Had been excluded by Legislature for two years
Nancy Montgomery, who represents Philipstown and part of Putnam Valley on the Putnam County Legislature, has been named as the chair of one of its committees for the first time since she was elected in 2019.
Montgomery, the only Democrat on the nine-member Legislature, had been shut out of committee assignments for the past two years by the Republican chairs. In 2024 and 2025, she served only on the Budget and Finance Committee, which includes every member.
This year, Dan Birmingham, who was elected chair on a 5-4 vote with Montgomery's support, assigned her to chair the Health, Social, Educational & Environmental Committee and appointed her to Protective Services.
Over the years, Montgomery had repeatedly requested to be part of both committees based on her experience managing group homes for the developmentally disabled, volunteering for the Philipstown Ambulance Corps and dispatching 911 calls.
Other than Budget and Finance, the Legislature's committees each have three members. They meet monthly and consider whether resolutions will be sent to the full Legislature.
"I'm grateful for the opportunity to serve on both the Health and Protective Services committees," Montgomery said in a statement on Wednesday (Jan. 14). "These committees sit at the heart of how we protect public safety, support vulnerable residents and allocate resources responsibly, especially at a time when federal decisions are creating uncertainty for local governments and communities.
"A key priority for me is strengthening policies and funding that support effective collaboration between law enforcement and social services, particularly around mental health and crisis response. I'm looking forward to doing the work, asking hard questions and helping ensure that Putnam County remains prepared, compassionate and fiscally responsible."
Committee Assignments
Dutchess Legislature
Molly Rhodes (D) (Beacon Wards 1, 2, 3)
Budget, Finance and Personnel
Public Safety
Public Works and Capital Projects
Yvette Valdés Smith (D) (Beacon Ward 4)
Majority Leader (ex-officio on all committees)
Putnam Legislature
Nancy Montgomery (D) (Philipstown/Putnam Valley)
Health, Social, Educational & Environmental
Protective Services
State Senate
Rob Rolison (R) (Highlands)
Aging
Alcoholism and Substance Use Disorders
Cannabis
Children and Families
Crime Victims, Crime and Correction
Labor
Local Government
State Assembly
Dana Levenberg (D) (Philipstown)
Correction
Environmental Conservation
Housing
Libraries and Education Technology
Local Governments
Jonathan Jacobson (D) (Beacon)
Cities
Corporations, Authorities and Commissions
Election Law
Insurance
Labor
Local Governments
Oversight, Analysis and Investigation (chair)
U.S. Congress
Mike Lawler (R) (District 17, including Philipstown)
Financial Services
Foreign Affairs*
*Lawler chairs the Middle East and North Africa Subcommittee.
Pat Ryan (D) (District 18, including Beacon)
Armed Services
Transportation and Infrastructure
U.S. Senate
Kirsten Gillibrand (D)
Aging
Appropriations
Armed Services
Intelligence
Charles Schumer (D)
Intelligence
Rules and Administration
In January 2025, Amy Sayegh, newly elected as chair by unanimous vote, excluded Montgomery from any committees. When asked by The Current for an explanation, she would only say that she was "using my best judgment" in making assignments.
In January 2024, Paul Jonke, then the new chair, excluded Montgomery for the first time. He claimed in a letter that her "inability to work collaboratively, and to act professionally and collegially," and the fact that she had "disturbed meetings" and violated the rules of order justified his decision.
He also cited her criticism of Republican legislators for making decisions in secret caucus meetings, "even after you have been provided with conclusive authority that such discussions are entirely proper, ethical and protected by state law."
On Jan. 7, Birmingham defeated Bill Gouldman to bec...