As we roll into the peak of festival season, we are given a glimpse at what movies are coming to try and scare you. In January, the announced movies are usually known commodities. Your sequels. Your reboots. A couple months in now, and we have a better sense of what offerings are on the table. In Episode 196, The Scariest Things talks about our most anticipated horror films of 2025.

As you might expect, this is much more of an art than science, as rarely does the most anticipated movie at the beginning of the year-end up as the favorite movie by the end of the year. For Liz, she hit the bullseye with Oddity last year. The buzz going into SXSW was strong, and the movie delivered. Similarly, two years ago, Talk To Me was getting lots of notice from Sundance, the earliest of the big festivals. The hype proved accurate. Some films spend a year in Limbo but build up a lot of good press, like Late Night With the Devil.

However, nobody saw When Evil Lurks coming. And sometimes, we have great hopes for some of the big sequels and reboots, like Halloween Kills or Exorcist Believer, only to be disappointed at what could have been. And yet, sometimes, the big studios deliver offerings like The First Omen. Like baseball’s opening day, the season begins full of optimism. The trend lines usually show up by June when the big festivals have run their course. 2024, even in the rearview mirror, was a bit of a mixed bag. The Scariest Things was divided about the outcome. Some thought, “Meh,” and some of us thought the year had great depth.

What will 2025 bring? Listen in, and then one year later, we’ll see who was right and wrong! At this point, we’re still playing darts.