America’s constitutional order protects religious liberty within a broadly Christian cultural inheritance. In this Special Report, we examine tensions between representative Islamic doctrines and American principles governing speech, sovereignty, and family law. Domestically, we defend equal civil rights, institutional autonomy, and accommodations for peaceful practice while supporting neutral arbitration and firm prohibitions on coercion and violations of others’ rights. Immigration policy should strictly assess risks associated with countries of origin and require applicants to affirm compliance with American laws and principles. Abroad, the United States should work with allies, including nonhostile Muslim nations, to disrupt militant Islam’s funding and isolate its ideological sources.