Reasonable Is Just Fear in a Nice Outfit
In this episode of Grit & Grace, Pam Rader and Erin Payne dive into a conversation many of us didn’t realize we needed—the hidden cost of being “reasonable.”
You know the pendulum:
On one end, emotional chaos and oversharing.
On the other, being so calm, regulated, and “mature” that you quietly disappear.
Somewhere along the way, emotional regulation got confused with self-silencing.
Pam and Erin explore how many of us—especially thoughtful, self-aware people—use reasonableness as a socially acceptable way to:
…and how that choice slowly chips away at our confidence, desires, self-trust, and even our dreams.
This episode is an honest, funny, and deeply grounding exploration of what it actually means to live in alignment—not as an emotional disaster, and not as a spiritually bypassing saint, but as a human being willing to tell the truth kindly, clearly, and courageously.
Why “being reasonable” is often fear in disguise
How emotional regulation can turn into self-abandonment
The difference between honesty and harshness
Why calm doesn’t always equal peace
How people-pleasing masquerades as maturity
The missing communication skill that keeps us stuck at the extremes
Why pursuing your desires may look unreasonable—but might be the most reasonable thing of all
How expanding your capacity often requires doing the thing that makes you want to pee your pants
Pam and Erin also share personal reflections on career, identity, entrepreneurship, separation, and what it takes to choose an unreasonably alive life—rather than a merely acceptable one.
“If you do reasonable things, you’ll have a reasonable life.
If you do unreasonable things, you gain access to an unreasonably extraordinary one.”
Take a moment to reflect on where you’ve been:
Staying quiet instead of speaking up
Choosing comfort over truth
Playing small to keep others comfortable
Calling self-betrayal “emotional intelligence”
What might shift if you allowed yourself to redefine what reasonable really means?
Pam and Erin extend an invitation that might feel a little unreasonable—and very aligned:
The Grit & Grace Retreat
📍 Spring Lake Ranch, 100 Mile House, BC
🗓️ May 21–24
Four days of horses, yoga, campfires, deep conversations, laughter, and spaciousness—designed to help you reconnect with what matters and remember who you are when you stop performing for everyone else.
Sometimes the most unreasonable thing you can do…
is choose yourself.
If this episode resonated, please share it with someone who might need permission to stop being so reasonable.
It helps the show grow, and we’re grateful you’re here.
Until next time—
may you keep turning grit into grace.