Why Non-Reactivity Is a Strategic Tool, Not a Soft Skill
Brenda and Cathy opened this conversation by naming something that often gets overlooked: the acceptance and non-reactivity piece of the Invitation to Change approach — which combines CRAFT, motivational interviewing, and ACT (acceptance and commitment therapy) — tends to get 'lobbed off and forgotten about.' The focus often goes to boundaries, natural consequences, and self-care. But Cathy described non-reactivity as something different: a tool you can think about ahead of time, almost premeditate on, so that when a charged moment arrives, you already know what to reach for.
What makes it so powerful, they explained, is that it does not require you to memorize a script or follow a set of steps in the heat of the moment. It is more about how your body feels and being mindful of that — which is something you can begin practicing right now, even in low-stakes situations.
How Chaos Needs Two Participants
One of the clearest frames from the episode: chaos needs two participants. There is a reactor and a reactee. When a parent stops supplying their reaction, their energy, their drama, the escalation simply cannot continue — there is no second part to it.
'I can't think of a single time with my son where it benefited both of us for me to come and match his level of energy and escalation and drama and chaos. Can't think of a single one.' — Brenda Zane
Cathy added that this is also true in situations involving manipulation or gaslighting — not just loud, escalating conflict. Matching the other person's intensity in any of those situations just leads to co-escalation, and as both hosts observed, everyone walks away feeling awful. Even kids, they noted, do not actually want that outcome.
What Reactivity Feels Like in Your Body
Both Brenda and Cathy described the same physical experience when they are about to react: what Brenda called a 'butterfly convention' happening high in the chest, followed by a pounding heart, and then a kind of disassociation — almost an out-of-body experience of watching yourself lose control. Cathy described it as feeling like the reaction is almost frightening in how physical it becomes.
The reason it matters to recognize these signals is that your body gets there first. Before you have consciously decided to react, your nervous system is already signaling. That is the moment to pause. And deep breathing — especially with a longer exhale — was described as a surprisingly effective way to start regulating the nervous system in real time, even when it seems too simple to work.
Real Stories: When Non-Reactivity Changed Everything
Brenda shared a story from a day when her son was supposed to help pack the house during a move. He was disengaged, and when he asked if they would be done soon, barely half an hour in, she felt the escalation start. She matched his energy — and they went at it for hours. Then something shifted. She stepped back, looked at him almost the way she would watch a two-year-old throw a tantrum, and said quietly: 'I'm not doing this. You can go. Just go.'
'That was, for me, I think the start of me realizing the power of my response was a lot more than I thought it was, 'cause I saw the instant change in him.' — Brenda Zane
Cathy shared her own moment — a screaming argument with her daughter about writing a thank you note to her grandparents. In the middle of it, she stopped, looked at her daughter, and said 'I'm walking away.' And she did. She described that as the beginning of her own 'very uneven recovery' — because it was not long after that things started to change in her home. She realized she had been contributing to the dynamic by always engaging.
Practical Steps to Take When You Feel Reactive
Brenda and Cathy were clear that non-reactivity is not something you can white-knuckle your way into in a moment of crisis. It requires what they called a rewiring of your whole system — an update to your operating system — so that calm becomes the default rather than the exception. Here are the practical suggestions they offered:
Start with a body scan. Even if you change nothing else this week, just begin noticing what happens in your body when you feel triggered. Run an experiment: observe without changing your response yet, just to gather information about yourself.Pause and breathe. Deep breathing with a longer exhale can immediately begin to regulate your nervous system. Box breathing was mentioned as one option. YouTube has many variations to try.Have a go-to phrase ready. The hosts shared a line from a previous episode guest: 'I love you too much to allow this to be part of our relationship. I'm gonna step away, and we can pick this up later.' Memorize it. Write it down. Use your child's name if it helps.Visualize ahead of time. If you know Thursday nights are always hard, picture yourself staying calm before Thursday arrives. Visualization helps you embody the feeling so it is less unfamiliar when the moment comes.Practice in low-stakes moments. Getting cut off in traffic produces the same physical signals as a conflict at home. Use those moments to practice noticing and pausing.Know when to call for help. Non-reactivity is not about pushing down a genuine safety concern. If your nervous system is signaling that you are actually unsafe, call a crisis line or ask for help. There is a difference between real danger and just being very uncomfortable.And when it all falls apart — because it will — Cathy and Brenda both said the same thing: give yourself grace, treat it as a teachable moment, and remember that the do-over is always available. You can go back to your child and say you did not like how you handled something. Another opportunity will come. It always does.