Gript Media Podcasts

Interview 13 - David Thunder - The Unreality of the Migration Debate


Listen Later

Gary Kavanagh sits down with Professor David Thunder to discuss his recent article on the UN Migration Pact. They discuss the technicalities of the Pact; the idea of discrimination in migration control, the formation of customary international law; problematic parts of the Pact such as the section calling on governments to stop the public funding of media outlets that 'promote intolerance'; the lack of debate or discussion about the Pact in Irish media and politics and what that says about Ireland.
00:50 - What is the UN Migration Pact and why should we be concerned about it?
02:50 - Why is the idea of a border and migration control that doesn't discriminate a problem?
05:45 - So are you saying the idea of a discrimination free border policy means there can't really be any control over the borders?
12:00 - Defenders of the pact will argue that the document doesn't give any legal rights, and so what's the harm in signing up for it?
15:20 - How customary law becomes law.
19:50 - What do you think of the media coverage we're seeing that is saying that only the far-right has any concerns with this Pact?
25:40 - Point 33.C says discusses, 'The stopping of allocation of public funding and resources towards media outlets that promote intolerance'. Is that not a worrying level of power to give governments over media?
35:30 - Do you think the way that nationalism is talked about by media and politicians is inaccurate and overly negative?
40:00 - Is this Pact really just the product of a global elite who don't feel a sense of place, who don't have that connection to land or a particular geography?
44:45 - Would you agree that the document doesn't seem to place any value on the concept of citizenship or the idea citizens, because they own their country, should be free to decide which foreigners are allowed to live in the country they own?
51:20 - There are really two stories about the Pact. The first is the Pact itself, but the second is the near total lack of discussion and debate about the pact in Ireland. What does that tell us about media and politics in Ireland that something like this can just pass through nearly without comment?
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Gript Media PodcastsBy Gript

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

7 ratings


More shows like Gript Media Podcasts

View all
The Last Word with Matt Cooper by Today FM

The Last Word with Matt Cooper

62 Listeners

Callan's Kicks by RTÉ Radio 1

Callan's Kicks

64 Listeners

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan by The Irish Times

Inside Politics with Hugh Linehan

148 Listeners

The Pat Kenny Show by Newstalk

The Pat Kenny Show

55 Listeners

The Hard Shoulder by Newstalk

The Hard Shoulder

15 Listeners

Your Politics by RTÉ News

Your Politics

8 Listeners

The David McWilliams Podcast by David McWilliams & John Davis

The David McWilliams Podcast

363 Listeners

Today with David McCullagh by RTÉ Radio 1

Today with David McCullagh

37 Listeners

Crime World by Crime World

Crime World

264 Listeners

The Other Hand by Jim Power & Chris Johns

The Other Hand

42 Listeners

The Indo Daily by Irish Independent

The Indo Daily

115 Listeners

Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning by Gold Hat Productions

Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning

66 Listeners

Path to Power by Matt Cooper

Path to Power

30 Listeners

The week that really was by John McGuirk, Sarah Ryan

The week that really was

7 Listeners

Indo Sport by Irish Independent

Indo Sport

55 Listeners