when free speech absolutist Elon Musk surpressed free speech on Twitter, i was happy to report the abolutely true and scientifically proven fact that Elon Musk lacks a critical bodypart, namely that "Elon Musk has no balls", adding that "he has, indeed, no testicles, no balls, a complete lack of reproductive organs" and that "A press release from Twitter HQ reads: 'It is true, our CEO has no balls. Never had.'"
Now, in an another unexpected twist, scientists grew teeny tiny testicles in a lab. These scientists confirmed in an exclusive interview with GOOD INTERNET that, yes, these organoid synth-balls were developed and realized with a fund coming from Elon Musk personally, who wants the organoid testicle-tech to be applied to his private parts asap.
Rumours coming out of Hollywood tell us that Mel Brooks renamed his long planned Spaceballs sequel into Synthballs, where Lord Helmet is renamed into Lord Hairtransplant and the evil emperor doesn't suck air out of the atmosphere, but sucks the fun out of social media.
On a personal note, i love that Musk literally followed the advice of the spokespersons from Mastodon and Substack who in a joint statement commented on this lack of organ back then: “We think that Elon Musk should grow a pair“. He did and i'm happy for the clown.
// JUST THE HEADLINES100 Notable Books of 2023 from The New York Times and The 100 Best Books of 2023 according to 1,542 Authors
The Last Linotype Newspaper: Operating the Saguache Crescent
Secret Mathematical Patterns Revealed in Bach's Music. I'd love to see Gödel Escher Bach-author Douglas Hofstadter commenting on this.
Cost and Features of bunkers built by billionaires to survive an apocalypse: The billionaires build their society-exit-strategies with "fiery moats and water cannons" for the rest of us.
A Rainbow "over Hawaii at 2000 ft of altitude"
Germany on track to partly legalise cannabis for personal use. It's about time. (Update: “Germany’s parliament has passed a law allowing individuals and voluntary associations to grow and hold limited quantities of cannabis, making it the latest in a small group of countries and jurisdictions to legalise the drug, at least in part.”)
Elle Cordovas latest has inventions hanging out and she's still the best.
@elle.cordovaInventions hanging out #history #civilization #inventions #skit #sketchcomedy Tiktok failed to load.UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.Jan Assmann, a german egyptologist, archeologist, semiologist, historian and intellectual, died two days ago (link in german) at the age of 85 in the city of Konstanz, where he taught at the university together with his wife Aleida since the 1960s. Their cultural and academic influence was massive, and their works on semiotics and history is unvaluable.
Together with his wife Aleida, he coined the term of cultural memory, in which societies express their heritage in monuments, scripture and, most importantly, canons, in an intergenerational dialogue that is foundational for all culture, politics and our image of the world. I’ve read his book on the topic twice (and i’m reading a book from his wife on semiotics right now).
This concept informed a lot of my thinking about digital cultures and how they differentiate from previous cultures, because the digital inherently knows no mechanisms for cultural memory. The web and the digital at large works as a humanly written RAM, which anyone with access can read and write and which happens on a grand scale in every second of every minute of the day, inscribing our collective short-term-memory with fleeting memetic expressions of stuff that happened.
As W. David Marx in No Canon for Old Memes correctly writes, "Memes are cheap, fast, and disposable. They lose their cultural value instantly (...) Memes should be understood as a medium for expression on contemporary matters. But what is said or celebrated at any moment is only meant for that moment."
There is no mechanism for a longterm cultural memory in the digital, everything stays fluid and is edited by a giant swarm of humans in every moment. The digital turns cultural memory in a constant river of changing cultural expressions.
But a cultural memory by definition is fixed, it’s canonized knowledge, it expresses itself over time in crystalized shapes and in things that shall not be changed. Society memorizes its history in mythologies, expressed in the arts, in rituals, in literature, in architecture and monuments, in a shared practice of doing things. Comparable to the biological neural memory in the single human brain we collectively write our history into culture.
This results in canons, which in their purest form are collections of holy scriptures that, after an initual phase of formative writing, become unchangeable by means of a social contract of agreement. The canon and the monument is what lies outside of our daily fights over meanings, it is what forms societywide consensus reality.
But canons are not limited to scripture, any form of collective cultural expression develops canons, from movies to music to skateboarding, and the canon is always in a resonant dialogue with cultural evolution and innovation, the unchangeable always talks to the yet unknown at the fringes, which, possibly, maybe, by human engagement and collective willpower, over time, one day may become canonized too.
This resonance between the fixed canonized and the innovative expands cultural spacetime and the way Jimi Hendrix shreds his guitar, one day, after many iterations and ritualizations, becomes, too, a way we do things in this society, and the formerly innovator enters the canon of guitar shredding.
The digital is inherently incompatible with this way of collective memorization, the very foundation of what glues societies together and makes them work in the long run. There is “no canon for old memes”, and cultural practice in the digital is in an ever changing, never remembered flux.
Because there is no mechanism for canonization in the digital, it has done great damage to societies' cultural memory, to our collective mnemonic devices for intergenerational dialogue about who we are and what we do and how we do it.
Truth is what connects usIn their 2018 acceptance speech for the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade, Jan Assmann and his wife Aleida quoted german psychiatrist Karl Jaspers who said that "truth is what connects us", the stories we tell, the memes we share, the monuments we errect and the canons we collectively agree upon, in an act of "persistent cultural labor".
But that "truth which connects us" in the digital is changing in every nanosecond. There is no long term memory in digital culture, no collective intergenerational mnemonic device to recall the historic, the relevant and the important over generations. There is a lot of "persistent cultural labor", but it always stays fluid and momentary, a shapeshifting swarm of cultural expression that provides a prismatic truth in a billion interpretations of events, but those never converge on a consensus reality, they are never agreed upon and thus, they are not memorized in an unchanging manner. There is no ROM (Read Only Memory) in digital culture.
Cultural memory as per Jan Assmann is also inherently violent, to which a human history rich in age long religious wars over canonized scriptures and crystalized ideologies, a myriad of toppled monuments and tore down palaces, lay testament. The absence of mechanisms for fixed cultural memories in digital informed societies in which we collectively construct collective identities along shared histories, myths and stories, is bound to create a good deal of chaos within those societies, which is exactly what we see today.
Again, the Assmanns quote Karl Jaspers, who identified Untruth as "the inherently evil, that destroys any peace", and which comes in many shapes, from "from veiling to blind carelessness, from lies to self deception, from thoughtlessness to doctrinaire fanaticism, from the inauthentic individual to the untruthfulness of the public condition". They continue that the "universe of communication has become infinitely more rich, flexible and diverse" but also "significantly more chaotic and above all, more uncertain".
It is this uncertainty in cultural memory which causes neverending culture wars over the meanings of recent history, and in the constant flux of the digital we can never agree, never form consensus, never canonize what shapes our identities and makes us who we are. With the loss of reliable mechanisms for the formation of cultural memory in digital informed societies, we are in great danger of losing our very collective selves.
The Internet Archive as a webcultural institution is one way to work against this fluidity of the medium, to form a constant image that remains and stays reliable. But the Internet Archive does not canonize, it is just a constantly evolving, additive snapshot chunk of a swarming activity. It’s success at being a component of true cultural memory for the digital is, at least, debatable.
In their acceptance speech, the Assmans also said: “It is absolutely fundamental that we can trust each other.” In the digital, trust is fundamentally impossible.
And this thought keeps me up all night.
I first read Jan Assmanns writings on cultural memory seven years ago, and despite his books are pretty much exclusively about ancient history in Egypt and Israel, his thinking stays highly relevant in this new age of the digital and provides some necessary historic larger frameworks that a lot of network theorizing lacks.
Goodnite Jan, and thanks for all the histories.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.OpenAIs release of its video model Sora made me think about the real and the fake again. In a previous post, i already wrote about some technical implications and timeframes in context of movie production, but here, i want to talk about the weirdness of it all, which goes beyond AI-tech and hallucinations alone.
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
The Weird and the EerieIn his posthumously published book The Weird and the Eerie, Mark Fisher described some of the "anomalous" fiction published in the 20th century wich worked to "de-center the human subject".
Here's Mark Fisher (not) talking about Deepfakes in his chapter Approaching the Eerie:
The weird is constituted by a presence — the presence of that which does not belong.
Here's Mark Fisher (not) talking about pretty much all image and video synthesis:
The eerie, by contrast, is constituted by a failure of absence or by a failure of presence. The sensation of the eerie occurs either when there is something present where there should be nothing , or is there is nothing present when there should be something.
He also writes that the questioning of authenticity and constitution of a thing inherently belongs to the weird and the eerie.
A bird’s cry is eerie if there is a feeling that there is something more in (or behind) the cry than a mere animal reflex or biological mechanism — that there is some kind of intent at work, a form of intent that we do not usually associate with a bird.
What exactly is strange about it? Is, perhaps, the bird possessed — and if it is, by what kind of entity? Such speculations are intrinsic to the eerie, and once the questions and enigmas are resolved, the eerie immediately dissipates.
This describes very accurately what is happening in the digital realm, not just since the advent of AI. On the web and in the digital, we constantly question the realness and the intent of what we read, see and hear.
