Principle of Charity

Libertarian vs Indigenous Ways: Which is the better model for society?


Listen Later

In this episode we contrast two very different ways of seeing the world — Libertarianism and Indigenous Ways, to consider which model is better for society. 



Libertarianism, with a focus on the version of this political philosophy that came about in the second half of the 20th century, usually associated with the centre right, does in fact cut across traditional left /right lines. It sees our individual liberty, our freedom as the most important political value. It's a political philosophy that values civil liberties, competitive markets, private property and free speech. It sees the government as a poor substitute for voluntary community and dislikes government intervention. Not just because governments may be corrupt or inefficient, but because of the real threat of force that lies at the base of all laws to coerce us to do what we may not want to do. Libertarianism sits on the extreme, but still well within a general Western enlightenment worldview with other pillars like capitalism and free functioning markets. One could say that the purpose that sits behind this entire worldview is the flourishing of the individual. 



In contrast to libertarianism we consider Indigenous Australian knowledge systems, which echo many First Nations’ ways of seeing the world. Here the individual is just one node in a hugely complex system of relationships that extend to the family, to community, to ancestors, to future generations, to animals and to the land — which is also seen to be alive and sentient — and to the creation stories themselves. While this system recognises we have individual desires and we should honour our individuality, it is driven by prioritising our relationships and obligations to all those groups mentioned above with an overarching sense of custodianship for a story that started in creation and will continue long after we are gone. 


There are some interesting crossovers between the two worldviews, such as a distrust of centralised top-down systems of control and a belief in the power of emergent systems that come from the web of human interactions, however these are two very different ways of seeing the role of the individual and their relationships and responsibilities in and to society. 

This episode contains some coarse language.



BIOS


Tyson Yunkaporta is an Aboriginal scholar, founder of the Indigenous Knowledge Systems Lab at Deakin University in Melbourne, and author of Sand Talk. His work focuses on applying Indigenous methods of inquiry to resolve complex issues and explore global crises.


John Humphreys is the Chief Economist at The Australian Taxpayers' Alliance. He has worked previously as a policy analyst for the Australian Treasury. John was the founder of the Australian Libertarian Society, the Liberal Democratic Party (now called "Libertarian Party"), and the Friedman Conference. He also ran a research centre and education charity in Cambodia for many years, for which he was awarded a knighthood in 2016. 



CREDITS

Your hosts are Lloyd Vogelman and Emile Sherman

 

This podcast is proud to partner with The Ethics Centre


Find Lloyd @LloydVogelman on Linked in


Find Emile @EmileSherman on Linked In and X


This podcast is produced by Jonah Primo and Danielle Harvey


Find Jonah at jonahprimo.com or @JonahPrimo on Instagram

 

Find Danielle at danielleharvey.com.au

  

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Principle of CharityBy Emile Sherman, Lloyd Vogelman

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

16 ratings


More shows like Principle of Charity

View all
Life Matters - Full program podcast by ABC listen

Life Matters - Full program podcast

53 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC listen

All In The Mind

761 Listeners

Health Report - Full program podcast by ABC listen

Health Report - Full program podcast

125 Listeners

Conversations by ABC listen

Conversations

841 Listeners

Big Ideas by ABC listen

Big Ideas

99 Listeners

Better Than Yesterday with Osher Günsberg by Osher Günsberg

Better Than Yesterday with Osher Günsberg

63 Listeners

Chat 10 Looks 3 by Chat 10 Looks 3

Chat 10 Looks 3

229 Listeners

This Working Life by ABC listen

This Working Life

19 Listeners

7am by Solstice Media

7am

118 Listeners

A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard by A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

84 Listeners

The Imperfects by Hugh van Cuylenburg, Ryan Shelton & Josh van Cuylenburg

The Imperfects

413 Listeners

Full Story by The Guardian

Full Story

170 Listeners

Good Weekend Talks by The Age and Sydney Morning Herald

Good Weekend Talks

19 Listeners

Not Stupid by ABC Listen

Not Stupid

58 Listeners

Read This by Schwartz

Read This

17 Listeners