After Duncan's mentor Darius is threatened by a powerful ancient immortal, Duncan musters the power of hope and training montages to bring down a superior foe. The Rewatchers discuss the moral effect of a quickening, Mac's role in the Napoleonic War, and the unceremonious send off of Rando McFarland.

When Tessa witnesses the immortal police chief of Seacouver throw a fellow artist off a bridge, Tessa must solve the case and stay one step ahead of the killer. The Rewatchers criticize Tessa's bogus art, discuss the best immortal job, and try to figure out the villain's circuitous plan.

Duncan thought he stopped the immortal Seacouver Scalper back in the 1920's---but when a copycat terrorizes the city, the gang concocts a harebrained scheme to bring the killer to justice. In this episode, the Rewatchers turn on their Predator Vision, take a trip to Municipal Stadium, and get a free lesson about motorcycles.

When Duncan receives a visit from femme fatale Rebecca Lord (played by pop star Vanity), Duncan sees the hand of his old immortal enemy Walter Reinhardt. The Rewatchers rag on Tessa's spray painted artwork, discuss Richie's future as a car salesman, and unpack the role of cops in the Highlander universe.

After Richie's old friend Nikki, and her three year-old daughter, get caught up with an immortal coke dealer, Duncan must confront his old communist rival Alexi while Tessa confronts her feelings of motherhood. The Rewatchers see Richie go berserk, receive an immortal PSA, and try to figure out where the heck Seacouver is.

When a sadistic surgeon (played by Joe Pantoliano, known for the Matrix and Memento) witnesses Duncan's immortal healing factor, Duncan must use the magic of computers to escape the mad doctor's clutches. The Rewatchers get a free opera lesson, make a software upgrade, and fire the world's worst receptionist.

When Tess is kidnapped by Caleb Cole, an amorous backwoodsman (played by Marc Singer of Beastmaster fame), Duncan must get in touch with his wild side to track Caleb through the Great North Woods. The Rewatchers discuss Richie's hatred of nature, enjoy the episode's soundtrack, and marvel at Beastmaster's incredible southern accent.

When a group of evil painters takeover Seacouver's courthouse—with Richie and Tess inside—Duncan must do his best John McClane impression and save the day. The Rewatchers uncork this bottle episode, wonder if there is any truth to Duncan's fairy tale, and try to figure out why half the characters in this episode even exist.

Joan Jett pretends to be a fledgling immortal in order to infiltrate Duncan's life and seduce Richie... It's gross. The Rewatchers unpack Joan Jett's plan, discuss the episode's music selection, and try to forget Richie's make out sounds.

When one of Duncan’s immortal friends is killed, and a passing veteran with PTSD is blamed, Duncan infiltrates a town of hillbillies to get answers. The Rewatchers wonder if this episode was based on Rambo, piece together why Duncan’s friend was killed at all, and take a crack at rewriting the episode.