"On the internet, noone knows you are a dog" is a statement about the weird, "the presence of that which does not belong" -- dogs afaik don't use the web very much and it is very unlikely that you meet a dog on social media. What the dog-meme as a metaphor says is that you can never be sure about who you're talking to, what you see and what you hear. The unknown, anonymous user/dog is weird as an entity that is inherently cut off from consensus reality by choice.
It is also a statement about the user/dog's eerieness, because you can never be sure about the intent of why that the "human pretending"-entity is doing that. Is that account a scam, a fake, a criminal, a honest person with a very high priority of privacy, a bad actor, a good actor, a state sponsored troll? You can't know. In the digital, you can never know. Encapsulated in the digital, mediated reality forever is doomed to be weird and eerie, and it has been since it's very inception.
Correlate EverythingAs the meme goes, AI is a Shoggoth, and nothing describes the weird and the eerie of AI better than H.P. Lovecrafts opening line in The Call of Cthulhu:
The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents.
Not not-weird and the not-eerie, the stuff we know and love, were we feel home and whole, is what we can relate to each other, which is never everything.
I've written plenty about how AI is making all the data it sucked up into an automatized knowledge interpolator, and what is the interpolation of data points other than "correlating all its contents"?
We invented machines to produce Mark Fisherian essays in the style of Ramones punk songs, which can be turned into a prompt for the image synthesization of a Picasso painting: Correlating all data points to all it's contents is weird and eerie. A Mark Fisher essay in the style of The Ramones does not belong to either Fisher or The Ramones, it's neither philosophy nor punk, it is weird and it is a failure of presence.
Arguably, the interpolative possibilities in a multimilliondimensional latent space are near infinite. Arguably, the number of narratives and stories posted every day in the web are, too, so large that we can't possibly grasp them.
It's a new infinity of "endless symbols" entering our daily lives on pocket computers we stare at all day, "doomscrolling" from funny vids to political outrage to sincere art to spam and ads to bits of news until our brains are mush and we're in dire need for digital detox.
The digital was inherently weird and eerie long before statistical models came into being, where a swarm of users was and is "correlating all its contents" to a much larger extend than we mere humans are able to do or to grasp. The advent of AI merely makes visible the inherent weirdness lurking behind the "task solving abilities" of boundless correlated digital data, which is both a property of AI aswell as swarm intelligence.
It's exactly that unsettling, unnerving, uncanny feeling in the face of the infinite that Lovecraft talked about in his stories of cosmic horror, and which Mark Fisher so profoundly identified as weird and eerie.
We carry around this weirdness on pocket computers and talk to it, day by day, and sometimes, we call them black mirrors.
The Post-FictionalWith lovecraftian Unknown Unknowns populating our daily lives, where we can never be sure what is the fictional and the real, or if we are narrator or the audience, we enter an age of the post-fictional.
By dissolving the difference of subject and object in the digital space, the weird and the eerie takes hold of and enters the real world through postfictional narratives. The postfictional layers atomized bits of the factual and the fictional into new narrative objects which are weird and eerie in a Fisherian sense.
If you take AI hypesters by their words (and you shouldn't), then AI has "read all of the internet" and "seen all of art history". Arguably and beyond hype, AI has seen and read enough to put out plausible text and somewhat believable imagery of anything.
We don't know yet if the much talked about "hallucinations" will ever vanish to such an extend, to make AI output truly reliable or in the case of imagery, truly indifferentiatable from photography. CGI has still not crossed the uncanny valley since the first computer animated scenes in the 80s and we can still see when "there is something present where there should be nothing" or when there is a "presence of that which does not belong".
But let's suppose we do cross that line and synthetic, computed images, video and text become truly indifferentiatable from humanly produced fictions and physical realities. This, then, would fully enable "the human mind to correlate all (the worlds) contents", to fully dissolve the difference between the fictional and the real, while the networked swarming activity of narration and reception makes sure that everybody is storyteller and audience at the same time.
AI and the digital traps us in a postfictional freudian uncanny, the Unheimlich in german, the un-home-ly, "where a familiar thing or event is encountered in an unsettling, eerie, or taboo context".
Here are some recent headlines illustrating our new post-fictional world, the dissolution of the boundaries between the fictional and consensus reality: the victims of gun violence and mass shootings lobby congress from beyond the grave, After breakups, the brokenhearted are creating AI clones of their exes, and Deepfake electioneering sparks AI 'return' of controversial dictator Suharto.
These are just some of the post-fictional stories of digital hauntology, where digital ghosts of the past manifest in the present by relating datapoints in a latent space to all contents in the world, where the swarming virality of those ghosts “de-center the human subject” and blur the boundaries of the narrator and her audience.
This is a world of Freuds Unheimlich, where Mark Fishers weird and the eerie meets a swarm of billions of users which, all together, create a new post-fictional space in the digital.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.The funniest story in AI last week surely was that Air Canada must honor refund policy invented by airline’s chatbot. Besides the fact that a corporate robot is part of the corporation and thus the corporation is liable for the actions of the robot, it is remarkable how Air Canada argued in court:
In effect, Air Canada suggests the chatbot is a separate legal entity that is responsible for its own actions. This is a remarkable submission.
They went even further and said that Air Canada "cannot be held liable for information provided by one of its agents, servants, or representatives – including a chatbot", which suggests that Air Canada thinks that it doesn't exist as a legal entity, as a corporation that consists of it's employees and products. I would suggest that Air Canada or its lawyers were not thinking very much when they made up that nonsensical argument and ofcourse the court didn't follow.
This episode is interesting besides it's legal shenanigans because we do have a word for "seperate legal entity" and that is legal personhood, and following Air Canadas argument here would mean that their chatbot would be legally recognized as a person, with it's own rights and responsibilites — in this case: Don't lie to our customer, chatbot, or you'll be held responsible and pay for the damages.
The debate of robot rights is old and came to mainstream prominence through Isaac Asimovs famed shortstory I, Robot. Many many books and essays have been written about the implications of AI or robots developing consciousness and if and how we as humans owe them legal rights, if that ever should be the case. For now and the foreseeable future, that's a neat intellectual exercise in the realm of science fiction, but not a legally pressing issue. AI systems are statistical models not able to perform any cognitive human functions. LLMs can simulate language, but they can't use language, because they lack any symbolic representation in their neural networks. They are not persons, but products, and the corporations developing them are legally responsible.
All of which, ofcourse, doesn't mean we don't anthropomorphize them.
In a 2015 paper robot researcher Kate Darling described "Empathic Concern and the Effect of Stories in Human-Robot Interaction", in which she finds that "story-shaped" robots (like, say, a Tamagochi or a Robot-Dinosaur -- Robots that resemble fictional or real life creatures that we project consciousness into) create emphatic reactions in humans.
LLMs and their simulated language are very much "story-shaped" robots in the literal meaning of the words, and anthropomorphizing them just comes natural to us: Toddlers at the age of nine months in a 'socio-cognitive revolution' first develop an understanding of another human as similar to themselves, as intentional beings, the first step to a theory of mind. This enables them to develop shared intentionality with other humans (parents, sibblings, friends) where both are focussing on the same thing and check each others attention. This enables kids to develop language and understanding of symbolic representations by imitation, to connect words to the signified object and, slowly, build a symbolic representation of their environment in their head, a world model. This also means that intelligence, the ability to form those models and then combine, dissect, transform them is inherently social.
But this also means that we, by human nature that is social, inherently ascribe cognitive functions to any system that can produce text, utter words, speak, point at and identify things, just like us. Where Tamagochis and Robots have a face for us to relate to, an LLM has text. It's just as synthetic and non-human as the plasticface on a robot, or the display on a Tamagochi, but that doesn't matter. We can't help it because it is built into our biology to recognize humans, and so we are bound to recognize a ghost in the machine where there is none.
Now, I don't think that Air Canada is suggesting that their chatbot is conscious or anything, i don't even think they anthropomorphize the chatbot on their website. But I do think they used this discourse around anthropomorphization and legal personhood for AI and it's philosophical implications as their last straw argument to save, what, 880 canadian dollars? That’s laughable corporate legal bullshit and nothing more.
However, the discourse about AI personhood gets interesting in context of what is called "responsible AI". The logic goes like, if you assign legal personhood to AI, it will make AI liable for it's own actions. If AI goes wrong and starts maximizing paperclips, we can at least sue them in court. (What a relief.)
We should be thankful to Air Canada and it's lawyers and the court to clear this one up: We already have legal responsibilities in AI, and they lie within the corporations that develop them. Air Canada is responsible for the bullshit their chatbot tells to its customers, which might also extend to ongoing defamation lawsuits against OpenAI. Just as Air Canadas chatbot is not a "seperate legal entity" with its own personality rights and responsibilities, ChatGPT is not a legal entity on it's own that can "hallucinate" bullshit about you or me or anyone else, but a product made by OpenAI, who are ultimately responsible for the damages it causes.
This would also apply to possible AI-systems of the future who found, steer and head new corporations: The legal personhood for them, then, would already exist as a legal fiction, without any need for a seperate personhood for the algorithm. Corporations led by sophisticated statistical models and human-organized corporations simply operate under the same rights and obligations with no need for "seperate legal entities".
In his good, long primer on the subject Lance Eliot calls this the "magic trick of pulling a rabbit out of a hat". But the trick here would not be to simply assign legal personhood to a corporation led by an AI (or the lame old corporation that merely develops said AI), but to not anthropomorphize it within the legal system.
