AutoExpert

How ANCAP dropped the ball on ordinary car-buying consumers


Listen Later

After a lengthy search, they have just appointed a fully qualified volleyball referee. I know that sounds like a joke - the pope and a volleyball referee crash into a bar, AND… - but unfortunately, it’s not.  

Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

ANCAP - the Shitsvillian and Sheepshaggistani New Car Assessment Program - appears to me increasingly to be doing you, out there in Consumerville, a disservice. These are the dudes who persevere with publicising (for example) Volkswagen’s alleged five-star safety rating with Amarok.  I just went to the ANCAP website this morning and checked. Searched ‘Volkswagen Amarok - current models only’. The result: five stars. This vehicle has not been tested for nine long years. Nine. ‘Current models only’ - please. Amarok, of course, lacks airbags for row 2 occupants, among other critical safety omissions. So it would be kinda lucky to get three stars if tested today.   Basically, you might survive getting gently T-boned in your allegedly five-star Amarok, but things aren’t so certain for the kids in the back… Would it not be a great pity if a tragedy such as that occurred after you had concluded that your Argentinain Volkswagen shitheap was ‘safe enough for the fam’ after cursory interrogation of the ANCAP website, as part of your pre-purchasing research? I think that would be a real shame, not to mention a gross consumer disservice.  In 2016, four years before now, and five years after ANCAP awarded Amarok five stars, the Volkswagen Death Star launched the popular V6 Amarok. At the launch, James Ward from CarAdvice asked Dr Jan Michel - who is some wonky Volkswegian international sales dude - about the still absent Amarok row two airbags:  “We are working on it.” - Dr Jan Michel, Invernational Sales Director, VW Commercial  They’re still working on it, four years later, apparently. Because: Still absent. So, well done there, on the management of a five-star safety rating, and the community dissemination thereof.  ANCAP will retort, of course, look at the date, dude, but to understand that, a consumer would then need to understand the temporal and physical context of the evolution of the safety ratings system. And, look at the typical YouTube comments feed: Many consumers are incapable of that.   This is ANCAP’s inherent dysfunctionality, in my view. The burden of understanding not all five-star ratings are equivalent should not be imposed upon ordinary people. Because not all of them can handle the truth.  Old five-star ratings are meaningless, basically. ANCAP, or course, lacks the budget and other resources to maintain a current ratings system, and today’s hodge-podge of retrospectively irrelevant ratings is systematically vulnerable to consumer misinterpretation (personal opinion).  ANCAP is also somewhat responsible for your next new car being so profoundly annoying. All those safety systems, warning you about all those nonexistent threats, incessantly. That’s a direct consequence of carmakers humping ANCAP’s leg like the dog that’s just gotten into the Viagra, so they can get five stars (not the dog - he doesn’t want five stars - the carmaker - pro tip).

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

AutoExpertBy John Cadogan

  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4

4

6 ratings


More shows like AutoExpert

View all
Background Briefing by ABC listen

Background Briefing

72 Listeners

The Howie Games by LiSTNR

The Howie Games

459 Listeners

Rusty's Garage by LiSTNR

Rusty's Garage

67 Listeners

The V8 Sleuth Podcast by Motorsport Podcast Network

The V8 Sleuth Podcast

37 Listeners

Full Credit to the Noise by Speedcafe.com

Full Credit to the Noise

26 Listeners

CarExpert.com.au by CarExpert.com.au

CarExpert.com.au

3 Listeners

AFL Daily by AFL

AFL Daily

65 Listeners

The Money Café with Alan Kohler by Intelligent Investor

The Money Café with Alan Kohler

35 Listeners

The Driver's Show by Paul Maric and Gordie Waters

The Driver's Show

2 Listeners

Bizarre with Mick Molloy and Titus O’Reily by Sport Bizarre

Bizarre with Mick Molloy and Titus O’Reily

72 Listeners

Chanticleer by Australian Financial Review

Chanticleer

22 Listeners

The Fin by Australian Financial Review

The Fin

16 Listeners

Neil Mitchell Asks Why by 9Podcasts

Neil Mitchell Asks Why

13 Listeners

The ReDriven Podcast by The ReDriven Podcast

The ReDriven Podcast

3 Listeners

Apex Hunters United by apexhuntersunited

Apex Hunters United

36 Listeners