A millionaire dentist, an (almost) ex-wife, a cop, and 2 psychics are what make up this case….

When John Yelenic, a small town dentist, meets the woman of his dreams, he tells his friends that he ‘got the homecoming queen’. John is a very wealthy dentist who showers his new wife with lavish gifts. But things soon go south for the couple….John’s wife has a confession. And John isn’t so innocent himself and also has something to confess. The couple ends up heading for divorce, and on the day he is to sign the divorce papers, John ends up murdered.

When 56-year-old Robert Haney is reported missing in January 2014, detectives search the property where he was living. And what starts out as a search for a missing person, quickly turns to a double murder investigation that includes a woman he was working for and her pet pigs.

Domestic violence is something that happens all too often. And unfortunately in this case a young mother, who is stuck in a love triangle, falls victim to it over and over again. In January 2015, Jessica Goebel ends up being attacked in her home and is stabbed over 20 times. But, she's STILL ALIVE! The killer leaves after the attack and a call is placed to 911. The police get to Jessica's house and find her leaned up against the wall on the kitchen floor, clinging to life. Her 2 1/2-year-old daughter and 9-month old daughter are in the house with her and they're covered in their mother's blood. Jessica is gasping for breath. Police try to save her and immediately bring her to the hospital. At the hospital, there is an investigation going on in the hospital room right next to her. Could her killer be in the room literally right next door? Jessica is placed on life-support and her family ends up having to make an unthinkable decision...

On September 1, 2016, a 13-year-old boy returns home from school. He hears his dogs barking in the basement so he goes to see what they're barking at. They're scratching and barking at a closed door. When he opens it, he finds his 52-year-old stepmother Rhonda Oakley....murdered. Detectives immediately search the house and find that a knife is missing from a set in the kitchen. When Rhonda's husband gets home he can't believe what he's seeing...his son crying, there are police everywhere...and they tell him that his wife has been murdered. While talking to police, he points out that it's not just a kitchen knife that's missing. Two other things are missing as well: Rhonda's car, and his daughter. Could the killer have stolen Rhonda's car and kidnapped her step-daughter? They need to get to her before it's too late.

In the late hours on August 26, 2012, 18-year-old Dana Woods and her 22-year-old best friend June Guerry stop at a fast-food restaurant. They call Dana's mother to say they are going to give a friend a ride home and will be back home shortly. But, the girls never return home. The next morning June's dad ends up driving around in search of the girls or their car. As he's driving he spots the car! They had just passed him on the road! But neither girl is driving it....instead, he sees a man driving. And he doesn't even see the girls in the car at all. He turns around to chase the car down but ends up losing it. He continues searching....and a little while later, police get a call. It's a man who says he found a car in the woods....burned to a crisp. It's the girls' car. Their bodies aren't inside though....so, where are they?

Debbie Gama was a 16-year old student from Erie, Pennsylvania, who was about to enter her Senior year of high school. But, she never gets that opportunity. Debbie is found strangled to death and floating in a creek. The man responsible for Debbie's death was actually someone she was very fond of..and someone no one would ever imagine to be behind this. After admitting what had happened to Debbie, her killer says it was a complete accident...that he never intended to kill her. But, then police dig into his past and find that he has committed other heinous acts against teenage girls...he's even lost his teaching job over it. So, why wasn't he stopped before it reached the point of killing Debbie?

During the Summer of 1979, two men who met in prison (now known as the 'Toolbox Killers') scanned the Pacific Coast Highway in California looking for girls between 13 and 19 years old. The men came up with a plan to act out a sick fantasy they shared...to abduct, rape, torture, and murder teenage girls. On Halloween 1979, the pair end up killing their final victim…and start making some mistakes that could get them caught.

On Halloween night 2004, three roommates in Napa, California, go to bed after handing out candy to local trick-or-treaters. One of the roommates goes to her downstairs bedroom while the other two go upstairs to their rooms. A little while later the downstairs roommate sees their security light go on outside but, she assumes it's just one of the other roommates' cats. Then, minutes later she hears someone enter the house and go upstairs. Assuming it's just a boyfriend she tries to fall back asleep. But, she is again awoken...this time by blood-curdling screams. She opens her bedroom door and tries to get a better listen of what's going on. She completely freezes in her doorway as she hears her two roommates upstairs screaming for help.....and someone is running down the stairs right towards her...

Episode 6, part 2.

Halloween should be a fun time for kids. They get to dress up in costumes, go trick-or-treating with their friends, and eat candy all night long. But on Halloween night in 1974, 8-year-old Timothy O'Bryan had his last candy hunt. While Timothy is going house-to-house filling his bag with candy, he gets home and his father lets him choose one piece of candy before bed. Timothy chooses a large pixy stix. Shortly after eating the candy, Timothy becomes ill.....and actually ends up dying. The candy he chose to eat that night was found to have been poisoned. Was Timothy the intended target? And WHO would poison a child?