As humans we can't help but see a ghost in the machine, but the law may not be prone to our psychological failings. Air Canada learned that the hard way in court and now must pay 880 bucks. I guess they'll get over it.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.So, OpenAI released a new video model called Sora that's capable of generating up to one minute of HD video. The results are impressive, and given the media storm around it, you probably heard about it.
I won't bore you with the nth iteration of how capable the model is, just watch the demos:
If you can’t get enough of it, here’s 24 Sora examples from Twitter/X that are not in OpenAI's Sora webpage.
Sora and AI-video in general has three implications: Technical regarding movies and games, technical regarding computer vision and AGI, and philosophical regarding perception of mediated reality. (I'll leave out the ethical implications of dataset creation with unlicensed material without compensation for now.)
I'll discuss the first two technical implications (AI for movies and entertainment, and Sora for AGI-world models) in this post, and follow up with some musings on the philosophical implications in the coming days.
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
Sora at the MoviesWhile fanboys on the tweeties will tell you that we'll see AI-generated movies, like, tomorrow, AI-tech to be actually usable for movies are at least a decade away. Sure, we do see a lot of shortfilms coming out of this and Runway launched an AI Shortfilm Festival last year, but besides its novelty factor and experimental setup, these films are not very interesting from a cineastic perspective. They are weird and interesting for being so, but that's pretty much all there is. And if they are not weird, they are generic. (Yet.)
Ask yourself how a movie creates intensity. It is never the otherworldly outlandish orgy of visuals that you can create, but actors conveying a more-than-just-believable emotion that you can feel while they act it out on a screen. This, in combination with precise camera movements, framing and lighting, encodes what a film is trying to say into a sequence of frames.
Movies are not merely plausible. Movies are more than believable. A good movie touches you, because you can relate, make a connection to the character on screen and that's hard to do. Nothing you see in a movie is coincidental down to the very smallest details like the fly on the face of Jack Elam in Once Upon a Time in the West.
In generative AI, everything is coincidental and it is still remarkable just how random the movements of those figures still are, and i don't mean weird hands with that.
In one of those Sora-demo-vids, a woman walks down the street. She walks aimlessly, and we don't get any sense, why she's walking or where she goes. It's just somewhat coherent walking, but the ultimate goal of walking is not to make one step after the other, the goal of walking is to go somewhere. Sure, she's just wandering around, strolling around Tokyo on a busy night, but it still feels unconnected to anything, there's no aim, no meaning behind the movement. And we do see that in that frames, that this woman walking in Tokyo has nowhere to go, she just makes one step after the other. This is not cinematic, this is flat and boring advertising aesthetics.
These aimless and random movements, and all the missing details in mimic and body movement, makes it impossible for synthetic video to convey a more-than-just-believable emotion that you can feel.
At the same time that OpenAI demoed Sora, TikTok published a paper about a new technique they call Boximator for more controlled animation edits, where you can tell an AI that a hand should move up or whatever and with which you can control somewhat, which areas should move and where, but you still can't control how they move. But these techniques lack the finegrained details to make acting work. A hand moving up doesn't say anything about how it should go up, how exactly the singular fingers will move, how the hand rotates, how fast or slow the rythm of the movement should be, how single fingers twist while the hand moves, how the figure contracts it's muscles so that a mere hand movement is viewingly feelable across the whole body on screen. With AI you have no control over any of these, while an actress spends years in class to have exactly this fine grained, exact and precise control over her body.
If you think AI can do this level of detail of bodycontrol of an animated figure within the next 5 years, i'm more than willing to place a bet against it. And then we're still years away to apply this level of detailed movement controll to every object in every frame. Even classic CGI, which is here for 40 years now, is not fully there yet and you can see the difference between CGI and real actors every. single. time. Human eyes are pretty good at identifying real life, you know.
I'm more than convinced that Sora will become good enough to replace some stock video stuff, like Midjourney and Dall-E is good enough to replace some stock photo and generic illustration stuff, because stock media is, too, ultimately aimless and shallow representation of commodified, hollowed out emotions. But, besides some experimental stuff, this is not film and that is not art. I don't think AI will solve that problem for quite a while.
Games are a bit more tricky to assess because they are not as fixed a medium as movies are. Once we see realtime generative video-AI (and that may be a technical hurdle not to be broken for some time, early experimental successess aside), i can absolutely imagine game environments generated on the fly based on user input. Question remains if those are fun to play.
You see, in contrast to what Andrew White says on the tweeties, OpenAI Sora can not simulate Minecraft. It can produce an incoherent video in the same aesthetic, but there's a pig running backwards and the jumps of the character are incoherent and needless to say, Sora can not simulate all the crafting.
Sure, in a few years, you might be able to sort of direct a game and simulate it's world by prescripting your generative game environments with a system prompt, but as with movies: To turn this into a coherent experience that is also fun to play will take a lot of time.
World-Simulators for AGIOpenAI releasing Sora has two reasons: One is to have a generative AI-product to attack the stock video market or provide video tools for moviemakers and make money from this. But the ultimate and bigger goal of OpenAI is not AI-cinema, but creating a world model for future AGI that is capable of "understanding" spatial realities, to build "general purpose simulators of the physical world". The visual output is a byproduct (and a good measurement of AIs "understanding" of those spatial realities).
Arguably, Sora is not anywhere near "understanding" physical reality. I mean sure it's way better at "understanding" what "eating spaghetti" means than the famed Will Smith eating spaghetti-GIF in a sense that while Sora has no idea how Spaghetti tastes and what al dente feels like when you bite pasta, but it clearly shows better "understanding" what noodles do when humans eat them.
Given the speed of advancements in AI-tech, i can imagine AI systems with coherent physical world models within a few years, depending on the quality of training data. "Coherent physical world models" in that context means: An AI system is capable of image recognition and "understanding" object constancy, a psychological feat kids develop at the age of six months and which means that we humans understand that an object stays in physical reality even when it's suddenly hidden by something. When i throw a blanket over a box, the box stays in reality and doesn't vanish. The AI model then "understands": What is a box and what is a blanket and how both behave in reality when they interact in various ways.
Sora is not there yet, clearly. In the demo videos you can sometimes see object constancy, sometimes you can't. Objects sometimes transform after being hidden by something (the windows on a train on a leaf suddenly vanish, a car going by in the background doesn't reappear after driving behind a tree, and so on).
Object constancy isn't the only thing Sora fails at. A dog walking outside a building from one window to the other would clearly fall down, which has nothing to do with "weird mutant hands" but a missing understanding of depth of field in combination with physical reality. Sora doesn't understand that a dog can't walk out of a window like that, it doesn't understand what a dog is and what "outside of a building" is. But if they combine this with image recognition ("what is a building", "what is a window", "what is a dog") with depth of field ("where is the dog in relation to the window and the building") and some knowledge about the physical world ("dogs walking out of windows will fall down"), it soon might develop the physical world model that OpenAI is aiming at.
Meta and their DINOv2 model made some good progress on understanding depth in visual inputs and with V-JEPA, they just released a new architecture for a "physical world model" capable of "detecting and understanding highly detailed interactions between objects". It's clear that both OpenAI and Meta are trying to develop components for multimodal AI-systems that have spatial "understanding" of the world, systems capable to read moving images kind of like we do, to understand movement, displacement, to get a sense for three dimensions, and to combine those visual-physical informations with audio and text.
And they are on to something.
In the fascinating paper Grounded language acquisition through the eyes and ears of a single child, researchers mounted some cameras to the heads of a child while he ran around all day, play, talk silly and point at stuff. They got 61 hours of video in 600,000 frames out of that, annotated with the 37,500 transcribed "utterances" of the child. Then they trained a "generic" neural network on this dataset.
Amazingly, their
model acquire(d) many word-referent mappings present in the child’s everyday experience, enable(d) zero-shot generalization to new visual referents, and align(ed) its visual and linguistic conceptual systems. These results show how critical aspects of grounded word meaning are learnable through joint representation and associative learning from one child’s input.
This study not only points at what AI models with spatial "understanding" combined with language and audio might be capable of in the coming years, but also how limited AI in it's current state still is.
According to (Alison) Gopnik, a psychology professor at University of California, Berkeley, babies have three core skills that AI systems lack. First, babies excel at imaginative model building, creating a conceptual framework to explain the world. They are also curious, adventure loving and embodied learners, actively exploring new environments, rather than being passively encased in lines of code. And babies are social animals, learning from all those they interact with, helping develop empathy, altruism and a moral sensibility.
So, OpenAI and Meta might be on to something, trying to give AI a spatial "understanding" with the goal for AI to be able to develop "physical world models", which correlate to text and audio and result in multimodal AI-Systems. But it's a very long path down that road and they are nowhere near a child which intuitively understands that dogs can't walk outside of buildings, that plastic chairs don't mutate and hover in the air, and that objects are persistent.
And even when we have AI-systems capable of somewhat "understanding" physical reality, i'd still bet that Robert DeNiro will beat them at playing a Schnitzel on the big screen for a very long time.
Take it away, Bob.
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.Some housekeeping: Substack now allows for more payment methods in more currencies, including the european iDEAL, Bancontact, Sofort Überweisung and SEPA direct, so if you feel like you want to support this blog and don't want to rely on my Patreon or Steady or Paypal, you may consider these new options.
