In their first ever bonus episode, the Rewatchers revisit the best and worst episodes from season one, rate the best guests and villains, rank the cops, count up Mac's quickenings, and discuss their high hopes for season two.

In the season 1 finale, when a mysterious group of mortal nerds hunts down immortals, Pirate Duncan must team up with his old friend Fitz to track them down. The Rewatchers hear a who, discuss the moral implications of the prize, and discuss the impact of Darius on the world of Highlander.

It’s Home Alone, Highlander Edition! When a diplomat’s son assaults the stepdaughter of an immortal, Duncan must set a series of absurd traps to defend the little jerk from an army of mercenary goons. The Rewatchers discuss a useless flashback, celebrate Richie’s “Big Star” jacket, and consider Duncan’s return to killing mortals.

Duncan must prevent an immortal with religious delusions from killing call girls in Paris. The Rewatchers try to figure out holy ground, marvel at Duncan's hacking skills, and, for the first time in a while, disagree on episode quality.

When Richie lights an immortal jewel thief on fire, Duncan must confront his old friend to save Richie's life. The Rewatchers enjoy some sea food, count up Richie's felonies, and discuss some awesome flash backs.

After the circus comes to town, Duncan reconnects with his former lover, Amanda, who sells him out to the villainous immortal Zachary Blaine. The Rewatchers handle way too much innuendo, enjoy Richie's first trip to the circus, and struggle to figure out the rules on 2v1 fights.

Duncan reconnects with an immortal healer from his past and must rescue her from her slave-driving ex boyfriend. The Rewatchers get sick of the song Amazing Grace, celebrate the return of Inspector Q-tip, and enjoy some fun dialogue from D-D-Darius.

Duncan must stop an "over washed" opera star who holds sway over a giant, music loving immortal. The Rewatchers perform the worst song ever, discuss some amazing costumes, and enjoy one of the best sword fights in the series so far.

After a fine young cannibal robs a jewelry store using deadly nerve gas, Duncan drives the immortal robber crazy by foiling his plan to gas Tessa's art show... And by chopping off his hand. The Rewatchers untangle Darius's religious beliefs, discuss the role of dismemberment in the game, and are grossed out by Richie and Tessa's relationship.

After a group of killer mimes terrorize Paris, Duncan must stay one step ahead of the police and an immortal assassin. The Rewatchers discuss Richie's taste in art, try to figure out why Tessa likes Duncan, and drop some serious absinthe knowledge.