AutoExpert

Is it safe to sit in row 3 of an SUV?


Listen Later

would you put your child in row three of an SUV or a people mover - if you knew the vehicle did not have head-protecting side airbags in that row? And how would you even know if it had that? I just carved up the market - 20 seven-seat SUVs and four people movers … and the row-three protection offerings might surprise you.  

Save thousands on any new car (Australia-only): https://autoexpert.com.au/contact

AutoExpert discount roadside assistance package: https://247roadservices.com.au/autoexpert/

Did you like this report? You can help support the channel, securely via PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=DSL9A3MWEMNBW&source=url

This week I went through the somewhat laborious process of figuring which vehicles had the airbags in row three.   In people movers, Kia Carnival, Toyota Granvia and Honda Odyssey get big ticks for row three protection (and row four as well in the case of the four-row Toyota). But the LDV G10 does not - nor does it offer that side protection in row one or two - which goes some way to explaining its pathetic three-star rating.  Among seven-seat SUVs, MU-X, Fortuner and Everest manage to offer that row three protection, while Pajero Sport does not. I’m lumping them together because they’re all essentially converted dual-cab utes.  Landcruiser 200 also offers you that side protection, as does Prado, Kluger and Nissan Pathfinder, but I cannot tell you about Pajero or Patrol, because ANCAP’s evaluations there are hopelessly outdated and the technical reports do not include this information.  LDV D90 - yes, for row three. Also in the ‘Yes’ column are Honda CR-V, Mazda CX-8 and CX-9.   The entrants which either fail to offer this protection, or offer it only partially, are X-TRAIL, Outlander, Santa Fe, Sorento, Ford Endura, and SsangYong Korando - but I cannot tell you about the Rexton because it has not been tested by ANCAP.  Before I let you go on this: I honestly cannot tell you if this is a meaningful metric about whether or not to buy a particular vehicle. Like: does it make sense not to buy a vehicle if it lacks this protection? In isolation: it’s probably a poor way to choose a vehicle.  I don’t know how many people actually die or are injured in row three - and I don’t know the modality of their injuries. I can tell you only 27 children aged from newborn to 16 died on the road in the six months from April to September this year. (Clearly, they weren’t all sitting in row three - some were probably pedestrians, and some were probably the victims of parental incompetence - such as failing to be restrained by drunk parents, or somesuch.)  Transport injuries - which is not just cars, but is probably mainly cars - hospitalises about 19,000 kids a year. (In perspective, falls are roughly double that, and ‘other’ is the largest official category of child injuries - at about 50,000 annually.)   I’d also want to know if side impact injury is even a major thing in row three - because if the modality of injury is mainly rear-enders, we’d clearly be better off focussing on structural protection and controlled crumpling to the rear, huh? It may well be that side curtain protection is something of a sideshow for row three. In the absence of data, how would you know?

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

AutoExpertBy John Cadogan

  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4

4

6 ratings


More shows like AutoExpert

View all
Background Briefing by ABC listen

Background Briefing

72 Listeners

The Howie Games by LiSTNR

The Howie Games

459 Listeners

Rusty's Garage by LiSTNR

Rusty's Garage

67 Listeners

The V8 Sleuth Podcast by Motorsport Podcast Network

The V8 Sleuth Podcast

37 Listeners

Full Credit to the Noise by Speedcafe.com

Full Credit to the Noise

26 Listeners

CarExpert.com.au by CarExpert.com.au

CarExpert.com.au

3 Listeners

AFL Daily by AFL

AFL Daily

65 Listeners

The Money Café with Alan Kohler by Intelligent Investor

The Money Café with Alan Kohler

35 Listeners

The Driver's Show by Paul Maric and Gordie Waters

The Driver's Show

2 Listeners

Bizarre with Mick Molloy and Titus O’Reily by Sport Bizarre

Bizarre with Mick Molloy and Titus O’Reily

72 Listeners

Chanticleer by Australian Financial Review

Chanticleer

22 Listeners

The Fin by Australian Financial Review

The Fin

16 Listeners

Neil Mitchell Asks Why by 9Podcasts

Neil Mitchell Asks Why

13 Listeners

The ReDriven Podcast by The ReDriven Podcast

The ReDriven Podcast

3 Listeners

Apex Hunters United by apexhuntersunited

Apex Hunters United

36 Listeners