In this roundup, you’ll find stories about and links to:
Schrödingers Artworks gets dissolved in acid when Julian Assange dies in prison
Preserving Banksy is impossible
Indonesia hints at the populist AI-election playbook
Judge throws out most of Sarah Silvermans ChatGPT copyright lawsuit
AI-Corps agree to develop anti-deepfake tech, again
The weird art of Niceaunties: Where you get your nails done?
Doom on Audio-Spectrograms
TikToks algo pushes rightwing media
Shut up and eat my trendbait
Art is old and doing Nothing is hard
Warner hates Looney Tunes now
Trailers for Sasquatch Sunset, Love Lies Bleeding, The Animals Kingdom, Late Night with the Devil, all the Superbowl-trailers and many more.
J.G. Ballards favorite books
and much, much more. Enjoy!
GOOD INTERNET is a reader supported online mag. If you like what i do here, you can support this thing by upgrading your subscription to a paid plan or use one of the other support options you can find at the bottom of this issue.
UPGRADE
// ART & DESIGNSchrödingers Artworks gets dissolved in acid when Julian Assange dies in prisonThe Artist Holding Valuable Art Hostage to Protect Julian Assange: Blood artists Andrei Molodkin claims that he gathered 16 artworks "by the likes of Pablo Picasso, Rembrandt and Andy Warhol" collectively "worth more than $45m" in a safe weighing 29 tons. In the vault there's also a pneumatic pump connected to barrels full of acid which he claims will go off if Julian Assange dies in prison.
The piece is "backed by Assange's wife Stella, whose husband is awaiting his final appeal against being extradited to the US, where he faces charges under the Espionage Act."
“I’m not trying to destroy art, and I don’t believe I will have to,” Molodkin told the Guardian, adding that the project, called Dead Man’s Switch, was itself a collaborative artwork like any sculpture or portrait.
“It’s not activism. I believe that Assange will be free and all the collectors and artists who have donated their work did so because they believe he will not die in prison.”
First, i don't buy this, smells like a stunt. But they sure do everything to make it sound legit, and i can absolutely imagine that the wife of Assange and an internationally reknowned artist are able to convince collectors to give minor pieces of famed artists for this.
Second, this is as subtle as a brick in your face, and i don't like neither blood art nor quantum acid dissolving "Schrödingers artworks" in protest. It's a provocation and that's fine, but good art -- maybe not.
Preserving Banksy is impossiblePreserving Banksy: public art database to document the UK’s murals: For a long time i've been saying that the art in streetart is directly connected to it's locality, which is why any Banksy or other piece of streetart preserved in a museum or flexed away for sales is inherently worthless and basically looses it's status as art. Which makes me a purist and fundamentalist, i guess, but you can't rip streetart from it's surroundings and expect it to preserve its meaning.
How do you want to "preserve" the art that lies within the sculpture of a tortured guantanamo inmate that Banksy illegally dropped into Disneyland in 2006? You can't, because it only works within it's context. It only works at Disneyland at the spot, in context of it's illegality. No documentation or preservation can conserve that meaning.
Or how do you want to preserve The Punking of Paris Hilton, when DJ DangerMouse created a remix of Paris Hiltons debut album, Banksy did the cover artwork and they shopdropped it in 100 records stores all over the UK? This piece only works for the customer when she's consuming, which is the whole point of the piece. The CDs later sold for 9000 bucks and i pitty the buyer, the poor soul, the know nothing.
How do you want to preserve the self-destruction of a painting, where the art lies within the destruction itself? You can't. All you can is preserve or sell artifacts to an art market dumb enough to suck it up. So yeah sure do the database Banksy, but don't even pretend it comes close to the real thing.
Tavares Strachan Reimagines 'The Last Supper' in a Monumental Tribute to Black Historical Figures: "In The First Supper, which took Strachan four years to complete, notable figures include abolitionist Harriet Tubman, activists Marcus Garvey and Marsha P. Johnson, nurse Mary Seacole, and singer-songwriter Sister Rosetta Tharpe, among others. Strachan places former Ethiopian emperor Haile Selassie in place of Jesus and himself in the role of Judas Iscariot."
I Don’t Give A Seat is an instagram feed full of ugly public transport seat covers which is old news for germans because our Sitzmuster des Todes are legend and our public transport covers are so famously ugly that the Berlin BVG now ordered new ones which are still very ugly. What you have to know about his is that public seat transport covers are this ugly because then you don't see the dreck and dirt and old bubble gum shit on them. Now you know.
How To Design A Better Urban Soundscape: "Thomas Kusitzky’s profession is unusual enough that it has its own consonant-heavy compound German noun: Stadtklanggestalter, or urban soundscape planner. Kusitzky, who believes he’s the only person in the world with that exact job description, works at the Berlin branch of an engineering firm called Müller-BBM Industry Solutions." This reminds me of a small indie movie in which something like an interieur sound designer works in the flat of a rich lonely woman. I can't remember it's name and neither Google nor AI are helpful, but it was pretty good. (UPDATE: It’s The Sound of Silence from 2019, about a “house tuner in New York City, who calibrates the sound in people's homes in order to adjust their moods.”)
// JUST THE HEADLINESDonut Man By Wizard Skull
Cover Bank is a collection of nigerian album covers
Typographic Art of Valto Malmiola: "A mosaic of tightly arranged brass rule and spacing material, made by Valto Malmiola in 1937" from moveable type.
Brian Eno’s Turntable II glows in different acrylic neon lights as the vinyl record plays
A 639-year-long John Cage organ piece just changed chord, for the first time in two years
"The Production Design pipeline for one single set from just inside the visual development department of Across the Spiderverse".
World's 'worst' album covers goes on display in Alnwick
From an article on How A.I. Is Remodeling the Fantasy Home, here's the insta feed of Tiny House Perfect, which collects a lot of AI generated tiny houses and i want one.
The Book Cover Review. Exactly what it says on the tin.
The Creator's Guide to Comics Devices, is like Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud, but different.
Today is election day in Indonesia, and the running up has shown us what the populist AI-election playbook may look like. The government of the worlds third-largest democracy is keen on "downsizing the scale of direct elections" and "working to install (General) Prabowo, one of the former dictator Suharto’s top commanders and a longtime U.S. protégé". They do this, in part, by using generative AI.
From Reuters: Generative AI may change elections this year. Indonesia shows how.
Prabowo is Indonesia's defence minister. But on social media, his chubby-cheeked AI avatar makes Korean-style finger hearts and cradles his beloved cat, Bobby, to the delight of Gen Z voters. About half of Indonesia's 205 million voters are under 40. (...)
The AI-generated cartoon has been central to the electoral rebranding of Prabowo, who is far ahead in polls. Instead of portraying himself as a fiery nationalist, as he did in two prior failed presidential bids, the 72-year-old's new catchphrase is "gemoy" - which is Indonesian slang for cute and cuddly.
"I'll vote for him because he's gemoy," said Putri, a first-time voter. "That's the main reason."
Prabowo - and his doppelganger created using technology from U.S. firm Midjourney Inc - is leading hundreds of candidates in using generative AI tools to create campaign art, track social media sentiment, build interactive chatbots, and target voters.
The Prabowo campaign and Midjourney, whose guidelines bar its use for political campaigning, did not respond to requests for comment.
Reuters also found that Prabowo's campaigning platform is run with tools powered by OpenAI, which just banned using them for political campaigning. After an initial investigation, OpenAI responded that they found "no evidence" of their tools being used in the Indonesian election. This must have been a very, very shallow initial investigation, because:
Political consultant Yose Rizal said the Pemilu.AI app he developed uses OpenAI's GPT-4 and 3.5 software to craft hyper-local campaign strategies and speeches. The Indonesian consultant said he has sold the app's services to 700 legislative candidates. Reuters was not able to independently confirm the sales.
Pemilu.AI pulls together demographic data and crawls social media and news websites, allowing it to generate speeches, slogans, and social media content tailored to a constituency.
Depending on the labeling of the data used in that app, it is possible to make this app look very harmless. You just pull in some numbers in some excel-sheets labeled as something and generate stuff depending on those numbers. Nothing will stop you from pulling in demographic data, making it look unsuspicious and customize automatized mass mailouts accordingly, surely not a series of words in a post on a company blog like "we ban the use of our tools for political campaigning".
If i were a political advisor, i would exactly give zero fucks about this sentence, pull in the data and get to work. I would especially do that if i were a ruthless ex-general who kidnapped and tortured at democracy activists and who positions himself now as a cuddly cartoon figure for Gen Z voters in this Waldo Moment for democracy.
Judge throws out most of Sarah Silvermans ChatGPT copyright lawsuitArs Technica: Judge rejects most ChatGPT copyright claims from book authors, here's The Verge: Sarah Silverman’s lawsuit against OpenAI partially dismissed.
The judge followed OpenAIs motion to dismiss filed in August 2023 and threw out all claims on vicarious copyright infringement, DMCA violations, negligence, and unjust enrichment, except for the claim alleging direct copyright infringement.
