I talk about my migration from Adobe Photoshop Elements to digiKam as
photo catalog software, or DAM Digital Asset Management as it often is
referred to nowadays.
My latest was release 14 which I bought 2015, which also was when I
migrated from Windows to macOS.
Photoshop Elements is without hesitation a good software. One major
drawback is that is a proprietary software from which I cannot export
data on my conditions.
After a few of years on release 14 the geotagging stopped working.
The error message told that this was caused by a change by Google. Adobe
Photoshop Elements had a fix for this error - but only incorporated in
the next release of the software. No fix was planned for my release. So
to get geotagging working again, I would have to buy a new release.
I also got problem that it now and then crashed and needed to be
restarted. Something needed to be done.
I considered if I should buy a new release of Photoshop Elements or
change to any other software. At the same time I also became more
attracted to Linux. I also became more interested in free and open
software.
A big drawback with changing to something else than Adobe is that I
most certainly will loose some of the work I have put into photos in
Photoshop Elements.
The Photo editing data and raw conversion settings for individual
photos will be lost. This is almost impossible to migrate between
software. What can be done is to save what I have edited as new photos.
I am fine with this, it will not stop me from changing
software.
Meta data is very important to me. Meta data contains not only
information about the shooting from the camera itself. But also my tags,
description texts and more I had added in Photoshop Elements. Meta data
also includes face tagging. This goes both for digital camera photos as
well as digitized analog photos.
Criteria for my new software:
Preferable free and open source
Available on multiple platforms, in particular available on macOS
and Linux
That meta data can be migrated including face tagging
The one that I found to best meet my criteria is digiKam.
DigiKam is mostly known for its catalog capabilities. But digiKam
also includes import and export functions as well as raw conversion and
photo editing.
My migration.
Photoshop Elements stores the data in a data base. It is possible to
export metadata to files and sidecars. But not all data. Face tagging
cannot be exported. The name of the person can be exported but not the
coordinates of the face tag which only is stored in the data base.
The data base itself cannot be read by other software, except by
Adobe software: Adobe Lightroom Classic can import the data from
Photoshop Elements data base into its own data base. This was very
important for my migration success. Lightroom can export also the face
tagging.
I discovered an issue with the time- and datestamps. In Photoshop
Elements it is possible to give incomplete date and time, for example
only state the year if I do not know all details. Already Lightroom had
problem to interpret this information correctly and I had to implement a
workaround with tags. In general, several time and date attributes exist
and it is something to understand what is what and how each of the is
defined, displayed and managed in the software.
From Lightroom Classic I exported meta data including face tags to
files and sidecars.
And migration to digiKam worked good enough. I still have access to
my Photoshop Elements database if I want to go back and check
anything.
My next step was to migrate from digiKam on macOS to digiKam on
Linux. This migration was relatively easy. My current settings in
digiKam is to always write data to sidecars, in addition to the digiKam
data bases. So I copied photo files and sidecars f