Judge Martínez-Olguín expressed skepticism of several of the authors’ claims. She wasn’t convinced of the allegation that OpenAI was intentionally removing copyright management information like the title and registration number, for instance, or that the authors had proven economic injury — since “nowhere in plaintiffs’ complaint do they allege that defendants reproduced and distributed copies of their books.” According to the court, the claim of “risk of future damage to intellectual property” was too speculative to consider. Martínez-Olguín also emphasized that the plaintiffs “have not alleged that the ChatGPT outputs contain direct copies of the copyrighted books” and “must show a substantial similarity between the outputs and the copyrighted materials.” The authors can file changes to their original complaint by March 13th.
The only claim to proceed alleges that OpenAI trained ChatGPT on unlicensed, copyrighted works, which always was the most damning and interesting part of the lawsuit to begin with.
Martínez-Olguín said that it's possible that OpenAI's use of the training data "may constitute an unfair practice."
I bet it does.
AI-Corps agree to develop anti-deepfake tech, againAI companies agree to limit election ‘deepfakes’ but fall short of ban: Google, Microsoft Meta, OpenAI, Adobe and TikTok are planning to sign an agreement to develop tech to "identify, label and control AI-generated images, videos and audio recordings that aim to deceive voters ahead of crucial elections", but they won't "ban deceptive political AI content". Notably, "X, previously Twitter, was not a signatory to the agreement."
I have limited confidence in this. Researchers tested AI watermarks — and broke all of them. And as long as i can download video, remove meta data, cancel out layers of watermarking patterns with filters, and remove any label that identifies the content as AI-generated, anyone can easily bypass those efforts, especially those who put in the effort to use those tools to deceive the public on a larger scale.
Accordingly, this new document "amounts to a manifesto stating that AI-generated content, much of which is created by the companies’ tools and posted on their platforms, does present risks to fair elections, and it outlines steps to try to mitigate that risk, like labeling suspected AI content and educating the public on the dangers of AI."
We've been here before. In summer 2023, Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft, and OpenAI signed a "White House Pact" making a "voluntary commitment" to developing "robust technical mechanisms to ensure that users know when content is AI generated, such as a watermarking system", to prevent AI from being used for fraud and deception. It took them 9 months to write another document that says the same.
Which means some time before the 2024 elections, they'll implement technological solutions that will not work very much and post useless warnings on their company blogs while shrugging. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Where you get your nails done?Niceaunties stays one of the most fascinating artists working with image synthesis. Born in Singapore and brought up in "a childhood shaped by the influential women in their family (...) including a great-grandmother who had experienced bound feet, a grandmother who transitioned from a life dedicated to kitchen duties to two decades of bedridden existence, and a sociable mother, alongside eleven aunties. These women, embodying a spectrum of suppressed talents, passions, and dreams, were a mix of strange, funny, mean, and kind personalities, fueling the narrative of Niceaunties."
They recently sold 1000 artworks as NFT/print combo which you can view on their website, and the latest piece Auntie’s Nail Spa is, once more, a surrealist fever dream cooked up from Dáli, Singapores aging demographics, sushi and pop art. They make some of the wildest AI-art i know of, and their stuff is a sight to behold.
Here's the nail spa, "just another day in Auntieverse", and a few favs from their auction.
niceauntiesA post shared by @niceauntiesOpenAI CEO Sam Altman seeks $5 to $7 trillion to build a network of fabs for AI chips. Scott Alexander calculates what that means for scaling-speed and AI-risk: Sam Altman Wants $7 Trillion. His conclusion: "(OpenAI is) genuinely interested in safety - but only insofar as that’s compatible with scaling up AI as fast as possible. This is far from the worst way that an AI company could be. But it’s not reassuring either." In other OpenAI news: OpenAI on track to hit $2bn revenue milestone as growth rockets. But also: Early Adopters of Microsoft’s AI Bot Wonder if It’s Worth the Money.
Google renamed Bard into Gemini and launched Gemini Advanced. I usually don't give a rats ass about product update news (the iphone is news, the iphone 14 is for suckers), but this is interesting for me personally because i'm already Google One customer and backup my gazillion Markup-file notes database which i organize in Obsidian to Gdrive, and Gemini Advanced will soon get access. Which means that i finally can automatically sort through my gazillion Markup-file notes database with a chatbot, streamline my hashtags and markup wiki-links, clean it all up and make it ultimately chat about my thoughts, so i'm intrigued. We'll see how this turns out. (Yes i know that i could run a local LLM but my machine is not good enough, and i'm too poor for a paid service. I'm also looking forward to get access to NotebookLM for this usecase.) Here's Ethan Mollick on Google's Gemini Advanced: Tasting Notes and Implications.
Arvind Narayanan play rock paper scissors with every new AI chatbot which already is funny enough. Here's Google's Gemini Advanced playing Rock Paper Scissors, and it's so very advanced that it, too, doesn't get that this game is based on simultaneousness, which can't be done in a sequential dialogue at all, and which also doesn't prevent it from answering questions about why it looses every single game. Very 'telligent they still are, those bots.
The Algorithmic Resistance Research Group extended the deadline for their Models For Making Distance-zine aiming at "gathering a multiplicity of manifestos, writing and instructions for art that confounds, confuses and misuses algorithmic systems for the pleasure of human observers or actors".
A comparison of human- and A.I.-produced jokes shows that people judged GPT3.5 more funny at jokes and satirical headlines than human produced jokes and satire from The Onion. This can mean a bunch of things, like a) participants in psychological studies are bad audience, or b) the AI-George Carlin guys should have let an AI write their jokes or c) AI will take over the job of Louis CK very soon.
Can Humanity Survive AI? is a good, wide ranging article about x-risk from an anticapitalist perspective that concludes with comparing AI-systems to other "misaligned optimizers" like corporations in the case of Exxon, and stating that the x-risk and ethics debate is fundamentally a debatte about runaway capitalism and how to reign it in. I largely agree with this take.
Introducing Semafor Signals and Semafor reporters are going to curate the news with AI. Semafor reinvents classic blogging style (fast, non-longform commentary, quote-and-link-heavy) with help of AI-tools. I think this will turn out to be a viable model of non-investigative news journalism in the future, because it's fast and cheap. Microsoft is paying "an undisclosed sum of money" to Semafor to sponsor the breaking news and "the amount of money is 'substantial' to Semafor’s business". All of this is interesting to look at in context of the Springer-OpenAI-colab too.
The head of public policy for Stability AI is arguing that Open-Source AI Is Good for Us. Beyond the standard open source arguments there's not much new here, and i'm not convinced because AI is an inherently new approach to software with inherently new capabilities. He neither get's that they are automatic knowledge interpolators nor that generative AI as we know it today is inherently mimetic and something else entirely from e.g. software for data management on a server.
Modern Day Cyrano de Bergerac used ChatGPT to talk to 5,000 women on Tinder and met his wife: "She was speaking with ChatGPT for the first few months of the relationship (...) She wasn’t angry when she learned her fianceé had been using ChatGPT to talk to her, just shocked. She says that initial conversations on Tinder are mostly about learning about a potential partner’s interests, hopes, and maybe their philosophies. Her future husband’s chatbot did perfectly fine at communicating this early on." Fittingly, the original Cyrano de Bergerac is counted as a very early pioneer of science fiction with his posthumously published 1657 novel Comical History of the States and Empires of the Moon and The States and Empires of the Sun from 1662.
// JUST THE HEADLINES:Inside the Underground Site Where ‘Neural Networks’ Churn Out Fake IDs and ‘Neural Network’ Fake ID Site Goes Dark After 404 Media Investigation. Rest assured that this service still exists, and will improve.
‘DignifAI:’ 4chan Is Editing Pictures to Clothe Women
This AI learnt language by seeing the world through a baby’s eyes
GOODY-2 is a over-aligned language model which refuses to answer any questions. However, I made its refusal rhyme in the style of Mickey Mouse yesterday, so you can get something out of it.
Interview with Neal Stephenson on AI and his 1995 novel The Diamond Age. Related: Stephenson just announced his new book Polostan which sounds not interesting to me, at all. (I'm not into spies).
Study argues that large language models can reveal breakthroughs in neuroscience that humans alone cannot
AI-Generated Grandma Porn Is Flooding the Internet. I do like cougars if you know what i mean, but this is a bit much.
Amjad Masad auf X: „Cyberpunk moment: Pakistan’s ousted/jailed former PM have been using AI to campaign for his party from behind bars and now uses AI to deliver his victory speech“
Open-source AR glasses use AI to translate languages, detect images, search web and more
A crowd destroyed a driverless Waymo car in San Francisco: "A person jumped on the hood of a Waymo driverless taxi and smashed its windshield in San Francisco’s Chinatown last night around 9PM PT, generating applause before a crowd formed around the car and covered it in spray paint, breaking its windows, and ultimately set it on fire." Here's video of the robot murder party.
Mozilla takes a deep dive on the common crawl dataset: Training Data for the Price of a Sandwich.
"LLMs = 100% memorization. There is no other mechanism at work".
Company worker in Hong Kong pays out £20m in deepfake video call scam: "her company was deceived of some HK$200m after she received video conference calls from someone posing as senior officers of the company requesting to transfer money to designated bank accounts"
Daily news headlines as AI-generated poems. I would happily subscribe to any newsletter summarizing the daily news in the style of Monty Python with additional fishslaps to all of its bulletpoints. This is the killer slap.
Open access book from MIT Press: Algorithms of Resistance: "How global workers, influencers, and activists develop tactics of algorithmic resistance by appropriating and repurposing the same algorithms that control our lives."
AI Deployed Nukes 'to Have Peace in the World' in Tense War Simulation. That's not very reassuring.
The rise of obituary spam: "AI-generated obituaries litter search results, turning even private individuals into clickbait."
AI adoption in newsrooms presents “a familiar power imbalance” between publishers and platforms, new report finds
China turns to AI tablets for students after tutoring crackdown
The latest in Doom-ports on weird ass devices: the ur-shooter on audio spectrograms, playable with audio inputs: "The game is displayed by generating an audio signal that can be viewed as a spectrogram, while input is taken from the microphone, with specific frequencies being mapped to specific keys."
Here's the source code and instructions on GitHub, and a video:
Back when everybody was talking about Mark Zuckerbergs Metaverse-thing, there were some more sane voices that claimed that it already exists and is called Fortnite and Minecraft. Disney must have read those articles and invests $1.5 billion in Epic to create ‘persistent universe’ tied to Fortnite and like Andrew Webster in his follow up piece i'm inclined to say that Fortnite is winning the metaverse with this move, simply because it's becoming a gaming version of Ready Player One, sans VR-headsets (and that's just a matter of time).
Jaron Lanier discusses the Apple Vision Pro in the New Yorker: Where Will Virtual Reality Take Us? More Apple Vision: Owners Are Wondering What They Bought, Zuck on the Apple Vision Pro, Early Apple Vision Pro Adopters Alarmed to Learn VR Porn Doesn't Work, The Apple Vision Pro Is Spectacular and Sad. Besides some own thoughts i posted here, i have this to add: Modern Love is automatic, a story in two memes.
// JUST THE HEADLINES:Netflix: Piracy is Difficult to Compete Against and Growing Rapidly and Music Piracy Is Back, Baby! Look, piracy never went away, baby. You can't give customers a trazillion different streaming services, delete beloved shows willy nilly and raise prices and don't expect them to torrent your shit.
Cern aims to build €20bn collider to unlock secrets of universe
Why Metaverse sexual assaults could be difficult to prosecute
Phone Spy Tool Pitched for ‘Riot Detection’ in NYC: "The company behind a global phone spy tool that is advertised as a capability for national security agencies also pitched the product as a solution for 'riot detection'."
Nuclear Fusion Machine Smashes Energy Record, Clean Energy Now 'Closer Than Ever'
Just 137 crypto miners use 2.3% of total U.S. power — government now requiring commercial miners to report energy consumption, while Rachel O'Dwyer writes about the cruelty of crypto in its promise to revive the American dream.
A treasury of Zork maps
Easy-to-Repair Knockoff of Original iPod is Crowdfunding Smash
Social media algorithms ‘amplifying misogynistic content’: A new study found that TikTok is "rapidly amplifying extreme misogynistic content, which is spreading from teenagers’ screens and into school playgrounds where it has become normalised (...) Researchers said they detected a four-fold increase in the level of misogynistic content suggested by TikTok over a five-day period of monitoring".
At the moment, we have a similar discussion about a successful finance influencer on the platform (link in german) spreading rightwing influenced desinformation and outright AFD-propaganda, with the dramatic similarity here being that these podcasts are aimed at kids.
In the 90s, we had "Rechtsrock", rockmusic aimed at rebellious teenagers spreading the hate. Today we have political podcasts on TikTok. Podcasters on TikTok also have the advantage of the underdog status, no matter if they're financed by the Kochs or pushed by Putin. I don't know how to effictively counter this development, except provide better outsider media that kicks ass.
Shut up and eat my trendbaitTikTok is full of made-up slang and trendbait: Becca Jennings at Vox complains about "trendbait", kids on TikTok inventing neologisms for attention. Funny enough, she invents the neologism "trendbait" for this.
"language is exploding on TikTok. It is kind of beautiful until you understand why. With every scroll, new terms compete for space in your brain: orange peel theory, microcheating, girl hobby, loud budgeting, 75 cozy. They are funneled into the collective consciousness not because they are relevant or necessary but because random people have made videos inventing these terms in the hope that the wording will go viral."
Rob Horning in Infinite concretude has a good post about this trendbaiting. According to Horning, following trends inherently aims at "being tired of trends", to make them a "backdrop against which we can imagine 'a real self'", all while "they allow us to participate in social momentum, to go with its flow or to stand against it".
In other words, anyone participating in trendy things is just bored by them an is using trends to play around and find their own ways of expression, remixing them into a version that represents themselves as a person. The classic hipster attitude: That Brooklyn band is hot as long as only me and 1000 other people know about it, after which they become a sellout, and then the hipster goes on to find the next band with the same sound but different look, and the hipster still participates in the "hot brooklyn band lifecycle", hyping up the next one when the old ones fade into stardom. Being a hipster is pretty much defined by being tired of trends, which just form the backdrop of discovering the next cool thing that forms a tiny pixel in your identity. The same is true af for cool new internet lingo.
Anyways, i made an online phrase go globally viral too: If you've ever used the "Shut Up And Take My Money!"-meme, I'm (not very) sorry to be part of your meme-lexicon.
Six months in, journalist-owned tech publication 404 Media is profitable. Great news for independent publishers who know what they are doing. I love 404 and link to their stories on a regular basis, and those ex-Motherboard/Vice-journos absolutely do know what they are doing, including balancing and mastering the fine line between clickbaity porn-articles and in depth investigations into surveillance capitalism. Well done, all around.
Is the Media Prepared for an Extinction-Level Event? I'm reading these articles since forever and it boils down to a simple equation: In a globalized media market where i can access any news from anywhere, i don't need 2000 journalists writing the same articles about the same facts. I just need one. And no amount of long form thinkpieces will do away with this simple fact, nor will local journalism save you. AI in the newsroom will only accelerate this, and yes, classic media might face an "extinction-level event" as Clare Malone puts it. We'll see what emerges from this, and if we're unlucky (and our timeline suggests we are), we get influencer driven "journalism" on TikTok. All of this sucks.
Online anonymity: study found ‘stable pseudonyms’ created a more civil environment than real user names: I'm not a big fan of the anonymous-paradigm of internet culture, but i accept the results of all those papers which state that anonymity and pseudonymity actually leads to a more civilized discourse climate. I can only guess at why that is, and suggest that using your real name binds your identity to your online statements and you become defensive when you're attacked, escalating the whole exchange, much more so than with anon or pseudonymous accounts, where you can much easier shrug it off.
No relationships between self-reported Instagram use or type of use and mental well-being: A study using a nationally representative online sample of UK adults: Because i'm very critical of social media i'm always looking into studies that contradict my view. Here's another paper that sees no correlation, and this paper comes not from Team Andrew Przybylski at Oxford, so i'm intrigued. While its results are also limited to Instagram, i'm still surprised by their no-effect results. Also, 498 UK adults is not very representative, and the age ranging from 19–82 years old does not include teenage girls, who are hit hardest in the teenage mental health crisis and it's precicely this demographic that should show psychological effects on body image issues stemming from especially influencer culture on Instagram. So, while this is an interesting result, it's not applicable to the most harmed demographic.
How to Quit Your Smartphone. Throw it in the river or the sea or both, throw it down the mountain, leave it at a bar or a cinema, smash it, burn it, make it kaputt. I use my phone pretty much exclusively as a mobile hotspot and some gaming, and i use feeds and RSS pretty much exclusively on a laptop. I don't like smartphones. I don't have much use for them because i don't like to call up people very much and i also don't like messaging. Then again, i'm a grumpy 50 year old hairy bloke who has seen way to much shit on the web and maybe you shouldn't listen to my advice. But throw it in the river, will ya.
Alone together? How social technology is influencing human connection and loneliness: "more than half of young people’s social interactions now occur via text", "online tools can create barriers to productive and enjoyable in-person interaction" and "ambiguity in the identity of one’s online interaction partners may be contributing more broadly to a sense of dehumanization in social life". Throw it in the river.
“Wherever you get your podcasts” is a radical statement. Anil Dash on the radicalism of tech like Really Simple Syndication, and Ernie Smith joins in with Does RSS Need A Creator-Economy Rethink? I dunno. I'm using RSS constantly since 2005 and my workflow with it is pretty much unchanged. I read hundreds of websites in Inoreader and i can't imagine a better way to stay up to date than RSS. RSS is still pretty great. For years I'm claiming that if Google didn't kill their RSS-reader we'd maybe live in a different world today, and it was their worst move ever.
A Simple Theory for Why the Internet Is So Conspiratorial: Three rules of Evidence Maximalism: 1. any small thing can be evidence of my thing; 2. any big thing is always evidence of my big thing; 3. all your evidence against my thing is, on closer inspection, very strong evidence for my thing.
// JUST THE HEADLINES:Facebook rules allow altered video casting Biden as paedophile, says board
The fediverse, explained: Mastodon, Threads, and the open future of social networking
Fighting the smartphone ‘invasion’: the French village that voted to ban scrolling in public
Meet generation stay-at-home: ‘You don’t need to pay to go clubbing: you can sit at home and watch it on your phone’
Russia Is Boosting Calls for ‘Civil War’ Over Texas Border Crisis. The 2016 playbook including a reanimated IRA.
Epik, the Far Right's Favorite Web Host, Has a Shadowy New Owner
Toward a unified taxonomy of text-based social media use
The internet used to be ✨fun✨, a curated list of articles lamenting the unfun of the modern web. It's missing one of the earliest of the genre, an article from Hossein Derakhshan who spend 7 years in iranian jail (for blogging) and didn't recognize the web he left behind: The Web We Have to Save.
Because hurricanes are measured not on an open scale like earthquakes, but are limited to 5 classes (yet), scientists propose a Category 6 because hurricanes are getting more intense thanks to climate change. I remember well blogging about when Australia had to add a new colour to their temperature maps because of rising temperature and this is the same, but for storms. Michael Mann argues that Cat 6 hurricanes have already arrived and that a Cat 6 would update the hurricane system to deliver cruicial messages to the public, where "Lives are literally at stake".
Why are people climate change deniers? Study reveals unexpected results: It's not "Self-deception to preserve a positive self-image" in many cases, but "denying the existence of human-made global heating forms part of the political identity". In other words, tribalism. And there are many populist bad actors exploiting this form of contrarianism, which is why i think we should stop listening to them altogether. Don't engage, don't talk, don't argue. The facts speak for themselves.
// JUST THE HEADLINESUS climate scientist Michael Mann wins $1m in defamation lawsuit | Climate science scepticism and denial. The hockey stick graph guy finally won.
‘Like a war zone’: Chile wildfire death toll reaches 123 amid race to clear rubble and In Chile, huge wildfires have killed at least 131 people, but one village was untouched and How climate change contributes to wildfires like Chile's (Paper: Extreme fire weather in Chile driven by climate change and El Niño–Southern Oscillation).
West's 'hot drought' is unprecedented in more than 500 years
Psychology study unearths ways to bolster global climate awareness and climate action: Different messaging styles lead to different outcomes in different regions of the world.
The world is reducing its reliance on fossil fuels – except for in three key sectors: Flying, Industry and Shipping. From those 3, industrial processes are crucial, contributing 30% to the US carbon emissions.
A bunch of handy charts about climate change
Did art exist before modern humans? New discoveries raise big questions: "There is increasing evidence for ornaments and various expressions of symbolic behavior since about 120,000 years ago in Africa and Europe".
The headline suggests you can draw a sharp line between modern humans and archaic humans, between the ability of symbolic thinking (and the expression of that symbolically representational thought in language and ultimately art) and human ancestors not able to think representatively.
But all of this exists on a chaotic continuum. A homo erectus finds it funny to make weird spheric shapes and other homo erectus join in, those spherical stones are found by neanderthals living in the same area and they get weird ideas in their large heads, and then all of this is forgotten for aeons, while others get other weird ideas and over tens of thousands of years, symbolic thinking and cultural expression emerges and then it becomes practice, transmitting itself via cultural evolution when they ritualise that behavior, and not-that-suddenly you have modern humans expressing themselves in seemingly mysterious cave paintings that were elaborate by the standards of cultural practice in the stone age.
For me, the question if art came before modern humans is irrelevant: Ofcourse art existed before modern humans, just as rudimentary ritualistic behavior exists in chimps. Cultural evolution existed before art, and evolutionary pathways are always fuzzy, where you can hardly pinpoint anything. What is important is that between 150k and 50k years ago, humans developed the ability to represent stuff with symbols, first in their head, then in language, then in art, and with that representation came the ability to play with those representations which sped up cultural evolution, which then lead to the invention of the iphone.
The question for me is not, when exactly this behavior emerged, but how it spreads and why. René Girards mimetic theory states that it is the desire to have what others have and then we imitate their behavior to get it, which seems reasonable to me, and this basic rule is the foundation of all things memetic.
Doing Nothing is hardThe art of doing nothing: have the Dutch found the answer to burnout culture? Nope. But the dutch rediscovered the philosophical concept of vita contemplativa which goes back to Aristoteles.
I recently read Byung-Chul Hans book Vita Contemplativa: In Praise of Inactivity, which states that "when life follows the rule of stimulus-response and need-satisfaction, it atrophies into pure survival: naked biological life", in other words: If we loose the ability to do nothing, we cease to be human. What Byung-Chul stresses in his book is that doing-nothing like modern lifestyle activities like Mindfulness or Niksen isn't doing-nothing without a purpose, because that purpose is wellness therefore integrated into the capitalist ideology of differentiating between work and free time, which means it contributes and has a purpose as a balance to a busy busy life and, as The Guardian shows in its headline, is a part of working culture.
Actually doing nothing is hard, and i don't think i've ever, sadly, truly done nothing in my whole life. But i, being the lazy bastard that i am, tried hard, i can tell you that.
Scott Aaronson on whether we’re living in a simulation. One problem of the "our descendands have a oomph more computing power"-argument is that it projects current trajectories into the far future and does not account for unknown unknowns, like unforeseen consequences of climate change. As fascinating the simulation hypothesis is, i also think it's wrong, but i do like the cosmological version of it, which states that our experience of reality is how it feels for god's (or whatever's) connected "neurons" to think, which is why, for instance, we experience stuff like harmony in a very special, awe-inducing way.
People Have Very Different Understandings of Even the Simplest Words. Trained professional in different fields have very different meanings for the same word, like "risk" means something else, entirely, for climate researchers and economists. Now put them all together with laypeople and politicians and activists and journalists and bad actors and businesspeople on Social Media and you get our cool new shitshow world. Wittgenstein is amused.
// JUST THE HEADLINESWhy We Anthropomorphize Animals (and Always Have): "Hana Videen on the Origins of the Bestiary and Its Role in the Medieval Imagination"
The brain is the most complicated object in the universe. This is the story of scientists’ quest to decode it – and read people’s minds: The history of BCIs and the emergence of neuro-ethics.
‘The self is suppressed’: psychologists explore the minds of the mafiosi: "Italian researchers say that joining the mafia is like entering a cult in which members must leave behind their own identity."
What Your Brain Is Doing When You’re Not Doing Anything. Quanta recounts the discovery of the default mode network.
Why Gödel, Escher, Bach is the most influential book in my life.
I wrote about the hubbub caused by Warner axing Coyote vs Acme, when the filmmakers fought back, supposedly successful and leading Warner to offer the movie to various other studios for them to show. Turns out, they never meant it, rejected all offers and didn't communicate with the filmmakers about the negotiations. The plan was to bury the movie all along and the so-called sale was a front for businessmen-bullshit, to sit out the tide of fan rage. I'm with Matt Zoller Seitz when he writes about Why Deleting and Destroying Finished Movies Like Coyote vs Acme Should Be a Crime.
All of this is not that baffling as some writers make it appear. Warner can write off the 70 Million dollars budget and lower their taxable income, and save the money to promote and release the movie too, which might even turn a profit for them. This is not baffling, this is business with a money shark at the helm, and it ultimately means that Warner loves tax write-offs more than Looney Tunes. The baffling part comes in when you look at Warner as a, you know, hollywood studio, because, after all, the job of a hollywood studio traditionally is to, you know, release movies, isn't it?
And it's even more baffling since Warners branding is traditionally intertwined with all things Looney Tunes, with the characters appearing in Warner movies like Gremlins 2, Gravity or Ready Player One and the tradition going back to the 1932 western Haunted Gold featuring John Wanye and an animated intro. The only logical conclusion i can draw from all of this is that under CEO David Zaslav, Warner hates Looney Tunes now. Brave New World.
Hating movies seems to be the go-to practice for movie executive David Zaslav anyways, who not only "made his name producing cheap, disposable reality TV", but who on his warpath against culture fucked up HBO and Turner Classic Movies too.
So, no, i have no expectations or trust in Warner, when they announce The Day the Earth Blew Up: A Looney Tunes Movie, simply because Warners head honcho is not a movie man, but an ex-lawyer good at accounting.
Related: Graham Reznick on Mastodon: "re: execs not seeing COYOTE VS ACME, here’s a delightful story from Harlan Ellison of a meeting in 1978 for I, ROBOT: When he realizes the WB studio head had not even read his script, he tricks him into admitting it and tells him to his face that he has 'the intellectual capacity of an artichoke'."
Carsten Kurpaneks Will E. Coyote-tattoo.// TRAILERSThe trailer for Sasquatch Sunset starts with fucking bigfoots and that's basically all you need to know about this movie starring Riley Keough and Jesse Eisenberg as wookies, coming from David and Nathan Zellner who made the Fargo-lean in Kumiko, the Treasure Hunter. Here's the plot: "In the misty forests of North America, a family of Sasquatches — possibly the last of their enigmatic kind — embark on an absurdist, epic, hilarious, and ultimately poignant journey over the course of one year. These shaggy and noble giants fight for survival as they find themselves on a collision course with the ever-changing world around them."
Here's all the Super Bowl Movie Trailers & TV Spots from the game last night, featuring the Deadpool & Wolverine Teaser, a trailer for the Wizard of Oz-spinoff Wicked, a new trailer for Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes, a trailer for a remake of Twister and The Fall Guy aswell as TV spots for Monkey Man, If, Despicable Me 4, Kung Fu Panda 4 and The Boys.
Love Lies Bleeding (Trailer 2): The new film from Rose Glass, who made one of my favorite 2019 movies with the fantastic Saint Maud. This one has Kristen Stewart falling in love with Katy O'Brian in a criminal compound and Ed Harris sporting an otherworldly hairdo. Can't wait. Here's the plot: "Reclusive gym manager Lou falls hard for Jackie, an ambitious bodybuilder headed through town to Las Vegas in pursuit of her dream. But their love ignites violence, pulling them deep into the web of Lou's criminal family."
The Animal Kingdom: "In a world hit by a wave of mutations that are gradually transforming some humans into animals, François does everything he can to save his wife, who is affected by this mysterious condition. As some of the creatures disappear into a nearby forest, he embarks with Émile, their 16-year-old son, on a quest that will change their lives forever."
Late Night With the Devil: “Presented in a found footage style, David Dastmalchian stars as Jack Delroy, the host of a fictional 1970s variety and late-night talk show titled Night Owls with Jack Delroy. The film purports to be derived from a rediscovered master tape of an episode from the show's sixth season, broadcast on Halloween 1977; during this live television broadcast, havoc unfolds when Delroy interviews a parapsychologist (Laura Gordon) and the subject of her recent book, a young teenager (Ingrid Torelli) who was the sole survivor of a Satanic church's mass suicide.
More trailers worth watching: A Quiet Place: Day One (Prequel to the whole Quiet Place-thing looks good but also exactly as expected) / Drive-Away Dolls Trailer 2 (Margaret Qualley <3 nuff said) / Oswald: Down the Rabbit Hole (ofcourse Mickey Mouse going public domain would mean the inevitable Mickey Mouse-horrorflicks and this seems to be one of them featuring the original Mickey Mouse when he was still Oswald the Lucky Rabbit, read more about the animated feature at Bloody Disgusting) / Cuckoo (second feature from german director Tilman Singer who previously made the ad agency horrorflick LUZ, this one seems to be a horror thriller set in a resort in the german alps), Damsel (despite not liking those new fantasy flicks very much i'm intrigued by this survival thriller packaged as a fairytale) / Rick and Morty: The Anime (i have nothing to add here) / Night Shift (a young woman running from a stalker starts working in a haunted hotel)
(In German) Der WDR hat ein sechsteiliges Hörspiel nach Tove Janssons Kinderbuch-Klassiker Die Mummins online gestellt. Ich liebe die Mummins seit den ersten Verfilmungen durch die Augsburger Puppenkiste und der 1978er Animations-Serie und "Underwater Moomins looking at bioluminescent glowing fishes in the sky" war einer meiner ersten Gehversuche in Image Synthesis mit Midjourney.
'The Fly II' Remains Malformed & Misunderstood 35 Years Later and 35 Years Ago, the Greatest Sci-Fi Body Horror Ever Got a Surprisingly Smart Sequel: I remember seeing The Fly II in a double feature together with Pet Sematary at the age of 15 and i had a blast at the melting faces and the exploding head smashed by an elevator and i cried tears at the cruel fate of Timex the golden retriever. I watched it again later and found it a bad sequel to the Cronenberg film, but an okayish effort as a standalone b-movie with a lot of ghastly FX which is right down my alley. Maybe i'll run a Fly marathon in the coming weeks, with all three classics from the 50s and the two 80s Brundlefly yuckfests.
New 'Evil Dead' Filmmaker Sébastien Vaniček Teases His Vision: "A Nasty Film... a Film That Hurts": Not much news here besides Sébastien Vaniček is directing an Evil Dead spinoff, they aim at a 2025 release and it's gonna be so gruesome, it's gonna ruin his carreer (which won't happen). Vaniček so far has only done the new spider horrorfilm Infested i haven't seen but the trailer looks quite good, and i'm on board with anything Evil Dead anyways.
The world need this Cliff Burton action figure from Super7 released on what would have been Metallica bassist's 62nd birthday. It comes with a bass guitar plus energy effect, lightning hammer (he wrote Ride The Lightning after all) and bird flipping hands. Shut up and take my money, as they say.
// JUST THE HEADLINES:What's In My Bag? featuring The Armed, the semi-anonymous hardcore punk musical collective who not only made one of the best albums in 2021 with Ultrapop, but also one of my favorite albums of 2023 with Perfect Saviors.
Gremlins 3 Gets Optimistic Update From OG Star After Animated Show Revival. Zach Galligan speculates on "Warners endgame" of aiming at a third live action movie, but i remain sceptical because Warner hates movies now.
Denis Villeneuve Dune 3 Script Almost Finished. Nothing new here, he's still writing and nothing official has been announced and if it will be make, he still want to take a break before directing it.
New Predator Film Badlands In Works From Dan Trachtenberg, who also directed the pretty cool Predator-prequel Prey.
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice has a movie poster and a release date on 6th September 2024. First trailer imminent.
Yes you want a Baba is You-Plush.
RIP Can-singler Damo Suzuki, here they are live at Rockpalast in 1970.
In an excerpt from J.G. Ballard: Selected Nonfiction, 1962-2007, Ballard writes about how he regrets reading classics at a too young age:
I now regret that so much of my reading took place during my late adolescence, long before I had any adult experience of the world, long before I had fallen in love, learned to understand my parents, earned my own living and had time to reflect on the world’s ways. It may be that my intense adolescent reading actually handicapped me in the process of growing up — in all senses my own children and their contemporaries strike me as more mature, reflective and more open to the possibilities of their own talents than I was at their age. I seriously wonder what Kafka and Dostoyevsky, Sartre and Camus could have meant to me.
I can relate to that. I read Kafka and Stanislav Lem and Ray Bradbury and Lovecraft in my late teens from 16-18 and i simply didn't have the experience at life to grasp what i was reading, and while i'm an avid reader now that i'm 50, gulping up one or two books per week, i always refrain from rereading Kafka because there just is so much out there that i don't know yet.
However, if you don't want to click through, here's J.G. Ballards ten favorite books:
The Day of the Locust by Nathanael West
Collected Short Stories by Ernest Hemingway
The Rime of the Ancient Mariner by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
The Annotated Alice by Martin Gardner
The World through Blunted Sight by Patrick Trevor-Roper
The Naked Lunch by William Burroughs
The Black Box by Malcolm MacPherson
Los Angeles Yellow Pages
America by Jean Baudrillard
The Secret Life of Salvador Dalí by by Dalí
I had no idea that NASA has an Astronomy Picture of the Day Calendar with monthly overviews of their APOD-images. And speaking of NASA, 40 Years Ago, astronauts captured this iconic space photo of astronaut Bruce McCandless free-floating above earth, seemingly alone.
We’re fast approaching the era of the trillionaire. What can we do to stop it? I don't like the idea of a trillionaire. I don't even like the idea of a billionaire. I think it’s vulgar and obscene to have those. I claim not to be a socialist and claim to be a social democrat capitalist, but i would also vote for an upper limit of income. Nobody needs more than, say, 100 million, or maybe 500 million or whatever. But, really, a million million bucks? For what? Come the fuck on.
Related: In The Fungus Among Us, Barry Goldman writes about how corporations are memes, mind viruses entering the mind via the desire for manymuchtrillions of money: "the CEO of a fracking concern is a zombie host mindlessly obeying the dictates of a parasitic brain fungus". This is also related to my thinking about corporations as "organizational AI" with a system-prompt that goes something like "nothing else matters than profit", and we removed friction for that mind virus by inventing "legal personhood" for organizations. And all of this is also related to my thinking about "capitalism as a system to release good products". If the CEO of Warner wouldn't have been infected by the meme-subsystem "profit maximalization" of the mind virus "legal person Warner", then we'd have a Coyote vs Acme-movie is what i'm saying.
// JUST THE HEADLINES:Did The Future Already Happen? - The Paradox of Time by Kurzgesagt/In a nutshell
Fantastic googly eyes halloween look
Well, there's sure worse things on this planet than gen Z ‘rediscovering’ the public library. The timing is pretty much perfect: Literacy crisis in college students: Essay from a professor on students who don’t read.
A bunch of women reenacting chicken head moves in the Chicken Club is wholesome.
The Asteroid That Impacted Near Berlin Has Been Identified As A Rare Aubrite. Now you know.
Scientists identify water molecules on asteroids for the first time
Bronze Age 'treasure' was crafted with extraterrestrial metal
Glow way! Bioluminescent houseplant hits US market for first time. I totally want a glow-in-the-dark-garden.
Kevin Bacon sings, fails to win over his alpaca, Sharona, with ukulele rendition of The Knack's "My Sharona"
Elle Cordovas Fonts hanging out p3:
UPGRADE
GOOD INTERNET ELSEWHERE // Twitter / Facebook / InstagramSUPPORT // Patreon / Steady / Paypal / Spreadshirt / AI-ShirtsMusicvideos have their own Newsletter now: GOOD MUSIC. All killers and absolutely zero fillers. The latest issues featuring The Menzingers, Girl Scout, The Drums, EASYFUN, Upchucks and many more. You can also find all the tracks from all Musicvideos in a Spotify-Playlist.Subscribe to GOOD INTERNET on Substack or on Patreon or on Steady and feel free to leave a buck or two. If you don’t want to subscribe to anything but still want to send a pizza or two, you can paypal me.Buy books on Amazon with this link and add me some pennies into my pockets like magic.You can also buy Shirts and Stickers like a real person.Thanks.From the publisher's feed